Honestly. First time here, have driven by this place for years! Whelp found my new pizza place!…read moreBEST pizza I have had in a very very very long time. Service was great! Order was ready on time. I walked in thinking it was going to be a very large place, nope standing room for pickup only. Looked like a well oiled/run machine and clearly shows they put effort into delivering a great product. Highly recommend!!!

It was the best of pizzas. It was the worst of pizzas. Two pizzas were ordered; a NY style large…read moremeatball and a plain upside down pie. The NY pie was not very good. The crust was so thin, there was no chew. All crisp and no chew. No layer between the crispy bottom and the wet, saucy side. Cracked and crumbled when folded. The ratio of crust to cheese to sauce was off. Baked on a screen. WAY too much gooey, non-snapping cheese. The outer crust had no chew to it and was too airy and light. Sauce was on point and meatballs were excellent. And, 16" isn't really a large in a REAL NY pizzeria. 18" is the NY standard. Then came the big save; the upside down or Utica pie. It was truly excellent. Probably pretty much the same ingredients as their NY style pizza, but WAY better in a different form. I ate it hot. I ate it at room temperature. Each bite was a flavorgasm. So, skip their NY style pie which is mediocre at best and order something memorable.

Went to the World tournament for Bocce Ball. American Pie was one of the food vendors. You walked…read morein the room and you could smell the flavorful sauce. It smelled amazing.... Since, we were wanting to sample things we only got the fried meatballs. The meatballs were deep fried this was a first for me but they were really good. Haven't been to their brink and mortar location but am looking forward to trying it. Their space was set up nicely and it was a great place to escape the heat and sit and grab a bite. The pizza looked amazing. If we go back to tournament tomorrow want to try a slice. Prices for being at a sporting venue were reasonable and am looking forward to a visit soon. Sorry thought I got a picture of meatballs but can't find

I've only had takeout from American Pie, but it was enough to keep me from going back. The cheese…read moreis extremely oily--to the point that it overwhelms the pizza--which usually signals lower-quality ingredients. The crust also lacks flavor, especially compared to other local pizza shops. Unfortunately, every time I've eaten it, it's been gut-ache central afterward. Pizza should be indulgent, not uncomfortable. There are far better pizza options in the area, and this one just doesn't stand out in a good way.

This is a hidden little secret we found in Little Falls. It's apparently just opened and has the…read morebones to be a great pizza joint. It was very warm inside, I'm sure the oven doesn't help, but not an issue they shouldn't be able to overcome. Also to be picky, why do restaurants insist on tacky planted half dead plants all around??? Ok, but pickyness over, the food. I had a figgy piggy pizza, delicious!! My husband had a calzone, his criticism was less ricotta, more mozzarella, as well as a side of sauce for dipping. (Which when we asked, they did provide). I really loved their dough!! All in all we will definitely recommend and return.

We made it to Mangia on Canal days looking for a bit of yummy lunch. This is a regular stop for…read moreHometown Pizza before at least one of our houses. It's under new ownership, but actually has gotten even better than we already thought it was. People were friendly, even though it was a busy time with the festival right outside. You really can smell the Woodfire oven bringing so much to the space along with the clean cut seating. We got our pizza and decided to sit outside. The garlic pizza we got was very yummy and being able to choose a couple toppings ourselves made it feel very personal. If you are there during the regular menu, you have to try the figgy piggy.

Sitting at work not knowing what to order for lunch, we called Nina's Pizzeria on a short notice,…read moreand they delivered again! Pizza and wings nothing crazy but they still came through with amazing food!!! Thanks again for taking care of us!!

Came here expecting some pizza excellence. After all, some of these reviews speak of Nina's as a…read moregift from God. Average pizza that is more bready than crusty. Way too much cheese & baked on a metal screen. I ordered two slices from their 24" pie. More gimmick than good pizza. Extra soft and not very crusty. The cheese is so gloppy, it spills off the crust and all over your hands. Unfortunate, because the sauce is quite good. I ordered an upside down pie and 2 garlic "giant" knots, too. The upside down was better than the plain cheese, but had the same soft crust, albeit with a better ratio of cheese to sauce to crust. Again, the sauce was the winner. The garlic knots were awful. Tasted like greasy day old pizza dough. No garlic flavor whatsoever. Price for large upside down, 2 large slices, and 2 knots? Nearly $40. Very disappointing.

Went in for a slice on a recommendation. They had about 6 different pizza choices ready to go for…read moreslices. They have a thicker slice than I prefer but I got the mushroom and sausage which was LOADED with toppings. The crust was golden brown looking great but a slightly doughy but hard bottom which made cutting it difficult with plastic silverware as to not dirty my dress clothes. They used a mild spicy sausage which I liked as it gave a bit more flavor compared to the canned mushrooms. Slice was ok and good for a quick easy meal. The cheesecake slice was large and VERY dense with a side of strawberry topping for me to use or not use. It was very thick with large chunks of strawberries. A slice and a cheesecake cost $9. Service was quick and straight to the point. Overall ok quality It won't become a regular place for me but it's good for a quick meal when you have limited time.

Since they changed ownership I noticed a drop in customers. The regular people that were working…read morethere have all been let go. The fryer was always going. Not anymore. I ordered 2 plain slices and 1/2 sausage roll. The girl range it up at $25.xx! I looked at her like I wasn't going to pay that....she recalculated and the price was now $16.xx. Also the pizza was gooie. Should have been baked longer. May have to start looking for another pizza joint To provide consistent good pizza and I think I found it.

La Roma's completely saved me the other day. I had ordered catering for a business meeting from a…read moredifferent restaurant, and they cancelled the order 30 minutes prior to the meeting. I called La Roma's frantic, and they immediately went to work & got us 10 pizzas & a salad in under 30 minutes for me to pick up. We're gotten catering from them several times in the past, and they are our tried & tru, they reassured me they'd never cancel my order right before an important meeting. Wonderful staff & great food!!

We went in a half hour before closed and apologized, offering to order our food to go. Server was…read moresuper nice and said not to worry and we promised not to linger. We both had salads with their homemade Italian dressing. My husband had lasagna and I had the chicken riggies. We both enjoyed our food but had to take to go boxes because the portions were enormous. The bread was good too and we got an extra loaf to go. Not sure when we will ever be back in Rome NY, but if we do visit again, I would definitely go back!!!

Love the food, it's really amazing, and good service! The ambiance could be better, but all goodread more

Pizza is always amazing. Food is good for take out, if you choose to dine in you may not like the…read morelooks.

We just had a great fresh haddock fish fry and it was delicious!! It was our first one from this…read moreestablishment and it definitely will not be our last.

A go to several times a week and the food is always great! Best pizza place in north Utica area IMO!read more