Delicious food! Butter Chicken Fresh Pizza and BBQ wings took less than 15 minutes. This pizza…read moreplace by far one of the best pizza places in the area, highly recommend!

Loved the Indian style wings very delicious and the service was nice…read more My only suggestion is that the pizza by the slice should be slightly under cooked so that when reheating it's not tough.

Had about six people to feed so I thought I'd check out the pizza shop around the corner from me…read more Unfortunately, their website is outdated with pricing so you may be in for a little sticker shock when you order. A sheet pepperoni was $27. The place is cash only. Ordering was straight forward, took about 30minutes to get the pizza -- the pizza itself has a thicker dough-ey crust. A pretty typically Buffalo slice! The 'za crust was cooked well and I enjoyed the sweetr sauce and pepperoni slices. Definitely recommended!

I have to Vent about Trees. But I'll save that for another day…read more Be sure not to confuse this pizza place with Mr. Ventry's a few miles away deeper into the Heart of the City of Niagara Falls. The other location is also five stars and open until the middle of the night. Both places are awesome. Still... This place is still very good and has a lot in common with the other location (different owner) - I think the owners are somehow related and the service is nice at both places. The pizza is great at both places. I still like the other one more, but you should really try both and judge for yourself because they are both very very good. However the owners shouldn't smoke in the doorway (lol) and smell of smoke while serving me slices (lol). Got a super nice response from him about it though, and I really appreciated it. I've tried the pizza 2 more times since writing this review, and it's right up there as top Niagara Falls Style slices, so I'm raising it to the 5 star it deserves. When in NF you MUST get Niagara Falls style pizza, it's incomparable.

Taste is there, quality food, $10 if you use debit on delivery $8 if cash, which tells me delivery…read moreis paid under the table to compensate their wages. Needless to say order delivery guy is 1 slice short of a loaf and expects a tip after $10 delivery, so many better choices in Welland. Other commentor's are right, every time I pick up, staff is snotty/bitchy and act like bozo's, get another job if you're gonna act like a red-headed step child.

Always hot and delicious! Order from there every time we get pizza and wings! (Large pizza and 2…read morelbs of wings)

enjoyed delicious Santoro pizza and wings last night. We ate in. Excellent friendly service along…read morewith the food. Thankyou! We felt like family! We will be back Try it, you will not be disappointed

I do live by the pizzeria,, I've tried the other pizza places that have tried the other places and…read morethey were no good .... I was pleasantly surprised,,, the pizza was hot and tasty,, they put on a ton of toppings and they were very busy ... The people were friendly ... the only downer is all they have on there menus is pizza and chicken wings ,, I wish they had more to choose from......

Been in & out of Town recently, but decided to try this long time little Italy sensation…read more.. I wasn't disappointed and am so glad they have the same recipe and everything... Everything was super good as ALWAYS... Am told they will be opening a full bar shortly !?! im in ! ... I suggest them to everyone to try to stop by & Support your local businesses

While visiting Niagara Falls, I was craving an authentic New York-style pizza experience. Yelp led…read moreme to Goodfellas Pizzeria, and it did not disappoint. The pizza lived up to the hype. The crust was crispy, the sauce was flavorful, and the cheese was perfectly melted. For a medium pizza, it was huge, probably like 16 inch. But what truly surprised me were the wings. They were massive! I've never seen wings that big before. Where do your chickens come from with wings that large?!?! And they were just as delicious as they were impressive. Crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, with a perfect balance of sauce and spice. On top of that, super meaty! Like some reviewers have mentioned this place is in a sketch looking part of town. It's not a super busy to high traffic place. We were the only diners here, but plenty to pick-up orders. If you're in Niagara Falls (the US side) and craving a taste of New York, I highly recommend checking out Goodfellas Pizzeria.

Brought my wife to Niagara Falls, had a problem with our rental car and the guy at the rental…read morecompany said "I'm pretty picky about my Pizza" - I knew that he knew. So to Broadway Pizza for lunch. He said the Dill pizza is becoming a thing around here and they have a good one. Walked into a true Pizza place. Line of locals waiting to order. The lady and her husband were taking the orders each local she hit with small talk. Great variety of pizza cheese, white, mushroom & pepperoni, Dill and half a dozen others. You could pick your own topping of you wanted but with this selection come on ... Tables and wooden chairs your typical pizzeria- you are not here for the furniture. Excellent place. Oh and they were making Stromboli's as well - maybe next time.

This place may not look like much but the pizza is terrific. Lots of options by the slice,…read moreincluding a pickle and ranch slice that was awesome, as well as full pies, rolls and calzones. The owner is super friendly, too

No longer there and the number is some random person. We went to Sting Kings instead. Hope you…read moreread this before trying to find the place.

I looked up burger spots and found this one. I'm so glad I did. I dont go to the falls often, but I…read morecan say it was really worth the drive. I ordered on doordash, a burger, fries and bacon cheeseburger eggrolls. Unfortunately the eggrolls were refunded and canceled but the burger and fries were good! There isn't much inside the pick up area but a table and tv. The restaurant seems to be connected to a bar or something. The only reason I gave 4 stars is because I had to pay $1 each to add lettuce and onions to my burger which is ok, but then I went to eat it and neither was on there. Well to be fair I had like 2 onions literally, but no lettuce at all. I wasn't about to call or go back for that, just wish it would have been what I paid for. I will definitely go back though because I want to try to eggrolls. Staff interaction was brief, I rang the bell and someone came out.

The food was amazing! We came with 10 people, and the owner greeted us right away and helped us…read morewith everything we needed. He was super kind and even brought out a metal illusion puzzle for us while we waited for our food, which was such a thoughtful touch. The Ninja Turtles decorations all over the walls make the place feel really fun and give Donatello's a cool atmosphere. Great food, great service, and we'll definitely be back when we visit Niagara Falls again!

The service and the atmosphere there was super friendly and welcoming. The owner there gave the…read moretable in front of us an illusion game, which the kiddos loved. Plus they have a little bucket of TMNT toys for kids to pick out of at the end of your meal. The Donatello decorations were absolutely darling, and added a nice, iconic touch to the restaurant. On top of that, the pizza was absolutely delicious and filling. I only got a single slice and it was still filling and delicious even after they reheated it :) The prices are very reasonable too. I would absolutely recommend this place if you're in the Niagara Falls area!!