The calzone was very good and the kids liked the pasta. Caesar salad was big and tasty. Glad I called ahead because the line was long! It was a rainy day and the people were packed in. read more

Popular place, but that's more so that lack of options than the quality of the food. If the wait is over 30 min it's not worth it.

Pretty good, not earth shattering, but definitely hit the spot. We went here on a day when our tourist beach plans where ruined. We got food to go, but when we got there, the atmosphere was so cool i wish we had ate in. Food was ready exactly when they said it would be. Pepperoni pizza was really tasty. And they have Bacon pizza (with precooked bacon, trust me it's the best), which is something that can be hard to find done right. They did it right. Good pizza, ok bacon cheese fries. I will definitely go there again to try more menu options, this place made me very excited to return. read more

I would give this place 0 fucking stars if I could. Shitty microwave cheap pizza that is NOT worth the 4 hour wait. My family & I ordered and PAID FOR 3 pizzas at 6:30 and by 10:30 they still hadn't delivered it. Fucking idiots. For a busy, vacation town they really suck at doing the bare minimum. You're better off grilling a gross fish you caught here than ordering their cold shit in a box. read more

Food was great! I didnt like all the signs in the building that seems to be idiot-proofing the place. People know how to hold my pizza and I know good manners! read more

I absolutely do not recommend eating in the restaurant. The woman that took our order and "waited" our table was awful. I understand people have bad days and I normally would never put a review but she was terrible. I asked her how we would get the sweet tea since we weren't given a cup and there were no cups and she acted like we were dumb and like we threw the cup away or something. Then she basically threw the pizza on the stand so when we went to get a piece it slid off the stand thankfully to the table. Food was good but service was awful. read more

This may be quite literally the best pizza I've had. The crust is light and flavorful. The sauce is seasoned just right - not too sweet. The atmosphere is fun and definitely kid friendly and the staff is the epitome of southern charm. read more

Angelo's Pizza - Spinach and mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

The pizza is bangin. That's all you need to know. A whole unit. They also have ice cream that looks good. I mean I haven't tried it yet but I'm sure it's bangin too. read more

Angelo's Pizza - Me eating the bangin pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

Good service and clean. Food was average. We had salad and pizza that reminded us of Papa John's.

The staff were friendly, the pizza was excellent. Good value. Looks like a locals place. One star off for cleanliness. Table and chair legs should be washed at least once a year. It looks like spills and food on the floor are just left till the end of the day (being optimistic). You have a good product here. Why not round it up to five stars with a bucket, mop and sponge? read more

Angelo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

Great food!! We had to wait a long time but our pizzas were hot and so yummy!! We had some left for lunch the next day and it was just as good then! read more

We ordered a peperoni & mushroom and an Angelo's White Pizza and both were perfect. No hesitation on ordering from them again. Don't sleep on Angelo's. We will be back read more

To the person who said it's the best pizza ever and they have been to New York is so funny because it's not even the best pizza on the island pretty average pizza Ninos is the best read more

Angelo's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

My family stopped here after visiting Ocracoke island for the day. It was one of the only places open on a Monday. The kids wanted pizza, so we all decided to give this place a try. We got fries and fried pickles for an appetizer which were great, but the whole reason we came was for the pizza. We were so disappointed! I have had frozen pizza that tasted better than the pizza we were served. The service was also disappointing. Our food was brought out to us, and the server did not even speak. We said thank you twice and it was not even acknowledged. Not worth the money! read more

My friends and I came on the island for a weekend and decided we wanted pizza, we went into Angelo's. We walked in and the lady at the counter was passive aggressive and sounded like she did not want to be at work or cares about her customers. The pizza tasted like any other pizza CHAIN restaurant. Nothing special. We also had to ask for our food because they had forgotten about our table on a not-so-busy night. The lady who gave us our pizza slammed it on the ground and walked away. They were so passive aggressive. DO NOT go here it's not worth your money! read more

Fresh. One word describes what we had. Based on another review we tried a salad. It was large enough to share, served on a paper plate. Everything was fresh. Romaine lettuce (not bagged) with onion, carrot, tomato, and cucumber and cheese. Excellent. The combo pizza had fresh onion, peppers, mushrooms as well. Hand tossed crust and fresh tomato sauce. Good stringy cheese. Prompt service and friendly staff. Was abut half full on a Saturday night but lots of carry out orders while we were there. read more

Great food and great service! Must try the white pizza! Well, try everything! Don't forget the fried pickles.

Stopped in for a quick bite to eat and something to quench our thirst. This was a fabulous little find! We enjoyed cheese pizza by the slice and some yummy crinkle cut fries. Along with fountain coke and crushed ice. Yes it's the little things that make us happy. Excellent service and super friendly. Highly recommend! read more

Food was great and ready fast the apps were delicious and the pizza is best on the island

Went here about an hour before closing on June 28, 2014. Had the calzone. The calzone was very large and piping hot, and the taste was excellent. I also thoroughly enjoyed the 1950s-themed decor in the dining room. The arcade is fairly average, with a selection of different types of games for all ages, including driving games, stand-up games, prize-redemption games, foosball, pool tables, and kiddie rides. Protip: Pacman is in a machine marked "Multicade". read more

See all

Great food and service!!! Not five stars because a little unsanitary, a person walked in with no shoes on which grossed me out. Other than that pizza, subs, and wraps were great! We were looking for a place to eat late at night and this was still open and I gotta say i'm satisfied!! I recommend. read more

We had dinner here while vacationing in the OBX. Honestly, we were just starving and chose it to grab some pizza close to where we were. From the outside it doesn't look like much, and in fact we almost changed our minds but I'm glad we went inside. The inside was newly updated with an amazing arcade/game room for the kids. Food came out hot, fresh, and quickly! My husband said he wished the fries and wings had larger portions (they were small), but the taste was great. We also got the Hawaiian pizza which was delicious. Overall, a great little hole-in-the-wall find! read more

On an island where the food can be hit or miss, I can say the food here is good! I was not in the mood for seafood or getting dressed up for a nice sit down restaurant. I came here twice and tried the pizza, cheeseburger, and chicken tenders. The tenders were probably the best I have ever had in my entire life. They were thin, breaded perfectly breaded and no weird chunks of gristle. The burger was really flavorful! I really liked it, but it almost reminded me of a philly cheesesteak, which I also love. The burger and the tenders dont come with fries on the side, you do need to order that separately. None of the sodas we wanted in the fountain drink machine worked. Tried the Coke, nope. Tried the Dr. Pepper, nope. Tried the Sunkist, it worked but it was flat. The cashier ended up letting me take a bottled drink instead since nothing worked. The girls working there are really young and always look super annoyed, but a little smile and saying hello really can go a long way ladies! read more

See all

This spot was ok. Food was good but employees were a bit dry and seemed like they were bothered? Nice game room. Pizza was good. Would get take out but not planning to eat in again. read more

Not really sure how others are giving this place a 5 star when the food is pretty subpar and the service is one of the worst I've had. It took 40 mins to get our food and some of it was cold when we got it. Others were getting their food well before us-one table came in after us and left before we even got our food! Pretty sad this is the first time I've been here but gave it 2 stars for convenience and okay food. read more

Definitely the best pizza in Frisco/Hatteras Island. Perfect for last night dinner as we cleaned up for early departure Sat. Our order of 15 pizzas was great. We called morning of our order to confirm they could manage our order. We called back by required 4pm to confirm types of pizzas. They not only had our order on time but also an order for 20! Every flavor we ordered was delicious, perfectly baked. We ordered every type with extra cheese but the veggie supreme. All veggies fresh cut. We devoured cheese, pepperoni, sausage, Aloha (grilled Canadian bacon before baking - best Hawaiian pizza my daughter has ever enjoyed). Very impressed, prices were comparable To all areas my family traveled from - Fl, KY, NC, FL, TX & AZ. read more

Got a regular cheese and a buffalo chicken pizza that looked amazing and tasted even better. Absolutely delicious! Also, had a very diverse beer selection behind the counter. Definitely hit the spot for a great dinner. read more

The deluxe pizza, and veggie supreme were excellent. A sign inside will inform you that the friendly cat keeping watch over the parking lot That's actually the owner of Angelo's Pizza! Be careful not to startle or harm he sweet thing. read more

Classic beach pizza spot. We tried a couple of appetizers, a salad, and a small pizza. The staff was very nice, but we were a little surprised when our salad took a few extra minutes and the waitress informed us they had 'run out of vegetables and had to run to the grocery store'. Overall, solid food, especially after a long day at the beach. read more

We ordered calzones, pizza and chicken tenders and fries. My kids enjoyed the pizza and the calzones were good. The prices for the tenders and fries were a bit high for the small portion. Overall, we'd return in the future. read more

Their pizza is really tasty, and prices are reasonable. There's also an Arcade inside. A family of 6 can eat for less than $50. The white pizza is one of my favorites. Their deluxe pizza is very good, too. They also offer burgers, wings, subs, salads, ice cream, etc. this is one of the places we enjoy going to when in Buxton. We usually get just pizza --that's what my review is based on. The location is very convenient and there is parking right outside the restaurant. read more

Got this after a long day on the beach and it was very good. Fries were were the worst part but it got the job done.

Wow! These guys make some serious pizza. Worth every bit of the wait(about 30 minutes after coming in off the street). We got fried cauliflower too. Excellent! When we saw that the EMS guys were eating there we figured we'd give it a try. Glad we did. You will be too. Skin that smoke wagon and see what happens. :) read more

I dealt with Robin and Finni, they were both super friendly and really made my family feel welcome. I LOVE their pizza, the ice cream is super yummy, and I think they are the only place in Hatteras with a Game Room for the kids! Friendly staff, amazing pizza, games for the kids, what else could you ask for? read more

A nice surprise! We ordered pizza to-go for a sunset picnic and night fishing at the point. Pizza was excellent. Staff was friendly and the restaurant was exceptionally neat and clean. Will return next year when we visit! read more

Pizza was good! The do offer pizza by the slice- hot and ready! Dough and ingredients tasted fresh. Friendly customer service. Angelo Pizza shares space with an ice cream shop and arcade. Both which are located in the back of the building. Ice Cream and Arcade area seems as if they were an after thought, seems to be an unfinished space. Pizza area was nice but the inside temperature was very warm. read more

See all

Great service the woman behind the counter came around asking how the food was and remembered my name and cleared my plates for me. Pizza by the slice was good, cheap, and fast. Was really just looking for some quick cheap food in between the beach. It was really greasy if you like that sort of pizza this will hit the spot. Lots of soda options. Ice cream case with about 20 flavors? Large old school dining room and game room in the back. Would stop in again. They also have full menu of burgers, sandwiches, lasagna, etc. read more

Angelo's Pizza - Pizza by the slice Pepperoni $2.99 - Pizza Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

Stopped after reading decent reviews. They had specials on the white board. I ordered the. " flounder sandwich with lettuce tomato tartar sauce and fries, no drink. My wife the fried chicken sandwich fries and a fountain coke. The charge was $22. Ridiculous even for a tourist trap. The chicken and fries were ok. The "flounder " was 3 small frozen fish cakes fried in dirty oil. Horrible! Save your money! read more

Um, best pizza? I don't think so. We ordered takeout after reading these reviews. Pizza is mediocre at best. Wings are barely recognizable (over-fried with no sauce). At least we didn't pay an arm and a leg... but won't be ordering again. read more

Angelo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

The best pizza on Hatteras Island - and truly the best pizza I've ever had. I've been to New York and Chicago - this pizza is better. Highly recommend. I make a point to stop here at least once every time I visit. Directly next to the entrance road for Cape Hatteras lighthouse, so you can't miss it. They have 20+ arcades in the back to keep the kids entertained. read more

Angelo's Pizza - Large pepperoni and black olive Angelo's Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

See all