I needed my ring resized and I originally went to the mall and stopped at a few chain stores (big…read moremistake), the employees were so rude. I decided to take my business to this small business and I was pleasantly surprised. The employees here are SO kind and helpful. I really appreciated how they made me feel comfortable because I was nervous walking into a jewelry store to begin with because I am young and I don't have a lot of experience with jewelry. I was given the option to pay a little bit extra to have my ring done sooner and my ring was done within hours! I will definitely be back for any of my jewelry needs in the future! Please don't waste your time at Kay, Zales, Jared, etc. this place is wonderful!

I went there because I needed to replace just the clasp for a watchband. The young lady who helped…read moreme didn't try to pressure me into buying anything, and she gave great service at a great price. I highly recommend that you try them out!

Rummeles Jewelry and "Mr. Rolex" delivered truly best-in-class customer service…read more Growing up in this blue-collar town, I never imagined I would one day own a Rolex. When the time finally came and I was ready to make that investment, there was no question where I was going -- straight to David, the absolute godfather of sourcing unique and hard-to-find models. He exceeded every expectation. From the first conversation to the final handshake, the experience was personal, professional, and memorable. David not only secured my Rolex Sky-Dweller masterpiece, but he also took the time to walk me through every feature with care and precision. The attention to detail and genuine excitement for his clients is unmatched. And yes -- celebrating the moment with a well-earned beer afterward made it even more special. I couldn't be more proud or grateful for the experience. If you're considering a fine timepiece and want white-glove treatment with hometown integrity, Rummeles is the only place to go. Highly recommend.

Adjustment of Citizen watch band. Helped immediately…read more Very professional/polite. Adjustment done quickly and proficiently. Didn't pressure (soft suggestion only) to make purchase of additional jewelry items....which probably will bring me back to purchase jewelry as holiday gift. Only thing I didn't like was the pawn store...buzz in...vibe front door....this town has no idea what crime is....which unfortunately exaggerates the "needs" to combat the "what if's" of a high end jewelry heist across the street from the POLICE STATION....come on. Keep it classy.

Mitch and his staff took very good care of us! I highly recommend Feldstein!!! Mitch wasn't not in…read morea hurry, showed us many styles and helped us pick the perfect ring. Very, very satisfied!

Made my rings look like new! I've used other jewelers before but nobody made my rings look so…read morebeautiful! I'm so happy with the work they did.

A locally woman owned fashion boutique with women's clothing and accessories. Great selection and…read morethe owner is so sweet and helpful! Great selection of jewelry and all kinds of high quality clothing.

Jeweler Kim Pedler rocks!! He is an artist who creates his own designs and executes each piece to…read moreperfection. He and wife Tammy have established a trusted name for themselves in the community, and Kim has won many awards for his unique, custom creations. The shop is fun to visit, with many unusual hand-made items which you will not find anywhere else. Even if jewelry is not your bag, you must stop in to browse the numerous other eclectic works of art and craft on display. Always something new! Love this shop!

I purchased a ring there in August and the stone fell out.I found it and contacted them.I sent it…read moreto them and it was returned quickly,they even reimbursed me for my postage sending it to them. So nice to deal with.I would highly recommend them.You don't get this type of customer service much these days.Thank you Pennisula Jewlers.

I had the most wonderful experience picking up my jewelry today. From start to finish, the entire…read moreprocess felt thoughtful, professional, and genuinely welcoming. The staff made me feel valued and never rushed, and they took the time to walk me through each piece carefully. The craftsmanship is stunning -- every detail is exactly what I hoped for (if not better). You can truly tell they take pride in the quality of their work and the stones they select. Purchasing fine jewelry should feel special, and they absolutely delivered. I left feeling excited, confident, and already planning my next visit. Highly recommend!

Service innitially was good I thought , they low balled me really badly on a pawn loan for a .22…read morerifle , it was a 400+ dollar item and the gave me 75.00 on a loan do I thought np I could just pay it back easy and pick it back up because I have a clean record and have purchased guns several times through dunhams and other firearms sellers like Virlee gunworks . I went to pay off and pickup and they started the background and it got a delay as they sometimes do so I waited and waited then called back and they said no update , waited another week they said still no update still in delay , mind you they are perfectly able to either call again for an update or bypass it because the 3day wait was well beyond and it is completely their choice if they want to return the gun or not , but why would they ? They get to keep a 400 dollar gun for 75 what a deal eh ? I will call them one more time and if this isn't settled I will be contacting a firearms rights lawyer and persuing actions . This is just scummy behavior and I understand once the gun is in their posession it is their discretion but they is very obviously purposely done for monitary gain or just plain ignorance , I have NO record and I was always very patient with them , no raising of voice or anything erraric that would ever suggest they would have cause to keep my firearm . I have already contacted nics about this and the first thing they asked was "did the shop call us back" us meaning nics , they had not . This is bad even for a pawn shop .

Fixed my RR watch where the ring holding down the basal came off by accident. Staff was polite,…read morepersonable,very knowledgeable and had my watch back within half the time they estimated it would take at A very reasonable cost! You have gained our future business as our preferred provider and we are so glad we checked you out. By the way, thank you Adam for a perfect job done on the watch.

The best jewelry store in Green Bay, high quality jewelry, great designers and a wonderful variety…read more I have a beautiful collection of pieces from Diamonds and Gold and plan to keep collecting! One of the best things is they are not snarky pretentious people here. I walked into Rummles once after I was at the gym and couldn't get anyone to help me, must have felt I was beneath them In my workout clothes. Diamonds and Gold treats everyone with respect and can help everyone with their jewelry needs

My husband and I just got back from a visit to Rogers & Hollands at Bay Park Square in Ashwaubenon,…read moreWi. Normally, I don't find the time to write up a review on Yelp. However, I am making time because our experience was exceptional! Upon our arrival, we were warmly greeted by the manager and the sales associates. Gina is the associate who stands out in my mind. She was informative and sincerely happy to assist us. Gina offered suggestions and advice without the pressure that I've felt at other jewelry stores. At times it seems like customer service, in general, has become something of the past. Not so at Rogers & Hollands. Thank you for making our experience a pleasurable one!

I went to Rogers & Hollands Jewelers on a specific quest to find a Hamilton Green Dial 40mm watch…read more I was pleasantly surprised to be greeted by Gregg Heller, the Assistant Store Manager. Although he didn't have that particular watch in stock, Gregg's love for timepieces and his knowledge of the Hamilton line got me to stick around. Before I knew it, he was showing me other watches in Hamilton's collection that were perfect for me. Normally, I wouldn't pull the trigger on an impulse purchase, preferring to do my research online, but Gregg's passion for Hamilton watches, and his focus on what I wanted out of a watch convinced me to buy. He offered me a fair price and made the entire shopping experience a joy. I will be returning to this store whenever I visit Green Bay!