On my way into Syracuse International Airport while picking up my rental car, a very friendly Enterprise manager recommended a pizzeria called O'scugnizzo. He mentioned it is the second oldest pizzeria in America, so I had to check it out. I'm so glad I did. This is a really cute, community-oriented spot with a warm and welcoming feel. I ordered a small pizza, but "small" definitely does not feel small here. It was actually a great size. More importantly, the pizza was super fresh and extremely delicious. What stood out just as much as the food was how kind everyone was. As someone visiting from out of town, I really appreciated how warm and friendly the people were. It also felt like the kind of place that would be great for hosting a casual party or gathering. Highly recommend. If you're in Utica, this is definitely a place you need to try. read more

See all

Went to New York and couldn't leave without getting pizza. This place was rated one of the highest in Utica. I would definitely eat the pizza again. They accommodated about 30 of us in a very short period of time. With an old time pizzeria feel and staff it's a great vibe. Wasn't the normal New York slice I was thinking of but I'd argue I liked it just as much if not more! read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - Large Cheese Pizza Mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

I'd had O'Scugnizzo pizza before but never dined in, so when I was craving some upside down pizza, we headed over. It's a super casual joint, with a large dining space with booths and tables. It reminded me of being a kid and going out to lunch at the local pizzeria. The staff was friendly and I could tell they enjoyed working together; the front area was full of laughing and lively conversation. We got some cheesy garlic bread, a small pepperoni pizza, and some wings. I was happy with everything, especially the pizza. It's a place I'd like to keep in my rotation for pizza night! read more

See all

Had a cheese and pepperoni pizza delivered. It arrived lightning fast, but the condition left a bit to be desired, it was so watery that topping flowed off of the crust. Tasted great though. Maybe next time I'll try eating at the restaurant. read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - Cheese and sauce flowing off of the crust. - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

See all

A must try, they have been open for over 100 years says it all . Seeing bar stool pizza review made me want to stop and it didn't disappoint. I walked in and ordered a small cheese and pepperoni pizza to go. Took 15 minutes as promised . Never had an "upside down" pizza where the sauce is on top. It was very good . Lots of sauce , the pepperonis are totally covered . And the cheese looks to be sliced cheese to give it a perfect cheese layer. Keeps the dough nice and keeps from getting soggy and for being a small it was a good size for the money ,they do sell by the slice too. Can't wait to have my leftovers . So good read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - Small cheese and pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

Grew up about an hour away from here and now that I am 30 and moved away I am finally coming here for my first time man am I upset.. I could eat pizza for breakfast lunch and dinner this place is 100% in my top 3 pizza places I will be coming back next time I'm visiting family read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

See all

You can just taste the history of this place and the portions are huge. The prices are reasonable $1.75 for a can of beer where in earth are we in some other parallel universe maybe? The young lady behind the counter apparently is the third or fourth generation of family operating this business and her service with a smile was outstanding. Nothing fancy about the building or the furnishings or any of that -- you don't come for the ambiance you just come here for the food. read more

Best pizza in central NY! Great place and shop. Would add to your list when visiting Utica

Best pizza hands down. Since I was a kid. This place still looks the same! I just moved back to the area. LOVE IT!

Pepperoni pizza tasted almost okay but the crust seemed old and stale. O'Scugnizzo's used to be my favorite for the last 50 years. Not anymore. Not consistent. read more

The seating area was large and the subs were looking good. The tomato pie did disappoint a little, soupy consistency and was my favorite crust. The employees were great though! read more

Hands down this is all Utica this a must stop for all they have a unique style that's hard to duplicate the famous number 7

A "must" just so you can say you have been here and tried it. It's been going strong for over 110 years. That clearly shows a lot of patrons love it! Unusual pizza - not like the usual American-style pizza. Crust is thick and becomes increasingly crisp and crunchy as it cools. Ingredients are scant amounts, so consider ordering double amounts. Steer very clear of the anchovies unless you absolutely love them. The anchovies are overpowering! Marinara sauce is 100% home cooked and heavy with tomato paste, which can be more bitter than sweet! It's ladled onto the ingredients in very generous amounts. The small pizza will easily feed three hungry adults. Prices quite reasonable. Ambiance? Ummmmm. LOL. You should try this place. You will either love it or shrug and say, "meh". read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

See all

The second oldest pizzeria in the country and a place you have to visit if you have not tried it yet. Their signature upside down pizza is hearty and tasty. The sauce is savory and full bodied. The dough is usually crispy. I would highly recommend the pepperoni pie and the sausage pie is delicious. Their pizza is the ultimate comfort food and perfect on a cold Winter day. read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

Very disappointed. Haven't had their pizza in over 5 years so was looking forward to it as I don't get to Utica all that often. Wasn't greeted when I entered. Waited about 4 minutes before spoken to(was only one in there). Ordered a pepperoni pepper pizza. When I got home it was sausage pepper. Dough tasted freezer burned. Sauce seemed burnt. Definitely NOT what I remember. Guess I'll wait another 5 years read more

Best pizza on earth. 100 years in business says it all. Dont miss it! We came all the way from LA for this. read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

Great neighborhood place when in town I bring my customers here. The portions are great. The kitchen staff is great. I'm a coach Bus driver and my group found this place read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria is really the king of pizza. Some places that are open for a long time coast on their reputation. They're still doing the things that make them great. Food: The pizza is so damn good. It's about the dough and the sauce, and they've got both down. At a lot of other pizza places, their dough tastes like cardboard, and their sauce is overly sweet or salty to make up for the fact that they don't know how to make a sauce. O'Scugnizzo got it right. Service: They were friendly and accommodating when I went. Ambiance: You ain't coming here for your wedding dinner. But that's part of the charm. read more

I feel a bit intimidated reviewing a legend, LOL. I mean really, there's nothing I could say that's going to make any difference to anyone...the place sells itself LOL. All that said, we had an excellent pizza here. Grandma style, wonderful wonderful, wonderful crispy crust that even stays crispy the next day when you reheat the leftover slices.... Interesting sauce, a deeper richer flavor and darker red than most pizza sauces the cheese is to die for....the old school mozz, not adulterated with fillers or flour like so many do now....the best cheese, really. I live in a world where everything we once knew is gone or else turned upside down, but not O'scugnizzo and thank god for that and thank god for them. read more

This wasn't a pizza, it was a massacre. It's rare I have a pizza so bad I have to write a review about it. But this. Was. Bad. No flavor. None. Sauce was completely tasteless, and the cheese was like glue. The dough was a greasy, burnt mess. I wanted to try their pizza because of the stupid Barstool Sports review. But good god I never will again I've gotten better pizza from Stewarts. read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - Only reason 2 slices are missing is I needed to eat SOMETHING. - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

Driving through Utica on our way home and wanted to grab a slice of their famous tomato pie. This place had good reviews and decided to stop on by. First off the employees were super friendly. I was waiting to order and asked about the tomato pie. He said unfortunately on Monday's they don't have any, but they did have pizza slices. He went on to explain that they have the sauce on-top and that they are the 2nd oldest pizzeria in America. I went and checked and they are. We ended up ordering 2 slices as well as their special which was sausage with potatoes, onions and peppers. We also got a chicken Riggies. The slices were delicious! Nice and crispy with a good sauce. It's messy so be prepared with lots of napkins. The sausage special was packed full on the container and very yummy. Will be eating the chicken riggies tonight and hoping it's just as good as the other dishes. All came with bread and recommend stopping here for some history, good pizza and food if you are in Utica! read more

See all

A friend of mine is from Utica, and I am of a pizza snob, but this sort of very old pizza place was on my to try list. It certainly is different than a metro-NYC pizza and not as good as say a Frank Pepe's which is the best, but this is a good cheese on the bottom sauce on top pizza similar to the style of Spumoni Garden's in Brooklyn. Definitely kinda trippy to see it in upstate NY. I could see a low review from someone who doesn't see this as "legit pizza" but this is basically an OG type of pizza that has survived for like 100 years. It is basically food history and worth a try for that reason alone. Will definitely return whenever I am in Utica. read more

Definitely a representation of Utica Italian! We stopped in on a Tuesday afternoon with our family of 5. We ordered two pizzas--sausage and pepperoni. While they were different than the NY style pizza we are used to near Albany, they were interesting and delicious. We also knew we couldn't leave without an order of the Tuesday Riggies special. The $8.50 was certainly well-spent. The creamy sauce coated the al dente rigatoni with a spicy kick. We asked to add the bread which seemed homemade, crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. The portions were plentiful, leaving us extra to take home. We wholeheartedly recommend O'Scugnizzo's for a family-friendly, reasonably priced Italian experience. read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - Tomato Pie with sausage buried underneath - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

See all

A different take on pizza. Fast, friendly service and a great pizza. Will definitely go back the next time we pass thru Utica. read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - OSP Special Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

See all

The pizza is great! Love the options and the history! Loved the greens too! Service is always great!

We were looking for a place for dinner after crossing the border and stopping for the night. I saw that Dave Portnoy came here and encouraging everyone to come here because it was one of the oldest pizza establishments. I had to give this place a try. We came here for dinner, so it was dark and we weren't able to see how the neighborhood looks in the daytime. LOL. The restaurant inside is bigger than it looks, with the place being split into two separate areas. The ordering area is very narrow, with the space consisting of a drink refrigerator and the ordering counter. The dining area greatly resembles a cafeteria, with the tables being green and rectangular and the booths and chairs being hard instead of soft. The walls are also gray and adorned with framed pictures while in the back, you can see stacks of empty pizza boxes on a table. We placed our order at the front and went to get a table and were told that we paid afterwards. We ordered a large meatball and cheese sub and a large pizza. I was a little disappointed with the pizza because the crust was pre-baked and they put tomato sauce on top of it. It reminded me of Sbarros. But, the sauce was pretty good, though. It tasted a little sweet. The meatball sub was pretty good. I thought it was better than the pizza. Service was pretty fast. When we got there, most of the tables were taken and we thought it was going to be a long wait. Turned out most of the tables were done with their dinner and just hanging out. I'm glad that we got a chance to come here and give it a try. read more

Classic pizza spot in Utica ... a must if you haven't already tried it ... wings are pretty good too, along with the service you get from the workers gives it a family vibe read more

This pizza apparently suits a certain taste, but not mine. The crust is far too thick, and tasteless. The sausage is good. The sauce seems off. Compared to New Haven, Brooklyn, and Chicago, it doesn't come close. Everyone should stop in once, but for me it may be only once. read more

Best pizza ever , born in raised in Utica and always have to come and enjoy true Italian Pizza . I always get the number 7 with wings, but I need to try their riggies . This the only place you can order you pizza to your door like they have at the restaurant . read more

See all

I grabbed lunch here while driving through Utica. It was a must considering it's the second oldest pizzeria in the US! The pizza ordered was alright, I wish it had been more flavorful. The sausage was a large patty under the cheese instead of the usual chunks that I prefer. The mac & cheese balls were a bit overpriced in my opinion. It was basically $1/ball and they were pretty small. read more

See all

If you've never been, it will be unique and unexpected. Unusual even. But I grew up on this and it's been my favorite all my life. I've lived in the Boston area since the 90s, but every time I come back, it's the first place I need to go. The sausage is all I've ever gotten and all I'll ever need. I find the layer of sausage under the cheese to be far superior to chunks of sausage on top. And the sauce is fantastic. Just don't expect your typical NY pie. read more

Delicious pizza! I arrived too late for the lunch single slice (available from 11:30- 1:00) so I bought a small pepper and mushroom pie. I've visited family Utica and New York Mills for over 30 years. Never been a fan of the cold tomato pie, but O'Scugnizzo's hot version of this classic showed me the light. read more

See all

I tried this place for lunch recently. I have heard this is the best pizza place in town. I heard the regular cheese pizza was delicious. El presidente gave it a score of 8.1. Those who follow barstool know that's a high score. I was told by locals to try the upside down pizza. It was delicious. Sauce was very good and just good ingredients all around. It is understandably messy and probably not great for kids. I have to visit Utica for work and totally plan on going back and trying more menu items. read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

Great salad! (After they were reminded to serve it) "Pizza" was like a warped piece of 3/4 inch plywood that someone carelessly poured a jar of spaghetti sauce on. Customers were polite and delightful. Staff was having a fight about who was going to work Wednesday. A loud fight. A long fight. A really long and loud fight about who was going to work Wednesday. Maybe that's why they forgot about the salad. Maybe the pizza is ok when there isn't a brawl brewing amongst the staff. I'm not going back on Wednesday to find out. read more

This Queens, NYC girl absolutely loved this place. Best pizza it's a must stop. The tomato sauce has a hint of sweetness to it. The crust is thick and airy. Just go. read more

O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Utica, New York

One of the oldest Pizza restaurants in New York and probably the country. Many try to replicate but there is only one upside pizza restaurant where cheese goes down first than sauce. Have been coming here for years. While the restaurant is far from a 5 star restaurant it has a lot of history and nostalgia. Not much has changed in the last 50 plus years. We tend to eat our pizza there as the pizza is best when served piping hot after of the oven. Love the crispy crust. Their wings are amazing too. While the cost has gone up it is still the best pizza in town. They have one picnic table outdoors which on a pretty evening you will find us eating outside. Highly Recommend read more

Great little spot with awesome staff, service and delicious pizza! Highly recommend this place.

Here's the thing. The reason we wanted go was the exact reason why they get 1 star. Thought supporting a 100+ year old family business would be nice. And got great reviews. They are beyond rude. Arrogant. Went out of my way to go for my birthday and they are horrible. Skip. Run. Don't go. read more

I grew up in Utica, we would only eat pizza here after 2 AM, when most other places were closed. It's kinda tasty, but soupy with the sauce on top. Tasted pretty good eaten off the trunk of a car when drink. I wouldn't bother going here sober. read more

First time trying this style pizza. I enjoyed it very much. I will be back for more next time I am in the area.