Anthony&#x27;s Pizzeria

Grabbed a birthday lunch at Perillo's today…read more My lunch partner is not much of a pizza eater, so decided to just grab a 2 topping slice and a meat ball sub for myself. Slice was pepperoni and fresh mushrooms, NY style. Delicious. (Took a bite before I took the picture). Meatball sub was very good with good crunch on the bread, and nice melty cheese. Meatballs were really good, and sauce was very tasty. Lunch partner had the Philly cheese steak. Said it was piping hot and very tasty. Came with a cup of melted nacho cheese on the side. Service was quick and very attentive. As regulars know, it is cash only. Will be back sooner than later this time.

They allow pets inside the restaurant. I thought that was illegal in Indiana. My first and last…read moretrip there. Food and service were great, but I don't want to share a table with someone else's pet.

Kitchen area

The crust was thin and crunchy on both the top and bottom. I didn't measure but this pie was probably 18"

See all

AMO Pizza

4.4(34 reviews)

7.5 mi

One of our all time favorite pizza places! Always a good meal. Never had a bad experience!read more

In the little small town of Amo, Indiana is Amo pizza. The pizzas here are amazing. The first time…read moreI seen it was on Fox 59 and Sherman was doing a segment on them. They were talking about the Around the World Pizza. The large pizza weighs 10 pounds. Well we couldn't eat a large so we got a medium 12 inch well we couldn't eat it 16 pieces,we ate 5. next time we'll go for the small. There is so many topping and it's thick. ( look at menu to see) They have indoor seating and outdoor seating. There is a little grocery store inside also, but you can't go wrong on their pizzas here. Plus, there's a great little ice cream store next to them.

See all

Chicago's Pizza

3.7(61 reviews)

16.7 mi

Pizza was cooked perfectly, crust was homemade and flaky. Toppings were generous and evenly…read moredistributed and the cheese was cooked to a perfect golden brown. Staff was friendly, service was incredibly fast , the pizza was served only 10 minutes after being seated. Clean establishment and reasonable prices, highly recommend!

Probably the worst service I've had in years. Only two waitresses on a Friday night who were…read moreexpected to take care of everyone from seating, drinks, cleaning, paying-- everything. Even though they were both trying their best, our server was lacking in many areas. When ordering our chicken Alfredo pizza the response we got was "we don't have Alfredo anymore" but no suggestions were made. After evaluating the menu we asked if a garlic Parmesan base could be substituted. "People do that all the time!" Pizza was pretty decent, but hard to finish without refills. Probably won't be back at this location anytime soon.

Cool atmosphere with TV's!

Deep dish pizza cheese and mushroom

See all

Pizza Niche

4.1(14 reviews)

17.6 mi

Tried this place when in town. It was a good pizza place in this town. Very limited menu and a…read moresmall dining area which was well decorated and clean. We ordered the deluxe pizza. It had mild peppers which I like but the wife didn't but never had that on a deluxe pizza before so it was a first for me. I believe it was a truly deluxe pizza with a lot of toppings and it was a thick pizza. The crust was done where the toppings didn't sag it but it didn't have any taste and reminded me of a frozen pizza crust which I don't think it was but just reminded me of it. I make my own pizza crust from scratch which has a flavor. But this was a great pizza place to get a pizza if you are in town.

Clearly Indiana is not a pizza Mecca, but Pizzia Niche can do better. Positives- the sauce was…read moregreat. Tastes home cooked and is well seasoned. The cheese had great flavor, Might be Sargento? Improvement opportunities- The crust was just bad, seemed like a frozen disk that was hard! Please consider a hand toss option. There is a great debate on toppings under or over cheese. Please move toppings that benefit from cooking to the the top, they are after all they are "toppings". The pepperoni was completely lost under the cheese.

See all

Brozinni Pizzeria

4.1(185 reviews)

45.7 mi

I was excited to come to this Brozinni after having been to the Speedway location and after a long…read moreday of hiking at Brown County State Park. I was satisfied. They have a decent patio along with the inside seating. They also have heat lamps out there for when the weather is borderline cold. Our server was friendly. Our pizza took a long time though, with two other tables near us that were served and then even paying their bill when we didn't even get our food yet. The pizza was quite delicious though! A nice meat lovers always helps to satisfy. We did get some free breadsticks for the wait. I'm not sure what took so long. Hopefully our next visit won't have this issue.

I absolutely love this pizza, and always stop here when in Nashville…read more The restaurant has indoor and outdoor seating and can accommodate large groups. We ordered the Greek salad, and the 34th street pizza. The salad was delicious, I love their Italian dressing. The pizza is absolutely delicious, and cooked perfectly. They also offer pizza by the slice during lunch hours. Service was fast and friendly, thank you Brozinni's!

That is a size or thickness reference and yes thats a straw .

Chicken bacon ranch pizza

See all

Tribeca calzone-incredibly delicious and filling!! Plenty to take home!

Amici's Pizzeria

4.6(19 reviews)

16.6 mi

Amici's is a good "go to" pizza for us. Everyone in the family likes it, and they never disappoint…read morewith service or food quality. I also like how involved they are in the community, as that goes a long way with me.

The family and I decided to try this pizza place out in Plainfield and it was pretty good. The…read morebreadsticks were soooooo good!! The pizza was also really good. Buffalo chicken pizza wasn't very spicy. Overall we enjoyed it.

Thin crust build your own 14" pizza-pepperoni, onion, black olives & green peppers on half

See all

Big Woods Pizza - Nashville

3.9(356 reviews)

45.7 mi

My husband and I traveled to Nashville, Indiana, and this restaurant came highly recommended. After…read moreour visit, we completely understand why! Everyone working there was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and helpful. You could genuinely tell they enjoyed their jobs, and that made the whole experience even better. Lucas S. took great care of us and gave us excellent beer and food recommendations--everything he suggested was perfect! It also happened to be my husband's birthday that day, and we had such a wonderful time celebrating there. Great food, great service, and genuinely kind people. We're so glad this place was recommended to us and would absolutely return!

Flight of beer, at the bar. Six foot espresso blond, Six…read morefoot strawberry blond, put a fork in it "pumpkin", Santa Quaff, there were no beers we did not like. Bar tended was friendly, and we had a friendly conversation with them and some others at the bar. The Put a fork in it is among the best pumpkin ales we have ever had. They sell individual mix and match bottles here in 4 or 6 packs. Next time we will try the food since it gets great reviews.

Steak Modena pizza 10 inch

See all

Menu

Wildfire 348

4.5(34 reviews)

20.3 mi

I have had the same perfect pizza several times, and my husband is working his way through the…read moremenu. 5 stars every visit.

We are in town visiting and had a bunch of our stuff stolen earlier today and we're super bummed so…read moredecided to stay in tonight and order pizza to be delivered. The food was AMAZING (definitely recommend adding goat cheese and hot honey to the cheese pizza!!!) but the food seal stickers each had a different Bible verse on them and it was exactly the pick me up we needed. Thank you!!

BBQ Wings

See all

Pepperoni Rollups

Overpass Pizza

4.6(39 reviews)

43.2 mi

Best pizza around! They have a family special to get a pizza a big salad that's better than any…read moresalad, better than Arnie or Pizza King! Everything is delicious homemade dressing then or thick crust, pizza, friendly people, and worth the wait..

This was our first time visiting Overpass Pizza and we were so surprised! It's in an unassuming…read morelittle building - off the beaten path. When we arrived we were seated right away but it was buzzing with locals and pick ups (good sign, right?!) We really enjoyed looking at all of the local memorabilia on the walls and our service was EXCELLENT! The woman that served our table was very friendly, upbeat, and knew exactly how to take care of her guests. Our food came out very quickly and we enjoyed all of it. We had the 12" thin crust pepperoni pizza and some garlic bread. Next time we'd like to try either the deep dish or some of the house special pizzas. I was pretty shocked to see that our total was over $45 for the 12" pizza, bread, and two drinks with tip. But really everything else made it worth it. And we got a slice of the most delicious almond cake on the way out for free - score!

Things to do in Coatesville

Funny sign in the restaurant

Cheese bread

See all

Order of breadsticks. Sauce was great (I wish they sold it).

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Derek T.

24

2

1

8 years ago

Great food, fast delivery. I would give 5 stars if they had their menu of the website

Anthony's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated September 2026

Best of Coatesville

People found Anthony's Pizzeria by searching for…

People who viewed Anthony's Pizzeria also viewed

Lizton Pizza

4.2

(12 reviews)

Ordered a medium pepperoni and breadsticks. Everything was excellent. The breadsticks were the…read moreright combo of soft, airy, chewy, and crispy. The pizza was loaded with cheese and the crust was great. Again, the perfect combo of thin and crispy with the right amount of chew. Will definitely be back.

The pizza and breadsticks are great. A definite step up from chains like Papa John's and Pizza Hut…read more The staff. Is quick and friendly. I love it. Will be back again and again.

Greek's Pizzeria - Plainfield

4.5

(22 reviews)

Had a chance to grab dinner with my daughter again at Greek's. Another half and half XL speciality…read morepizza (1/2 Greek's Special and 1/2 Cordon Bleu) and some breadsticks. Plenty of toppings. We usually do take out from here but decided to dine in. Good pizza and more than enough to take home and have some for lunch the next day. Plenty of parking just across the street. Reasonably priced with daily specials.

Great pizza and great value! Picked up an XL pizza with breadsticks last night after trying Greeks…read moreat a community event earlier in the year. This location is so involved in the Plainfield community, it makes their business even more meaningful. Ordered online a few hours prior and it was ready for pick up promptly, as scheduled. Small inside with a small outdoor dining area, would love to try in the summer. Happy to give this community business my support and plan to continue to do so in the future.

Chicago's Pizza

4.4

(7 reviews)

Excellent Pizza and Breadsticks!!! Excellent Service and Fast order/pick up!!!…read moreWe will definitely order again!!!

Probably in my opinion the best bread sticks in Lebanon. Have tried the sandwich's and they are…read morewonderful. The drive up is convenient and staff is friendly. To my knowledge no dining inside is available. Give the bread sticks a try, you won't be disappointed.

AMO Pizza

4.4

(34 reviews)

One of our all time favorite pizza places! Always a good meal. Never had a bad experience!read more

In the little small town of Amo, Indiana is Amo pizza. The pizzas here are amazing. The first time…read moreI seen it was on Fox 59 and Sherman was doing a segment on them. They were talking about the Around the World Pizza. The large pizza weighs 10 pounds. Well we couldn't eat a large so we got a medium 12 inch well we couldn't eat it 16 pieces,we ate 5. next time we'll go for the small. There is so many topping and it's thick. ( look at menu to see) They have indoor seating and outdoor seating. There is a little grocery store inside also, but you can't go wrong on their pizzas here. Plus, there's a great little ice cream store next to them.

Perillo's Pizzeria

4.6

(138 reviews)

Grabbed a birthday lunch at Perillo's today…read more My lunch partner is not much of a pizza eater, so decided to just grab a 2 topping slice and a meat ball sub for myself. Slice was pepperoni and fresh mushrooms, NY style. Delicious. (Took a bite before I took the picture). Meatball sub was very good with good crunch on the bread, and nice melty cheese. Meatballs were really good, and sauce was very tasty. Lunch partner had the Philly cheese steak. Said it was piping hot and very tasty. Came with a cup of melted nacho cheese on the side. Service was quick and very attentive. As regulars know, it is cash only. Will be back sooner than later this time.

They allow pets inside the restaurant. I thought that was illegal in Indiana. My first and last…read moretrip there. Food and service were great, but I don't want to share a table with someone else's pet.

Sal's Famous Pizzeria

3.7

(60 reviews)

If you want a quick lunch, this is the spot. I came for lunch and did the special where you pick…read moreany slice of pizza, breadsticks or salad and get a drink. The pizza is out on the counter so you can see all the options. My food was delicious, I would be back!

If you're craving authentic Italian cuisine, Sal's is pasta-tively the place to be! From the moment…read moreyou walk in, the warm, welcoming atmosphere sets the tone for an incredible dining experience. The menu is filled with classic Italian dishes, we tried their pizza. The service at Sal's was just as impressive. The staff were attentive, friendly, and made us feel like family. They were quick to offer recommendations and ensured that every detail of our meal was perfect.

Frank's Place

3.6

(85 reviews)

For a small town Italian restaurant it's five stars and one of a handful of locally owned…read morerestaurants I happily venture back to in the area. To be clear, Frank's wouldn't be five stars if located in a suburban or urban area but for Danville- it's solidly a great option! I've always found the restaurant designed well & to have friendly and attentive staff. The food is very good- I thought the chicken parm was delicious. The only thing I would change is how they prepare the "Antipasto Salad," it would be much better if they served this as a chopped salad vs seemingly throwing whole pepperoni slices, tomato slices, etc on the lettuce. Tiramisu was also wonderful. Frank's is Paul's pick for when in Danville IN.

$22.00 for spaghetti & meatballs says it all. Service &…read moreambiance are great, but food is mediocre and pricing is beyond beyond ridiculous.

Pizza King

3.7

(9 reviews)

Service was amazing, so friendly and attentive. The food was fresh made and perfect temp. Might be…read moreworth a trip back to check out the lunch buffet. The only thing I noticed was it was a tad warm inside but it likely is due to the extreme high heat and ovens being used. Other than that, it was nice and clean. We took our order to go and enjoy at home. We'll be back!

Stopped in to try the buffet. Employees were friendly when paying but they weren't actively…read moreinteracting with anyone other than that. The inside looks like its in need of a fresh coat of paint, however the walls appear to be sketched in pencil as if they are in the process of painting a mural. The food was good but seemed average for a buffet. The salad (also on the buffet) was amazing and extremely fresh. Would go again.

Brothers Pizza

4.3

(48 reviews)

One of the best pizza places in town. Service is amazing very friendly and clean…read more The chicken club and Chicken bacon ranch are my two favorites there..

Yeah this place is good, been going here (getting pickup) for years, they make their pizzas well…read moreand the service seems pretty nice. There's not any ambiance because you can't actually go in there to eat. Overall above decent.

Brozinni Pizzeria at Speedway

4.4

(195 reviews)