This is a little tricky -- the place definitely doesn't have that fresh/clean look inside. It seems…read morea bit run down and maybe even dingy. But maybe think of it as a cast iron pan? Because my family loves the food from here. The burgers are everything you'd want in a smash burger -- flavorful, cooked to perfection, a good portion, and lots of tasty toppings. The fries are also seasoned well -- my kids usually don't like french fries, but they devour the ones from here. The staff is terrific, and the music inside is great, too. So, if don't let the first visual impression of the interior get to you, you'll be in for a great meal.

Not sure what happened, but it's been closed for a couple of months, there are cones across the…read moreentrance. Personally I think it's a bad location even for a fast food restaurant, as other establishments before them at the same location closed after a year or so too.

I have ordered from this place twice so this review is basically a "first impression". What they…read moreget right: Plenty of parking Friendly service Plenty of offerings Cheeseburger is pretty good compared to most places in this neighborhood Actual Wings are about on par (size, flavor) with most of the local joints but the have a ton of different sauce flavors that all sound appealing. Things that were questionable: Cash only Bottled drinks only Prices seem a little high (locally) The wings come just drowning in sauce. I ordered mine on a bed of fries (thinking I would save $) but there was so much sauce on the order I couldn't see the fries and they came out a gloppy soggy mess. Check your order before you leave to see that you actually get the extras you paid for because I didn't. I guess the review reflects the fact that neither I nor my wife finished our (small) orders of wings. I like buffalo Bills better but they are further away.

Ordered a SteakSalad. It was steakums frozen food! $ 12 !!! When you order steak you expect STEAK…read more IT WAS DISGUSTING! Dog food!

The burgers were fresh, moist and tasty. The buns are from a bakery and the meat comes from a…read morebutcher. The staff is friendly, attentive and informative. We will definitely be returning!

Fast friendly service. Best burgers around. Love the chicken wings…read more Owners and staff are very welcoming

The review I posted on the 23rd disappeared, so this is a rewrite of that review…read more My granddaughter got the regular beef burger (can't remember the name of that one) and I got the Wagyu burger as usual. If it isn't broke, don't fix it. The food, of course, was good, served hot and as ordered. No complaints. Our server, Amy was outstanding. She was very knowledgeable and patient (we asked a lot of questions). She was also very friendly, genuinely friendly, not forced friendly because she had to be. You can always tell. It felt like being at an old friend's house for dinner. Great service truly (imo) enhances the meal. I'd definitely want Amy for our server the next time we visit!

Great branding concept, menu full of fun flavor combinations, and very active social media…read morepresence. Burgatory is exactly what modern restaurants should be. They aim to make a memorable experience with clever marketing, current food trends, and very customizable items. This location is even cooler as it pays homage to the once Blue Spruce Motel that was demolished for the current shopping mall. The wall has a cool graphic with the callout and the fits perfectly into the decor. Only downfall is the online ordering pickup. I get it... every restaurant wants to find a way to minimally impact their employees with fulfilling orders for takeout. But sending customers to the bar and forcing them to flag down the bartender... it's just not right. Designate a counter spot, add signage, or bring the bags to the front desk... For a company up on everything, this location should reconsider how they serve takeout orders. Still the food was phenomenal... We split a Sonoma Chopped Chicken Salad. Burgatory salads are HUGE! And the ingredients are always super fresh... I mean look at how perfect the avocado is! We tried the wings and... wow! The skin was so perfectly crisp and the seasoning was just spot on with spice and flavor. We tried the onion rings... and well... you can't win them all. The batter was soggy and way too thick. Not sure even the perfect cook could've crisped and fully cooked the batter. We won't be doing these again.

Grabbed a quick lunch with some friends while we were close by in zelienople for the afternoon. I…read morewasn't super hungry so went with a mini smash and got the Maggie's farm burger. It was pretty good, the flavors were a high point but just an average smash burger patty I'd say. I also got their hazy ipa which was nice to sip on, on a hot day and pretty refreshing. Service was fine.

Overpriced no flavor burgers with poor service and long wait for food…read more The menu options looked promising with a variety of burger choices. I went with the "MEXICAN WAR ST". What I got after a 20 min wait was a messy smashed thin patty with toppings that could not be identified. Was it worth the wait? No. There is a place in Dallas (Rodeo Goat) that I thought this place would be similar. Wasn't even close. Service was barely there with an attitude, while place was pretty empty , a bit surprising.

Came here for Mother's Day lunch. Staff were very friendly. The food was delicious and the…read moreportion was large enough I had to get a to go box. Definitely coming back.

Breakfast warning. Do NOT get the bacon. They 'deep fry' it and it looks and tastes like a strip…read moreof leather. I think I may have broken the dish had I banged the bacon on it. I 'asked' for 'pan fried' bacon, but there is no way this was pan fried. The eggs were good, but stay away from the bacon, cooks there do not know how to make a proper strip.

Best burgers around. 4th street is where it's at…read more.. You don't come to Irwin hungry and not stop at Burgher Burger. After lunch, you stop by Millers and Feathers for personalized shopping, then grab some Ice cream at McFeelys on the way out!

Handsome husband and I came to Burgher Burger for the second time last Saturday. Hubby got the…read moreMitchell Burger-- two stacked patties, pastrami, lettuce, tomato and BurgherB sauce. I got the Mander burger-- two stacked patties, Brie cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and raspberry mayo. It was DELICIOUS. The Brie was tasty and soft and they put on a generous amount. I took a gamble ordering something with unique flavors and it definitely paid off. The Brie paired well with the raspberry mayo. The server was efficient, attentive and pleasant. It's a cozy atmosphere. With the refillable fresh cut fries, you're getting plenty of food and more bang for your buck! It's a great location- we went to Feathers Gift Shop and McFeely's for sweets afterwards and enjoyed walking around downtown.

The food was so so delicious! The best thing is their service, they are so nice. Also it looked…read morelike they opened yesterday it was so clean. Highly recommended! The kids menu is AMAZING!

We decided to try valley dairy for dinner because we absolutely love breakfast and lunch but I'm so…read moresad to say it was HORRIBLE .We both took maybe 3 bites of our dinner and felt sick. My mashed potatoes were crusty on top and my boyfriends food looked like a pile of throw up. The fried pickles were really good though.

So I had gone to the former GM Burgers for YEARS!! Dad's is now in its place and I couldn't be…read morehappier. They do an amazing job paying homage to GM with dare I say even better food? Got to stop by on a recent visit home and was so pleased to see my neighborhood spot (lived half a block away) being immortalized with the most delicious smash burgers and fries! It's like Pittsburgh's own In -n- Out but better. Kudos! Get there stat! Delish times a gazillion. Bloomfield rules.

This place is great. Had the hotdog and fries and it did not disappoint…read more I will back.

Service was amazing and so was the food! 2 servers and they did a great job! Nico is making his…read moreGrandparents proud! They were great friends of ours.

One of the worst experiences we've had eating out. My girlfriend's burger was cooked like a hockey…read morepuck. Bacon was so overcooked she couldn't cut it. They took it off the bill, but made no apologies, didn't offer anything else. Very disappointed. Then they blocked me on Facebook with no response to the issue. Would give zero stars if I could