Craving Pizza on the Island? Sorella's is a Must-Try! While visiting the island, I found myself in the mood for some good pizza, so I decided to check out Sorella's for dinner--and I'm so glad I did! With its reputation for hearty, flavor-packed dishes, it was the perfect spot to satisfy my cravings. What We Ordered: * BBQ Pizza * Big Daddy Pizza * Stromboli BBQ PIZZA This pizza was a savory-sweet masterpiece! The olive oil base paired beautifully with the barbecue chicken, caramelized onions, and smoky bacon. The addition of jalapeños brought the perfect kick, while the cheddar and mozzarella created a rich, melty layer of cheesy goodness. Topped with a barbecue swirl, every bite was packed with bold flavors that balanced sweetness and spice perfectly. It was a creative twist on classic pizza flavors, and it didn't disappoint. BIG DADDY PIZZA If you're a fan of the classics, this one's for you. The Big Daddy Pizza was piled high with red sauce, beef, sausage, pepperoni, green peppers, red onions, mushrooms, and mozzarella cheese. Each ingredient brought something special to the table: the meats were perfectly seasoned, the vegetables added a satisfying crunch, and the mozzarella held it all together with a gooey, cheesy blanket. This pizza is a hearty, crowd-pleasing option for anyone who loves a fully loaded slice. STROMBOLI This was the showstopper for me! Stuffed with red sauce, pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, red onions, mushrooms, and mozzarella, the Stromboli was simply heavenly. The crust was golden and perfectly baked, with just the right balance of crispness and chewiness. The filling was indulgent, packed with meat and cheese, making it a dream for any meat lover. Every bite felt comforting and decadent--a must-try if you visit Sorella's. We opted for takeout and enjoyed our meal during a cozy movie night at our rental. The pizzas and Stromboli held up beautifully, still warm and fresh when we dug in. Sorella's proved to be the perfect blend of convenience and quality for a relaxed evening in. Sorella's nailed it on every level--flavor, portion sizes, and variety. Whether you're in the mood for a creative take on pizza like the BBQ Pizza, a classic loaded option like the Big Daddy, or the indulgent Stromboli, you're bound to find something to love here. If you're ever on the island and craving pizza, Sorella's is the place to go. I'll definitely be back for more! read more

See all

Great pizza - delicious crust and toppings that exceeded our expectations. We ordered carry out while staying in Ocracoke for a week. Quick and friendly service. Highly recommend! read more

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and it definitely hit the spot. Service was great and they do free delivery! I personally thought the sauce could've been bolder, but overall a solid pizza place that I would order from again! read more

Sorellas Pizza & Pasta - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Ocracoke, North Carolina

The Pizza is Amazing! We ordered the Big Daddy and had it delivered to our hotel. We were too tired to venture out. The crust was perfect. The toppings were abundant and the sauce was spot on! The person who took our order was polite. The delivery team was awesome. We will definitely purchase another when we are on the island. Thanks read more

I give up on this place. I tried calling them 4 to 5 times but they won't pick up the phone. Then I walked there to order takeout and they tell me it's an hour wait. I guess it's popular with many people, but never with me. read more

Hey guys really like the pizza here but the shrimp scampi pasta was very unusual.... very liquidity so I called and indicated what I had and she was like oh yeah that's the way it comes and it is what it is. So not right but whatever just beware it's not shrimp scampi..., just saying!!! Omg read more

Good pizza and a little pricey. Best part is they can make gluten free pizzas. Worst part is they don't have non-dairy cheese. Allergies are a thing for some. They produce a pizza that's pretty good but not the best I've ever had. However, for an island - surprisingly good. I recommend. read more

Amazing pizza, calzones, etc. Be sure to call ahead BUSY BUSY but so worth it ! Big Daddy OH MY GOODNESS. Be hungry read more

Visited Ocracoke during July 4th weekend. Originally from NY so I know good pizza. Found this place on Yelp and had to try it. Got the fatboy pie and it was delicious! If you're in ocracoke-do yourself a favor and eat here! read more

Great pizza. Fresh and always good quality. I've eaten many pizzas from here and they are always great.

One of my absolute favorite places when on Ocracoke! The calzone.... Is so so good! Live the girls that work the counter and they always get the food out fast! Best pizza on the island read more

The best pizza on the island, hands down. Sorellas is my go-to if I don't want to cook, and I've never been disappointed. Their BBQ chicken pizza is delicious and their green head pizza is just ~ chef kiss ~. Their crust is always deliciously crispy and I've never had their pizza feel too greasy or heavy. The only reason it's not 5 stars is because of the wait on the phone -- now, I honestly give it 4.5 if I could because personally I don't really care about having to call a lot but I know some folks just don't like or have that commitment. I think my record is calling 26 times (in peak season, so July) but when I do get through they're always quick to take the order. It's easy to pick up (or deliver) too. read more

The food is delicious. Mouth is watering just thinking back to it! We ordered a fat boy pizza. Lots of meat toppings! The pizza crust is thick and delicious. Very authentic! We split the pizza between three pizza and it was just enough. We also split a salad between two of us. The salad was amazing. Very fresh and pretty big! The restaurant is small though. I can't see more then 20 people being served inside. While we were sitting down to eat there were a handful of people who looked at the menu and then got up and left. They didn't have any pasta the day that we went in so I'm not sure how the menu really works. We went in August so it's probably dependent on the season. I noticed they deliver though! A guy kept coming and going-- grabbing pizza left and right. They deliver on a golf cart! read more

We ate here twice. The first time we had the large Fatboy pizza. It was enough for two full meals for my wife and me! I judge a pizza by the crust, and this crust was so good I enjoyed it all to the end. The second visit we ordered the Stromboli. For $13 I could not believe the size! It is huge! My wife and I split it and were amply full! The crust was really thin and crispy! The staff are nice. Local Ocracoke residents eat here! This is a must stop for your Ocracoke visit! read more

Sorellas Pizza & Pasta - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Ocracoke, North Carolina

Got the Green Head and the Big Daddy specialty pizzas. Each pizza was a solid island pie that exceeded expectations. Walk up pickup window with social distance markings was easy, and smooth. There's nothing about this meal I would have changed and although the Green Head was the crowd favorite (better than similar pizzas from Mellow Mushroom), all was delicious and enjoyed thoroughly. read more

See all

Margarita pizza and salad hit the spot and was much much better than I had imagined. Lots of cheese and fresh ingredients made it quite yummy and pre ordered and picked up in timely fashion. First time visit here although Ocracoke is a frequent destination. Will def be back!! read more

Very slow paced to go. If they say 39 they mean 1.5 hours. If your white and waiting they will take walk ups and have it ready before you leave while waiting for your order. Good food just not good service. More about the money and their people rather than costumer service. Will not return to this spot. read more

OMG is the food delicious! I had my heart set on trying gnocchi carbonara. Got to the place to early. So I biked around for an hour. Waiting was so worth it. The food,Gnocchi Carbonara, was heavenly and so was the service read more

See all

My wife and I both have a gluten allergy. We aren't picky. We understand that we need to understand food services that may not be able to accommodate: They have been extremely accommodating. We can not recommend them enough. The gluten free crust, the toppings, and the service are A+!!! Highly recommend. Do not pay attention to the nay sayers. A big "THANK YOU!" to Sorellas for a great pizza topped with amazing service!! read more

Great pizza! Only reason I rated them a little less- a little frustrating to order. I had to go in person because their phone lines were busy. I tried several times. Then once I placed the order, it was 45 minutes before it was ready. But definitely worth the wait! read more

Sorellas Pizza & Pasta - Blue cheese and Grape pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ocracoke, North Carolina

I had food delivered from Sorella's a couple of times during my stay on Ocracoke. I initially did it because the weather was bad and they were the only place that delivered. I was pleasantly surprised--the food is great. It is fresh. The pizza was amazing. The salad was fresh and tasty. Overall a great experience. read more

So glad they are back after the hurricane last year! Had great delivery services with an extra no-bake pizza for the following day when Tropical Storm Arthur was due to hit. We will not miss them on any trip including our next one in July 2020! read more

Stromboli was killer, and their tamales were to die for! Small place, but great service and amazing food!

What a great experience!!! We called in two pizzas and two salads and they were ready in 20 minutes and oh so amazing! The crust was soft and crusty and the salads were unique and a nice variety of greens, cheese, nuts and fruit. My husband and I shared the white mushroom and it was sooo good! Definitely a place to visit again. read more

Sorellas Pizza & Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Ocracoke, North Carolina

See all

What can I say besides outstanding!! 3 pasta dishes and one Big Daddy pizza and all there were delicious!! An easy pick up and just 30 minutes from phone call to pick up. Just what we needed after a big day on Portsmouth Island! Wish we had a Sorellos at home! read more

Amazing pizza and friendly staff! We got a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza and it was one of the best pizzas I've ever had.

I am a bit late reviewing this place. I still miss the taste just by looking at this picture and am tempted to drive 11 hours and go on a fairy ride just to get this again! read more

Sorellas Pizza & Pasta - So fresh, best ingredients I've tasted. Why can't you be closer?! - Pizza Near Me - Ocracoke, North Carolina

super great ! our pizza was delivered in 40 mins which we we thought was super fast, pizza was still hot and delivery driver was nice we hope to go back soon to see the interior and try some entrees, one of the better places on the island read more

The food is good, but the service is terrible. We had the stromboli, the calzone and the Hawaiian pizza. Each dish was better than the other. The prices were very good, too. However, it is the bad, bad, bad service that hurts this restaurant. That's why I give it two stars only. We had to wait for 50 minutes, and the waitress wasn't very nice. We had to ask for napkins and forks. We were not allowed to sit inside because the restaurant was "closed" even though the order was placed before closing and there were people still having lunch. We are never coming back. read more

Awesome, what can I say. This IS the place for Italian In Orcacoke. Pizza is great, good service, plus they deliver. You CANNOT beat it. Give up, this is it. Enjoy! read more

It is totally possible that the best pizza in North Carolina is 20 miles off-shore. If you are on Ocracoke -- the Key West of North Carolina -- go straight to Sorellas. The Margarita Pizza has fresh garlic and a deep layer of cheese. So good that I returned to the restaurant the next day to compliment them on the quality. read more

The chicken parmigiana was the best I ever had. The sauce on the linguine was wonderful. I will eat here again. Note, the times that they are open is wrong in yelp 5:00pm to 9:30pm is when the are open in fall. Not 5am to 10pm. read more

Quiet, laid back but classy. Very polite and attentive staff. Food and wine was excellent! Very nice new place and I hope they make a go of it! read more

Just an FYI - it is to go only. We came based off the pictures to eat in and then had to place a to go order with a 1 hour wait. If I'd known it was going to be to go only then I probably would have ordered on the ferry. read more

Nice spot for a family meal. Decent prices for the portions and staff was friendly. We have a pizza and linguine bolognese.

We ordered a Fat Boy pizza with light sauce and the Four Cheese pasta for delivery. It was so good! Like, surprisingly good? The pizza was covered in toppings, perfect amount of sauce and cheese, with a nice thin crust that held up to all that stuff on top. The pasta was fairly simple, but super flavorful, and honestly I feel like I could eat it every day! read more

Ordered a pie here on our first full day here. It was good and well topped and was made quickly! The trouble is going to be to keeping it going! Will you be the same in 2017 read more

Most delicious pizza on the island. We went 4 days in a row for dinner. The crust is just right, the toppings are fresh, and the sauces are delicious. Highly recommend the place. The waiters are super friendly. Feels like a family run restaurant. read more

It's off-season so there's not a ton of places open. The niece and nephew wanted pizza and Jason's was closed so we tried this place. This might be the new go-to. It's actually the best food I've had out since I've been here, though we've only been here three days now. Pretty solid pizza, as good as a decent mom and pop pizza place in your neighborhood unless you live in a place renowned for its pizza. Mad decent. read more

See all

This pizza was fire! The crust was handmade and it was easy to tell they cared for the process. Highly recommend when living on or visiting Ocracoke. read more