Came with a big group for dinner here! A few of my table mates had been here numerous times and really like the food. Good price for the food too! Hard to find in this economy. I tried combo #2 since it gives you a little bit of everything: Alfredo, chicken Parmesan, and lasagna. The lasagna was my favorite! Well seasoned sausage. Chicken parm was good too. Thin, not super greasy or heavy. The Alfredo was a bit bland. Portions overall were good! You can choose the small or the regular. Mine was small. Can't imagine more food than that! It comes with bread and salad. The butter was the best part! Had to take a couple slices of bread home with some butter slathered. It was seasoned with garlic and parsley. The salad was also a decent size. The house dressing was a vinaigrette that came with pepperoncini on the side. We had a really attentive server. She gave us a pitcher for water and made sure we all had the correct food. She was funny and very personable! Tons of parking on the side of the building and out back. Definitely a staple in central Ohio! read more

Ann & Tony's Restaurant - Combo #2: Alfredo, chicken parm, lasagna - Italian Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

See all

My partner and I were invited to meet up with some friends for an early dinner before the Buckeye game on Saturday. I honestly wasn't even sure where West Jefferson was and had never heard of Ann & Tony's, but I'm so glad we went! It was such a nice time and was pleasantly surprised with the food. We started with bread baskets and herbed butter (that was amazing), followed by salads. I went with the house Italian dressing, added some black pepper, cut up my pepperoncini into small pieces, mixed everything up, and topped it with grated Parmesan. Very good! For dinner, I had the small Combination Plate #2 with Chicken Parmesan, Lasagna and Fettuccine Alfredo, plus a meatball on the side. The Chicken Parmesan was definitely my favorites and in general loved that red sauce. Chris had the prime rib with au jus, and it was one of the largest cuts of prime rib I think I've seen! Our server explained that cooking it IN the au jus is something they're known for. The food was delicious and the service was good. Collin took good care of our large group and clearly knew how to handle a busy table. It was not her first day at the rodeo. We both left with leftovers, which I think most of us input group did.I am excited and will be enjoying later today. Really we were introduced to Ann & Tony's. Great food, great service and good company. Nothing major though I would have liked to have had some refills on water offered to me, enough to-go bags, even communication to all guests (not general) and some more frequent individual check-ins on in we needed anything. I'll definitely recommend and the the old school Italian restaurant decor and atmosphere. I would totally take a trip back out there and I look forward to trying some more menu items. Address: 211 E Main St, West Jefferson, OH 43162 Website: https://ann-tonys.grubbio.com read more

See all

Met a group of Yelp friends here for an early dinner. The food was top notch! Started with the herbed butter and fresh bread. I had the house salad which was very good. Collin was our waitress and she handled our group of nine without any problems. I had the smaller size of combination plate #1. I loved my chicken Parmesan. I was then too full to eat the spaghetti and lasagna. Leftovers to go! I did order the chocolate cake to go also. The food and service were both great. I will be back. read more

See all

Home cooked Italian food!! Love it and my drinks are always made perfectly. Service is on point, and food is always delish! Highly recommended for the West J area! read more

Ann & Tony's Restaurant - Italian Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

See all

First time here and the food was exceptional. I ordered Eggplant Parmesan with spaghetti and corn fritters. The bread and garlic butter were amazing and Eggplant was delicious. Service was good and atmosphere was very pleasant. Hubby ordered the Prime Rib and he enjoyed it very much. For dessert we shared Spumoni ice cream. read more

Ann & Tony's Restaurant - Eggplant and Spaghetti - Italian Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

See all

The ambiance was super homey and sweet. Food was great, and the staff were very friendly and provided great service! read more

Ann & Tony's Restaurant - Lasagna - Italian Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

Just Wonderful. Great food and atmosphere. And Wonderful Employees. A must Stop, Stop in Have A Cocktail and A Great Lunch Or Dinner.

Great food for the value! Chicken parm with spaghetti is $12.99. It comes with a salad and bread. The butter with the bread is real salted butter which is leaps and bounds better than margarine. The chicken parm was a good sized serving and I think it was better than Olive Garden. Atmosphere is grandma-core. Placed even smells like my grandma's house did. But, that's usually where you had great meals as a kid. Service was good. We sat ourselves for lunch and after a few minutes the server brought menus and then even less time later we ordered. Salads came out quickly and by the time we were done with salad, the main dish was ready. Our price for 2 people (entrees and drinks) was $40 including tip. I would definitely come back! read more

Ann & Tony's Restaurant - Chicken Parmesan with spaghetti. I added a meatball to the spaghetti. This was excellent! Better than Olive Garden and much cheaper! - Italian Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

See all

We enjoyed this restaurant. Old school style and big portions. Not super high end good but good. And the portions and price point make it a good value..Tip: Order the small portion unless you're really hungry. The large portions are huge. read more

Don't waste your time The atmosphere was pretty cool and the people were super nice but it's definitely food that you can purchase from Walmart and make yourself at home. I literally felt like not One thing was handmade or homemade and I've had way better in other places. It is not worth the money or the time. I don't know how this place is even open. read more

I had a gift card for this dump. They told me it was no good unless I had the paper receipt that came with it because they didn't have a reader to read them any more. food was ok but overpriced. BAD customer service. I won't be back. read more

This place is a hidden gem. Prices are great at lunch. Staff is always very nice! And it's always busy but you can still get in with no problems. The portions are just the right size. Plus you get fresh bread. read more

First time dining at this restaurant, and I was pleasantly surprised by the variety on the menu and the very affordable prices. The food was excellent. Our server was kind, attentive, and truly went above and beyond. We watched her gently assist an older gentleman as he stood up to reach his walker. My husband offered to help, but the gentleman quickly assured him that the server knew exactly how to assist him. That small moment spoke volumes about the level of care and service here. If I'm ever back in the area, I would definitely eat here again. read more

Love the food and love the friendliness. If we don't eat in we order carry out about once a week. Their meatballs are the best!!!

Heard great things so we had to stop in for a visit. There is plenty of seating inside and bar to stop in for a drink. The portions sizes are very generous and the sauce has nice flavor. Each member of our party ordered a dinner which included salad and bread. We also tried a cheesecake dessert which was really nice as well. read more

See all

Some of the best Italian anywhere! Though we did not all have Italian the food here is amazing! The service was outstanding tonight especially as we dined with Collin (sp?)(sorry doll) and she was great! This place is so cozy and the ambience is great. You can see in my pics the green check tablecloths, they serve fresh Italian bread, and the food is homemade. They have been here for a long time and I hope they stay forever!! read more

See all

We went to Ann & Tony's when I lived in the area over 30 years ago - we were back visiting family and friends and joined my cousin for dinner. The restaurant is family owned and managed with the same recipes and attention to details. The service is what you'd expect from a small family run restaurant in a small town. The ambiance is quaint Italian and everyone is so friendly with large portions at very reasonable prices. read more

This is a hidden gem! Good homemade pasta and more than you can eat. Small Italian eatery, nice ambiance. I had the Spaghetti with Italian sausage and had a great meal. My wife had the sampler and it was all very good too. Nice glass of Merlot to go along with it. This is a good place to travel to. Probably reservations are recommended but we got in no problem. read more

Wow, I'm so disappointed to say how much this restaurant has went down hill. We arrived for our 2pm reservation on Father's Day. They were not busy. The hostess stand was friendly and seated us right away. We were put in a side room that was noticeably hot (the air conditioner in this room is obviously broken). Not sure why they would continue to seat people in this room. We were BOILING. It took over 40 mins. to receive our salad and bread. The salad looked kinda sad, but the Italian dressing was still very good. 2 members of our party received their food around 7 mins before the others. The food tasted great as we had a party of 6 and everyone did enjoy the food part (once it came!). Overall, super disappointing. I hope they can get it together. No longer a fan. read more

I had Prime Rib and it was outstanding. Tender, juicy and flavorful. We had a group of 15 people including three kids. They handled us perfectly. Great service staff! We had a separate room which was very nice. A nice interior and plenty of onsite parking. A great place enjoyed by all! read more

Traveled out to West Jefferson today for some lunch. Decided to finally check out Ann & Tony's, been on my list for quite a while. Ordered the Italian Combo #2. It consists of Lasagna, Chicken Parmesan and Fettuccine Alfredo. It also came with a salad and bread. The Alfredo had a weird flavor to it, like it was really buttery taste to it. The Lasagna was really tasty with a nice tomato sauce on top, a good layer of cheese and a lot of meat layered in. There were a number of layers to it. On to the Star which was the Chicken Parmesan. It has a nice crispy exterior with a juicy chicken inside. Had a nice layer of cheese and sauce on it. Very flavorful. The salad was nothing special. Italian bread was nothing special either. I wanted to close this with a positive which was my waitress Brittany. She was on it from the beginning and timed out everything, Checked on me a number of times and made sure I was well taken care of. read more

See all

This was my second visit here in the past 8 years and the food was just as good as the first time. I intend to come more often. I met Mike G for a Friday night dinner; we had reservations and were seated at a booth. The back dining room had been cleared of a few tables, and all staff wore masks. Great old school Italian restaurant: impressive service, food, portions, prices, and you can't beat a $6 glass of wine (a large pour). My grilled perch with red-skinned potatoes and grilled, breaded zucchini was a wonderful comfort food dinner. The pasta dishes are served with a meat sauce, but you can ask for the marinara instead. There are seafood plates. Dinners include salads, and rolls with herb butter. I passed this time, but they have a large selection of desserts. read more

Ann & Tony's Restaurant - Grilled Perch with red-skinned potatoes (zucchini not pictured) - Italian Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

We stopped at Ann & Tony's on our way home, looking for a place we hadn't been before. The portions are generous. The lasagna was the stand out. read more

Ann & Tony's Restaurant - Small combination #1 - Italian Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

Passing through, and pulled up Yelp for a good place to stop for dinner. We weren't disappointed! Delicious dishes, and huge portions! Give it a go! read more

The service was excellent, and the staff were more than warm and friendly. I always feel bad leaving a review that's less than excellent, but I didn't love the meal. The food was fairly well prepared, and I'd say it was good, just wasn't so good that I'd make the trip back to eat there again. I don't mean this to be mean, but the menu felt like it was from maybe the 70's or 80's, and hasn't really been updated in decades. I got the prime rib. It was huge and pricey as a result. Would be nice to have an option for a smaller cut as many others offer. It didn't say the size, but I think it was 20 Oz or more, which is more than an average person would typically eat, I'd think. But overall, the flavor was kinda mild, and didn't really excite me compared to others I've had. The bread seemed like store bought bread, which isn't what I'd expect from a nice Italian restaurant. I hoped for something unique and delicious. The salad and the house dressing also seemed like little care was given to their creation. Just nothing special about it. If you like old school mom & pop Italian food, and live close, there's really nothing wrong with this restaurant. And again, the food isn't bad in anyway. It's just not something that was so good, that I'd make a special trip to go there again. read more

We had Good food. We had a fun waitress and she provided good service. A little pricy for what they provided, but we will be back. Yummy leftovers for the next day, too. read more

Back for another family dinner and visit! Limited menu and staff still due to covid and I'm sure some supply chain slow downs. The cute little shop has been moved out unfortunately. Food is still great even with the smaller menu. Portion sizes are still massive thorough, so don't get the large unless you're planning on leftovers! read more

We visit the restaurant almost every time we are in town. The family owned history brings a personal touch with their food, customer service and charm. We receive excellent service and delicious meals read more

Perfect food .always busy good sign . Very fair prices. Feels like home . They are truely a mom and pop place .

Small town Italian restaurant with tons of seating. Unfortunately hit by the pandemic they are understaffed but so friendly and accommodating. The sauces are made with love but don't expect a diverse set of dishes - pretty much just Alfredo and spaghetti as far as pasta goes! read more

Planned a surprise retirement party and had at least 20 guests. The server came in and said if the balloons bother her, we would need to get rid of them. My husband ordered a second beer after his first was done, glass taken, she brings him a beer and he asked for a glass to which she said "drink it redneck style" She had other tables which I thought was silly since our reservation had been set for at least 3 weeks, she was hardly in our area. The food, I had always heard great things, but it was not great. I had the spaghetti with Italian sausage and had a plate full of water & 2 small sausage halves. I'm sure back in it's prime it was good, things have gone downhill. read more

Waited 20 minutes for someone to come to the register to pay our bill Food was average. Mushroom soup was excellent read more

For starters they had a sign on the door that said masks are optional and none of the employees were wearing masks which was awesome to see! It felt like life is slowly but surely getting back to a sense of normalcy! Thank you for using common sense. Now for the service. The service was excellent! Our waitress was very nice and took great care of us. Our food came out rather quickly. Now for the food. The house salad was warm like it had been sitting out for awhile. The house Italian dressing was very good. However, some of the lettuce looked wilted and some of the edges were brown. I had the Veal Parmesan with spaghetti & a meatball. There was water under the spaghetti from them not draining the noodles properly. The sauce just tasted ok I've had better. The veal was ok tasting. It was not the best veal I've eaten. The meatball was good though and had a good flavor. Overall, my wife and I were not that impressed with the taste of the food. She got a combination plate with Chicken Parmesan & Lasagna. The lasagna had a funny taste to it. The rolls when our server brought them out were soft and warm but, after they were sitting on our table for a bit, they became hard like a rock. I give the food a 1 star but I'm giving them two stars because our server was good and friendly. We will stick to our favorite Italian place in Gahanna. Sorry Ann & Tony we gave your place a try but, it wasn't as good as we hoped it would be and not worth the long drive to get there. read more

Ann & Tony's Restaurant - House Salad - Italian Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

See all

Wonder small business that is worth the trip every single time. Authentic Italian and some of the best Prime Rib you will ever have. If you have the opportunity check it out. You will not be disappointed! read more

See all

Best kept secret in Columbus. One of the very best Italian restaurants is nestled right in the middle of West Jefferson. Never had had a bad or even mediocre meal here. Food is 5 star and the service and staff are top notch as well. If you want an authentic experience take a small drive and definitely check them out! read more

Food is delicious. We have been going to Ann & Tony's for 40 years. The food has always been good and still is delicious. The service is always good and friendly. Ambiance is good also. read more

Good friendly vibe and the spaghetti is nice and your taste buds will thank you for the amazing food

This is a good small town restaurant - Always yummy stuff on the menu. The staff and owner are super friendly and glad you decided to visit with them for your meal. We've been here a few times now, and it's always been good. Prices are relatively cheaper than what you would get for the same meal at another restaurant. I'm not sure if they do specials on all the days of the week, but we've had the Sunday specials - and they're really good. They smoke their own ribs out back and they're delicious!! read more

Ann & Tony's Restaurant - Salad and bread to start off - Italian Near Me - West Jefferson, Ohio

See all

Food and service was great. Waitresses were very attentive friendly and the food was hot. Very reasonably priced.

We were standing outside Ann & Tony's after celebrating my grandma's 90th birthday dinner Sunday afternoon. There were 14 of us and we all were commenting on what a wonderful time we had at this restaurant. We were all very impressed with these folks and the great service we got here. Everyone ordered something different from lasagna, to prime rib, spaghetti and meatballs, sampler platters and crab cakes. All of us enjoyed our dinners (unusual for us). Our dinners ranged from $14 to $20 so it was an excellent value for the quantity and quality of food we received. I ordered the Fettuccine Alfredo with Grilled Shrimp and it was quite good with a nice buttery sauce over pasta with plenty of shrimp on top. The sauces they use are homemade too, so extra points for that. The service we received from Angie was excellent. I give her kudos for being nice and polite while giving us that "just right" balance of friendly but not obtrusive service. As Bill S. said in his review, Ann & Tony's is "Truly a find." Anyone who enjoys Italian food, steaks and seafood will like this quaint little independent Italian restaurant just 10 minutes west of Columbus. The atmosphere is comfortable in a homey relaxed setting. I understand that it used to be a house years ago so there's several different rooms, of which two of them have fireplaces which was cool to see. I guess this place puts me in mind of Villa Nova in Clintonville if that helps you get a visual. My grandma's 90th birthday was important to the family and these folks came through for us with shining colors. I couldn't find anything wrong with our experience so, 5 stars. read more

See all