Been in & out of Town recently, but decided to try this long time little Italy sensation... I wasn't disappointed and am so glad they have the same recipe and everything... Everything was super good as ALWAYS... Am told they will be opening a full bar shortly !?! im in ! ... I suggest them to everyone to try to stop by & Support your local businesses read more

See all

Goodfellas has gone completely downhill ever since this new owner took over first of all he's ignorant and disrespectful he argues with all the customers The food isn't even good anymore they raise their prices they want to charge you just to come in and pick up your food now I'm driving to the restaurant to use my gas to pick up the food that I'm paying for and I got to pay a $2.50 fee just to come in and pick food up there's just completely ridiculous and the workers in there always got something racist to say definitely wouldn't waste your money in this place no more read more

While visiting Niagara Falls, I was craving an authentic New York-style pizza experience. Yelp led me to Goodfellas Pizzeria, and it did not disappoint. The pizza lived up to the hype. The crust was crispy, the sauce was flavorful, and the cheese was perfectly melted. For a medium pizza, it was huge, probably like 16 inch. But what truly surprised me were the wings. They were massive! I've never seen wings that big before. Where do your chickens come from with wings that large?!?! And they were just as delicious as they were impressive. Crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, with a perfect balance of sauce and spice. On top of that, super meaty! Like some reviewers have mentioned this place is in a sketch looking part of town. It's not a super busy to high traffic place. We were the only diners here, but plenty to pick-up orders. If you're in Niagara Falls (the US side) and craving a taste of New York, I highly recommend checking out Goodfellas Pizzeria. read more

See all

One of the worst pizzas i've ever had. Couldn't finish a single slice. Tasted like Billy Batts after they dug him up. This toilet is the dregs of Pine Avenue, and that's saying something! read more

My favorite pizza in New York so far. That taste was amazing!!! I did order double pepperoni and wow, very delicious. It had that great crunch to the bottom and the sauce was scrumptious. Definitely give this place a try if you're in town. read more

See all

$8 before tax. I had to remove the tinfoil because it was stuck to the cheese and had to drive back for more gravy. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Fries - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

I'm a huge fan of the charbroiled wings, normal wings are also solid and they follow instructions if you like them cooked a certain way. we always get extra crispy and extra saucy, pizza is solid as well but not my favorite. read more

From the exterior, sketchy building in back of a parking lot that contains McDonald's, Goodfellas does not look good. The exterior, and honestly the dining room doesn't look that much better hides a hidden gem. Great pizzaserved hot and fresh in squares served in half or full trays or traditional pie shape. Wings were big and flavorful. Did carryout on a rainy day and it really hit the spot. Prices were fair. Service was rough, but friendly. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Half tray pizza with sausage and pepperoni in front. Back is 10 hot wings - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

We were looking for some GOOD New York style pizza and found this place online. It was not very easy to find and didn't look great from the outside (and not the best area), but we were hangry once we finally got there (we had walked). The pepperoni pizza was the best NY style pizza we have had in NY! I would definitely recommend driving there though as walking back felt a bit iffy in the evening. read more

I would return to Niagara Falls just to visit Goofellas. Family atmosphere. located a bit off the tourist path. The pizza was fantastic. We celebrated a large family gathering and everyone loved the full tray of pizza with wings combo. A half tray is a cookie sheet, shaped square style with light tangy sauce and generous cheese with the old fashioned pepperonis. It mixes very well together. A hit with everybody. read more

Two days ago, I walked into their restaurant and was ignored for 3 minutes before being assisted while one senior staff (possibly manager) sat there with her back to me although could see me in the mirror they were facing. I bought 20 medium wings, got home, and discovered while trying to eat them they would have been better strapped to the bottom of my feet and worn like a great pair of leather shoes. The wings were overcooked, dried out (not a hint of juice anywhere), and little flavor not absent only because of the sauce. I attempted to eat them only because of my hunger and lack of time to return them. I sorely chewed and swallowed half of them chucking it up to being just a bad order. I wasn't going to say anything, but then the next day the thought of $25 for dried out, nastiest wings I've ever been served, changed my mind. I returned to the restaurant and explained the condition of the wings and how I had eaten half of them, miserably. I never asked for anything. I merely wanted to express my dissatisfaction and give them the opportunity if they chose to accept it to remedy the situation. I was told they weren't going to do anything because their "policy" (stressed several times) was the wings had to be returned the same day. I explained I didn't have time yesterday and it fell on deaf ears. Instead of treating me as a customer, they treated me as somebody trying to scam them out of 10 wings. I felt offended and boldly told them they just lost a customer! They didn't seem to care at all and merely reiterated their policy as I left. Customer service was lacking and the quality of the food was abysmal. I was surprised considering how much I've enjoyed their pizza and wings in the past. Perhaps they have a new line cook, but it doesn't matter. I recommend their managers and employees take a course in providing quality customer service. Maybe then they would realize the importance of customer relations and realize how having one dissatisfied customer can quickly become 10 or more, just by word of mouth alone, about their experience. A better policy: Serve quality food to begin with and nobody will want to return it. If the customer's not satisfied, bend over backwards to try to appease them and keep them as a happy "paying" customer. Those working there might want to start seeking employment elsewhere if they continue with their current customer policy practices. Shout out: Yelp is our voice, and if you experience something good or bad, share it here! read more

For the ladies working at Goodfellas, this rating has nothing to do with your service. You were great. The pizza though was so disappointing. I know this isn't NYC, but geez the pizza was worse than something you'd find at Dominos. Every slice we'd pick up, all the toppings would just slide off, cheese and all. Zero flavor. read more

Food and service good. Ambiance fair. Recommend the fried Zucchini, pizza, Strombolis, calzones, and smokehouse chicken salad.

Haven't been here in years, but when I did use to come the pizza was good. Well after all these years the pizza is still good, especially their char pitted wings. This pizza is the thicker (doughy) type crust that some people love or just hate it. I really enjoy it. You can eat inside the restaurant, but I strongly suggest you order out. As many others stated, this place is old and run down. I honestly believe, the only ones eating inside here is friends and family. There is also a bar area to catch a drink or two. read more

See all

The inside of this place is so worn down, tacky, and falling apart. The seats have rips in them, the walls are dirty and discolored, the bathroom stalls won't lock, and the floors are disgusting. So I would suggest if you are desperate for their pizza, get it to go. The pizza was good. The sauce was delicious and there was just the right amount of cheese. I ordered slices and was disappointed when they brought out square slices from clearly two different pies. I'm pretty sure they had some left over cheese pizza, threw some pepperoni on it, put it in the oven for 5 minutes and served it. The prices were excellent however. $5 for 4 square slices. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Worst pizza in the city. The cheese is cooked on top and raw underneath. Tastes like raw shit

Has the best chicken fingers hands down that I had in a longtime you won't be disappointed

Amazing!! If you are in the area of Niagara Falls you need to go here. It's on a side street but it is the best pizza and wings ever!! The best brick oven crust pizza and the wings are the best we have had. Waitress was also the best!! read more

See all

i love this pizza!!!! this is the only place i order white pizza from. delicious!! i have ordered red sauce pizza as well with multiple toppings, and it's just as good! they are never skimpy on the toppings. pizza always cooked to perfection. love goodfellas. read more

There are just not a lot of Goodfellas around anymore. And those that are good, are already taken. Taken by the deliciousness of this Pizza, that is! I'm not really sure if there is much competition, but this is hands down the best pizza in Niagara Falls. It's also one of the better pizza options in Buffalo because it's so noticeably different to the pizza in the WNY region. I honestly don't think there is anything else quite like Godfathers (oops, I mean Goodfellas), but it's very delicious. You might even say it's St. Louis style pizza, except that I don't like St. Louis pizza, but I love this place, so I'm not sure how that works itself out. What's even better than the deliciousness of the pizza is the price. You can get a slice for $1. They're not very big, but they're utterly delicious and 2 or 3 of them will easily fill you. If you have never tried this place you simply must try it because it's so different and you might find that you adore it like I do. It sometimes can be a bit of a wait for the pizza, but it's worth it. The place looks a bit like a run down bar (like Partners, maybe, in Lovejoy), but the people are friendly and the pizza is magnificent. It's also a little bit hard to find in a kind of run down city (why is Niagara Falls USA run down? I have no idea, but it is. It's embarrassing that America lets one of its most famous towns be so underfunded, honestly). But once you do find it, off Pine in the heart of Little Italy next to a large parking lot on what looks like a sort of back alley type street... my word it's so worth the visit. It's right round the corner from Michael's, too, which is one of the best Italian restaurants in the area. WNY actually has the best Pizza in the world - check my "best Pizza in the world" list to see all the best Buffalo pizza places, lots of my choices are Buffalo based. read more

This place was sooo good the garlic bread delicious. Pizza was really good hot and delicious!!!!! This is such a nice place. The owners and waiter was soo nice! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Large - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

Dined in here yesterday. The place is not easy to find as it's located within the market behind McDs. It's in need of a major remodeling, or just tear it down. Torn front sign, super old furniture, old bathrooms with things falling apart and no toilet paper, about 6 booths but uncomfortable seat cushions, very dark lighting--it's pretty nasty inside folks. The server was friendly and immediately gave us menus. Reasonable prices, we ordered pizza and wings. It took about 25 minutes for them to make it. The pizza came out first and it was fantastic. Excellent chewy crust, tasty sauce, and tons of cheese--a big winner! The wings came out 10 minutes later and were too overcooked (possibly our fault as we asked for extra crispy). The mild wings didn't seem to have much of any sauce on them, the hot wings were the typical sauced wings, but not that great. I would not eat in here again due to the conditions, this place is best used for takeout. read more

See all

My written review is down below poor service just a waist of my $ this has just been recently I'm not sure what's changed but I won't be back read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - A mess from Goodfellas Pizzeria this is the second time within 3 weeks - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

Had a colleague in from out of town and solicited my friends that live in the Falls for where to take her for wings. This was the ONLY place suggested by 4 of my friends. Was told chargrilled wings hands down. My colleague got her wings mild chargrilled which seemed a bit dry to me, but she enjoyed them. I got my wings hot bbq and they were tasty, charred just right and spicy! We both ordered the pizza logs as well, since they are a local thing too! The logs were crispy without being greasy and the accompanying sauce was good too. My boyfriend had a turkey sub and said he enjoyed it very much. All three of us left satisfied and full! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Hot BBQ chargrilled! - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

I do like their food but it's so inconsistent. The Pizza when it is on it's the best in Niagara Falls HOWEVER the pizza there is mostly always sloppy AF. And it us also the most expensive pizza in Niagara Falls that when the pie is sloppy, the pizza dough thin to thick makes for such an unstable slice to eat. I had to give up on good fellas. If it was cheaper maybe I would over look how inconsistent the food is but no. There is a lot of good pizza options that #goodfellas sloppy inconsistent pizza pie doesn't pass the high price threshold test. I'm sorry too many times have I been delivered shitty prepared pizza. read more

See all

Constantly great pizza where ever I get it. Recently I had a godfathers pizza from a travel plaza and it was just as delicious as from any of their restaurants. Best pizza in the world I love a humble pie. read more

We ordered food at 8:16 PM and told food would take about an hour to be delivered to our hotel. (so around 9:16 PM) We called at 9:45 PM, now 1.5 hours after the food was supposed to be here and the woman on the phone was very rude and frankly didn't give a crap. She said she is supposed to tell everyone about 1 hour for delivery but that could also actually mean the food could take longer and she doesn't know what else to tell us . Probably not the right answer! We were told about an hour. About an hour should not mean HOURS! We also told the woman on the phone that if the hot food is cold and the cold food is hot, we're sending it back. She said thst was fine. It is now 10:24 PM and still no food. This was our first time ordering from Goodfella's and we won't ever again. I understand they are busy but as a business owner and if I treated my clients this way I wouldn't be in business. Goodfellas's, please understand that great customer service comes from the heart. it doesn't sound like the person answering the phone cares to be there. I see a lot of good reviews fr the food. Unfortunately, we will never know how your food tastes. read more

We order regularly. Always consistent. Great food, friendly staff. I want to share an employee went above and beyond for me. I was there for a pickup. The total was a couple dollars more than I had available. I was going to go home for 2 bucks, but this kind woman insisted my safety during this blizzard was more important and she hoped to see me again! So kind! We were already loyal customers, but I hope this post helps find them even more! read more

The service was quick and very friendly. I had one of the best burgers I've ever had! The portions on all meals were huge! If you're in the area, I'd definitely recommend eating here. read more

Good pizza. This is a place I wouldn't *want* to go to eat, but would love to order from for take out. The decor, if you can call it such- feels the the garage of a bachelor in the 80's.it's REALLY bad. The pizza , chicken fingers and fries were delicious. Crispy chicken fingers and fries, which were just greasy enough for us. Pizza crispy edges, perfect amount of cheese, light sauce and loved the pepperoni. Affordable, and the polite, friendly service made up for what was missing in ambience. read more

See all

I recommend the char-broiled wings. They don't accept card over the phone for delivery so that is inconvenient. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

VERY disappointed in Goodfellas. Ordered wings @ 2pm to be delivered by 5pm. Didn't get here till 5:45pm. I ordered half medium/half honey garlic. Received half plain/half honey garlic and ALL cold. Smh... and they're ranked one of the best in the Falls. Uhhhh how? read more

Pizza was hot and delicious when it was delivered to our hotel. Not to mention they delivered to us in a March snow storm. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza , which was massive!! Super cheesy. I would not recommend extra cheese. Pepperoni was delicious ! I'm not from this area , but would order from here again when I come back !! read more

Usually don't order from here because I was never impressed with their pizza but we thought we'd try their pasta dinners. We ordered what we were told was rigatoni and meatballs and when we got the order the pasta was not rigatoni it was penne noodles. Also the sauce was very generic and bland. The food was just okay by they gave you a lot. I would say great on quantity but a fail on quality and they need to know the difference between rigatoni and penne which is a huge difference. The dinners also came with bread and salad read more

Other than the place being in need of a remodel, we were glad we yelped "pizza" in Niagara Falls and found this place. It took a while to get our pizza after we ordered from the very nice server but man was it worth the wait. Just the right amount of sauce and grease puddles in the curled pepperoni. The not too thick not to thin crust was spot on. Would definitely be back here the next time in the area. read more

Food is amazing but how are y'all going to close at 12 and stop taking orders at 11 y'all lose so much business!! That's completely insane

Ordered for the first time today bc it's close to work. Never again. Customer service was horrible. And was hung up on! I'll spend my money else where food sucked read more

Told that delivery is an hour and at 1.5 hours called up and not only was the women on the phone rude but coming up on 2 hours food seemed to never arrive, for 2 cold subs and 1 hot sub. The excuse was we are really busy but if you don't know how to estimate your delivery times and how long your cook times on a maybe a 10 min prep time for the food then you shouldn't be in business! read more

Really loved this place at first, but the service isn't worth the food. They rush you on the phone and then take forever to get the food out, even when it's dead. Last time they wrote my to go name wrong and then refused to let us pick it up because the name didn't match. It sat in the window for 30 minutes before they finally let us take it and by then it wasn't worth it. Won't be going back. read more

Excellent pizza, but since this is a review we all have to be picky about something. So next time don't burn the bottom of our pizza!