If you're looking for an old school pizzeria , this is the place to go. It's been around for ages. Ask for the toppings underneath (that's how it ALWAYS used to come). You won't be disappointed. Cheese and mushroom is my go to! read more

In my opinion there is no better pizza in the Village of Lewiston. It is consistently made and never disappoints. The crust is amazing-and always the right amount of toppings. Service is quick and orders are ready when promised. My favorite go to for pizza or subs! The steak and cheese sub is especially good! Lots of meat and cheese. Exactly what you expect. Don't overlook this gem. Worth the trip! read more

Loved this pizza! We got a half tray of pepperoni pizza (love that they use the cupped pepperoni) and 20 wings, and the food was great - perfectly done pizza and tasty, not soggy wings. Will definitely come back again to try other pizzas and subs Also, posting the menu since I couldn't find one online and the last one here was 3 years ago read more

Vincenzo's Pizza House - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Lewiston, New York

See all

I've been enjoying this pizza since 1969 when I enrolled at nearby Niagara University. I had no experience with NY pizza, as I came up here from Tampa. This pizza is thin, drenched in plentiful fresh ingredients. The sauce is delicate but robust. Like most western NY pizza, the cheese is not the star; the crust and toppings are meant to shine. read more

You can't place an order! It's been my experience that from 6PM until 8PM closing The phone is off the hook! How do they stay in business if they don't take orders. I wonder if the owner knows this is going on. It's too bad because the pizza is good! Is there another way to get through read more

Local favorite. Probably best to order in advance for pickup. Wings take 20 minutes. They have square pizzas with thicker crust than a "NY" pizza and sell by the slice. If you come after the lunch rush, you get the leftovers. I made the mistake of grabbing a slice of cheese (all that was left) and wings. The slice was incredible, I mean one of the better pizza slices I have had, and I went back for another but they were cleaned out. No more slices until dinner rush. The interior is basic as most folks get the food to go. Wings were good. Not memorable but would be remembered as a good solid wing. Pretty happy with this place. read more

Vincenzo's Pizza House - Good wings. Fresh, hot, and meaty. - Pizza Near Me - Lewiston, New York

Pizza and subs are always amazing. Love the half tray pepperoni. Subs are always fresh.

They really need to update the website and HOURS!! You never know when they're open. They say they're open till 9pm but don't take order after 8pm or sometimes 730pm. They say they're open on Sundays at noon. Drove by at 1245pm... surprise... surprise, they're closed. This establishment is very inconsistent with hours and orders. Now the pizza is TOP NOTCH! Very good pizza, but needs better MANAGEMENT! read more

Old school, down state NY pizza. Thinner crust, with tasty cheese that is slightly browned and the right amount. Reasonably priced and food is ready for pickup on time. read more

We have been patronizing Vincenzo's forever! Their pizza is second to none, delicious. It's a takeout place. There might be a few tables but people typically sit there and wait for their orders. read more

Ordered the half tray pizza and 20 wing combo (half hot, half mild), $32 for takeout. They needed 45 minutes to make it on a Saturday evening. Finding parking was a bit of a challenge on the street. Coming in to pick it up was uneventful. The staff here are focused on making the food, not really serving the front counter in a quick or overly friendly way. The place inside is run down with a crappy tiny restroom. Though, it does have a good number of tables, and I think it's probably best to eat your wings here, than get them for takeout. They put our 20 wings in styrofoam containers, with barely any air holes, which made them super soft and soggy. They also didn't cook them that long, so there probably wasn't much crisp to them in the first place. The hot wings didn't have that much hotness, the mild tasting a bit better with a hint of buttery flavor. The half tray pizza was cooked well, with the cheese and tiny spicy pepperoni, but the crust was too thick in the corners. read more

See all

I stopped by here awhile ago with my father for dinner. We were in the Lewiston as we were going king salmon fishing the next day. So whenever we were looking for a place to eat, pizza appealed to us. We actually ended up outside of the restaurant but due to Covid precautions, no one was allowed inside. So i had to place my to go order on the phone while sitting outside the restaurant which was certainly weird. We ultimately decided on a large pepperoni pizza and were given a 20 minute wait time. After killing that, and a little more, we were able to pick up our pizza by calling the restaurant and paying, all outside. Once we got the pizza back to our campsite for the night we dug in. It ended up being quite good as there was a ton of great tasting cheese! The pepperoni also tasted nice on it and while the flavor of the sauce was a little lost, it had a decent crust as well. With all of the cheese on it, my dad and I were unable to finish it. The bottom line for me is that I would stop by here again in the future. Don't be like me and try to go in to order during Covid. However, I liked the amount of cheese that was on the pizza and was pleased with it. read more

Vincenzo's Pizza House - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lewiston, New York

Old school since 1966. We had originally drove to the Silo to eat but they were closed for the season. We found this restaurant nearby and decided on eating here but their in room dining is closed - take out only - bummer. We ordered a Cheesesteak sandwich and french fries. We waited in our car across the street while it rained for around 10 minutes. As I was about to go pick up the food the girl had come out in the rain with our order and found us across the street - now that's service. As for the sandwich it was so delicious and that bread is amazing and so were the crunchy fries. read more

Vincenzo's Pizza House - Old school since 1966 - Pizza Near Me - Lewiston, New York

First time for us and we had pizza & wings. Both were delicious! Definitely will order again.

Great pizza! Service was friendly and delivery was fast. I'm looking forward to trying more of their menu items.

Good pizza, standard pep and banana pepper always delicious. Thicker than others which is how I like pizzas.

Great pizza, very clean atmosphere, fast and friendly service! I would highly recommend to family and friends. Definitely will be back for a broader experience. read more

Vincenzo's Pizza House - Pizza was amazing, dropped in, spur of the moment idea and the price for a slice was very reasonable! - Pizza Near Me - Lewiston, New York

Great pizza and subs. The food is always fresh and the service is professional. For years we have been going there and it's always a great experience read more

We got wings to go! Lots of flavor, just enough spiciness and very fresh. Absolutely delicious traditional wings. read more

See all

Called at 7:50pm on Thursday July 9th to place an order for pickup. Girl on the phone says "We're done taking orders for the night"... Me: "Your hours say you're open until 10pm" Girl: "The owner says we're done taking orders for the night" WTF -- You stop taking orders 2 hours before closing?!?!? I am back from California for a visit and love their pizza from back in the 70's and 80's but screw you guys from now on... I will never try to order from here again. Time to call Favorites. Now and every time I'm in town. F this place. read more

Now that I finally got in, I can honestly say GREAT steak and cheese subs! Rolls were great and everything was fresh. Definitely returning .

Stopped in here on a whim while we were in Niagara Falls for a few days. Gabriella could not have been nicer. And the pizza was amazing. The town of Lewiston is well worth the short drive to enjoy local hospitality and food. read more

Vincenzo's Pizza House - Three cheese steak pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lewiston, New York

Great pizza representative of the traditional Italian palettes of old Niagara Falls. Easy parking, and great prices.

Awesome steak and cheese subs!!! They also make their own sub rolls. This sub is comparable to violas subs, mariposa subs and gas and grill in Youngstown. I love steak and cheese subs so believe me when I tell you they are to die f read more

Steak and cheese sub had a lot of steak and very tasty. Ordered close to closing time and no problem, no rush and excellent food and service. read more

716-754-7383. My second favorite number when I visit my hometown! I miss this pizza weekly while back in Cleveland. Each time I arrive home, we hit that number up once we go over the Grand Island bridge. 35 minutes- music to my ears. My favorite pizza of all time. Almost identical to old man Vinny. Keep it going guys. Still has a great taste. read more

Really enjoyed their pizza and wings. They loaded the meat lovers pizza with tons of sausage bacon and peperoni. They use real bacon and sausage and not that simulated garbage. The wings are big and the price was reasonable. read more

We ordered subs two weeks in a row and they are some of the best subs we have ever eaten. The rolls are amazing and I like the tight secure packaging. For two large subs it is $20 and they are hearty and large! We will continue to order from here during this period and thereafter. Thank you for being open! read more

Best Steak and Cheese subs in WNY. It's a small place with what appears to be a high volume of orders. If you're patient, it's well worth the wait. Very original pizza and incredible wings! read more

Ordered from this place for subs after previously having some very sub-par pizza a few months back. Very disappointed with what I got. My whole order was 1Meatball Parm, and 1 steak & cheese sub with sautéed peppers and onions, and light Mayo. The Meatball parm was cold in the middle and the Steak & cheese sub was a mess. Not only was there no cheese and very skimpy but they filled it almost full of UNSAUTÉED red onions, peppers, and so much mayonnaise it was oozing out of the sides. Would rate 0/5 stars if I could. read more

Horrible service. Messed up order there twice now. DO NOT ORDER HERE. Poorly managed and lazy workers.

This reviewer has been frequenting Vinny's since the late 70s when the old man was the only one in the kitchen. Now there's a revolving door of cooks resulting in pizzas of varying quality. This is, unfortunately, Vinny's achilles heel: inconsistency. Sometimes the pizza are 5* quality, sometimes 4*, sometimes 3. You just never know what you're gonna get. Inexplicably, somebody decided it would be a good idea to switch to a different kind of pepperoni and to stop putting the pepperoni under the cheese. Not since New Coke has a food-related blunder been committed on a more gargantuan scale. Pepperoni under the cheese was Vinny's trademark (despite the fact that Pizza Oven on Niagara St did it first). There was never a sloppier, greasier, tastier pizza than a Vinny's half tray, certain to leave stains behind, and an oil trail that moved from the palm of one's hand, down the wrist, inevitably finding its way to the inner forearm, and oftentimes the elbow. And it was the pepperoni oils intermingling with the sauce under the cheese that created those distinctive Vinny's slabs. You'd better have a paper towel roll handy because napkins didn't stand a chance. One thing about Vinny's slabs is their very short shelf life. If you happen to forget to wrap them up you're likely to find them several hours later in a transformed state, as hard and rigid as a discus and just as aerodynamic, as i happened to find out once at a stag party in the back room of the Stone Jug. The honored guest that evening was a Vinny's aficionado who grossly overestimated the amount of half trays required to feed attendees. About 8-10 boxes of Vinny's half trays sat for hours while revelers debauched themselves on skunk beer and raffled liquor. As members of the bridal party indulged lesbian strippers and low-grade pornography, the slabs slowly hardened until as they became as stiff as a 2 by 4. A dispute broke out between two groups of drunken individuals who soon discovered that Vinny's slabs could be used to seriously injure someone else. Both sides quickly scrambled to secure ammunition and the battle ensued: Vinny's slabs were fired in anger back and forth as uninvolved parties dove for cover. Dozens of slabs whizzed ominously toward their intended targets like Chinese stars, and frequently committed similar carnage. Horrifying. On a more pleasant note, Vinny's homemade sub rolls are of very high quality and definitely worth investigating if they haven't discontinued them. i highly recommend the steak and cheese with everything on it, if it's still available. It's nice to still have Vincenzos around even if time has changed us both. But i'll say this and not a word more: No matter how the wind blows me toward the gatekeeper and his keys, i'm keeping my eyes on the prize and the pepperoni under the cheese! read more

I haven't eaten here since the old man owned it. I may have been just legal drinking age. Ordered a cheese half tray, frigging excellent. We used to call them slabs, and I'm happy to say, this pizza is still awesome! read more

Ordered a pizza last night to be delivered. We were told about 45 mins. It was more like an hour and 15 mins! We kept trying to call the restaurant and it was continuously busy. When the pizza got here it was burnt. Needless to say I was very disappointed. read more

Worse customer service. When we rang the bell for someone to help a man came out from the back and he asked us what we wanted in a very impatient way. It felt like he wanted to get rid of us as soon as possible. The pizza wasn't very good and was really greasy and with a tough crust. It may not of been very fresh. I would not recommend. read more

This is one of my favorite pizza spots in queens, the pies are always made fresh and the thin crust is the best part. Their speciality slices can't be beat. read more

First time ordering here. Had chicken finger sub, chicken parm sub, onion rings, and fries. Called in the order. Loved how quick the order was ready, compared to our local fav pizza place that takes double the time. Went to pick up & the place was empty. The subs were borderline Ok. Chicken didn't seem to be good quality and there was hardly any toppings. It was wrapped in many layers of plastic wrap, hard to open without making a mess. Onion rings were great. Fries were the standard frozen steak fries. Really liked how they have half orders of fries that you can add onto your sub order for half price. Won't be going back there for subs anytime soon, the other shops in the area are much better but I'm open to trying their pizza. read more

See all

Everything you want from a pizzeria. I've noticed a lot of other places in town focus on a variety of weird specialty pizzas and subs and it seems like their food suffers because the kitchen staff is trying to do too much. You won't find that at Vincenzo's. It is a small family owned and operated spot and has been since 1966, and after being in business so long you can tell they have mastered the art of making a pizza. Great crisp crust, a perfect ratio of sauce and cheese, and always perfectly cooked. Cannot say enough good about this business. If you're visiting from out of town you have to try this pizza! If you're a local, then you probably already love it! read more

See all

Been eating pizza from here all my life, it's the best pizza in Lewiston. It was heartbreaking when they closed for a while and once they reopened I went there at least once a week for months. So glad that they're there and going strong, you must experience this place!!! Now I live in Arizona and anytime I come back home I make sure I get a half tray from them!! Favorite pizza: double cheese with onions and banana peppers. Sooooo good!!!! read more

I love Lewiston, and it's amazing restaurants. I have purchased 4 times from Vincenzo's. I just cannot continue to give them my business. Yes, the service is slow. That's fine, sometimes a pizza place can be busier than it appears. But their pizza is just simply....bad. I am the least picky person when it comes to pizza. Favorites in lewiston is superb...but I sometimes want to give my business to other proprietors. I thought maybe it was me, so I ordered a tray and had some friends over. Asked them what they thought of the pizza. They exclusively all agreed it was average to bad. How can you mess up pizza?! I don't know if it's their sauce or cheese, but it's just not a great pizza. It's frustrating to pay more for their pizza as opposed to their competitors and get such a poor product. If you want sub par to bad pizza, this is a can't miss! read more