Was in the mood for a burger so stopped in here to see what this place is all about. With Burger in your name, you would assume there would be some good eating in this spot! Walking in there was nobody else in there, so we were able to order right away. You order at the counter and you can pick from burgers already created, or create your own which is nice. I decided to try one that was already created. I do like that they are on the thinner side. Most of them are doubles I think because they are thin but I requested just one patty vs two. I had the cajun style burger which was really good. Loved the what seems like fresh cut fries as well. My only complaint is that there were several tables that weren't clean, so we had to walk around to find a clean table. Since it wasn't busy one would assume that there was time to clean the tables. It was also really really cold, so be sure to bring a jacket! Pricing is okay. For two burger meals which included fries and a drink it was a little over $40 a little high but not overly for this area of Fishers. read more

See all

4 stars. Popped in today to observe National Burger Day and take advantage of the $5 Classic deal. No line, no wait. The cashier told me everything that came on the burger and asked if I'd like to make any changes. I appreciate her sharing the setup with me because I'm not a fan of raw onion on my burger, so I 86'd it. My burger was freshly prepared and it was hot and juicy. The only gripe I have is that it wasn't seasoned. If I'd had a lil salt n pepper, we'd be cookin' with gas. Lost a star for lack of seasoning. Otherwise, it was fantastic. The toppings were fresh and crispy and bright in color. I would not pay $10 for it, but it was certainly a great lunch at $5! read more

Wayback Burgers - CLASSIC - double patties!! - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Made to order. Came out piping hot . Fresh Sooooo good!!! I can't believe I hadn't been here sooner. The Sweet & Spicy burger is a must try!!!! Not too spicy and the right amount of sweetness to balance it all out. The pineapple jam needs to bottled! My first time ever having an upside down bun. And I liked it! So much that that's going to be my go to from here on out. I ate my seasoned fries first, per usual. Then devoured the burger. Each bite was packed with all the flavors. Did I mention how the pineapple jam needs to be in a bottle? It does! It needs to be a staple on the menu. I tried the Birthday cake shake and although it was good, it had way too many sprinkles for my liking. So much that I didn't finish it all. Other than the sprinkle overload, the shake was good! I'll definitely make my way back. read more

See all

Our first time trying Wayback Burger. The food is delicious and it's not too big of a portion. The service was quick and easy to order; they have a self-service kiosk as well to order food. It was calm and quiet when we came in, and the place is actually clean. Would definitely come back whenever I'm on that side of town. read more

Best burger in Fishers! Argue with your mama! Decided to check this place out on a whim for date night and boy am I glad we did! The burgers were absolutely delicious! Full of flavor, super juicy, and the toasted bun held all the goodness together! I had the tots and they were seasoned to perfection...I didn't even want ketchup! We both just ordered fountain drinks, but next time I'm splurging for one of their tempting shakes! read more

See all

On Wednesdays in August 2025, they offered BOGO classic burgers. I customized mine with mushrooms, probably Swiss cheese, etc. Burger tasted fine, but I think it needed more flavor. Maybe one day I will try a more expensive burger from them. Better yet, I hope they will participate in a Yelp event. read more

Wayback Burgers - My customized classic burger - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Friendly staff and tasty burgers. I got the Cajun with a subbed in Impossible patty and fried pickles on the side. The fried pickles were fantastic. The dinning room was clean and inviting. read more

Wayback Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Tried Wayback Burgers for the first time today, grabbing it to-go after a long day of running errands--and it totally hit the spot. I went with the Cajun Burger, which had just the right amount of spice, and shared an order of Chili Cheese Fries. Everything was cooked perfectly and packed with flavor. Yes, it was a bit on the greasy side, but in the best "comfort food" kind of way. Service was quick and friendly, and from what I could see while picking up, the restaurant was clean and had a fun, upbeat vibe for a Saturday afternoon. Definitely looking forward to trying more from their menu next time. read more

See all

We were greeted when we walked in. The store was clean including the bathroom. I was really excited that they offered a garden burger since I don't eat impossible meat. There was a miscommunication when placing my order, but its my fault for not looking at the screen. My total was $24 before tip. I ordered a garden burger, fried pickles, onion rings, and a drink. When I got my food, I took everything out of the bag. A long dark strand of hair was sitting in the middle of my onion rings. No big deal. I took it to the counter to let them know. I then opened my burger, and it was really meat with bacon on the sandwich. I still didnt get upset, just let them know I had a meat vs garden patty. I believe it was the manager on duty that ended up helping me. She became very agitated with me and said, you ordered a cajun burger. I in fact did not because I dont eat meat. I looked at my receipt, and it did say cajun burger. I did ask for the cajun sauce on the side but I never ordered a cajun burger. They corrected my order. I asked if there was a price adjustment. She said yes but never gave me a receipt. I was excited to try out a new place but, I'll never go back. read more

See all

I was craving a good burger, fries, and shake. Wayback Burgers hit the spot! I ordered the Cajun burger. It was hot, juicy, and delicious. Not as spicy as I expected. The fries were crispy & fresh, and the shake was nice and thick like I like it. I was greeted as soon as I walked in, and felt very welcome. My sister and I arrived around 4:40pm, we decided to eat inside. No one else was dining in but it was a very nice atmosphere. read more

Wayback Burgers - CHOCOLATE MILKSHAKE - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

So I'm just going to tell you this place has gone down hill when it comes to the night and weekend shifts. Really young staff likely teenagers. We came in around 810 this evening and placed our order at the counter. There were two staff members one who was consumed with cleaning while the other took care of the counter and the kitchen. We ordered the value baskets they have on special right now, one single and one double basket. I got the double with tater tots and they gave me 9 tots. Everything was hot and fresh, my burger was cooked maybe to medium well so I endured through it but my preference is no pink. My other family member got the single and it was cooked barely to medium. So he took it back to the counter and the girl and the counter took it from him said nothing and walked away rolling her eyes. When our food was finally ready the kitchen the guy put it on the counter and told the girl cleaning the order was ready and she just kept cleaning for a few minutes before finally bringing our food. We confronted her about the attitude and eye roll and she denied it, she was also making so much noise with the chairs it made the experience unenjoyable. Food is alway good here it's the service and portions (this time) that's the problem. I am pretty sure the manager that's here during the day is also the owner, things go a lot better when she's around. You won't get a better burger around here but service must improve for us to continue to dine here. read more

Wayback Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Food wasn't bad however I almost walked out what the gave. Luckily I was waiting for my brothers food to arrive also and the person came with two things the forgot to put in my bag. At that point they should've given me something for free ;) read more

Had been wanting to try this place since it opened and finally went tonight... Greeted by the friendly and helpful staff, as we entered and ordered. The restaurant was pretty clean and we ordered our food for dining in. Unfortunately, it took 24 minutes from the time we place our order until the time it arrived. This was a lot longer than we expected. (We ordered around 7:50pm, so definitely not during the dinner time rush.) Burger was delivered as ordered. Hot fresh and accurate. Burger looked and smelled great, and if we had to compare it to another fast food chain burger the consensus at our table was Wendy's-ish in flavor. (Just not Wendy's pricing) We had bacon cheese fries... (consensus we were not a fan of the fries). Mid at best... read more

Wayback Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

This spot is very clean. The service is 5 stars!!! While the staff is young, they are very attentive and polite. I appreciate that and good job!! The food is where I lost a star. The fries are meh. The tater tots are crispy and fine. The burgers are a good size but they lack flavor. A little bit of seasoning would make these 5 stars for me. The buns are nice and soft. The best thing I had was the cookie butter milk shake !! 10/10! Cookie butter is one of my favorite flavors and this was delicious. I could taste the cookie butter and it didn't taste artificial. It was very rich and buttery but not overly sweet. Sadly it's only here for a limited time! read more

Wayback Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Nice, family friendly, clean. I had a tasty Cajun burger; sauce was good. They have real Cheddar . The quality of the meat is just ok. That's what keeping these from being a 4.5-5 star burger. Fries were decent as well. overall a good experience. read more

Wayback Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

The build your own burger option was great to see. The Impossible burger was generously portioned and cooked well. Other meat burgers included two patties. We also tried the fries, cheese curds, and fried pickles. They were good, nothing special. Employees were friendly. Parking is ample as well. read more

Wayback Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Pretty average burgers and food. It was a typical burger spot. It was our first time trying them.

Wayback was an exceptional burger joint and the restraunt itself is very modern and has a open floor plan. The people working here have a very positive attitude which helps to improve the experience. I ordered a double with cheese ans nothing else on it and it came out hot and correct. I also ordered the side of fries with the chilli and cheese and they were amazing and crispy. This will be one of my quick go to burger joints in this area. read more

Wayback Burgers - Chilling cheese fries - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

It's burgers and a great chicken sandwich, elevated by unique flavor options and Amazing shakes!!! This is a female-owned business that is people-focused and inclusive. The food is delicious and an elevated version of a great burger spot. The fries, the tots (cajun-spiced tots), and the onion rings hit the spot. Throw in the cinnamon toast shake, and there's a little bit of magic here! The team is friendly and available when needed but never intrusive. If catering is what you need, they are also working with EZ catering to make that an option. The owner came out to check on us and shared a little of her passion for great food and the great team at Wayback, which she uses to provide a memorable and delicious dining experience for her guests. read more

See all

Tried this place the other night and it was ok. The fried pickles were very salty and the burgers were just average not much flavor to the meat. Food was still hot when I got it home so that was nice. read more

Everyone is friendly and professional, food is freshly made,hot and amazing I would recommend this 100% read more

Wayback Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

My Grandson and I have been on a journey to find the best cheeseburger. He loves cheeseburgers so much his grandmother told him he was going to turn into a cheeseburger! So after visiting Wendy's, Steak n Shake, Burger King, DQ, and McDonald's I suggested Wayback burgers. After he ate a few bites he looked up and said Papa, Steak and Shake is no longer number one! I looked at him and smiled and said so this is the best cheeseburger? He said yes! We both laughed! The food was excellent and although it takes a minute I told him it's because they make it fresh! The fries were delicious and I like that they brought the food to me. Facility was clean and people were friendly! read more

Wayback Burgers - Grandson loves Wayback burgers! - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

A newer place in Fishers, we popped by to check it out. The space is clean and bright due to the windows. The staff working were very friendly. I had the double cheeseburger with tater tots. It was ok. I would venture back and try it again. read more

Wayback Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Service was good, young kids working. They were nice, polite and provided good service! a long wait for food. It's not a good value. The chicken was a nice juicy chicken breast. The onion fringe were not great, they were 5.39. See pic of serving size. We won't return. read more

Wayback Burgers - Onion rings. $5.39. - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

This is comparable to Shake Shack in flavor and cost. Flavor is okay but costs too much for just being okay. It is slightly better than Shake Shack because of the menu options. The service when I picked up my order was very friendly and considerate. My order filled 2 bags and I had 2 milkshakes. She brought my food to where I was sitting and waiting, and she made sure to bring a drink carrier. read more

See all

Great Grand Opening with an acoustic singer! Ordered the chili dog with toppings on side for my daughter she loved it with the fresh cut fries! Made to order juicy burgers were devoured along with the Cajun Burger and Cheese Curds! Excellent chocolate shake as no milk is on menu for kiddos but totally worth her smiles! The service is counter service and open air kitchen watching them make everything to order! Fun environment and staff were so friendly! They have a drive thru can't wait to see this location to grow and great location! read more

See all

I order from Wayback quite often because it's close to where I live. This isn't the first time I've had issues with missing items. But I did think their response was odd when I informed them of missing items. To preface: the bag was sealed and I met the delivery driver outside. I sent an email to Wayback letting them know I had missing fries and the ranch that went with my chicken tenders "boxed" meal. The reply from Wayback: "Sorry that happened. I reviewed the cameras and everything went into the bag. I'll reach out to the delivery partner and let them know your concerns." I emailed back asking what was seen on the cameras? Because my bag was sealed upon arrival. No more communication from Wayback. I wanted to see the camera footage. 1. That's disturbing if someone is removing items out of the bag and able to not disturb the seal. 2. That's wrong if WayBack is trying to push an issue off on someone that's not responsible. read more

Wayback Burgers - Wayback order - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Saw this place from the highway, decided I need to try it. Ordered online. I had a code for a free milkshake, but after a number of tries, I could not figure out where to put the code in. This was disappointing. My food was ready pretty quickly. I order right before closing, but the staff was super friendly. Fries are fresh cut and good. Burgers are big. Probably should have gotten singles. They are tasty. This place seems like an upscale, better version of Five Guys. read more

Food was delicious and fast! Staff is amazing and clean facilities and will stop again when in the area

Me and my fiance get food from wayback all the time, always good and staff is always nice and has helpful suggestions for first timers.

The service is top notch, the food is amazing! The one and only criticism is the app. You can't make the items a meal like in the store. Ordering everything separately is really expensive compared to ordering as a meal in the store. That definitely needs to be fixed. If it's on the menu, it should be in the app. Still it's amazing and the kids love it. Best fries ever!!! read more

Wayback Burgers - Steak and Swiss sandwich with extra meat, side of fries, my favorite!!! - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Good food. Music so loud I could barely order. Shockingly messy. Floors and tables really dirty.

Nice eating spot seemed to be a local favorite. We were visiting from California and heard about the burgers. Every burger is You c customized to order the day we visited it was only two staff they could have used so help read more

Wayback burgers is Indy's newest place to enjoy a fresh burger in a fun, upbeat atmosphere. We were greeted with a warm hello from the helpful staff, who also checked in on us throughout our dining experience. The food is delicious. Our family tried the double bacon cheeseburger, double burger (+wayback gold), chili hotdog, Cajun tots and fries. The Cajun tots and classic burger were my favorite. The smash style patty is delightful along with all the fresh topping and condiment options. My son and I have a dairy and egg allergy and their online menu helped us select items that were allergen friendly ahead of our visit. We were excited the buns, tots and hotdog didn't contain milk or eggs! Others in my family said the cinnamon toast milkshake was amazing. The restaurant style is modern, fast-casual. read more

Wayback Burgers - Store front - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

First time trying Wayback today, but won't be the last. I had the classic cheeseburger with some changes and fries. They were both delicious. The burger could use a little salt, but otherwise, I loved it. The fries were hot, crispy and everything I want in fries. Found out from my friend that I could have added Cajun seasoning to them. Maybe next time. Her son got the cheese curds and they were really good also. I would definitely buy them too. My friend raced about her red velvet milkshake. I was just too full for a shake. The staff was really nice also. They came by a couple of different times to make sure everything was okay and to see if we needed anything. Had great food, great service, with great friends. Takes me Wayback to the good ole days :) read more

Went here yesterday evening to celebrate my birthday with family and my son who had went here the day before and recommend . The burgers, the fries and the tots were very good as was the service as they are very accommodating and always close by to bring us anything we wanted. The setting was fine other than the cold air coming through the doors and not quite enough area to sit for a Friday evening and the place was clean all had a good price read more

Really good juicy burgers fry's are really good staff was really nice would go again menu was nicely displayed the waitress was very nice and it was a very good restaurant and I look forward to going back soon. read more

Wayback Burgers - B BOURBON BACON BURGER - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

The burgers are juicy, fresh and delicious with nice fresh toppings. Their chicken sandwich is perfectly breaded white breast meat. The onion rings they serve are some of the best we've ever eaten and if you're in the mood for something else, they have wonderful tater tots. The staff there is always friendly and welcoming. This is our favorite place for burgers. read more

Wayback Burgers - Crispy Chicken BLT with onion rings - Burgers Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

A newer place. I'd never been to this location before but had eaten at the one in Evansville a few weeks prior. I like their menu. Lots of burgers, plus stuff like cheesesteaks and other handhelds. Salads as well as shakes. I ordered the A1 Steakhouse Burger. It's very very good. The fries were good too, and the bill was fine. Counter service. They have a rewards program that's excruciatingly confusing and convoluted to figure out how to enroll in and use. I eventually gave up, even after two of the employees tried to figure out how to do it (they were unsuccessful as well). I can see this being a once or twice a year kind of place. It won't bowl you over, but it offers really good food at a very good price. read more

Their burgers and their shakes are indefinitely tasty, but I was left wishing my burger was a bit bigger and far less greasy than it was. I'll be back on the occasions where a greasy burger feels like it will hit the spot, but this isn't my top burger spot. Highly recommend their shakes, though they were a bit pricier than I'd hoped read more