We always loved this place - but clearly the owners, managers, and workers could literally care less about customer experience. The second to last time we ordered online for pickup, my husband and I each got our own pizza. Each pizza had several ingredients on it. For some bizarre reason, they piled my pizza high with ingredients (which is great) and they put almost no ingredients on his pizza. It was basically a cheese pizza with a few scattered toppings. But we didn't discover this until we drove all the way home. So my husband was stuck with a pizza that wasn't very good, because he doesn't like cheese pizza. I don't understand why they would completely cover one pizza and not the other. I filled out the feedback form AND the contact form. Zero response. Many weeks later, we decided that it had to be a fluke, and decided to order online for pickup again. We were in a hurry, but I figured that if we wrote a note on the receipt to please cover BOTH pizzas with a lot of ingredients, they would. So I did. We picked the pizzas off and headed off to meet a friend. Unfortunately, when we arrived, we discovered that YET AGAIN they did the EXACT same thing. My pizza was absolutely covered - excessively so, including an absolute carpet of arugula on top. And my husband's was basically a cheese pizza. To be honest, it felt like they read my note, and decided to leave the ingredients off of one, just to spite us for asking. I don't know that that is actually what happened - but I couldn't figure out why one was absolutely coated and the other wasn't. It was really weird. So, AGAIN - I filled out the feedback form AND contacted them through the website. Nothing but complete silence. Management couldn't even be bothered to reply or try to make it right. So the only conclusion that I can draw is that they not only do not care about customer experience, but that they actively spite their customers. Don't eat here unless you can watch them make yoyr pizza in front of you. If they mess it up, they will not care and they will never make it right. read more

See all

So, we were next door at the jump park, and after a good hour and half of jumping, my kiddos were ready for lunch. Luckily, this place was just a couple doors down. They both like pizza, so it was an easy win. The set up here is kind of like those MOD pizza chains - you can basically make your own pizza from any of the ingredients/toppings they have available and then they fire it right there for you. They have some pre-made recipes as suggestions - I went ahead and ordered the margarita and my kids just got plain cheese. The pizza itself was okay. It wasn't amazing, but for "fast food" pizza it was tasty and filling enough that it did the trick. The kids meals came with a scoop of their gelato, which really was a treat for me (I've got one kid who doesn't do ice cream, so I got his scoop of the mango - delicious! - while my little one got vanilla - also good). Service was fast and friendly, and the dining room was clean and spacious. Overall, a good experience! read more

See all

People working here were kind, really care about their customers and the quality of the food. The two young guys working New Year's Day had really good customer service skills. Definitely coming back. read more

Arrived and waited to place an order. There was no one in line ahead of us but the three people working on preparing pizzas ignored me for at least five minutes. I finally asked if I was supposed to order somewhere else and one of them said, no, you order here. We continued to wait another five minutes before they took our order. My husband came out of the bathroom meanwhile with our children where a paper towel dispenser fell off the wall and cut my son's eye. Our pizza was edible but burned on one half. When we received our caesar salad we put on the dressing and started to mix it up revealing a salad riddled with rotten lettuce. We requested a refund for the salad and then told them about the paper towel dispenser. They said sorry and walked away. read more

Came here real quick for Dinner!! with the fam. It wasn't packed but it was enough people inside. The staff were pleasant , greeted us and took each of us at different points immediately!.. everyone ordered pizza! & salad or just pizza!. I got my usual whenever I stop in! The Lineage which is a supreme deluxe! But hold the black olives. It's so flavorful from the sauce to the ingredients which they don't skimp on your whole pizza is covered beautifully lol. The brick oven is nice and cooks evenly never met a crust burnt or undercooked pizza yet!. I got my free order of cheese sticks which I didn't have before they were so good! & I didn't even heat them up when I got home!. I love that the dining area is spacious, they keep it cleaned and make everything easy to order as soon as you come in. The board is on the wall so even with a vision impairment it's big enough to read. The paper menu is in bold large print once you go to the counter, side bar they have gelato/ice cream. I'd come back here for sure the customer service, food, and flavors . read more

See all

We called for takeout as it was getting late and we forgot to eat. Girl took our order with no ID or credit card over for phone. Quick rom the resort down to Elkton so very convenient. Could eat in or take out and restaurant was clean. Pizza was done just as we got there.Our pizza was very tasty. The store had many items to choose from if you aren't in the mood for pizza and all were reasonably priced. We will go back on or next stay here. read more

Do not order delivery. Ordeted 2 gelatos with 2 scoops each. Received one with a spoonful of gelato. Pizza was cold. Delivery was horrible. Glad I am only visiting this area. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Gelato received for over $5,00. Was supposed to be 2 scoops! - Pizza Near Me - Penn Laird, Virginia

On our way back from Harrisonburg, we decided we were hungry...right after we left town. The wife dove into Yelp and came up with this little gem. I got the hot honey pepperoni and she got a supreme. Both of them were delicious. It was very good and I am happy we stopped in. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Hot Honey Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Penn Laird, Virginia

Today we tried them for the first time, based on the good reviews on yelp . The pizza was not very good. The ingredients were sparse and certainly did not look like they do on the website. The crust does not seem hand tossed, and was tasteless. Much better pizzas are available down the street at Vito's Pizza pie or, better yet, at Ciro's in Elkton. As a final note, when I ordered online, the default tip was 30%. read more

This was our first visit and we loved our pizzas. I had the "chose your own toppings" option: Italian sausage, ham, and red onion. My husband had the Hot Honey Pepperoni. We will definitely be back. read more

We had the wood fired cheese pizza and the cheese breadsticks. They tasted fresh and good. The crust is made in front of us ,which is nice. Service is good. Staff is welcoming. Ambience is good. read more

Love this place! The service is great and the quality of food is awesome. My husband and I order pretty regularly here and I can say they don't just slop things together like a typical food chain. You get what you pay for here. I ordered the peach, prosciutto pizza and it was beautiful! I mean, the presentation was unbeatable. It looked just like it does on their signage and tasted SO good! It's almost like a personal luxe pizza. Highly recommend! read more

Great pizza good staff. Nicer than I thought it would be for a counter service. Had DJ/kareoke for Tuesday night.

This place! We came in today-Opening Day! The restaurant is beautiful and bright, with lots of seating- appropriately spaced during COVID-19 social distancing! You create your own custom pizza from a large selection of ingredients including flour, wheat, or cauliflower crust. We chose two pizzas to give different things a try. Straight up pepperoni and the BBQ chicken. Both were excellent. They do not scrimp on sauce or toppings. The pizza is perfectly cooked in their large brick pizza oven. In fact, they were so good we ordered a 3rd pie- The Nat. This pizza is one of the best pizzas I've ever eaten! The best thing about the menu here is that the options are literally endless. Crusts, sauces, toppings are all interchange for the ultimate pizza consuming experience. Add to all this the option of pasta dishes and paninis, sodas, chips, and gelato! Any combo of pizza is only $8.50 no matter how many toppings you choose. (Gluten free crust is an up charge). We will be back and often!! read more

Your Pie Pizza - The Nat - pesto sauce, sun dried toms, basil, chicken, mozzarella-YUM! - Pizza Near Me - Penn Laird, Virginia

See all

OMG! What a great place! The flavors are amazing and ingredients are fresh! Built my own pizza is the way to go! But their "favorites" are also a nice choice. Was our first time and it was delicious and will come back for more, nothing beats a freshly made pizza just the way you want it! Also their pumpkin gelato is wonderful! read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Penn Laird, Virginia

Nice stop along route 33 outside of Harrisonburg. They have an outdoor dining area (which is dog friendly) and ample parking. The pizza can be purchased as part of a combo, with a choice of side (chips, side salad, or scoop of gelato) plus a fountain drink for just a few dollars more. Pizza was ready quickly and the wheat crust was very good. read more

Your Pie Pizza - A create your own with mozzarella, banana peppers, tomatoes, and pineapples in a wheat crust with tomato sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Penn Laird, Virginia

Great pizza, amazing caprese salad (a must try). Pizza had great flavors. It arrived on time. Instructions for Gelato were followed. Their Gelato is mind blowing too ! (Must try ) read more

Quality food with great service. Highly recommended for family to indulge at a reasonable price.

First time visiting Your Pie, and we really liked it. Staff was very helpful in figuring out how to build the pizza to our liking. I really liked the pizza crust too! The side salads we got were so-so and a bit pricey ($2.99) for a pre-made salad in a plastic container but were tasty. We'll definitely be back again. read more

We were driving through with the camper on a Friday evening. We knew we wanted a place to stop and it looked like it was big enough to turn around. I was able to get in pulling a 34 ft camper. They have parallel parking along the back side of the building. There was plenty of room to park. They had plenty of outdoor seating. The beer selection was very good. I ordered a meat pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and bacon. It had a very good taste, loved the sausage. You can get a combo with your choice of chips, gelato, or small salad. I took the chips but just typical bag, I could of gotten the gelato. Easy stop heading west on 33. Will stop by if we are heading through. read more

The pizza was delicious. Fairly priced. The adults and kids all enjoyed it. The salted caramel gelato is amazing. Kind workers and very clean. read more

The brick oven pizza here was great. The service was quick and the best bang for our buck was clearly and concisely explained by staff, Kendall. We appreciated her kindness, her effort in making sure we were well taken care of, and the way she sung the praises of the business and the upper management/owner. Thanks Kendall for serving us today! Nicole read more

This is our every other week dinner spot! We love the pizza & it's fresh and simple. The staff is friendly and you must get the gelato

Picked up a couple of pizzas here on a Sunday night. They were ready when I got there. I wasn't blown awaynor anything but they were pretty good I guess. Not sure if I'll go back or not. read more

For what is advertised as the "subway" of pizza, you get exactly that. The food is fast, fresh, healthy and they have good variety. The best deal was the kids meal, which was a whole pizza, drink and scoop of gelato for $6! Pizza was tasty, but very light, not your traditional pizza. The staff was very courteous and they did a good job of social distancing and maintaining COVID guidelines inside and out. The patio had great views of the valley. Overall, it's a good alternative to fast food, but if you are craving more legit pizza, would probably check out Vitos or even Pizza Hut. read more

Great food. Friendly staff. My wife had a pasta, the kid and I both got pizzas, we all loved our food.

Amazing food! Kids their are super nice and know what they are doing! Pizza is well made and their is proper food safety used by everyone read more

Vitos Pizza Pie is were I have had the best pizza ever since it is so authentic Italian, and the service by Tony was very very good. Keep it up Tony. read more

Great little place!! Unfortunate timing for opening but will hopefully be worth it. Convenient single pizza concept that they are continuing to expand. I loved the pizza, the cheese, the crust (I do like them thin!). I could easily eat three of them. Owner very engaging, even with six feet of separation and will hopefully make it through all this craziness. Beer and wine license pending-looking forward to my next visit already. read more

Was excited by the pictures and unique pizza offerings. Sadly, we were disappointed. We ordered a cheese for the kids, Peach Prosciutto & Hot Honey Pepperoni for adults. The cheese/toppings did not go to the edge/crust. The only one with any flavor at all was the pepperoni. Bland, bland, bland. Luckily,we were so hungry, it didn't matter. read more

Tried their pizza for the first time on our recent stay at Massanutten Resort. My new favorite pizza - anywhere! I love the made to order options where you can put unlimited toppings of your choice on the pizza (including a variety of sauces). We went here twice on our vacation and tried the Nat Pizza the second time and loved it. The basil pesto sauce was perfect. The thin crust and pizza oven bake made the pie very flavorful and the crust crispy and yet a little chewy like you would expect from a pizza. My husband and I chose the 10" pizza and had 3 slices each, plenty for the two of us. We even shared a side salad. The dinning area was clean and spacious, and the staff were friendly and prompt. Will definitely go here again next time I'm in town. I would recommend this restaurant to others. read more

The pizza was amazing. All of the toppings were fresh and delicious (especially the mushrooms). My boyfriend and I each got the combo and it came with a salad and drink. Very good price for the quantity and quality of food we got. Definitely coming back! Also the outside patio was a nice touch read more

Stopped by today to try their peach- prosciutto pizza. Its really good. Place is nice. Staff is vey friendly.

Delicious pizza. Light and not greasy . And gelato is real. Oh and there's indoor and outdoor seating right now.

In a word "wow". The family and I visited Massanutten for spring break and decided to have pizza for lunch. Our first choice was Vito's, but they were closed- and I must say I'm glad that they were because Your Pie is absolutely amazing. The wife and I got the Family Pack for two( the Meats and the Nat pizzas with cheese sticks/bread, two sodas and two brownies). Everything was perfect- the pizzas were delicious. This is now hands down my go to spot for pizza when we are in the area!!! read more

Revised review about our fourth visit after two poor service times. This time everything went very well and service much improved. Food is good and clean restaurant. We watched them start to make pizza's and then moved down the cafeteria style line so no issues. This worked We'll give them credit for reaching out to insure customers are satisfied and we were. Definitely worth a stop if you enjoy pizzas. read more

Heck yes I'd recommend! We don't eat cheese and hate that we cannot buy a pizza on a whim on lazy nights. We love the cheese used on this vegan pizza and it's cute that you have your own sizes. I would like, however, the option to order a large or extra large pizza as an easy family dinner because I really hate having to deal with all the personal pizza boxes and it would be nice to save a little money and buy one large instead of getting a family's worth of personal pizzas. read more

While visiting Massanutten we stopped here for a quick lunch- pleasantly surprised! The pizza was of good quality and the staff so polite. Will definitely be back again! read more

I have been wanting to find a place like this in Harrisonburg & I'm so happy I finally did! The inside was very nice & clean & big. I should have stayed to drink a beer at the small bar , many options on tap. the pizza was good! I'm definitely going to go back read more