Food, Service and ambiance are excellent. Bagels and burgers are delicious. Experience this spot for yourself, because the negatives comments must be from competitors. Time and time again their fresh bagels and coffee are better than any Starbucks, etc. thank you for your service!!! read more

Service was great and very attentive. Food was excellent, perfectly cooked. I'll definitely return and recommend it to my friends. read more

All Star Bagel Lakehurst - Bagels Near Me - Lakehurst, New Jersey

The bagels are too Small, thin, center. They need to be bigger, fatter and very little gap or hole in middle. The previous owners did it right. Need to make a real bagel or you'll lose customers. read more

when you pay $8 for a breakfast sandwich, you expect more than 1-2 strips of bacon with two full burnt eggs on it read more

All Star Bagel Lakehurst - Bacon egg and cheese - Bagels Near Me - Lakehurst, New Jersey

My first experience was not great but I read a APP story about the young man and how he spent his college money on this bagel store so I wanted to give it another try. Unfortunately, it was terrible. I went today, a Sunday, at 9AM and it was empty. Under previous management the store would have been packed. I ordered my everything bagel with cream cheese. The first thing I noticed was the Bagel was the size of a hockey puck. I mean ridiculously small. There was hardly any cream cheese on it and I don't know how it's possible but it had absolutely no taste. How do you make an everything bagel that has no taste? Unless this young man makes some drastic changes fast I'm afraid he's not going to make it in this business. read more

The bagel was fine, but wow, I haven't been here in 6+ years and it looks terrible compared to what I remember.

New owners ? The bagels are soft, seasoned and perfect sized bagels! Also - regular bagel prices.

I walked in there intentionally wanting to order five chicken salad BLT sandwiches one gluten-free first question to her was do you serve gluten-free bagels she seems so offended that I even asked that and she didn't even look up from her phone so I walked out and she lost out on the four additional sandwiches that I was going to order without a gluten-free bagel there goes that 40 bucks read more

Machine made if you can call them bagels. The size of a donut. I gave them one star, because they were close to my residence. You can get a better bagel at Wawa, on their breakfast sandwiches.Lesson learned. read more

Horrible service waited 20 minutes for my bagels not too long ago and I realize I was actually dealing with the owner hotel me I wasn't waiting 20 minutes for my bagel boo hiss. This place won't last long under this management. Milo, the owner just text me back that nobody that they waited more than 10 minutes the issue Milo the owner is when I told you that you disagreed with me and told me I did not wait those 20 minutes. You're only 18 you are inexplicably experienced I guess if you get more experience then maybe just maybe it might work out good luck. read more

The service is amazing! Loved the care and concern, the food the freshly made bagels! To die for! The atmosphere is welcoming and comfortable to sit and eat and chit chat. Definitely recommend! read more

New owners had high hopes but the bagels were hard and tasted like they had been sitting for days. Asked for cream cheese and barely got any. At least the employees were nice read more

All Star Bagel Lakehurst - Practically no cream cheese for the price absolutely no flavor - Bagels Near Me - Lakehurst, New Jersey

Best bagels ever! I love this sign. Way too many people don't appreciate great customer service! read more

All Star Bagel Lakehurst - donuts and a sign - Bagels Near Me - Lakehurst, New Jersey

Since the new owners took over we love coming here. The bagels are great and they have a good variety of them. They also have a nice assortment of flavored cream cheeses in addition to plain. They also make a terrific bacon and egg on a bagel. Jennifer behind the counter is great! read more

Excellent bagels and service. Martha is the best at the counter and Brian makes the best egg and pork roll sandwiches!

I went to get bagels on July 4th at 11am and they were already CLOSED!!! Today is Sunday and the website and this site says it's open until 2 pm and it is CLOSED!!! Is this place still in business I'm so confused ... read more

I had high hopes, everyone on base raved about All Star so I tried it. Horrible. These bagels are so tiny,thin and just not a Jersey bagel. I barely had any cream cheese on my bagels. 27 dollars for crap. Plus, I was about to pay and the woman at the register yells back how much my platter was, and I see her mouthing something to the guy in the back. So unprofessional, uncomfortable and makes me think they switch their prices to each person. Also, it was 7 in the morning and barely any bagels out and they were still baking them....why?? If they had a rush, they wouldn't last 20 customers. The bagel shop I grew up going to were up at 2 am and had an entire inventory locked and ready to go for morning rush. This place is unorganized and just not a Jersey bagel shop. read more

HUGE DIFFERENCE with new management. Been to a few All Stars, the customer service and food is great here.

Friendly staff. Very clean inside. Bagels and coffee are always fresh. Always a pleasure to stop there.

First time in all star with the new owner. Inside of the restaurant was nice, the service was great. The food on the other hand wasn't. Compared to what it used to be the bagels were not as good the bacon wasn't crispy, the pork roll was decent. But what got me was when I opened up my sandwich I didn't realize that were would be an ounce of grease in the small package that my sandwich was wrapped in that spilled on my sweat pants. They are now completely ruined and the stain won't come out. Definitely have some sort of warning that an ounce of liquid hot grease may spill on you and ruin your clothes. Not what I expected. read more

Just moved to the area, this place is right by my house. Service was quick and the staff is pretty cool and really friendly. Ordered the standard pork roll, egg & cheese sandwich, it didn't come toasted, so I'll have to ask next time. That being said, the bagel was super light and soft. Very yummy! They have a nice variety of flavors, including French Toast, which you don't see everywhere. All in all a nice little joint, worth giving it a shot! read more

All Star Bagel Lakehurst - Bagels Near Me - Lakehurst, New Jersey

See all

Good bagels, good specialty cream cheese, lox was very good. Clean and a friendly staff read more

Friendly staff nice atmosphere helpful breakfast sandwiches are good sized for that morning hunger

I call up and try and place an order and ask if I can pay right now and he says no and hangs up on me he's too busy. Some customer service there. read more

May 3, 2020. Bagel with a schmear of COVID-19? No thanks! Owner preparing food without mask. When I asked why, instead of apologizing and asking him to put one on, his wife tried to justify it by mumbling something about the police telling them that masks are not required for people that work there...only for customers. Board of Health will get a call. read more

I picked up my bagel platter as well as a personal order for myself at 6:30 AM today. It was ready on time & the lady that gave me my order as well as offered her assistance to help me to my car. I highly recommend this place & will use them again in the future. read more

Love this place. Best bagels and breakfast sandwiches around. I come here ever time I'm near and sometimes even drive 30 minutes just to get some. Great staff friendly and polite. read more

If you're looking for a classic good breakfast thats fast and easy look no further. With bagel sandwiches, bagels, and a small lunch menu it can quench any early morning desire. Melissa always made my visit a good one, though I haven't seen her in there in a while I hope the other employees follow the customer service provided. read more

Customer Service is the "iceberg" that sinks this new business. I have eaten here at least twice a month since it opened. I am generally satisfied with the food, but by 9AM, the selection of bagels are slim and not as fresh as when they first opened. Coffee canisters have been found empty many times, seemingly unchecked with up to five employees behind the counter looking at each other. My LAST visit I walked in to order a bagel sandwich at 12:45 PM on a Saturday. They close at 1:00 PM and I was turned away after being told the grill was off for the day. The is a customer service FAIL! You clean all the burners, leaving one on until closing, you check the coffee canisters every 10 minutes.... I shouldn't have to tell them how to run their business. I took my family and my money to another location on Rt 70.. that cooks until they're actually closed. I will never return and although my $20 purchase a week will only put a little dent in their business... I hope they take this review and steer clear of the iceberg that is dead ahead. I will not be returning to this business when there are several better choices available that are interested in my business. read more

Terrible bagels. Stopped in to buy 18 bagels. Was told I should have called in advance to order? A dozen and a half bagels? Ridiculous. When I asked why so little bagels...I was told "I hate baking its so hot" As obnoxious as it was I replied " You should have stayed in law school. (shame on me) No Breakstone butter, No Philly Cream Cheese? What kind of a bagel store is it? Bagels are not boiled first and are not good at all! read more

Best bagel I've had in a month of bagel eating in New Jersey! We found them on a trip from Toms River to Philly and I don't think I'll ever go to Philly again without stopping at All Star on the way! This is the kind of place that makes you want to go out of your way to write a good review so you can make sure they exist forever! Simple bagel shop. Nice people. Fast service. Good Coffee. Boars Head. GREAT BAGELS!!! The kind of bagels that take you back to the good old days when good bagels were something you took for granted in Jersey. Thank you All Star!!! I'm already planning my next trip back. read more

I couldn't be happier with this place! The staff could not be friendlier! Always sweet and personable... The bagels are awesome (esp French Toast!) and the Veggie spread is to die for! I usually get there after church (12:30 ish) so I rarely expect to find much selection and since they are very busy, I don't always get to indulge in my favs. That's my problem going late, not theirs! I need to change churches and a very real obstacle is that I enjoy going to this place quite frequently afterwards and will miss that! read more

Rude rude rude. Who do they think they are. You have to talk quick, not be on your phone or they won't wait on you. I wanted to order some bagels and she rushed me and already rung my order up and totaled it. There was no line but yet she rushed me. She's so rude it makes me question going there but it's the only one in my neighborhood. The bagels are not that good. They are always burnt. DON't waste your time. read more

Delicious bagels and a wide variety to choose from! Always a wait but usually well worth it, sometimes they're not too generous with the flavored cream cheese depending who makes your bagel. BUT overall it is always pretty good. It's a tad expensive in my opinion but staff is courteous and it's well lit and clean, they have really yummy breakfast sandwiches too! read more

This is my local bagel store. Coming from Brooklyn I am pretty picky when it comes to bagels. They are great. The girls behind the counter are awesome, always friendly and welcoming. Feels homey. Love it! read more

Yummy!!! Their bagels are gray. My favorite is toasted French toast bagel with Maple butter. Oh my !!! it's delicious.

my mom moved to south jersey and we haven't been able to find good bagels in toms river where she lives. We stopped here on our way to the outlets and were pleasantly surprised- remind of us the bagels up north! read more

Decent bagel, but kinda limited selection. Service with a smile.

First time here, I'm from north jersey and have been to great bagel places! This place had great service and the bagels were fantastic... Oh and try the crumb cake !! OMG read more

Food is good but the cleanliness of the place isn't that great. Staff that work there smoke cigarettes outside of the store all day. Dirty dirty.. if they only cleaned up a little it would be a 5 star review. read more