Sampled Lemon Italian Ice- will get next time. This was an ice cream kinda day. I got Double chocolate,(or some such). Delish. Our waitress was so patient and kind. read more

Just horrible in my opinion I had a few ice cream places. I definitely wouldn't recommend this. I got chocolate chip chocolate cookie sandwich the vanilla version of it and a twisted cone with a topping 15 but OK that's understandable a little pricey, but the fact that it taste like frostbite and hard as a rock Horrible never again. read more

Yellow Brick Road Ice Cream Shop - Chocolate chocolate chip cookie sandwich - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

My favorite ice cream shop ! Nice selection my boys love it . People are friendly there and it's close !

I was so excited to try this place because of the theming and it was amplified after looking at the flavor list. What a let down. I was excited to try the Fruity Pebble- tasting Play Doh but it didn't taste like Fruity Pebbles at all. Even my little one made a face and I never saw him do that with ice cream. I opted for the Brookie Dough, which I probably should have sampled also. It ended up being more like cookies and cream to the point where I actually went inside to look again and make sure I got the right order. There was barely any cookie dough at all. The kids got Cookie Monster and regular cookie dough. We get Cookie Monster from our local place often, so my son was set on it. He didn't even want to eat this though. Odd taste, barely any cookie. Same thing with my daughter - I was prodding her to eat and then I tasted it - odd taste, barely any cookie. It tasted syrupy, maybe like maple. My husband loves s'more flavored ice cream so got the Philly Graham Slam and that was the most tolerable, though not even close to other versions. I am surprised to see the line out the door when we drive by. I don't think it's inedible, but I would rather opt for another place. The outside area to sit and eat was nice, mostly clean, and they provided wet towels in case the tables needed cleaning. That was a pretty cool touch, and I did enjoy the bit of Wizard of Oz soundtrack I was able to hear. It's not enough to make up for the flavor deficiency. read more

Great service! They made an icecream cake with our specifications to match the invitations! read more

Yellow Brick Road Ice Cream Shop - Icecream cake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

PROS: When I went there it was during the time of covid. They had many flavors posted on their door and the nicest staff serving you making sure everything went well and that they kept sanitary. The prices were normal for an ice cream place and the ice cream tasted great and was prepared well. CONS: Unfortunately, the parking lot is very tiny and there's hardly any seating. At the same time, it's a small building so when you're allowed to go inside it can be packed. Not sure if there's a bathroom open to the public either. OVERALL: Despite those cons I'd give this place a 4 stars because you have to keep in mind that its an ice cream parlor, not a diner, so these are common cons to smaller ice cream places. However, I have seen a good amount of ice cream parlors in the area that have a good size parking lot and a lot of room to sit inside read more

We threw a high school graduation party for my son this past weekend. He had requested an ice cream cake with a layer of regular cake. The Ice cream shops I normally go to did not make that type. This led me to try Yellow Brick Road, and I'm so glad that I did! I gave the order over the phone, and the employee was so helpful and friendly. The price of the cake was totally reasonable. But the very best part was how delicious the cake was. The vanilla and chocolate ice cream were so creamy, there were lots of crunchies, a layer of cake, and a layer of rich chocolate syrup. Everyone at the party absolutely raved about the cake! I don't believe I will ever get a cake anywhere else. read more

The ice cream is pretty good here but nothing out of this world, pretty average to be honest. I like the whole theme and concept of the yellow brick road and wizard of Oz carried throughout the place. There's a decent list of ice cream flavors ~20 and some pretty creative ones like Brookie Dough or Brownie S'mores. The ice cream sandwiches are usually a hit in my house, we like the chipwiches and they're a quick and easy grab if you're in a time crunch. This place does get busy quick and often times there's a line out the door so be prepared to wait. The inside usually gets very crowded and a bit hectic at times so it's best to know what you want ahead of time! read more

Of all the Ice Cream Places in the Brick/Point Pleasant area, they were the only ones able to recreate the vision I had for my sons first birthday cake! You could tell the ice cream cake was fresh and not one that had been frozen in a case for awhile. Will definitely been getting all of our ice cream cakes from there going forward! Thank you again Yellow Brick Road (: read more

Yellow Brick Road Ice Cream Shop - Ice cream cake - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

My daughter and I stopped in on Labor Day weekend to get an ice cream cake for my husband's birthday. While we were waiting for the cake to decorated, a very kind gentleman (maybe the owner?) asked if he could give my daughter a small ice cream with sprinkles for free. It was such a sweet gesture and my daughter was so happy! Even better, the ice cream cake was delicious and my husband and party guests were very happy with it. We are customers for life now. Thank you! read more

Saturday night my husband felt like having ice cream as we were driving home from dinner. We drove by Rita's to go to Yellow Brick Road. My husband has the simplest of tastes. He only eats Vanilla . He ordered Vanilla Ice Cream with Chocolate sprinkles. We got home to find out he was given Chocolate ice cream. He took one bite and put the remainder in the freezer where it will sit till eventually we throw it away. I get the message that it's hard finding workers, but this is ridiculous read more

I went to this place and was expecting a normal size Italian ice, instead I received a microscopic cup that u would use to take shot of whiskey with. My order was RAINBOW REGULAR SIZE Italian ice. Not only was the regular extremely small but the rainbow was not mixed. It was obviously cherry, blue raspberry, and lemon scooped in one tiny cup. I don't mind the flavors but I would've liked to known that they weren't mixed. It was also very expensive for the size of it. I will not be returning. read more

Yellow Brick Road Ice Cream Shop - The tiniest cup of Italian ice in the world - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

Ice cream was ok, milkshakes sucked. Asked for a peanut butter/vanilla shake and got vanilla icecream and actual peanuts in the shake... they have no idea what they're doing. Not returning read more

Let me start by saying this ice cream is terrific and is one of the few places that has peach..my favorite BUT when Alex handed me my one scoop I actually laughed. He said you want another scoop? I said sure, thinking that paying for the extra scoop would make it a normal size. Wrong! It was just another golf ball sized scoop on top of the first. Do yourself a favor and go to Hoffman's in Point Pleasant Twice the size for half the price. read more

Now this is a good ice cream place... away from all the hype of Seaside & the Point. Spent 10 mins just tasting different flavors. Nice shop with out door seating and you can get in some people watching as they drive by. read more

Yellow Brick Road Ice Cream Shop - Cherry-vanilla my fav!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

I don't eat a lot of ice cream - or much in the way of dessert-like food of any kind - but my wife and I have an annual tradition we call Ice Cream for Dinner Day, and we celebrate it every year at the Carousel. We went in last week, and I ordered a mocha shake. The girl behind the counter asked, "Is mocha chip okay? That's all we have." Huh? There are a few different ways to make a mocha shake, and using actual mocha ice cream is not one that would ever have occurred to me, but she didn't seem to know any of the others. Let's see... you could put coffee syrup in chocolate ice cream, or chocolate syrup in coffee ice cream. You could even combine coffee and chocolate ice cream. The girl was stumped, I tell you. When I suggested all of the alternatives, you could actually see the light bulb appear over her head, and then explode from the overload. Sometimes I cry myself to sleep thinking about our poor world and how, someday, it will be held hostage by our most current crop of high school graduates. A big selling feature at the Carousel is the fact that they make waffles. There isn't much better than soft vanilla ice cream on a hot Belgian waffle, though I can only eat a bite or two. To me, it's one of those one note dishes where the flavor and texture, lovely though they may be, start to make me feel very ill in short order. My wife, however, loves them dearly and seems impervious to their effects. I believe she forces herself to stop three quarters of the way through, because she feels that to eat the whole thing by herself would be unseemly. They used to have a wide and varied selection of both common and unusual candies, but it appears the owners have shifted away from that. I was shocked to find candy cigarettes for sale as recently as two years ago; you may remember those fine confections of what seemed to be sugar and chalk, touched by a hint of wintergreen. Really? In this day and age? If I hadn't seen them, I'd have never believed any company was so bereft of good conscience as to still manufacture them. There were five packs left, and it was obvious that the candy operation was winding down, so I bought them just to get them off the rack and away from children's eyes. I display them on a bookshelf in my living room; they are an interesting artifact, and quite the conversation piece. Being that there are thankfully few instances of bad ice cream through the courses of our lives, there is no way I could recommend against the Carousel. Also, their prices are very reasonable, and the portions tend toward large, if you're the sort who goes for cheap and plentiful. You should definitely stop and treat yourself to something on one of these beautiful summer evenings we've been blessed with lately; it's one of those small things we don't always think to do, but that bring real joy to life. read more

Great ice cream - totally hits the spot. I got chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream in a waffle cone with sprinkles; The Man got a chocolate malted shake. Both were awesome - and I don't even like malteds. The setup of this place is a little off-putting - 'chaotic' would be the best way to describe it. But the employees are very friendly and helpful. And the ice cream is super good! read more

I've been going here for years, even undertook their "pail of ice cream" challenge when they used to have it. That was basically a pail literally with ice cream that earns you a spin on their prize wheel and your name on the wall though I don't believe they do that anymore. I did cheat by sharing, ha! Best milkshakes around and the chocolate brownie yogurt is a delicious, kind of sorta low-fat treat. Fun too, can't go wrong. read more

THE BEST!! Only ice cream shop in Brick I will go to. When they close for the season, I stock up on their ice cream cakes and go to their Silverton location for regular ice cream often! Their ice cream is awesome, their Italian ice is awesome and their cakes are awesome. My dog loves their dog ice cream treats as well! They all around have great products of all sorts. Their owner is such a doll- so so sweet and she gives back to the community, which is awesome! Love YBR, my favorite ice cream place. read more

On my way to a meeting and I pass this shop. I stop by and try a sundae. I was greeted warmly. They have many flavors of hard ice cream and the typical soft serve. My sundae was large and they give good portions. The place is clean and inviting. Located on the road and easy to see with its yellow exterior. The prices seem to be the standard rate. Go, check it out and enjoy!!! read more

Yellow Brick Road Ice Cream Shop - Large Sundae with whipped cream and two toppings Nice!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Brick, New Jersey

My husband surprised me with a chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream cake for my birthday. With delicious creamy ice cream and lots of different layers and textures, This was by far the best ice cream cake I've ever had, and I'm no rookie. Apparently they're a little pricey, but dang read more

Ice cream is very creamy and good. Hubby & I got vanilla I cream with cherry dip.. yum.. kids ordered playdoh cookie monster cotton candy all the ice cream is good and reasonably-priced. read more

Great Place, Awesome flavors, Kid friendly! .....highly, highly recommend, certainly a family summer staple!

Ice cream is unbelievable! The cakes though... oh my goodness. They should be illegal. We get yellow brick road cakes for any occasion, and I even started getting them for work friends! Mantoloking rd is closed in the winter, but hooper is open year round. Decor in both locations is a bit odd, but overlook it. read more

Love Yellow Brick Road on a hot summer day! Great ice cream and friendly service. read more

Best place with the best atmosphere and the best people! I love getting a cannoli sundae here!

Love this place. The woman owner is such a doll. The people ice cream is great, but they also have dog ice cream. Whenever we go there, we walk and bring our dog. He sits outside, and she comes outside with a complementary treat for him and some water. Dogs also get a complementary cup of vanilla ice cream. She's checked with a vet and the ice cream is totally fine for the dogs. Also, she has a freezer filled with dog ice cream sandwiches and dog ice cream cakes with dog cookies on it. She's a total dog lover and we love it!!! It's so nice to be treated so well and then also have your pet treated so well! I would always give them lots of business! read more

Great local shop. They made a beautiful and delicious ice cream cake for my sons birthday. Highly recommend!

They keep on up in the price on their ice cream I can get a whole container ice cream at the store with the price that they're selling it for earlier two scoops of it with toppings I just got ice cream sandwiches tonight and I was not impressed with the price of it basically $10 for 6 ice cream sandwiches I do not recommend that I will be going back read more

Super creamy mint chocolate chip ice cream! Service was quick and staff was friendly! Nice little spot!

Horrible parking lot. Your taking your life in your hands pulling in and out of there. No good outside seating either. Ice cream ok but I think Hoffmans or sundaes is way better. read more

Best ice cream around! Absolutely love the peanut butter twirl flavor. I also think it's really cool that they have different fun soft serve flavors each week aside from the vanilla and chocolate. Hands down my favorite ice cream place! read more