Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Alewife

    4.3 (329 reviews)
    Closed 5:00 pm - 9:30 PM
    Updated over 3 months ago

    Alewife Photos

    Business Info

    ALEWIFE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Hipster
    Casual
    Trendy
    Classy

    You might also consider

    More like Alewife

    Recommended Reviews - Alewife

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Ryan C.

    My wife and I were looking for seafood and found Alewife. Reservations weren't hard to come by for 5PM on a Friday. Small little place on the corner, we actually missed at first. Street parking only but wasn't hard to find. We came in being one of the first parties in. Our server explained the menu in full and all the specials in full. To drink we had the Bebot and the Monkey Business to start, both were really good. The thing we knew we needed to have to eat was the Siren's Song special which was a lazy Susan full of different dishes. The Siren's Song consisted of oysters, fried clam strips, smoked fish dip, seared tuna, pineapple fried rice, and a fried fish collar (sorry don't remember the fish, maybe Skate) with a Szechuan dry rub on it. This seriously was an amazing display. Every single dish just took it up a notch. They were also super nice to accommodate making it pescatarian because the Siren's Song usually has meat elements. The fried collar really blew me away. So meaty, fried perfectly, and the dry rub was so flavorful but not too salty or hot. Despite finishing the whole Siren's Song, we also got the Cascatelli without guanciale which was also delicious. We finished off with their caramel custard which wasn't too sweet and had a great mix of textures and flavors. Also tried one of their NA drinks and a glass of their special chilled Grenache Noir which was surprisingly good (not a big red wine fan). Overall, we absolutely loved it here. Each dish was amazing, drinks were also good, service was on point, and it was just a beautiful dinner. We will definitely be coming back.

    Wine menu
    Ana B.

    What a stunning airy and bright restaurant in Church Hill in Richmond. It's immaculately decorated, and the staff is super friendly. Whenever I see something written on the board that says: ask about... I will always ask. In this case the chalkboard said: Ask about the Siren Song. Mermaids are my all time favorite thing so we asked. Essentially it's a chef's appetizer pairing of several dishes made from the left over pieces of the fish, it changes daily and it's not always available. There were three of us, and we weren't sure how many items to get, and thank goodness the waitress was like Woah, you're ordering too many things. We started our meal with some espresso martinis (we were exhausted and needed a little pick me up) and they have a nice walnut bitter and I liked it a lot. I have a hard time with the espresso martini currently, it can be too sweet. We ordered for three: Siren Song, raw & chilled oysters, local green salad, the crispy softshell crab and a fish special. I liked a lot of the items on the siren song and what a great way to be sustainable and provide delicious food. I found their crispy clam strips to be a little too salty, but otherwise enjoyed the sauce and spices. Their oysters were interesting, I've never been served raw oysters already dressed and I did really like the michelada and garlic chive oil, but I do wish I would've dressed them myself. The salad was my favorite, the crispy ham, asparagus and boiled egg was what I needed. Overall the meal was good but nothing super special and the cocktails were a bit smaller than what I expected at the price point. However, it's a great spot and it's close to some of the other bars in the area that we wanted to check out. I think you should always get the siren song here! It's a cool and niche thing and delicious.

    Dalton S.

    Decided to give alewife a try while my mother was in town and I have some mixed reviews on the experience. Started out with drinks and they were ok. My mother tried to order a drink and they said that it wasn't available so she had to order something else, she tried to order her entrée which they said it was unavailable as well which left us a little disappointed off the rip. However, when the food actually came out, it was actually good. It was seasoned a little bit salty for my mother's taste however, in my opinion, everything was seasoned well. My steak was cooked just like I liked it and personally I was happy with the way the entrées turned out. Not sure how frequently I would return, but overall, some marks were hit and some weren't.

    Scallops
    Stephanie A.

    Alewife is consistently amazing; everything from food to service, to the atmosphere. Went out on a double date last night with friends and all of our meals were incredible. Everything came out hot, perfectly seasoned, flavorful. My favorite part of our meal was the braised cabbage, which typically would be the last thing I would ever order. It was THAT good. This is the type of restaurant where you could order anything on the menu and you would love it! 10/10, go check them out :)

    Harrison C.

    Alewife is the perfect place for a slightly elevated evening out! The food is delicious and the atmosphere is laid-back but clean and slightly elevated. It's a nice quiet spot for a really good meal. We got the clams as a starter then I got an oyster Poboy. Everything was absolutely amazing.

    Pork katsu
    Julia W.

    Beautiful presentation, mid food, not sure what all the hype is from these reviews. I had high expectations from the raving reviews, and while the dishware and presentation was exquisite (some of the bowls are $50 a plate online!), the food was disappointing. First, when we walked in around 5 PM to a basically empty restaurant on a weekday, we were told that the tables were all reserved and we had to sit at a specific area at the bar. Even if the tables were reserved, most of them were not filled until more than halfway through our meal so that was a little strange why we were placed at the bar. Then the food, the fish was a minuscule piece, they definitely could have used with larger portions. The brown butter cabbage underneath tasted just burnt. The pork katsu was so dry!! We didn't finish it and ended up throwing away the leftovers because of how utterly unappetizing it was. The oysters on the half shell were nothing really special. The basque cheesecake was just alright. The only items that were better were the fried clams and fried oyster sandwich, but certainly not at the level that I think deserved the glowing raving reviews. Overall was disappointed in the food and our experience when being seated, and won't recommend or return.

    Andrea A.

    Food and service were amazing during brunch. We shared a few small plates and really enjoyed everything. We were even greeted with a complimentary nonalcoholic drink for our friend's birthday. The restaurant has plenty of seating and is the perfect backdrop for a special meal. We started with the beet salad and smoked fish dip. Both were fresh and flavorful. I especially loved the fish dip, which we heard will never come off the menu. The grilled focaccia and pickled vegetables were a nice touch. The beet salad has a tangy but perfect vinaigrette. I got the fish which came with an amazing sweet potato puree. The puree was nothing short of perfect! The dish also had roasted carrots and the skin on the fish was oh so crispy. I'm excited to go back for dinner soon!

    Apartment in the City...kinda like a Manhattan...kinda like a Negroni.  Really fabulous
    Randy B.

    Solid 4 stars. Reservations highly recommended. They do have a few seats available at the bar, but I prefer to sit at a table in the back corner to view everything going on. Food is excellent, and craft cocktails are fantastic. Both the dinner and bar menus frequently change.

    Duck
    Zara T.

    Popped in while on a work trip. I sat at the bar with my book, and had a lovely time. The menu switches often, maybe weekly (?), so I couldn't tell you completely what I ate or drank (LOL) but it was pretty enjoyable. The drink was definitely a heavy sipper, and it was great for sitting and reading - no real time line. One was enough! The duck was yummy, there were creamed parsnips or something along that line that I didn't love, but were alright. I'd say I really liked but would try something else next time. I LOVED the Virginia oyster and would get 10 of those next time!!! I didn't need dessert, though I got one. It was good, tasted like a toasted strudel. Again, enjoyed but would pick something else next time (or skip dessert, which is on brand for me). The bar was pretty and the restaurant felt cozy. Pro tip: order the siren song to get a sampler of like 12 menu items. The girls next to me ordered and shared one, it looked good! Too much for one person for sure.

    Spanish Mackerel
    Mary Beth B.

    Spectacular night at Alewife. There is a reason it's always ranked one of the best in Richmond. It's in an adorable part of Church Hill and worth going early or staying late to walk the neighborhood. We were asked if it was a special occasion and it was our Anniversary and they gave me sparkling wine and my husband a sparkling non alcoholic drink on the house They knew he wasn't drinking from our order. Such a nice touch. We started with the fish dip, clam strips and rock shrimp appetizers. They were all amazing. The star was the clam strips. They were lightly fried and had a middle eastern flavor (cumin and I think a bit of cinnamon) with scallion greens cilantro and dried chiles. Outstanding. The rock shrimp was like a ceviche with pickled peppers, tiny pepper dews and a wonderful sauce. It was light, bright, acidic and the shrimp was cooked perfectly. The fish dip comes with the best grilled bread on the planet. Seriously. And lots of pickled veggies to stack on the bread with the fish dip for the best bite. We could have stopped with just those things but we ordered entrees because we are chronic over orderers. So glad we did. My husband got the Cobia and I got the Spanish mackerel. Both were delicious. Mine came with an amazing cucumber salad that I'm seriously going to email them and ask for the recipe. It complimented the fish perfectly and I have a garden full of cucumbers. There were pickled scapes and watermelon radish. The fish was cooked to perfection and mackerel is like dark meat, so it's rich and flavorful. My husband's cobia came with butter beans, corn and shishitos that was kind of succotash like. It was wonderful. The service is impressive and they don't hover but know when you need some more of that amazing bread! Alewife decor and atmosphere vibe with Church Hill and while it's busy it's not too loud or overwhelming. The spot is adorable. Go to Alewife. It's outstanding!

    Banana flan
    Jeremy T.

    The name of this restaurant seems so familiar but I have only been to Richmond 1 time before, and don't recognize the interior. My visit was during restaurant week, so I don't know if that's a good thing or bad thing, but during that time of year it is a limited menu. It doesn't really force you to order dessert though since you can sub for a 2nd savory dish. I chose the mussels, skate wing, and flan. PEI mussels - a little spicy and comes with a Texas toast slice, sliced diagonal. Maybe a half portion since it's restaurant week, but I really liked them since I enjoy anything spicy. Grilled skate wing - I don't eat this a lot living in Texas, but I really enjoyed it since it had a nice seasoning on it that is pretty good. The apple slices were the best part of the accompaniment. Just not a lot of meat in this dish, if you're hungry it would not be a good choice. Banana flan - I asked for a scoop of ice cream to go with my Flan and they brought out the ice cream which is sometimes homemade. This one was just a sea salt vanilla but pretty dang good. The flan was even better with a strong banana taste. The tricky part is the miso caramel syrup and making sure it doesn't drip everywhere. Overall, a really good experience here during my short stay in Richmond. I even enjoyed the iced tea here since it's slightly bitter but slightly fruity. Beware though, there are no free refills, so that was a bit of a surprise to me.

    Yes
    Lauren M.

    Love Alewife every time I go. The food is locally sourced, prepped fresh, and consistently good. I love that the chef brings in his Mediterranean roots with the occasional Asian influence. Always try a fish or potato dish. Chef. Does. Not. Miss. The greens are typically cooked with a southern flare and any sauce you get is perfectly braised to accompany your dish. The menu rotates often, so there's no true recommendation. But trust your wait staff, especially for events like restaurant week... They typically try the foods before you.

    Fried clams
    Valencia A.

    We enjoy a quick bite here usually after church on Sundays. We love the Smoked Fish Dip and Arctic char, when it's available. But we've also had and enjoyed the skate wing and the strawberry Nutella stuffed French toast. Today, we tried something different and I tried to do a food critic overview with one of the chefs. Hubby had the soft-shelled crab which was delicious. I went with the fried clams: lightly battered and seasoned to perfection, with a hint of heat at the end! Always enjoy our meals here! Not excessive, but certainly enough to enjoy, every time! It has a cool eclectic vibe, a courteous and attentive staff and when the neighbors are in, it has a "Cheers" atmosphere.

    Soft shell crab

    See all

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 9 of 9

    Ask the Community - Alewife

    Are walk-ins welcomed at the bar?

    Yes! I'd def check out the other reviews to see if anyone mentions the dinner time crowds.

    Does Alewife offer raw oysters?

    They have oysters on the half shell right now. They seem them seasonally.

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Seafood 1,460 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Hard Shell - Ribs and Fries!!!!

    The Hard Shell

    3.9(427 reviews)
    1.2 miDowntown
    $$

    We stopped into The Hard Shell before a late imaging appointment at VCU, and it had been years…read moresince our last visit. It was a good reminder of why this place has stayed around. The atmosphere is still charming. The Slip location has that classic Richmond feel, warm and inviting without trying too hard. Parking was easy, which never hurts. Service was excellent, even with a large private party in progress. The staff handled it effortlessly and everything felt well paced. We started with the crab cocktail, which was outstanding. It is one of those dishes that justifies ordering out instead of making it at home. My only hesitation is Old Bay, which I know is a personal preference and not a fault of the dish. Even so, it was very well done. The calamari and truffle fries followed. Both were strong. The calamari leaned slightly salty on its own, but the sweet sauce brought it into balance. For entrees, my husband had the rockfish over greens, and I ordered the crispy rockfish with Brussels and polenta. Mine was excellent. Crisp, flavorful, and thoughtfully composed. I could not finish it, but that had more to do with our enthusiasm for appetizers than anything else. After all these years, Hard Shell remains a reliable, polished choice in Richmond. Consistency like that is not easy to maintain, and it shows

    I grabbed dinner here the other night. The server was kind and helpful with answering questions…read moreabout the menu. They have a nice selection of items, and it's a great place to get seafood or a steak. I had the brussel sprouts to start. The flavor was good. I had the mahi for my meal. It came with sticky rice, mango salsa, and a plantain chip. I was looking for the wow factor, but it was just okay. The crème brûlée was excellent! They have a nice ambiance.

    Photos
    The Hard Shell - Back booth

    Back booth

    The Hard Shell - Lobster Dip

    Lobster Dip

    The Hard Shell - Honey Garlic Glazed Salmon (RRW)

    See all

    Honey Garlic Glazed Salmon (RRW)

    Sugar's Crab Shack - Fresh fried oyster

    Sugar's Crab Shack

    4.3(233 reviews)
    3.0 miVirginia Union
    $$

    Best place to get fresh, succulent deep fried oysters in a flash!…read more I treat myself to their dinner plate with bettered fried okra as a side. It's a bit of an investment, but the freshness and food quality is excellent. The wait staff and window folks are courteous and very competent. I've never been disappointed. I wholeheartedly recommend Sugar's Crab Shack for a delicious meal you'll be sure to remember fondly!

    Today my wife wanted to get some fish and I was already down with the plan. We went to our spot…read moreSugar's and we were the first in line and had a short wait no more than 20 minutes since they started serving people. I ordered the just fish that comes with ten (10) pieces. Yes count them 1, 2,3,...10. Just like the Count on Sesame Street. Everyone is locked on right. I paid the money and the guy at the counter charged me for how many? Ten (10) fish pieces. After my short wait, my order was ready. The guy at the window showed me the fish looking golden brown and delicious. Hot piping hot. I said they looked good and ready for liftoff. Got to the car and my wife and I were happy at the time. After several hours and other stops we made it home. We live in Baltimore Md. A short 4 hour ride away. When my wife had unpacked the food and she asked me did I eat any fish? I said No? If I had she would have killed me before the plate got cold. She said that then they (Sugar's) did not give us piece number 10. The Boss was not happy and neither was I. Now I don't mind paying for delicious food and will do again. What I do mind is paying for fish that does not appear on my plate. I felt RIPPED OFF! If someone in the back of the house can't count to ten (10) and your employing someone who doesn't know how to count to 10, I am wondering what else is going on in the back of the house. Advise 1) Moving forward I will ask them to count them before accepting the finished product 2) Don't buy the Onion Rings. My wife does not care for them and she is an Onion ring person. Let's do this again but I'm bring the Count with me and the number 10 JUST TO MAKE SURE WERE CLEAR!

    Photos
    Sugar's Crab Shack - Where to order

    Where to order

    Sugar's Crab Shack
    Sugar's Crab Shack - Ordering window

    See all

    Ordering window

    Rappahannock

    Rappahannock

    3.8(615 reviews)
    1.8 miDowntown
    $$$

    We were in Richmond on a Sunday evening and traveling with our four legged friend. There were…read moreseveral options for outside dining and the menu suggested this was a good place to start. Soon after we. Ordered the octopus and mussel appetizers a storm came in and the rain fell pretty hard. Our choices were to run back to the hotel or stay and dine huddled under an umbrella. Being a little wet with beverages and good food seemed the better option so we ordered more food. The octopus was great. I have tried it prepared many ways and here it was both tender and flavorful, really done well. Shrimp cocktail is usually pretty basic, but often the simplest dishes demonstrate the most skill. This is truly one of the best I have ever had. The shrimp were plump and flavorful. Their cooking stopped at just the right time leaving a slight bit of translucent hue, but still cooked through. Very nicely done. The salad with home ranch was dressed nicely and the dressing was light. The scallops were cooked well and perhaps my only criticism is that the corn purée was better in concept than execution. I can't say enough about the staff. We were two people on a Sunday night crazy enough to dine in a downpour. The staff never made us feel like they wanted to punch out, embraced us being outside and were creative in waiting on us with umbrellas to keep the food from getting wet. It would have been understandable for them to limit the trips to check on us, but they persevered and made us feel welcome. If you are in the area, highly recommended stopping by, rain or shine, and sampling their menu. Nicely done.

    The food here was amazing! The grilled octopus was so tender and the risotto was delicious. I…read morewould've liked a touch more lemon zest in the gremolata though. The pan seared fish was moist, but the grits it came with were not crispy. The whole fish was also moist and tender, but the exterior could be a bit over-charred for some. The blueberry upside down cake was great. The staff were friendly and attentive. Overall, I would definitely come again!

    Photos
    Rappahannock
    Rappahannock - Ceviche with plantain chips

    Ceviche with plantain chips

    Rappahannock - Grace St. Spritz

    See all

    Grace St. Spritz

    Croaker's Spot

    Croaker's Spot

    3.9(971 reviews)
    1.8 miManchester
    $$

    We had the pleasure of visiting Croaker's Spot while in town from Northern Virginia and stopped in…read morefor an early dinner. From the moment we arrived, we had an amazing experience. We were warmly greeted by a lovely hostess who ended up being our server, Jamila, I hope I spelled her name correctly. She was truly one of the best servers we have had in a long time: attentive, friendly, knowledgeable, and full of great suggestions. She checked on us often without being intrusive, and her customer service was exceptional. When I mentioned that I did not care for the mac and cheese, Jamila immediately offered recommendations for another side. To our surprise, the chef even came out personally to apologize and brought me a fresh serving of mac and cheese. The replacement was much better! That is what I call going above and beyond to make customers happy. The food was delicious. I ordered the catfish dinner with collard greens and candied yams. The catfish was moist, fried to perfection, and seasoned just right. The collard greens were flavorful and well seasoned, while the candied yams reminded me of my grandmother's homemade yams sweet, comforting, and absolutely delicious. The portions are huge, so you definitely will not leave hungry. Between the wonderful hospitality, outstanding service from Jamila, and amazing food, Croaker's Spot gave us a memorable dining experience. We will definitely be back!

    I've been coming to Croaker Spot for years! I went to VCU, so I'm definitely no stranger to this…read moreplace. I even remember when they were in their old, much smaller location before moving here over a decade ago. This time, I stopped in after a soccer game with a party of four, and we had a great time. I ordered the oyster dinner with yams, collard greens, mac and cheese, and cornbread, plus a sweet tea. Everything was delicious. The only slight miss was the collard greens, which were a little firmer than I prefer. They tasted like they maybe could have cooked a little longer, but it certainly wasn't enough to take away from the meal. One thing to keep in mind is that there is only ONE single-stall bathroom in the entire restaurant. Unfortunately, it was occupied every time I tried to use it for about the first hour we were there. I kept going back and forth checking because I had to pee SO bad! Obviously, Croaker Spot can't control how long someone stays in the bathroom, but having only one toilet for the entire restaurant can definitely become an issue when it's busy. Our service, however, was excellent. I unfortunately forgot our server's name, but she was attentive without being overbearing. She gave us space to eat and enjoy ourselves while still making sure we had everything we needed. She was also very down-to-earth and relatable, which made the experience even better. All in all, we had a great experience, and of course I'll be back. I've been coming to Croaker Spot for years, and I don't see that changing anytime soon. I also really want to check out the Petersburg location because I've heard it's much larger!

    Photos
    Croaker's Spot
    Croaker's Spot - Mashed potatoes

    Mashed potatoes

    Croaker's Spot

    See all

    Alewife - seafood - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...