The food was amazing! We came with 10 people, and the owner greeted us right away and helped us with everything we needed. He was super kind and even brought out a metal illusion puzzle for us while we waited for our food, which was such a thoughtful touch. The Ninja Turtles decorations all over the walls make the place feel really fun and give Donatello's a cool atmosphere. Great food, great service, and we'll definitely be back when we visit Niagara Falls again! read more

Donatello's Restaurant - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

The service and the atmosphere there was super friendly and welcoming. The owner there gave the table in front of us an illusion game, which the kiddos loved. Plus they have a little bucket of TMNT toys for kids to pick out of at the end of your meal. The Donatello decorations were absolutely darling, and added a nice, iconic touch to the restaurant. On top of that, the pizza was absolutely delicious and filling. I only got a single slice and it was still filling and delicious even after they reheated it :) The prices are very reasonable too. I would absolutely recommend this place if you're in the Niagara Falls area!! read more

Fast and helpful service, good attitude, professional, BEST PIZZA OF BUFFALO I love the family comittment and heritage. Funny TMMT ninja turtles donatello references. Pizza came fast, perfect, and intense! Perfect proportions and presentation! Great deals and prices. You cannot beat this place! 99/100 i will choose to eat here when im around the area. They reign supreme! Thankful for the helpful lady with tattoos upfront! read more

See all

A great find. Looks like mom and pop operation serving great food! Pizza was delicious. Serving size was huge. Ordered the half tray thinking it would be a half a pan but it was much bigger than expected. Wings was crispy and seasoned just right. Parking at the city lot next door was free. So a great experience overall. read more

See all

We stopped by this place for lunch after our visit to The Niagara Falls State Park. We ordered a whole pepperoni pizza pie and some chicken wings and we love them. The pizza was fresh made and came out hot. It was very cheesy and my kids love it. The amount of pepperoni was generous. The chicken wings were tasty. It was more like a self service sit down place which you could get your own drinks from the fridge and paid at the end of the meal. The food was good, but the seating was very limited and not good for big group. The table was very sticky when we sat down. Street parking, but parking was relatively easy to find during our visit. read more

Reasonable prices,Tasty menu, and friendly atmosphere. Located two blocks from the Seneca Niagara Casino read more

We came to this restaurant on Recommendation from Player Sports bar. We tried a variety of menu options: Buffalo chicken wraps, chicken fajita wraps, pizza, salad. All of it was very good and the restaurant personnel were very friendly and helpful. Total bill was under $100 for 7 people, with tip, we thought that was very reasonable. Very good food. Those buffalo chicken wraps were spicy! read more

Donatello's Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

The business is located close to the hotel, so access and parking was great and accessible. Ordered pizza and salad and was ready within 20 minutes. Pizza looked great; have never seen black olives that large on a pizza before. The whole experience was smooth. Everyone was very nice and attentive. If you're in the area to visit Niagara Falls, this is a must stop! read more

Donatello's Restaurant - Taco Salad (Chicken) - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

Ambience with locals lovely, #servers friendly. They phoned me quickly to retrieve forgotten item Stick to Authentic, being from California i ordered a hybrid w habanero, however it needed a lighter touch. Sadly no freshly grated cheese was available which diminishes experience but that may be a supply chain dilemma. Overall due stars for ambience and stick to it tive ness in this Economy. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! read more

Donatello's Restaurant - $8 montepu ruby red - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

if you're looking for pizza in Niagara Falls, look no further than Donatello's restaurant because this is the slice of New York that you've been looking for, it's the best pizza in the Niagara Falls area. The staff provides great service and you're greeted with tremendous positive energy , AND! not only is the pizza good but everything else speaks for itself. Nothing is done with mediocrity. Everything is done efficiently, and the food is great and also affordable, which is even better in this economy. If you're visiting, go to Donatellos, you will not regret it. read more

In search of great food in the Niagara region, wow, we are pleasantly surprised and appreciative of this hometown quaint family run business! The hostess was very friendly and helpful, gave me great options and brought the food to the table. We order fish fry, Friday special; you have to try this flaky white fish cooked to perfection. A full menu to choose from, great for many food options . The atmosphere was lively and friendly, many local people with children and couples included. Very convenient in the middle of town, walking distance to everything. This place is a must try for any and all food preferences! You will NOT be disappointed, i promise read more

Had an amazing experience at this local gem! Really good authentic pizza and the menu has amazing items! A+ I will be back to the US side of Niagara Falls! Looking good and gonna check out the casino tomorrow! 10/10 read more

If you don't mind being sexually harassed by the cute little old guy taking orders, it's a great place to either eat in or out. Wings were hot and delish and the meat lovers pizza was yummy! read more

Wings and Pizza One tray and 30 wings $70.00. The tab came to $85.00. They basically requested a tip for pickup. I gave it but I don't know why. lol I thought the pizza and wings were Both were good Service was friendly and accurate. read more

Wow! When is the last time a sub brownout away??? Come here to find out. Everything looked so good. Someone ordered a toco salad and pizza. Looked amazing read more

See all

Found this mom and pop pizza place. Staff able to serve hot fresh pizza right before closing which we really appreciated. Pizza had generous toppings and tasted amazing even with carry out option. The family eating in restaurant sold us on spot while walking by. The cheese pull is legit! read more

Tasty pizza crust. Give it a few moments for your pizza to cool down so your toppings aren't oozing of your

The owner was the sweetest, very welcoming and friendly. We ordered an all meats and a slice of pepperoni pizza. So glad we stopped here after our visit to Niagara Falls, beautiful experience. read more

This place is one of my favorite places to go. We ate there 40 some years ago when it first opened. We ate there last year when we were in town and it is still wonderful. Th food,the wine, and the serviceis always spot on. The restaruant is very clean and the ambiance is very enjoyable. read more

Donatellos is a hole in the wall restaurant. The workers are extremely nice and welcoming. The food was wonderful. My family got a little bit of everything... chicken, pizza, and shrimp and not a single one of us had any complaints! read more

Donatello's Restaurant - Personal Pie with Pepperoni, Ham, and Jalapeños - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

It is amazing and I definitely would come back. It's a local little pizza spot classic NY pizza read more

This is what you call a quintessential NY pizzeria. No muss and no fuss. What they do have is a very friendly staff. The one employee immediately welcomed us when we stepped in and gave us instructions on how their ordering process goes. The older gentleman was a sweet and welcoming guy. He brought over a horseshoe magic trick for my kids. They weren't able to solve the trick, but their old dad knows a thing or two and figured it out. Now the food: I generally don't gravitate to pizza for food when out of town, unless it's a small, local business. Those are the types of places that generally make legitimately good pizza. Donatello's does not disappoint. The pizza had the right amount of sauce and very tasty without tasting sweet as some of the national chains usually taste like. The other key factor into a good pizza is the crust. When I saw one of my kids move to throw away their crust, I almost screamed! Nope. That crust is entering my belly! As I alluded to earlier, the place is not much to look at. It adds to its charm and the fact that a large, if not majority, portion of their business is takeout. If you're on the US side of the Falls, then give this place a try! read more

Donatello's Restaurant - 9" Personal with sausage, mushrooms and anchovies. - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Beware. The owner, Dony, was dishonest. They lost my coat, which had been left at the coat check (and he said he had it on tape). Dony promised to reimburse me, kept telling me a check was in the mail. It was all lies. This has been going on since December, 2024. read more

It's a friendly place to visit and the staff is great. We enjoyed our pizzas. It had great flavor and the crust was just perfect. read more

Donatello's Restaurant - Beef Taco Personal Pie - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

Great pizza. Even better than some of the NYC pizza we had a few days later. Plus owner gave kids a puzzle to figure out. Nice guy!

Good food and good prices for the amount of food. Went on a friday and the fish was good! Definitely a hole in the wall restaurant but very good food and service! read more

Horrible food! We had wings and pizza and both were terrible!. Very stale food and smelled weird. We had to throw both. The previous reviews are misleading. read more

Awesome service and kind staff. Got a couple of personal sized pizzas after trudging around Niagara falls on no sleep. A little expensive but I think the pizza healed me. It's in a nice spot too I was able to take a stroll while waiting for my food and look at the street art. read more

Donatello's Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

We came in from out of town - the service was great, the food was even better. Would definitely recommend!

Nothing to say, but: fantastic, fantastic, fantastic, fantastic. Get there as fast as you can! This is an excellent pizza and hamburger sub. I will come here anytime and they let me bring my dog in and sit with us at the table! They've got me for life. read more

This place is amazingly delicious!!! The workers are very kind and fun, they let my daughter play with a horseshoe puzzle chain. GO TO DONATELLO'S!!! read more

After visiting Niagara Falls from the New York side, we were ready for lunch. We used Yelp to look for a good place to eat and discovered Donatello's, which is very close to the Niagara Falls International Rainbow Bridge. Since Donatello's received an average of a 4.5 star review and had over 270 reviews, we figured we would try out this mom & pop restaurant. There is no parking lot, so you have to find street parking, which may be difficult during the peak hours. It is self-seating inside, so you order first and find a table to sit. As for the food, I didn't think it was all special. The wings were just okay, but I really liked their service and enjoyed the friendly conversation with the owner. He shared his story that his son's favorite character was Donatello from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. He does have some Donatello artwork and toys around his restaurant. Overall.., I would give this place a 3.5 star review. I'm willing to back here to try out his other items the next time I'm visiting Niagara Fall from the New York side. read more

See all

We ordered pizza from this location on Friday night and wow! The pizza was delicious and better than I expected. Not only did they deliver to our hotel, but the delivery guy was very friendly. We ordered a large cheese pizza and a large meat pizza and they arrived quickly and were very flavorful. We will definitely order again if we are in the area. read more

Great hot and cold sandwiches, slices, and economical but tasty full party trays. My go-tos when dining alone are their personal pizzas $10-12 (which are slightly undercooked for my taste- ask for well done/ crispy) and large fries ($4). read more

Great service and great staff. We just had a couple of subs and gravy fries, so it came out pretty quick. Again, it was just a couple of subs, but they were very good! I highly recommend the grilled chicken and turkey club. Since the sandwiches were that good, I imagine the rest of their menu is pretty good too. We'll definitely be back when we're back in town, I know our boys would love it! read more

See all

Pizza is amazing. The crust is so good, sauce is the perfect combo of spicy/sweet and it's not overloaded. The cheese was so fresh. Yum!! True local joint. Grab a menu when you walk in, then a seat. Go to counter to order, they'll bring it to you. If we lived in the area we would be regular's. read more

I'm actually surprised at the high reviews, because that absolutely wasn't our experience. Ordered delivery from them while we were staying in Niagara Falls, based pretty much on the high rating. What we ordered was a beef on weck sandwich (a regional specialty featuring horseradish), a cheeseburger, a side of garlic bread, and a couple cans of Coke. The order came promptly. What we got were soggy and cold fries with our sandwiches, lukecold bread that didn't taste at all like garlic. My sandwich was okay, but my horseradish-loving wife reported that the beef on weck was barely edible. And for this meal, we paid $55, including tip. We would have had far more food, hot to boot, if we'd just stopped in at a pizza place on the way back to the hotel. We would NOT patronize this place again. read more

The service was very nice and helpful in choosing a dish. It's just tables on the inside cafeteria style. You feel like it's the store from yesteryear. They believe in community service and I saw this. read more

See all

Our office ordered food for lunch today and some ordered subs, some lunch box sandwiches and pizza. In the past, the lunch box sandwiches were always very good. Today, they were not up to par. The bread was not fresh. It tasted stale. Hopefully the next time we order, we get fresh bread. So disappointed! read more

The pizza seemed like the crust was frozen. That being said it was fine. Wrap was solid. Solid choice but not "NY pizza" in my opinion. Staff was great. read more