Very skeptical about their requirements for a Woodside rental…read more.. The broker told me I had to Zelle a thousand dollars in "good faith" in order to receive an application.... Like that right there feels weird!! The broker also mentioned not to call my bank to get my money back either.. It was mentioned, If i qualify it will be used as a down payment towards the fees.. but still. I personally wasn't comfortable with giving $1k for an "application". Like i have never heard of this.. especially this day in age. if it looks like a scam, feels like a scam... ITS A SCAM!

My colleague and I have been looking for an apartment and we came across his site. We saw some…read morepostings on the site, made some inquiries about them, and guess what, we never got a call back. There were claims that his site is inaccurate and that they don't know what those postings are or they aren't up to date. That isn't exactly my problem. We were told that he would get back to us in a few days, and its been a few weeks going on a month and we still haven't heard from him. And this site telling me that the response time is around 20 mins is absurd. Youre 20 mins late 3.5 weeks ago. Website - epitome of laziness and lack of professionalism. If you dont want my money, ill take my business elsewhere.

I've lived in a building managed by Alex for the past three years, and I truly can't say enough…read morepositive things about my experience with him and the Building Equity Management team. Alex is kind, understanding, and consistently communicative. He often replies to emails within minutes! Sokol, the super, has also been wonderful to work with. He's incredibly responsive, helpful, and always quick to address anything that comes up in the building. It's rare to find a team so reliable and easy to work with in property management, and it's made my experience living here seamless and stress-free. I'm very grateful to have had such a positive experience and would highly recommend Alex and the team to anyone.

For the past seven years I've lived in an UES pre-war building managed by Building Equity…read moreManagement. It's been a fantastic experience both as a resident as well as from someone having served on the co-op board as a Director and for the past five years, Board Chair. Michael Vinocur and his team are professional, always respectful and super responsive. They have handled every situation whether routine or emergency with great skill and attitude. I highly recommend Mike and his team!

Sharing my experience in the hopes of helping others avoid similar issues. Throughout my time as a…read moretenant, I encountered several unprofessional practices. Unethical Broker Practices: In April 2022 (post-COVID market peak), the brokers involved in my lease signing (Matthew Ryan Moreno and Randal Smith from R Brokers) pressured me to pay an additional $2,000 on the broker fee or risk losing the apartment. As licensed real estate agents, this behavior appears unethical. I reported them to the Division of Licensing Services and the issue was eventually resolved. However, BlueStar continues to work with this company. Misrepresentation on StreetEasy: BlueStar and R Brokers advertised the apartment on StreetEasy for $200 more than the actual rent, potentially manipulating the already inflated market. I reported this as well, and the listing was corrected. Disorganized Move-In: The previous tenant was granted extra days in the apartment by Bonita Burrell of BlueStar, but I was not informed. This left me scrambling to find last-minute accommodations and services for myself and my belongings on the expected move-in date. Despite my repeated attempts to hold BlueStar accountable, Bonita and her colleagues never took responsibility or apologized. Joshua even dismissed the issue by claiming the contract dates were "just estimates." Unclear Lease Renewal: Despite a declining rental market post-COVID, BlueStar opted to raise my rent. Conflicting statements from Pikus and Kaufman regarding the new lease amount caused confusion and delays in my payment. Early Termination: In December 2023, due to a job loss and visa situation requiring me to leave the US, I informed BlueStar. Although I had grounds to break the lease due to previous harassment, I opted for an amicable solution. They reluctantly agreed to terminate the lease on February 2nd in exchange for a $450 fee and my cooperation in showing the apartment. Security Deposit Withholding: Despite fulfilling my obligations and leaving the apartment in excellent condition on February 1st, BlueStar has not returned my security deposit of $3,300. On February 27th, my inquiry about the deposit went unanswered. As of today (April 3rd), they informed me they would retain the entire amount due to "costs involved", even though the lease was terminated by mutual agreement. New York law mandates the return of security deposits within 14 days, with any deductions clearly documented. Failing to do so within this timeframe necessitates the full return. Jeffrey Pikus appears to be aware of this law but disregards it. Similarly, Bonita Burrell's negligence regarding my move-in date resulted in additional expenses for me (over $1,000 for a last-minute hotel). Taking Action: To ensure I receive my deposit back and hold Jeffrey Pikus accountable, I have filed complaints with the New York Attorney General's Office and the Division of Licensing Services. Security Deposit Details: There's no justification for withholding a $3,300 deposit, even if a new tenant pays less due to market fluctuations. Here's why: i)The lease termination was agreed upon by BlueStar. Security deposits cannot be used for market-related rent reductions as stipulated in the lease agreement. ii)The new tenant likely moved in shortly after I left, with only four months remaining on the lease. Even if the rent was $300 lower, the total withheld amount would be significantly less than $3,300. iii)BlueStar failed to report any alleged "costs" within the 14-day window as required by law. Their decision to stop showing the apartment for a few days might also explain these additional costs. Additional Information: I have documented evidence to support everything mentioned in this review, including recordings, screenshots, and communication with authorities. If any claims are disputed here, I will be happy to post this proof. Help for Others: If you are experiencing similar issues with BlueStar Properties, feel free to contact me at revistas310@gmail.com. My name is Carolina, I will do my best to assist you.

AWFUL DO NOT RENT FROM THEM. We had major bed bugs issue in our apartment and they would not deal…read morewith it in a professional manner. In fact, we were blamed for the issue when it didn't even have to do with us. Every time we spotted a bed bug it was reported right away. The people they hired never properly treated the areas and the problems never went away. We basically fought these bugs all year. Bed bugs is one thing but the upkeep of our building was terrible. Our ceiling was caving in. The super (of which we had two) were unresponsive. The place was a mess. It was cheap and spacious but not worth all the drama extra money we had to spend because of all the issues. The MAJOR issue was the disrespect and lack of communication. I am understanding that infestations and accidents happen; but not being able to accommodate for your renters is absolutely ridiculous. PLEASE DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH THEM. IT IS 1000% NOT WORTH IT!!!!!

THEY DON"T EVEN DESERVE THE ONE STAR…read more DO NOT RENT FROM THEM. I lived at 231 East 76th Street for 21 years before it was sold to new owners who brought in MGT Property Management -- and it was the worst thing that ever happened to this building. We raised our children here because the apartments were large, charming, and full of character. Under the previous management, ROSE, there were some issues -- as with any NYC building -- but nothing too bad. When MGT took over, it felt like the entire energy of the building turned dark overnight. Not "movie evil spirits" -- real-life toxicity. They immediately began forcing out long-time tenants under the guise of "renovations." Those renovations destroyed the original spacious layouts. They crammed in closets (yes, useful in Manhattan) but at the cost of shrinking living space to tiny, cramped rooms. The only apartment that kept the original floor plan was ours -- because we fought for it. From the start, they treated tenants like prisoners. Punitive, rude, dismissive. Zero concern for tenant needs. Packages left outside if the doorman is on lunch -- and management's response? "We don't care." Apartments advertised as having central air -- they don't. "Full-time doorman"? Not true. They even rented units for a year with washer/dryers that were not hook up. If you have a serious issue with a neighbor (and trust me, there's a nightmare neighbor in the building), management will ignore it. They market this as a luxury building. At $9,300/month for a two-bedroom, you'd be far better off finding a place where management actually values tenants. After 24 years, we left. The building we moved into decades ago was gone -- replaced by a place with terrible energy, cold owners, and a management company that makes it clear: Once you sign the lease, you don't matter. And here's the lowest point: They refused to renew leases for long-time tenants just to renovate. One woman, in the middle of chemotherapy, begged them to let her stay. They claimed they "needed the apartment immediately." That apartment, 5C, sat empty for a year after she left. Horrible management. Horrible owners. Do not rent from them. Do your research there are plenty of reviews on this company NONE are positive.

0 stars is giving this management company a higher rating than it deserves. It has been over a…read moremonth, and they still haven't returned my security deposit or even replied to many of my MANY emails and calls. I also did not have working heat for over 6 months during the dead of winter and it only got resolved when I withheld rent to force action. They are pathetic by all accounts and if you can avoid any building run by them, I would. KEEP YOUR MONEY SAFE AND DO NOT RENT FROM THEM!!!

I've worked with a lot of property managers over the years, and I can say this team stands out!!…read moreThey're responsive, kind, and genuinely care about the people who live here. Every time I've had a question or request, it's been handled quickly and professionally -- no runaround, no attitude, just solid service. The property is always well maintained, clean, and feels safe. You can tell they take pride in their work and treat the place like they'd want to live here themselves. Special shoutout to the staff -- always friendly and helpful, whether it's a quick fix or just a smile in the hallway. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a well-managed property and a team that actually shows up for their residents!!

I have been waiting for the refund of my balance since when I sold my co-op apartment in August,…read more2025. In a phone call REM, staff even acknowledged that I had that balance of over $1,100.00! REM is till holding my money! J. W. 3/3/25

This company has left a decrepit property (614 Woodward Avenue) long abandoned which has led to…read moretrash build up, an infestation of rodents, and ultimately severe hazardous conditions for the Ridgewood neighborhood. They have raked in over half a million in fines for various violations yet refuse to fix a problem of their own creation. Not only are they slumlords based on the other reviews here and elsewhere, but they are a burden on the city as a whole.

Got a call from some guy claiming to be Silver Properties located somewhere on Long Island…read moreaccording to his area code. Claimed to be calling about an offer on a commercial property that is not listed for sale, because it is not for sale. Got my cell number from his "research team". When I explained I am not my Dad, and everything is in an ESTATE and he could lose my number, he wants to resort to calling me an inappropriate name. TOTAL LACK OF PROFESSIONALISM so you have been warned. One star only because it's mandatory.

Terrible customer service, would barely respond to emails, was 5 months late on returning our…read moresecurity deposit and that was ONLY after we consistently called, emailed, AND showed up in person at their office. They are clearly just trying to take advantage of their clientelle.

Absolute worst management company! The elevator in my building has broken down 50 times in one year…read moreand I've gotten stuck in the elevator and the super wouldn't answer. The elevator doesn't stop on my floor and I have to use the stairs. After reporting this to my super, he brushed it off. Our rent was increased by ten percent tho we are already overcharged. If the location weren't convenient, we never would have lived here.

I paid an expensive subscription fee to access a 6-month lease. After only 2 months, ALL TENANTS…read moreARE BEING ASKED TO VACATE because the master lease was lost. NO REAL SOLUTION WAS PROVIDED - No compensation, no reasonable alternative, and no assistance have been offered. We are just out.

I stayed with them for 6 months. They are terrible landlords who discriminate against people with…read moredisability and different races. They have rats in their buildings. One bathroom for 4+ people at the time. They scam you with different prices for same rooms same building. They don't comply with city and state laws. If you paid a deposit you will never see it back. Do yourself a favor and look for better options elsewhere.

Update: After posting my initial review John and Nick did reach out, and I received the check for…read morethe security deposit back today. Both were very helpful despite the initial issues we had. Just straight up never returned our security deposit and never gave us a receipt. Claims there was "no record we paid a security deposit" despite living in our apartment for 2 years and re-signing a lease. Impossible to get in touch with as they intentionally hide their email addresses / phone numbers.

Tenants living with chaos, noise, parties and destroy quality of life. Erodes the sense of…read morecommunity with transients, revolving door tenants.

Service was excellent while applying for new lease. Dan was our contact person and was super on top…read moreof everything right from the start.

Because the bar for property management in New York City is so low (lots of vendor lock in/high…read moreswitching costs), industry where consolidation and cost cutting has made quality drop, as a co-op board member, I have been incredibly pleasantly surprised by Daisy when we switched to them from first service residential. If you're considering the way to do it now. Worth it. They don't drop balls.