This place was popping. So let's see if they're pretty good eh or ew. I got their cannoli Amy's delight cake slice, and of course snoopy sugar cookie. This was my first time having a cannoli and it had a soft shell and was filled with plenty of thick a bit citrusy cream and crunchy chocolate chips. Eh. The cake slice was MASSIVE and had layers of fluffy, delicate, not dry white and chocolate cake, a thin layer of silky custard, plenty of not too sweet whipped creamy icing, fresh strawberries and bananas that added a nice fruity pop and was surrounded by some roasty toasty crunchy almonds. The snoopy sugary cookie was SUPER CUTE, had a yummy, fun, not too sweet, crunchy icing and buttery not dry cookie. Lowkey obviously my fave thing. Overall this place is pretty good. Cannoli $4.95 Whole cake $50 Sugar cookie $4 read more

See all

I placed an order for a cake last week for my father-in-law while he was visiting from out of town. This bakery has always been his favorite bakery, and he has enjoyed their cakes for many years while living in Montebello. When I called to place the order, I was directed to submit it online. I completed the online order and received a text confirmation stating that I would receive a response within two days. After two days passed with no response, I called to follow up and was told that someone would be contacting me regarding my order. Another two days passed without any communication, so I called again to check on the status. At that point, I was informed that my order had never actually been placed because a deposit was required. However, I was never informed of any deposit requirement during the ordering process or in any of the communications I received. I was then told that, unfortunately, the bakery would not be able to make the custom cake. I explained the entire situation and shared how much this cake meant to my father-in-law, as this bakery has been a special place for him over the years. Despite explaining the circumstances, no effort was made to find a solution. As a business owner myself, I understand that mistakes can happen. However, I also believe in doing everything possible to make things right for customers when issues arise. Unfortunately, that was not my experience here. Due to the lack of communication, misinformation, and poor customer service, I will not be ordering from this bakery again and cannot recommend it to others. read more

Amy's Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

The pastries are excellent and the cakes are awesome. But the service is not what it should be . There were 4 us in line and 6 people behind the counter just looking at us , as good as our cake was . We will probably never come back . Because of the service read more

We went to buy a birthday cake for my husband. No wait time. Excellent service. Great customer service. Delicious pastries and cakes.

Picked up some goodies for work. I did a cookie assortment and everyone loved them. They have a good variety and even had a gluten free option. When in the area give them a try you will not be disappointed. read more

Amy's Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

All the cakes we have purchased from Amy's bakery my last one was the Roblox for my son any cake I show them they tell me won't come one exactly as shown but yes they do read more

See all

I ordered two custom cakes for executive level staff and they loved how beautiful the cakes were and the flavor of the cake! They were both red velvet with cream cheese inside and buttercream frosting! Amy's is my go to when I want to impress! read more

See all

Update: called the shop and spoke to mgr ginger about why no one has called me or emailed back after I was told to email my concern and she started they will reach out, but can't give me a timeline. She did advise because I was delivered a cake to replace my order (not what we wanted and smaller than what I paid for) I would not get compensation or difference. I am severely disappointed and now I will look for a different bakery for our family needs. read more

Amy's Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

See all

I visited this business about a month in advance regarding a custom cookie order for my event and was instructed by the cookie decorator to come in 2-3 days before the event to place the order. When I followed those instructions, I was told I could not place the order. It's disappointing to be given information that isn't honored. Not only was my time wasted, but I was also left with very little time to find another option for my event. Terrible customer service. read more

Over the years we have had many fun and tasty treats from Amy's. Cakes, pastries, cookies,.and great breads. Today was a cookie run! Assortment of Macarons and decorated Sugar cookies! Halloween is coming! read more

See all

I recently purchased a full sheet cake. I asked for pineapple/custard filling. They did not add the custard as for the Pineapple preserves they only added a tiny film. So very disappointed! Next time I will order my cake from COSTCO since they offer special ordered full sheet cakes with designs & inscriptions! read more

Very disappointed in the overpriced cakes here. The prices have gone through the roof and they definitely Ra*%#¥+ people now for their money. It's time to start giving my business of 16years to another bakery or small business. Trying to charge $100 for a 8" round chocolate/banana cake. Mind you I ordered the same cake just about 3-4 months ago and paid $55 bucks, nothing near $100. RIP Amy's. You've lost a loyal customer. I would've still maybe ordered if it was about $75 bucks but $100, come on now. Thanks Iris! read more

Amy's Pastry - Pictured is the same cake I purchased about 3-4 months ago and only paid $55 bucks. They now want $100. - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

My mom picked up some pastries for my birthday and wow -- I was so impressed! The presentation was absolutely beautiful and everything looked so elegant. I got the crème brûlée, fruit tart, and cheesecake. All of them were delicious, but the fruit tart was hands down my favorite. So fresh, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. I'll definitely be coming back just for that fruit tart. Highly recommend! read more

Amy's Pastry - Cheesecake, crème brûlée, and fruit tarte - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

No hands free payment option. Their coffee flavors are empty, all they have is regular coffee and lattes. The employees were the highlight of the business. read more

Very impressive neighborhood bakery! It's very clean and organized. Take a number when you arrive from the ticket machine near the door. Start browsing at the available pastries, cupcakes, cookies and cakes. When your number is called, go to the staff who called your number at the counter and tell them what you want. I picked out a variety to try. Got a spinach pastry, a huge apple turnover, blueberry strudel, creme brûlée cup, Neapolitan , custard chocolate mini eclair and a fruit tart today. Oh boy, my family is going to have a treat when I get home! (Later ...everything was great! Even my husband said so! ) * An additional comment on the bakery selection is that they NO longer make the Dobash cake I was going to buy today. Also , I noticed the Neapolitan pastry used to have a thin raspberry layer and some icing on top which was missing as well. read more

See all

Well I am here today my old stomping grounds I have not been here since I was 25ish omg still excellent. I remember getting cream puffs and still amazingly delicious. I can't eat it without milk with ice so good and the staff super friendly total about $7 bucks n change great memories here from my childhood and now will coming more often I live close to hear. Definitely worth the stop you see what they have and you can eat it here or on the go. Plenty of parking if you are at the DMV come by it's across the street. read more

See all

I live an hour out of the area, but I had to order from Amy's for my cousin's 50th birthday cake. I saw the custom cakes on Yelp and had to order one for this very special occasion. I ordered in shop and paid in full one week before. They have you select all colors and items on cake in detail to get your order right. I called in advance to make one small change five days before pick up. I showed up on time to pick up cake. Yet, they wanted to make sure to set it in their refrigerator so the frosting wouldn't move on my drive home. No worries, because it was gorgeous. My entire family loved it. It tasted great also. The birthday girl was so surprised with the extravagance and beauty of the cake. Thanks Amy's for making my cousin's 50th birthday a day to remember. read more

Amy's Pastry - Custom order cake. Letter "A" cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

What an absolute disappointment it is to pre order a specific cake and cut into a completely different cake at your event! So sad. We were really looking forward to this! Not to mention the bad attitude at pick up was unnecessary, well that was 150+ dollars worth of disappointment!! read more

Service was great.help me with my gender reveal cupcakes super last minute. I forgot the girl who helped me but she was super sweet.

I was not happy with the cake I custom made you cam see the picture I submitted and the flowers of my cake. $125 for this unfortunately read more

Amy's Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

The employees were very nice. No shade to them or the business but I bought 2 crème brûlées and when I got to my car I realized they didn't torch the top. I went back in and kylie said that they don't torch the top because it's comes pre torched but since it's in the fridge, the top melts together with the bottom and it just looks liquidy. So they don't torch them and they can't cause they'll burn the fruit. I told her to take the fruit off but she said that she didn't have the equipment. Had I known, I wouldn't have bought them. I'm only posting because it just sucks to pay for something and not get the standard dessert that I was expecting. If this is the way they do it here, I understand but just in case someone else wants to get the crème brûlée, at least they're aware. read more

My family and I have come to Amy's for over a decade, and plan to continue supporting as the good outweighs the bad. The review is for the service. The staff seems to have high turnover, there's usually someone new every visit. The service is consistently bad. 4/5 of my last visits were with individuals who were not friendly, extremely impatient, and overall did not seem like they wanted to be working. I HOPE management takes some action, Amy's is a Montebello staple, but I would consider going out of my way to other bakeries if it meant better service. Cakes here are great, they offer custom cakes (good luck with the service at this counter), a coffee menu, fresh baked tarts, cakes, grab and go cakes, etc. Inside is large, parking is ample and free. read more

Aesthetically pleasing pastries but, not worth the price. Each of their mini palm sized pastries ranged between $6-8 dollars (about 3 inch diameter). Service is quick, they have a ticket dispenser you can grab a number to wait if there is a wait. I wanted to try out this place as I was in the area but will not be returning as it's very pricy for no wow factor. I can't say much about their made to order custom cakes that other people are raving about, haven't tried them. Heart shape mousse were light and not too sweet. Fruit tart was an ordinary fruit tart, custard underneath fruits. Crème brulee was not great, no caramelized hard top either. read more

Amy's Pastry - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

I asked for a cake to be made for my dads 80th, I gave them the picture and type of cake I wanted and it came out perfect!!!! Exactly as the picture and the staff were all great!! I will be back!! read more

Amy's Pastry - Dads 80th birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

See all

Customer service is great very attentive to your needs Delicious pastries very flavorful. read more

I haven't had the best experiences here lately and I decided to give it one LAST try but this is it. $50 for a tasteless 8 inch cake... no thanks. By the way, the lady told me it was $35 for the cake but rang me up at $50. She clearly didn't know the prices but I wasn't going to go back and forth with her since she had already wrote "happy birthday" on the cake. read more

So disappointed in the quality of their cheesecakes and the horrible customer service. I picked up a small cheesecake for Easter Sunday. It was awful. It was dry and tasteless. I've had to call the bakery six times to complain. I spoke to an Iris, manager, and she said she would call back within two days. Well, here it is a week and still no return call. So sad that their standards have fallen so low. read more

I have always loved Amy's, but I won't be going back. I recently bought a favorite Yum Yum bundt cake. I taste like motor oil smells. It was horrible. Not to mention embarrassing as I had served it to guests. Obviously had to toss it out. Never again. read more

Amy's has been one of our family's favorite bakeries for years---since my childhood. For the past few years, I have been ordering the Pecan Ring on Christmas. This year, I waited too long to order it online, and when I finally went online to order it (probably a few days before Christmas) the online ordering was not available. I called the next morning, and was told that they had been swamped and were no longer accepting online orders. She said it would be first-come-first serve, and just to come in on Christmas Eve. So I went in the morning on Christmas Eve, and was surprised that there was not a line outside. I entered the bakery and took a number. I still had to wait, but I was out of there after 30 minutes or so. The bakery was very festive with holiday decorations and music---the ambience was nice and cheerful. Once my number was called, service was quick and efficient. I just picked up the Pecan Ring, which we had for Christmas breakfast the next day. The Pecan Ring is a flaky pastry covered in whole pecans and coated with a light icing. It's best warmed up, and such a great accompaniment to our Christmas breakfast. We really enjoyed it! Although I only got the Pecan Ring for Christmas, I have ordered many a birthday cake from Amy's in the past, which are always good! read more

See all

Cute pastries, tasty, good texture. Ambiance is super casual, more of a pick up n take to someone's house. read more

Amy's Pastry - Pastries - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

I would have to say the staff there is very unfriendly and rude. Like they would rather be somewhere else. And the store was empty.With the exception of Lauren she was helpful. The others (a guy and another girl didn't get their names) were short and impatient. I came into the store twice. Used to be a busy place back in the day even at 9 in the morning after the morning rush. If they even have a morning rush anymore. I grew up in Montebello and remember when that store opened. It was booming and great stuff. Seems to have lost it since new owners. My ordered turned out nicely but not sure I'd go back because of the customer service. There are plenty other bakeries around. read more

Went to visit Amy's Pastry while I was in the area! They have a large selection of bread, cookies, pastries and cakes. All the employees assume that everyone who walks in the door knows what to do, so I didn't realize I needed to grab a number from the ticket dispenser till they started calling out numbers! I visited in mid September, and by then, everyone is excited for Halloween! So they had a whole bunch of Halloween stuff up and various Halloween cookies up for sale! I had to try one of their cute zombie cookies, and made sure to try a dozen of their normal cookies as well! My favorite were the chocolate thumbprint cookie, and the cupcake! I forgot to check in on Yelp, so make sure you do so you can get that Free cupcake! (Sept 2023)z Will probably come back to try their cake, my friend says the lemon cake is amazing! read more

Amy's Pastry - Seasonal Cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

See all

Good pastries but ready for wait times! They are so short staffed so be ready to wait 30 minutes just to get something

Amy's is the bakery I compare all other bakeries to in LA. They are the absolute best in LA. I will go to Amy's every time I'm in the area. If you're within 45 minutes of here, man's it s point to go here. read more

I've been here a few times but on Monday 10/20/25 for a coffee and a pastry but a pumpkin pie caught my eye so I purchased it. Boy oh boy it is delicious!!! It's perfect creamy I don't know how to describe how amazing it is you have to try it for yourself to see what I mean. It is a little pricey but it is worth it! The service from the young lady was great. Smiling and answered questions very politely. read more

I was having a theme party and the staff really got it and I was so happy. I'm a baker myself and would usually make my own cookies and cakes, though I wanted a more professional look and took some things off my plate! The cake was so beautiful my guests were Wowed, the scones were delicious. The themed cookies were so precious, I could have not pulled off the cake or the cookies myself. Worth every penny and then some, the party was fun and Amy's bakers made it look so festive and fun Thank you read more

See all

This place is quite large for a bakery which I like! Not too crowded. Very spacious and lots of options too! I got the Mexican Mocha. Very tasty and well balanced. Sweet but strong robust flavor! Will definitely return. I am grateful for this place . Such cute pastries didn't try them but look how cute they are!! read more

See all

A community favorite! People from the office celebrate with delicious cakes from Amy's! This time I was here to pick up some cannoli, since we had some recently in Boston. The store was dark inside and only a few customers - in contrast to Boston where it was bright and crowded with delicious cannoli. I didn't wait long and took my order home. The family commented that the cannoli was OK, not great. Not many places have it though. read more

See all

Killing time waiting for friend and ran into this place. People were friendly and coffee was good. read more

Amy's Pastry - Hello Boo Kitty - Bakeries Near Me - Montebello, California

See all

Their pastries are pretty good. However, the last time I ordered their Carrot Cake for my friend's birthday was a disappointment. It was dry and crumbly. read more