This is about the SERVICE. The place and product are our favorite. Tonight 5/14/22 at 8:30 we arrived with no one in line. There were 5 girls working and they all appeared to be teenagers. One girl had her hood up and her cap on top of her hood. She sold someone some candy and then lingered behind the candy counter appearing to be staring at the cash/monitor screen, never looking around. Another one stayed at the far end of the ice cream counter folding napkins as slow as she could. One was making 3 malts. The other 2 appeared to be filling orders for those eating in. During the 15 minutes we waited we were totally ignored. After one girl finished orders, she came over in front of us, ignored us, and began scaping ice cream off of the sides of containers. One girl finally acknowledged our existence after 6 other folks came in and formed a line. In all of the many years we visited Aglamesis we have never seen such rude and incompetent workers. I regretted having recently referred a new person to them fearing that he might experience this awful awful service. There appeared to be no manager monitoring this group. read more

I've been going to this location since I was a little kid (for over 35 years)! It's part nostalgia of course, why I'm such a fan, but the candy is phenomenal, the ice cream amazing, and the service and staff are outstanding. I think their ice cream is better than Graeter's and the decor is very classic with a 1950's feel. They also have some unique smoothie and soda concoctions. Give this place a try! read more

Aglamesis is so classic and a real TREAT to go to. Best ice cream in Cincinnati....and yes I'm including Graeter's in that comparison- don't get me wrong Graeter's is also wonderful but Aglamesis puts the cherry on top for me. Also it should be noted that they put two little butter cookies around your straw if you get a milkshake! It's exciting read more

This place is a throwback to brilliant ice cream joints from days gone by... The recipe is so freakin' smooth and the flavors are amazing... I know most have an affinity for that Graet Ice Cream joint Cincy is most known for but, I love this place, it's authenticity and its tasty treats. It definitely gives that other joint a run for it's money... Y'know I once told a patron, at a previous job I held up the road, that I prefered Aglamesis taste and texture to that of the other joint (when they asked specifically for my favorite) and don't you know as I stood, with stars in my eyes, recollecting my last visit, that Richard "you know who", the president of that other joint, was standing right freakin' next to me... Smiling... He introduced himself, shook my hand and thanked me for my honesty when I explained that, "I calls 'em like I tastes 'em..." Just sayin'... read more

Compared to most people, I am not that crazy about ice cream. *Jaw drop* My weakness is cookies. (And chocolate and froyo and pudding and macarons). But I must admit that Aglamesis is one-of-a-kind. First, the store itself is so old-school. You actually sit down to order dessert from a menu. Color scheme is pink. All they need is a few booths to make it feel like you're back in the 50s. Cute place for a date, as many have probably figured out. Then, you get to indulge in the most decadent French-style ice creams you could possibly get in the Midwest without taking it straight from the cow's udder. I ordered the Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip just to see how it compares to Graeter's, and holy COW... everyone's right--the flavor is so intense. I also got a scoop of the Champagne Sorbet, which was just OK in my book (others love it, apparently). I tried my friend's seasonal Peach ice cream, and it felt like fireworks went off in my head... amazing, amazing flavor. read more

It doesn't get any better than this! Graeter's pales in comparison to Ag's. Aglamesi's ice cream doesn't have that greasy taste to it nor the waxy texture to the chocolate chips. All flavors are crazy tasty, but I love the mint chocolate chip - you can tell its made with real mint because its not a crazy radioactive artificial green color. My dad also claims that their butterscotch ice cream is by far the best he's had in his whole life - and he's a connoisseur of butterscotch. Which brings us to the toppings - wow! The butterscotch is amazing, but i love the option of marshmallow cream or whipped cream. The whipped cream is great because they make it by hand, but also because they'll flavor is for you - chocolate whipped cream, mint whipped cream... the possibilities are endless! The candy is by far the best in Cincy. AND they offer a wide variety of sugar free candies for my diabetic friends - which is amazingly difficult to find in Cincy. The easter eggs are my favorite - try the opera cream. And to top it all off - the shop is just about the most uplifting and charming place, a throw back to the "old time" soda shops. You can have wait service or buy it by the pint - either way its tasty! read more

This gem in Oakley is surprisingly unknown to even locals. I have a feeling people keep this secret to themselves should popularity somehow corrupt the purity of Aglamesis Bros'. On a recent visit I bought a bag of malted Easter eggs and am now too spoiled to ever crave store bought ones again. I love the sampler boxes because they prevent an indecisive gal like me from spending an hour gawking at the tantalizing display case. If you're looking for a unique Mother's Day or Valentine's Day (or any day for that matter) gift, a little sweet treat from Agalmesis would be perfect. Another recommendation is that their lunch sandwiches are very tasty. I really enjoyed the chicken salad, but the turkey and cheese was good as well. Nothing fancy, just fresh bread and high quality ingredients. My only minor critique is that the lemonade is very tart. Almost too tart for my liking, though that may just be a matter of taste. read more

Ordered a butter pecan waffle cone and it was the best butter pecan I've had in Cincy. This ice cream has vaulted to the top of my list and their menu seems to have a lot of options. read more

We went on a weekend at the beginning of summer and they were swamped. We were able to get a table, but had to wait a very long time for someone to come to our table and a very long time to get our ice cream. However, it's a very cool place that makes you feel like you've stepped back in time and the ice cream was amazing! Would definitely go back but would not pick a weekend night to do so! read more

Aglamesis Bros - Banana superb. Def lives up to its name! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

This is my favorite ice cream parlor in Cincinnati. The ice cream is really good and I have been enjoying it since I was a child. When I was younger, my favorite flavor was the Banana and I still love it but with age it has become harder to pick a favorite. Not long ago I tried the Butterscotch and it was amazing, though it was very sweet so be warned. My wife loves the Mocha Chip and I agree that it is one of their best flavors. I also really like the Dutch Chocolate. They also do seasonal flavors like Black Cherry or Red Raspberry and hard to find flavors like Rum Raisin. I often pick up a couple pints and take them home but sometimes we stop in to enjoy a treat and sit inside. All the ice cream is made in small batches in the back. They also make their own chocolates and candies. They have a full case of chocolates and candies and you can purchase them one at a time or as a box of assorted ones. One of the greatest things about Aglamesis is the experience. The outside of the building is light pink and as soon as you step inside it feels like you went back in time. Tiffany lamps, marble paneling, cute little tables and chairs, and employees in older styled uniforms. It may be the only ice cream parlor left like this in the world. If you eat inside they serve you ice cream in old fashioned stemmed metal dishes. This is a fantastic way to enjoy a banana split or a sundae. I highly recommend this to anyone that has never been. They also have great floats and even a good coffee frappe. And with regard to the Cincinnati discussion of whether Aglamesis or Graeter's is better, I always choose Aglamesis! I personally think that Graeter's focuses too much on the chocolate chips and not enough on the ice cream. While Aglamesis offers some flavors with chocolate chips, I mostly prefer flavors without. read more

Came here because I was not impressed with the store bought container and I actually was unaware that it was a local creamery. I thought that the idea was really cute and comfortable. It is a full service ice cream parlor, which you don't come by often. Everyone was dressed to the part and I loved the Cincinnati love it showed. The sundaes were to die for. So many to offer they were just very pricey!! Double dollar sign for sure for ice cream $$. Aglamesis is very easy to spot out along the street with their inviting pink décor and outside, and inside matches. My boyfriend got a chocolate malt and is was nothing but malt. A little disappointed because we were really not able to taste the ice cream because it was so malty and milky. On the plus side, they do offer you a lot of ice cream. They fill up a cute glass and then give you all the extra that was left in the mixing cup. The sundae I got was amazing! I was a brownie with fudge and caramel and pecans and whipped cream! It was a lot of toppings but again, not much ice cream, but it really was delicious. Overall it was a really good experience. I just wish I would have been able to get a real good taste of the ice cream, because I've heard such agreat things, rather than all the addatives. read more

Excellent. I ordered a vanilla malt and my fiancé ordered a scoop of cookies 'n creme with a waffle cone. I hadn't been here in years and it was delicious. The malt was perfectly blended and super delicious. My fiancé's ice cream was also really good. This is a great Cincy spot for out of town-ers and is close to Oakley square and several lunch/dinner spots. If you're looking for something "healthy" they have a good selection of what they call fresh fruit ice which is sorbet ice cream. I haven't tried it but with how good everything else is I'm sure it's delicious. read more

I have been coming to Aglemesis Bro's for years (aka since I first came to Cincy). I am not a huge dessert person, but I love this place. The store and the decor are on point. It is old fashioned and comfortable. It really reminds me of a scene out of an old 80s movie. The ice cream is also pretty good. I am no connoisseur but from what I get, its not as heavy as Graeters. I would argue that this is a positive for me. My favorite is the pistachio, but this is only seasonal. Else the last time I went, I thought it was the best strawberry ice cream I had ever had. It was nom nom delicious! I give it 5 stars, because Its a go to spot for me to bring new people in from out of town. read more

I must admit I'm a born and bred Graeter's girl so it took me a bit to warm up to this place but I'm not sure why I ever resisted. Some of the menu offers overlapping flavors but I've learned to appreciate each place for what they do best. I'll stick with Graeter's for the Cookies and Cream but I could eat Aglamesis Black Raspberry Chip all day long. The charm and history of this place rocks. They are generous with samples and service is always great. Walking here is one of the best parts about living in Oakley! read more

Growing up behind the Aglamesis Bros. ice cream shop in Montgomery (and frequently visiting), this place has always been my favorite Cincinnati ice cream place. Their traditional French ice cream is made even sweeter with their pink soda pop parlor decor, and it is hard to pick just one handmade flavor to enjoy while visiting! I stopped by the Oakley shop after eating in the area with my boyfriend. We ordered one scoop of their Chocolate Chip and Chocolate Almond ice cream, and they were both decadently rich and delicious! We got out ice cream to go, but if you stay in the shop, they will serve you at one of their tables. read more

The staff is phenomenal and the environment and history can't be beat. They are currently celebrating 100 years in Oakley. We were seated and got water quickly. Their service was great and our bourbon sundae and mint chocolate shake were great. We'll be back soon. read more

See all

In Cincy for the weekend and was taken to this delightful little old fashioned ice cream parlor. Two people at the counter had ice cream sodas that looked delicious, but I opted for the mocha chip in a sugar cone. The coffee flavor was wonderfully intense with large chunks of chocolate. Although Italy's divine gelato is always Number 1 for me, I'm not there. In Cincy, this is very good ice cream. read more

I've been here twice with my wife. Outstanding both times! We will definitely be back!

Aglamesis is a favorite of mine because I feel like I'm in a time machine. It is beyond retro and very cute. There seems to be a war between Aglamesis and some other cincy favorite and I would like to say that I vote for Aglamesis! Their ice cream is delicious but I especially love their sorbets (also known as italian ice). Their numerous flavors are unique and never disappointing. I have gotten a different flavor each time I visit and I have loved them all. Go visit, sit out on their patio and enjoy a frozen treat :) read more

Thieir ice cream is amazing. My favorite is banana chip and the chocolate covered oreos are awesome ! The shop itself kinda makes you you feel like your a ice cream shop from back in time. The staff is always inviting. I recommend anyone with a sweet tooth visit here! I always bring my guest here when I have company in town. read more

Let me start with the fact that I don't love ice cream. It's good, but I fancy myself more of a French fry person than one who, say, enjoys sweets. Therefore, if you want to keep reading this review, let's do it! Otherwise, if you don't trust my non-discerning opinion, feel free to check out (see also: you should keep reading if only for fun). That said, it should be no surprise that I've not been to Aglamesis Brothers in my 27+ years of life. Just this past weekend, Date and I decided that needed to be changed. Location: planted amid the hustle and bustle of Oakley Square, Aglamesis Brothers (it's written Bros., so I will continue to write and pronounce it as "Bros"), an ice cream confectionery boasting a pink facade, couldn't have earned a much better location for its shoppe (I feel like it deserves the English spelling, no?). With a number of restaurants surrounding it, Aglamesis lends its perfectly dessert-like hand in a convenient location for post-meal delicacies. If you're looking to check it out after a delicious meal in the Square, walking is perfectly doable. If not, a number of parking spots are available in lots and on the street as well. [Pre-Aglamesis Bros meal suggestions in the Square: Oakley Pub for a burger, Habit's Café for any of its extensive menu, Baba India, Boca for pricier fare and valet parking, Maribelle's for a burger or brunch, or even Skyline or Dewey's for more popular chain restaurants.] Atmosphere: Sitting inside of this ice cream parlor, I felt like I was either auditioning for or had a small role in The Music Man. That's not necessarily a bad thing (I happen to really enjoy that movie); merely an observation. The interior decor is home-like and comfortable, if a little kitschy (read: way too much pink). It truly feels like a confectionery, complete with plenty of ice cream options, pastries, and candies (we got the 12-Flavor Gummy Bears which were delicious). Food: In standard ice cream form, I opted for one dip French Vanilla and one dip Holland Dutch Chocolate on a sugar cone overturned into a bowl (if an ice cream place can't master the originals, what's the point?). I could have easily done without the French Vanilla, as it was nothing to blog home about. The chocolate was very good, though, even if it reminded me a ton of Graeter's. Date decided on Mocha Chip in a rainbow jimmy-dipped waffle cone. He seemed to enjoy it, despite the ice cream making its way through the cone opening at the bottom (this was his only vocal complaint--he's kind of quiet though, so what do I know?). Next time I go, I decided I will get Banana Chocolate Chip, mostly because I've never seen it elsewhere, and secondly because they were out last time I was there (probably a good thing--it wouldn't have been awesome to have to choose between my "regular" and that). Overall Grade: C+ [out of a possible A+] -- rounded up to a 4 for Yelp rating purposes. I'm really glad I finally got to try this place. While I don't particularly love ice cream (especially of the scoop persuasion), it was good enough (read: above average) and I'm sure I'll be back in the future. If you like Graeter's, you must check this place out. read more

Let me start this review off with this simple fact, I LOVE ICE CREAM. Remember that kid when you were little that you would see chasing the ice cream truck across the neighborhood? That was me. But Aglamesis Bros is different, and takes ice cream to a whole new level. What I loved most about this place was the ice cream experience they offered. When you enter the parlor there's retro pictures and items, you feel like you are transported to the 60s, back when going to the ice cream parlor was THE Friday night activity. There's a lot of discussion between which is better, Aglamesis Bros or Graeter's, but frankly they are just different. Graeter's is known for the delicious chunks of chocolate in their ice cream, while Aglamesis boasts rich and creamy ice cream. You really can't go wrong with either, but if you haven't tried one, you must. read more

The reason I love Aglamesis is not because of their ice cream, but because of their "ices". The sorbets are the best in town and always fresh and flavorful. The champagne ice is one of my favorites and always a good pick me up that doesn't make me feel as terrible about myself as ice cream. It's like a fat free, frozen wine (not really alcoholic by the way) of happiness. Not to say their ice cream isn't good - it really is. Their chocolate is nice, smooth, and dark. Their peppermint is my second favorite in town. The store itself is too adorable to be true and very old fashioned. It's a great place to shoot some photos in the area because it is so well maintained and set up. Service is always good. Definitely worth stopping by. For experience and atmosphere, this beats out any other ice cream parlor around. read more

Love it. From the pink lotus lamps to the handwritten additions to the menu board. I always buy gifts for co-workers there for the holidays, and my little one, husband and I treat ourselves to the variety of flavors to choose from the ice cream side. The ice cream? The best...pure, creamy and the flavors stand out, even when your tongue gets numb from the cold. How could ANYONE turn down Butterscotch ice cream? Or Peppermint stick with a little dish of bittersweet chocolate on the side...ok. Enough. I'm wishing I was there again, even though I was just there on Monday! Their candies are excellent, their ice cream better, and the staff is so much more friendly than any area Graeter's I've ever been in. read more

Charming neighborhood shop with fantastic ice cream and wonderful service. Beware of the handmade chocolates on display. I had a root beer float with chocolate ice cream. Divine. read more

Great milk shakes and ice cream in a soda fountain atmosphere! Black raspberry chip and mocha chip are my favorites.

Stepping though the front door of this ice cream parlor/candy shop is the closest thing you can get to time travel. Upon entering and seeing the old-fashioned set up, you're almost forced to turn around and look out the windows to make sure you haven't taken a giant leap into the past. I'll go ahead and get the obvious out of the way. The ice cream....great. The candy....great. The staff....great. The turn-of-last-century atmosphere....pretty cool. The prices are a little higher than what you might see at a Baskin-Robins or Graeter's, but remember, you're not just paying for the ice cream. You're paying for the experience as well. Some of the things I really appreciate about this place is that it's located smack-dab in the middle of the neighborhood (Oakley), it has a history spanning nearly 100 years, and it's still family owned. In fact the last time I checked, the family that owns Algamesis Bros. are directly related to the same family that opened it so many years ago. Algamesis Bros. is one of those hidden gems that every city has. Lifelong residents can stumble upon this and think to themselves, "How have I never known that this was here?" A great way to kill a bit of a summer afternoon. Mahalo, and enjoy. read more

This is the cutest ice cream shop you'll find yourself in Cincinnati. It has the feel of the 1950s and is family friendly. It feels like utopia. The ice cream is one of my favorites in Cincinnati. They have all the right flavors (banana too!). The ice cream is lighter then other Cincinnati favorites which is why I love it so much. The chips are plentiful and in every bite. I tend to get flavors other than vanilla or chocolate but when they were offering their free ice cream for the 100th anniversary I tried both. Both plain vanilla and chocolate were superb. I may order a plain chocolate scoop next time I'm there. It was that good! The only thing I wish there could be more of is outdoor seating. We tend to stop by while walking our dog and it can be busy at times. The dog loves stopping for ice cream too because there are always other dogs around and a water bowl to quench his thirst. read more

I honestly have to say that I'd never been to Aglamesi's prior to last weekend, but at the suggestion of a couple friends, decided to indulge. I love the interior - definitely has an Old Fashioned decor, complete with imported Italian Marble table tops. Choose a table, and a hostess comes over with a complementary glass of water and menus. There are not as many flavors as other places, so if that's your thing, you should probably go elsewhere. I settled on a dip each of double chocolate chip and mint chocolate chip in a dish. Of the two, the mint chocolate chip was the hands down favorite - very minty, which I loved! The price wasn't too bad - about $4 , which is about what you pay for two scoops in a dish at Graeter's. The store has a huge candy selection, which thanks to generous friends, I was able to sample some. I highly recommend the chocolate covered pretzel covered with peanut butter chips! read more

From the moment I walked in the door of Aglamesis Brothers I fell in love! The decor of the place is so charming, and my friend and I were surprised when we were told we could take a seat and a waitress brought us a menu! I've never been to an ice cream shop with a waitress. Our waitress was extremely nice and very helpful and quick. I got the strawberry ice cream and it was definitely the best I've ever had. So smooth and a great fruity taste. My friend got the butterbeer, the drink from Harry Potter! It was also delicious, though he found it slightly too sweet. We will certainly be returning to Aglamesis Bros sooner than later. Best place in Cinci for sure. read more

Everybody has a calling. Something that they are meant to do. For some people like Paul McCartney it's to make awesome music. For others like Mike Brown, it's to run a major league sports team into the ground. For the Aglamesis brothers, it's to produce decadent chocolate candies and extraordinary ice cream. Not familiar with the Aglamesis Bro's shop in Oakley? Let me paint you a picture. Imagine if you will homemade ice cream served to you 1950s countertop style in a silver dish. And not just any ice cream. Creative and celestial flavors fit for a god like banana chocolate chip ice cream. And cinnamon ice cream. Imagine also that you can turn any one of their 20+ flavors of ice cream into a kickass sundae. And not just any ice cream sundae but sundaes that make UDF sundaes look like the ice cream bar at Golden Corral. Ice cream not your thing? How about a 15 foot long case filled with blissful orgasmic chocolate candies. And not just any average candy. I'm talking about delectable chocolates that make Hershey and Dove chocolates taste like your grandmother's sugar free diabetes candy. Seriously, there is bourbon soaked cherry cordials, dark chocolate sea salt caramels, and award-winning chocolate covered creams. With every day that passes my calling becomes more clear to me than ever. Meet one of the Aglamesis sisters and make her my wife. And then live out a long jubilant life filled with banana ice cream, bourbon soaked cherry cordials, and happiness. read more

Came here the other night for dessert following dinner at Bakersfield, it was our first time having Aglamesis, and yes I have lived in Cincinnati my entire life. It was very good, since it was our first time, we ordered a scoop of vanilla, my brother a hot fudge sundae, and I ordered a basin sundae containing vanilla and chocolate ice cream with fudge sauce. I like how you order at the table and the employees bring the ice cream out, like at a normal restaurant, plus the ice cream is served in a silver dish. Very nice shop and employees with a lot of history, I will be in again, I however like another Cincinnati ice cream over this. read more

Just wow... I mean, what can I write that will convince you that this is awesome ice cream? Just go... now... I had chocolate chocolate chip with strawberries and whipped cream... oh, if I had a bowl of it now! GO NOW! (as Hannibal Lecter says) read more

Oh Aglamesis, how I miss you. My husband and I loved stopping in for ice cream when we lived in Oakley - your ice cream was one of my favorite things in Cincinnati. I was never a Graeter's kinda girl (I hope its safe to say that now that I don't live there anymore). I loved your super cool old school ice cream parlor - truly genuine and not contrived. And your tasty, freshly-flavored ice cream. Mint chocolate chip in a waffle cone (oh so very minty and delicious). Perhaps one day if I find myself in the Queen City I'll get to visit again. read more

Definitely as good as it gets in my opinion. It's not that every single flavor of Aglamesis Bros deserves the highest ratings. I have had flavors I thought were not as well done as they could be. But when they get it right, there is ABSOLUTELY no better ice cream to be found (in my humble opinion). The current black raspberry chocolate chip is literally, 'to die for'. It is that good. The butterscotch and the pineapple pecan are also great. I haven't tried many flavors, so I am sure there are more that are just as good (my next trial might be the red raspberry chocolate chip). Bottom Line: Aglamesis is a Cincinnati treasure. The shop in Oakley is a fun place to visit, and there is just no better place I have found anywhere in the midwest at least, that is better for ice cream. read more

Such a great Cincinnati business! So much more fun then Graeters boring locations. We love going there on a hot day!

In my opinion the best thing about the place is the ambiance, the look of a 1950's malt shop. Reminds me of old family photos with my parents on 1 of their earliest dates or my grandparents out with the family on a 'ice cream night' to celebrate a special occasion! The ice cream is always great no matter what flavor you try. The service is sometimes inconsistent depending on the how busy they are. I have recommended the place to multiple people who always report being happy with their visit. I will continue to be a customer. read more

Close to home. Better than the other guy with a good product. Location allows for other shopping, like grocery, pet supplies vis Pet People, Kroger and a locally owned wild bird shop. read more

Yummy! The BEST peanut butter malts EVER! Go there! Try it! It is good stuff!

I loved the decor and want to have one of the counter lamps so bad! The staff is great and let me try plenty of samples before deciding on butter pecan and double chocolate. My son got chocolate chip which was also very good and my husband the strawberry with fresh strawberries, all was very very good and even though there are only your standard flavors to chose from those are made extreamly well! read more