This is in response to Michael K. Sounds to me like you…read moredidn't do your research/homework on your purchase concerning the size motor that you purchased with your boat. Can't blame them for what you didn't do. Any time I make a purchase for that amount of money I usually spend time on forums seeing what other people have done. It's best to learn from their mistakes instead of making your own. No type of dealership is perfect whether it's cars, boats or motorcycles and Boater's Landing is no different. You should always do your research and be on your guard when you deal with salesmen that work on commission... Here is a photo of my boat that I purchased from them. It is also a Key West 239FS but it has a 300hp on it. It will do between 50-55 mph depending on water conditions and load.

I wish I can say that my experience was amazing but UNFORTUNATELY it was not. I purchased a 2018…read morekey west brand new so that son was safe along with my self on the water. After a year in the boat has had multiple minor issues that Billy lied and told us was under warranty, refusing to fix by saying "its my problem" . We purchased a 239fs powered by a Yamaha 200ph, if you call any other dealership they will refuse to ever take the boat on trade due to be WAY Underpowered. When I brought this to Billys attention, he told me "tuff shit I already purchased it" after that he asked me if I wanted to trade my boat back in so he can collect another percentage of commission. I could not believe this actually came out of a business owners mouth. After calling calling around to other key west dealers, I have found many others are treated the same. I would suggest asking around before pulling the trigger like I did. From out customer service to how

We always rent from Monroe Canal Marina because their service is fantastic every time. Our recent…read moretwo‑day rental of the Hurricane Deckboat 22' on May 24, 2026 was smooth, timely, and the boat was in great shape. Friendly staff, easy process -- highly recommend!

We rented a boat for the day. She ran like a top. They provided maps and GPS. Great location for…read morefishing or a boat day. We saw dolphins and collected a few shells. This was our second rental and they are good people.

Dishonest, rude, condescending dealership. Recently I had a…read morenon start issue with my boat that I purchased at Fishtale. I took my boat there thinking I could trust them. BIG MISTAKE. They gave me a written estimate for over $10,000 in parts plus labor. Are these people serious, or were they trained by Richard "I am not a crook" Nixon. They were condescending, rude, and pushy. They told me that the engine (with only 107 hours on it) was not worth saving and I should just have them put a new one on for $20,000 plus. I have never been treated as poorly as the Fishtale employees I met with. Dejected, I went to another dealership, Pier 41 Marine, where I was treated with respect, and honesty. Pier 41 quickly repaired the engine for a small fraction of what Fishtale was asking, and also informed me that the trim motor which Fishtale reported as leaking was in fact NOT LEAKING. If I could give Fishtale less than a one star review, I certainly would. They deserve a NEGATIVE TEN. These people would not know what honesty is if they fell over it. Incidentally, the tech who worked on my boat stole my gas filter wrench, at first he denied it, but when I insisted that we look in his tool bag, guess what? It was sitting there. He replied "oh, I must have accidentally put it in there?" It is not enough that the dealership rips you off, the Fishtale tech also tried helping himself to one of my tools, hoping I wouldn't notice. As Cher so famously said, "gypsies, tramps and thieves".

I am buying my Third Robalo Cayman from Fish Tale Boats. I…read morerun my business on these boats and have to trust the boat as well as the place I get them serviced with my livelihood. These guys are the guys to go to! I have worked closely with Joe Davis and Ray Jahn on every sale and always look forward to seeing them and make a point just to stop and say hi because they're just great people! The service department is full of great guys with awesome knowledge. Honest and fair. Best around. You're making a good decision to deal with Fish tale boats in fort Myers

I purchased our boat from Walkers new back in 2014 when Jimmy Walker owned the business. Very…read morehonest and excellent service. Our boat was damaged in IAN so i took it to Walkers for repair of Gelcoat, powdercoat and electronics connections. The repairs were supposedly completed 6 weeks later. I showed up late in the day to pick up the boat by water. The boat was absolutely filthy even though I was told it was washed. The electronics were not repaired, the powder coat repairs were further gouged and scuffed by the "cleaning" crew. I reached out to Kim the service manager with no replies. I then spoke with management who assured me they would come to my home for the repairs which never happened. I was forced to hire another company at my cost. I disputed the charges by walkers with Capital One to no avail because walkers argued it. They are dishonest and it was theft in my opinion. NEVER USE WALKERS!!

If you ever want to feel like the least important person trying to sell a boat, contact Tom at…read moreWalkers Marine. 2 months after hiring them - I called to get an update and was asked -- Why are you calling me. After 6 1/2 months they returned the boat looking like no one had taken care of it for 6 1/2 months -- wait -- no one had taken care of it for that time. No wonder it hadn't sold. Every time I talked to Tom, it was like I was bothering him. The response to it not selling -- its filthy and the market is no good. I even offered to pay to have it cleaned. He said if you do it on our lot -- we will up charge you even though we have no one to clean it. The only option is to to lower the price or remove it from our lot. I wouldn't do any business with them on any level. They are the worst dealership in southwest Florida.

Had 100 hr service done in may always salt away appearantly they dont do anodes in the service for…read more2200 bucks my review will change depending the outcome. Pair of 300 suzukes service done at 20 hrs.. 100hrs. 135 hrs and has 155hrs on it now.

Nice people but horrible customer service! I took my boat in for service- they screw up another…read morepart of the boat and now for over 45 days. I've had to call them- have a nice per say "I'll have my service manager call you" and they never do. When I call he or she is unavailable. Terrible service... No pride in work done. Just take your money & next... Based on my experience- if you need service. Go elsewhere!

After the Hurricane IAN our families home on Sanibel Island boat lift was beyond repair. The crew…read moreat Stokes Marine was able to remove the damaged boat lift and replace with a new lift in a short amount of time. The knowledgeable crew from their in-house service department not only custom set the bunks to our Key West but also set all the auto stop limits and explained how to use the GEM remotes. Their response time to help us and professionalism is TOP NOTCH!! Would Recommend them for all your Dock, Sea Wall, Canopy and Boat Lift service.

Stokes recently completed our dock on the NW spreader and my wife and I have been extremely…read moresatisfied with their work. We would choose them again, without hesitation. Stokes built us the dock WE wanted, while other company's proposals were often trying to talk us out of things. In the planning stages their "we can do that!" attitude, the way Nick returned phone calls quickly, his enthusiastic professionalism set them apart from other builders. We were happy with the type/specifications of the lift they included in the bid plus the canopy and tiki sub-contractors they chose. They were not the lowest bidders but we felt assured that they would deliver quality work. And they 100% did. This positive attitude followed through into the construction phase where the crews showed up as scheduled and, once they started, worked non-stop from 8am to dark, and even weekends sometimes. They worked like an efficient, well-managed team. Credit to the team lead Rod for his positive can-do attitude, work ethic and attention to detail which you could clearly tell inspired his crew to live up to his standards. We really can't say enough good things about Stokes. We absolutely LOVE our dock. I mean how often do you get to design and build a dock! Enjoy it!! You can trust Stokes to make it a good experience.

Group of 3 guys came over and quickly and methodically placed the 2 pilings I lost during Ian, they…read morethen built the necessary framework and added the nice top composite decking...looks great! They then hauled away the old scrap wood from the previous dock. The original quote said new ladder and they honored that and added the new ladder. Thank You

Responded to our damage after the hurricane within days. Came to do the work like two weeks later…read more Did an amazing job and repaired the dock to my expectations. Would definitely recommend and use them again!!

I took my boat in for service the 11th of May and wrote out a list of things needed done. Replace…read morespark plugs, clean and adjust carburetors, replace pump impeller and adjust gear shifter, it's grinding when I shift. I checker back a few days later and they said they were waiting for parts, OK, I checked the following week, and they said still waiting for parts. On Wednesday the 20th of May they said they were just waiting to take it out and check out the work and I came by to pick it up on the 21 Of May. I got to talk with the mechanic who said it seems OK. They only changed the spark plugs and adjusted the carburetors, nothing else. They had it for a week and a half and that's all they did. What parts were they waiting for? I believe they forgot about me and only did something when I checked on my boat. Not complaining about the cost, just the lack of work they didn't do. Now I will have to take it someplace else to have work done that I wanted done.

The team here is great and ensures they take the time to explain everything they are doing. Prices…read moreare fair and service is quick.