Grabbed a quick slice after dropping my son off at Cortland. It hit the spot. I had the buffalo slice, my husband had the cheese slice. Prices are very very reasonable. $3.50 a slice I believe. Service was great. It was quiet. They were very nice. We ordered at the counter and there were other slices on display. They make rolls too. It was perfect for a quick bite. read more

See all

Ordered from this place regularly. Big orders. Never great but convenient - through the Slice app. Got an order tonight - 4 pies... one of them had a screw in the crust. Yes - a screw. read more

A Pizza & More - The screw that was in my pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Cortland, New York

the young people who "handled" ( i use that term loosely) the phones were condescending & disrespectful. have n e v e r been spoken to in a such a disrespectful manner after being placed on hold indefinitely!!! don't waste your time anymore; all they care about is the college business and screw the locals who like this pizza! totally humiliated!! george & tony should be pissed!!! read more

Terrible customer service. Never gets order right. Does not resolve issues. Never delivered satisfactory

The price was hefty but they offered online ordering and decent delivery fees. The delivery came quicker than expected which was exciting. However, the $10 garlic knots were verh burnt, and didnt even come with marinara. Then I opened the pizza and the pepperoni was missing! Very disappointing! The only saving grace is that they quickly refunded me $13.75 when I flagged these issues. read more

We ordered a large chicken, Bacon ranch Pizza last night had it delivered and didn't open the box until the driver left, my mistake! The pizza was so burnt we couldn't eat the bottom nor the crust! Very unacceptable especially after I had heard such good things about this place, just lost a costumer for sure! read more

Best pizza around. Sometimes service is bad during college days. Hard to get delivery at times, especially at night. A rude man tends to answer read more

I don't know the girls name but she left the food out on the front step didn't bother calling the number I posted when I ordered and when she retuened with the soda she forgot an hour later she said it's not in her job description to call customers when they deliver food I normally have good experience with this place but this woman is terrible and something should be done if she just leaving peoples foods outside I live in an apartment with an enclosed porch and then another solid door so I don't hear people knocking so when I order I specifically request to be called pizza and more Cortland ny 8/25/24 @ 7:15pm read more

Ok! Let me begin by telling everyone that THE PIZZA GUY and the GIRL that takes orders and answers the phone are THE reason I buy 1 MONSTER MEATBALL and a Medium BLT PIZZA EVERY WEEK!!!! usually on Fridays. THE BEST PIZZA in town. Hands down! FRESH ingredients Great service. The crew right now is on point! The food is on point! I Pick up because I want to come in and say hello!!! THANKS SO MUCH!!!! guys you RULE! read more

The pizza here is excellent. pro-tip: Order by the slice rather than a whole pie. Odd I know, but after they put the slice in the oven, the crust crisps up. Just magnificent. read more

Workers are so rude. They act like it's an inconvenience to serve their customers. There were slices of fresh pizza yet they gave me the old cold pieces. Vibes are terrible and the people there don't want anything to do with helping their customers. The prices are way too high read more

I almost knew better but was starving so I went to a pizza and more when I asked how old the pizza was that they were giving me a slice from I was told an hour although from experience I could see that it had been sitting there probably all day so they still charged me $350 and when I asked for it to be heated up the girl was gone like 10 seconds and brought me back my pizza cold and then they wanted to give me an issue because I wanted it hot. They have the worst customer service they have the worst food they should be giving away free pizza to the homeless. read more

Ordered pizza delivery. Very fast delivery. Pizza was hot, fresh and delicious! Great job!

this place at I like the sauce on pizza. it may not be as big as others in the area but I'm more for taste. I ordered a pizza and salad for my family as I'm 3 hrs away. the man who took my order Oct 20 in the morning was very nice customer service means a lot. professional and sympathetic as well due to the nature of why I called. I've eaten pizza at surrounding local areas and I still prefer this place. as a customer we have a sense of duty to say exactly what we like how it's cooked and ask questions what's included vs complaining about something that wasn't up to their expectations hence neg reviews. their clean and I was a cook once and came with a pizza snob there and it was fine. communication when ordering anywhere for any place is key and smiles. and this place was good enough for us. read more

poor customer service, false advertising, poor management. Do not waste your money, you won't get what you ordered. read more

we ordered half chicken and half mushrooms. there was chicken and mushrooms everywhere, like they were just thrown on the pizza with their eyes shut. $32 for one medium pizza. the crust was burnt, it was the worst pizza we've ever had. will not be ordering from there anymore. read more

The best breakfast pizza in Cortland County Friendly service from the person taking the order on the phone to the person delivering the pizza to me thank you for the great service and awesome breakfast pizza read more

Ordered at 7:30 pm. Called for an update at 9pm, they said any second driver will be here. Never showed. Wouldn't answer their phone again to either update or cancel the order. Very poor. read more

will never order here again. asked for meat on only half of the pizza, and the whole thing had chicken. the pie is swimming in grease. asked for the wings extra crispy, and they are barely even warm, even though the order was just coming out of the oven as i arrived. the small pizza & wing deal comes with a 2L Pepsi product, and they gave a large fountain drink with a straw. so sad when i was very excited to support a local business. read more

I'd give a zero if I could for customer service. Horrible workers...they lie about calling and attempting to deliver just because it's time to close. I waited over an hour for my pizza and I called at 10pm to find out how much longer and they said they were closed and had no drivers. read more

We asked for blue cheese on the side... they filled a cup with mozzarella cheese on the side and didn't give a refund read more

A Pizza & More - We asked for blue cheese on the side and they litterally gave us a cup of mozzarella cheese on the side. I called and they refused a refund - Pizza Near Me - Cortland, New York

Slices are delicious! Try the chicken bacon ranch. Especially after some drinks next door! Slices start around $3. Either I was pretty drunk, or this pizza was really good! I opted for a slice of plain with pineapple on the side. read more

We have been customers for some time. We've had good pies and bad pies. As of lately they have been very good. When we asked them to be conscious of not burning the bottom of the pizza because we have kids who won't eat it if it's burnt, they have been great at complying. Will continue to patronize them. read more

First off, when I called I heard a bunch of the workers clapping and chanting in the background while I was trying to take my delivery order. Rather than working, they chose to giggle and laugh and mess around, but that's why they all get minimum wage. The girl on the phone was extremely rude and couldn't hear me over her buddies goofing around. After giving my card info she said "ok you're good" and hung up.. if I was the manager or owner I would be never embarrassed. This is also why you don't hire crack addicts, students or people with no work experience/ references. Completely a zoo and out of line, get it together Mr. Manager read more

I stop in for a slice of pizza to take home probably 6 or 7 times a year. In-house ambiance is bland plastic. Prices are reasonable. Garlic knots are good. Service at the cash register is very prompt and friendly. I once forgot my wallet (Ii live nearby and sometimes stop by on the way home from a walk around town) and the cashier, who recognized me, said no problem, just bring the money next time you stop by. She got a $5 tip for that the next day. I always ask for double pepperoni and I used to tell them "if you can see any of the cheese or sauce you don't have enough pepperoni on it yet" but I don't need to now 'cause they know me. They are the only pizza place I've ever been to anywhere that actually DOES do what I ask and put on all the pepperoni I could ask for. I like the pizza at Dominos and Pizza Hut at least as much if not more but at those places when I pay for double pepperoni and ask them to on LOTS of it, I'm lucky to get half of what they give me at Pizza and More so I come here more often. read more

I would give less stars if possible. The staff last night (10/19/2017) was both rude and disgusting when it comes to the conversation they were having in front of my friends and I. They spoke about the broken bathroom and how they were all using it anyways and letting their feces sit there, followed by how the sewage system "leaks across the dance floors" in the neighboring bars. They had no care that my friends and I were sitting there eating and clearly grossed out and disgusted by the conversation. Unhygienic and sickening. read more

The pizza is okay for upstate. It's pretty good after a night out but they don't have very good sanitation awareness. Everytime I go I get a cold cheese slice and the guy never uses gloves and touches all the slices and cheese bare hands and gave me attitude bc I asked him to use gloves read more

Usually great pizza and delivery. When we ordered tonight, delivery took over two hours. We were told "Sorry it's a busy night for us!" Sooooo ..... HIRE MORE DRIVERS. Not impressed, Pontillos for this holiday's gatherings. Wings were also cold and spilled everywhere. read more

ordered a small pack asked for pizza well done it was barely cooked,charged me two dollars for extra sauce didn't get it also didnt get the soda that was suppose to come with the deal asked for wings with extra sauce what I got was wings with extra oil and soggy from sitting in the oil do yourself a favour open a can of cat food it will taste better and save yourself almost thirty bucks including the tip for the driver read more