1. Wickersham Jewelry

    1. Wickersham Jewelry

    0

    Marshfield, WI

    Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Wickersham Jewelry

    1.0 (1 review)
    Open 10:00 am - 6:00 pm
    Updated 2 months ago

    Wickersham Jewelry Photos

    Recommended Reviews - Wickersham Jewelry

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Wickersham Jewelry

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Paul Gross Jewelers

    Paul Gross Jewelers

    3.0(4 reviews)
    26.2 mi
    $$$

    I am not from the Wisconsin Rapids area, but have been making my purchases from Robin for twenty…read moreplus years. If you really what something special, Robin is the go to. Especially with diamonds, she buys them for you in Belgium and at a very reasonable cost. In store repairs and cleaning is a plus also. Paul Gross is a "Jewelry Store", not a costume jewelry store. If that is what you are looking for, try Walmart.

    There are a few areas of concern that I want to address about this business. First a little about…read moreme. I have been working in the jewelry business for over a decade and have made multiple trip abroad to gather gems and fine jewelry alike. I always try and work with local jewelers as they are often rooted in the community which gives support back to that community. With that being said, the biggest concern that I would warn people in the Wisconsin Rapids area is that Paul Gross, in specific Robin, has a very entitled opinion and frankly can be very standoffish. I brought a loose diamond in to have set - when asked if they could set this the first request was what type of setting do I want to have.... this is typical and expected. I chose a couple different settings and when I asked about price I was amazed at what I heard. Now, I know the lights have to get paid, but for a simple setting with less that 60 ct. pts, I would not expect platinum to come in at over 2800 USD. Taken back a bit, I explained I may use my own setting and have their gold smith set it for me. Needless to say, I left the store with a very unsure answer and frankly I felt like as soon as I just asked for the stone to be set no one else in the store wanted toe help me. I know 200 USD isn't the typical 5k plus they want for sales, but remember this is a small community and a sale is a sale. I called back about three days later and asked if they would be willing to set the stone. The owner gave me a blunt answer of "NO." I then asked where else in town I could get this set, after a lengthy explanation of why she didn't know I said thank you and good bye. In short this business is garbage: 1. No customer support 2. Not willing to give you the time of day if you won't drop a serious dollar 3. Rude 5. Over bearing 6. Lies I would never go to a jeweler I do not trust... and I DO NOT TRUST THESE FOLKS.

    Eric's Diamonds & Fine Jewelry - Engagement Ring

    Eric's Diamonds & Fine Jewelry

    3.9(7 reviews)
    62.9 mi

    i went here for the first time yesterday. ( I have been searching for a jeweler since I moved back…read morehome 4 years ago)... and omg they are THE BEST. They took such great care of me, eased all my concerns & worries & were just really amazing. Thank you ladies for all your help. So happy to have found a place & people I can trust with things that are very precious & special to me. 10 stars!

    I have bought my rings from Eric's Diamonds for years and then when the new owners took over…read moreeverything went downhill. The band on my anniversary ring broke and so I took it in to be fixed. The woman that waited on me said that it would take 2 weeks. But I wasn't going to get it back until July when they reopen again after a 1-week break. So, on July 10th I went to pick up my ring. The girl that waited on me gave me my ring and I put it on. But it didn't fit. I told her that it fit before it was fixed and I asked what happened? I told her that the day I dropped if off I asked the woman who took my ring about sizing my figure to make sure she had the right size and she told me that no need to because she would just pinch it and tap back together. I couldn't even get the ring over my knuckle. So, I asked what it cost to get the ring sized and she said $221.00. I asked does that include the $75 for fixing the ring and she said no. I told her I wasn't going to pay for that and that it was their mistake that they didn't size my ring to make sure it was put back to the right size. I will never shop there again. The anniversary ring was given to me by my husband after 35 years of marriage. Now I can't even wear because Eric's Diamonds ruined it.

    Photos
    Eric's Diamonds & Fine Jewelry - Wedding bands, Anniversary bands

    Wedding bands, Anniversary bands

    Eric's Diamonds & Fine Jewelry - Diamond Ring

    Diamond Ring

    Eric's Diamonds & Fine Jewelry - Tanzanite ring

    See all

    Tanzanite ring

    Wickersham Jewelry - jewelry - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...