Use extreme caution when dealing with this company. We had a large tree limb spontaneously fall in…read moreour backyard, crushing our children's playhouse overnight. When we expressed our concern about the integrity of the tree (after it had been damaged by a fire 1 year ago), the property manager lied and stated it had been assessed by a certified arborist and deemed safe. Based on my home cameras, I knew this to be a lie. I hired an independent certified arborist who immediately advised the tree was a safety hazard to anyone living near it. Had I accepted their lie, I would have continued to let my children play under the tree and who knows what could have happened. Their willful negligence and dishonesty is unacceptable for anyone claiming to be a professional.

We love PMI Gulf Coast and the whole team! They are highly professional and they are quickl to…read morefollow up. We love how responsive they are to their customer and vendor partnerships. I highly recommend them!

Extremely Poor Property Management Experience - Fort Myers…read more Marshall Reddick did a very poor job managing my property in Fort Myers. I relocated to California for work (RTO) and left the property in August, giving Marshall Reddick full authorization to manage everything--including tenant placement and payment of utility bills. This was by far the most horrifying property management experience I've had, and I own properties managed in other states. Over several months, I was instructed to reduce my rent five separate times due to what they claimed was a "poor market," yet the company changed real estate agents 3-4 times without my consent. Each time, they failed to run the live Facebook marketing campaign they had explicitly promised. Most alarming, I was later informed that power to the property had been shut off for three weeks before Marshall Reddick notified me. I was told this occurred due to a lack of funds, and only after the prolonged outage was I informed of a potential microbial growth issue--a serious risk to the property that should have been addressed immediately. Despite providing a 30-day notice for non-performance, Marshall Reddick ignored the notice entirely and continued to demonstrate a complete lack of accountability, communication, and urgency. This experience showed a complete disregard for: Basic property oversight Timely communication Tenant placement execution Utility management Owner fiduciary responsibility I would strongly caution any property owner--especially those managing remotely--before trusting Marshall Reddick with their investment.

I've had a great experience with the Florida branch of Marshall Reddick so far. They've been…read moreresponsive to my requests and proactive around lease renewals. There has been a lot of turnover recently, but generally the staff has been pretty easy to work with

This is, unfortunately, the very first time I'm writing a bad review on the internet…read more 1) If you look into the first room to the left in their office, you will see piles of folders on the floor! So, how do they keep from losing paperwork? That's simple! They don't. They lost my paperwork and it's been tough proving to them that I did turn it in. They lost it! So, save everything. Every email, every text message, every maintenance document. Request a copy and save it all! This sounds overly-cautious and paranoid, but they will try to charge you for everything when you move out and if you haven't saved everything, you will have a tough time fighting it! 2) Take photos of everything (light fixtures, windows, carpet, walls, bath tubs) right when you move in, and try to get those same camera angles and take photos right when you move out! Don't alter the photos at all, just move them to your hard drive. The EXIF data will show the original date the photo was taken and they can't argue with that. 3) Be super detailed on your move-in inspection. If there's little pin-holes in the wall, if the sliding glass door sticks, if there are no curtain rods, if the carpet looks old, etc. You should attach paper to it, listing all of the things clearly, instead of trying to fit it in the tiny spaces they give you. And make them sign a copy showing they received it! 4) Make a note of everything they tell you, even if it doesn't seem to matter. If they marketed the place has "new flooring in the main area of the house," then that means the flooring in the bedrooms is probably old and that the flooring in the main area was really bad, or else nobody would have paid to put new flooring down. So, make a note of that! 5) Don't expect Amy to talk to you, ever. Her phone rang while I was in her office and she exclaimed at the receiver, "No matter how many times you call, I'm not picking up," quite amused with herself. If you really need to talk to Amy, then go sit in her office. She'll have a hard time ignoring you then. Alternatively, you can call the office number and ask to speak with Amy about a property you found online. She'll be so eager to talk to you. Lifehacks! Literally, I asked Amy for a call more than 15 times this week. Her last email to me ended: "This email has all of the necessary information needed; therefore there is no reason for a phone call." Never mind the poor sentence structure; this was rude! 6) Maintenance issues are hard to get fixed, because I think they only have one person coordinating maintenance for all the properties they manage. Poor guy. He's really hard to get a hold of, himself. 7) Amy's assistant Lisa is actually pretty awesome. Too bad Amy's not her assistant instead. Her going out of her way to follow-up with me today was greatly appreciated! Megan's also good! She's an actual human. She showed empathy and all! These two earned one star each for the company in my review. 8) Avoid the cleaning fee on the lease! Your unit will probably not be clean when you move in. So many others have said this in their reviews and I wish I listened to them! The WORST that happens is they put a claim on your deposit for $175 because you didn't clean well enough. If you have sufficient pictures from the day you moved out, you can easily fight that, too! 9) And my last bit of advice: when you move out and they charge you for a ton of things fight them if you don't agree! Since you're following my advice, you have a paper trail and photos of everything that happened! You can confidently list everything out for them and prove that you're competent enough to win this fight! I'm not saying don't rent from them. What I'm saying is to be diligent and keep records of everything with them, so you can get yourself out of having to pay for invalid charges along the way! I waited until I received word that I am getting my deposit back (yay) before posting this. This company needs to learn how to communicate as human beings! And they need to hire a temp to organize their files right away!

Worst property management group ever! They replaced our condo mailboxes and have failed to provide…read morea key to our mailbox. When I called to let them know I'm coming to get the key to my mailbox key they replied with I'll give you call when we get the keys? EXCUSE ME! I HAVE BILLS TO PAY THAT WILL NOW BE LATE! And it's been over 2 weeks TERRIBLE!

Dan Baber is a true professional in a business filled with mediocrity. Running both a property…read moremanagement operation as well as a real estate brokerage gives him a grounded and realistic perspective that is valuable for me as an investor.

Carol helped me with my Condo at Positano. From the communication, listing, showing to the…read morepaperwork - everything was great. I would highly recommend her.

Reed Property Management has been managing our rental real estate portfolio for over 3 years, and…read moredoing a great job. our revenue has increased and our day to day headaches decreased. They are very knowledgeable and professional and work through problems to conclusion. our properties are inspected and reports generated at least twice a year, and in many cases quarterly. Kim and Shay are very honest in their approach to management and are responsive to ownership and residents. It is well worth the cost to have them. D Cooper

Terrible handling of Bromelia place 55+ senior living in immokalee!! Property management lies and…read morereally doesn't care about residents!

We were able to conduct all of our realtor related transactions remotely with full transparency and…read moreease. It was a pleasure doing business with Lynn and her team. With my full endorsement, Jim Priest

Lynn and Pamela are incredible and have a keen pulse on the market. I've been talking to Lynn for…read moreover two years as my plans to move have changed a few times. Lynn was so patient and understanding while I figured out my timing. Once I was more committed to a timeline, Lynn and Pamela went right to work and made the entire process so smooth. By the time we were ready to put the house on the market, we had so much interest and momentum generated that our house had multiple offers within hours. We ended up getting everything we asked for plus more and all within the timeline we had planned. Lynn and Pamela are compassionate, competent, and well connected to exceed your expectations in selling your home. They communicate very effectively and provide sound advice throughout the process. I selected them purely on reading reviews and I am happy to add to the long list of 5 stars that they deserve.

I live in Horsecreek Estates in Naples, Florida. Our HOA is managed by Sandcastle Community…read moreManagement and our representative is Briana Clavijo. she is fantastic at her job. She responds within 24 hours for a routine question and gives excellent professional and efficient service. The most recent matter that she handled expeditiously for me was an ARC Application for a new roof. I would also like to compliment the board of our HOA who handles everything expeditiously as well. We are truly blessed to live in Horsecreek Estates Naples, Florida. i would also like to thank my Roofer, Norman Hinspeter, whose professional professionalism and quality of workmanship are excellent

It took a week to receive a response to a simple question. Return calls, messages promptly. You are…read morein the service bus. 2) I asked our property manager's job description so that I could confirm I was in the right dept. she said:"I am a portfolio mgr."That sounds like banking to me. She became curt with me. Communicate with residents/owners on how to navigate your Byzantine management process

Brandy is the best realtor ever. She listens, asks great questions, only shows you properties that…read morematch your search criteria, and is super fun, while being professional. We were not from the area, so she helped us understand the different areas and pros and cons. You will not be disappointed- choose Brandy.

In this crazy market, you definitely need an experienced, knowledgeable realtor and Brandy is just…read morethat plus more! She knows how crazy it is negotiating the sales of homes right now in Cape Coral and well, anywhere great to live these days! Of course it was a weekend and she had a funeral, but she was patient and understanding and went out of her way to help. We didn't get the house, but hopefully soon! M Y R E A L T O R

Just be careful at the end of your lease when you leave they are always going to charge and…read morededucted from your deposit paint which is -$900 and the filters. Even if you replaced and put new filters this company is such a scam that they will take out of your deposit those -$900 and the excuse is the paint and filters. Even if you do not make any holes on the wall and leave everything clean they will take that out of your deposit if you lease with this company be aware of this concern. They did it to me and my friends and also 3 family members. 5 different locations and everything was clean and no damages. They are scamming everyone with that issue. Paint and A/C filters. Stay away or be ready for their -$900 commission at the end of your lease. Even if you go to their office and complain they will keep saying that the inside cost of paint is -$900 so that means that even the if you leave everything clean and no damages they will take -$900 for them. Stay away !!!!!

I purchased two preconstruction apartment units from Benoit Properties in 2022. At the time of…read morepurchase, I was told the project would be completed by the end of 2024. Later, they changed the timeline to the first half of 2025. As of today, the building is still stuck at the third floor -- now I see new ads for this building and says that it will be completed in 2027. Throughout this process, the service I received from Benoit Properties, especially from salesperson Brad Craw and his manager Matt Lavin, was absolutely unacceptable. When I tried to sell or transfer one of my units during construction, Brad completely ignored my requests. When I escalated the issue, Matt Lavin was not only arrogant but also dismissive and unhelpful, treating me with clear disrespect. Do not believe a single word they say. Once you purchase, you are on your own -- no support, no professionalism, and no accountability. I will never again buy anything through Benoit Properties and would strongly advise others to stay away. Save yourself the stress, disappointment, and financial risk.