Amazing pizza! The sauce has a great flavor. The crust is a perfect blend of not too thin and not too thick. Don't take my cheese pizza photo for what they would make you--I always ask for light cheese and heavy sauce. Our only wishes--serve the breadstick sauce hot not cold. And offer green olives as a topping and you would be perfect. But we are pizza picky for sure. Take note, as of Oct 3, this place is take-out or delivery only. We had never been here. The employee was really nice. We placed our order to go and went outside. He brought our order to us in our vehicle within 15 minutes. Great service. The prices are also very reasonable. $24 for 2 pizzas and breadsticks. We will definitely add this pizza place to our list of places to return. read more

See all

Yeah this place is good, been going here (getting pickup) for years, they make their pizzas well and the service seems pretty nice. There's not any ambiance because you can't actually go in there to eat. Overall above decent. read more

Decided to give their pizza a try for dinner while passing through town. They only offer carry out or delivery, something important to know. The building is a bit dark and odd inside. The individual taking our order was really nice, informed us that our order should be ready in about 15 minutes and she was spot on. Breadsticks were so delicious, they were only slightly firm on the outside and super soft and chewy on the inside. Pizzas were a bit on the greasy side (like puddles underneath them), but were good. Pepperoni was spicier than expected (which wasn't a bad thing) and the Cheese Boss was (dare I say) almost too cheesy. Definitely worth giving a try if you're looking for good pizza on the go. read more

See all

In town for work and the hotel recommended this place. The staff was friendly, that why they get 3 stars. The pizza itself was meh. Crust was chewy and more doughy than I expected. Ingredients were scarce and all piled up in the middle. I'm still trying to find the sausage. We all have different tastes. This one just wasn't for me. read more

Brothers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Crawfordsville, Indiana

Love this place. It's becoming my favorite pizza joint. Here is why: Delivery. You know if they tell you 25 minutes, or if they tell you 35 minutes and they show up at 30 minutes, in on case you're upset and in one you're happy. The only difference is what you were expecting. They are always early and friendly. Quality. Good stuff all around. We have never purchased anything we did really like. Staff. Everyone is friendly from the phone contact to deliver, everyone is great. Do go. read more

My family loves brothers pizza. Almost every friday night is a brothers night. The thin crust Hawaiian add jalepenos is the best.

The pizza and breadsticks were very good. Had them delivered to our motel. The delivery driver was very nice. read more

Brother's is the best non-franchise in Crawfordsville. You have to order the cheese boss even if you don't love cheese pizza. It's our favorite! We also love their calzones and breadsticks. A little pricier than the competitors but it's supporting a local business so it's worth it. read more

Good food and fast delivery everything we have ordered has been good and fast. Thanks

Brothers offers delicious, hot pizza at a reasonable price. They are always friendly. The vegetarian pizza features lots of veggies, sauce and cheese. It is quite a treat. The crust is fresh and mouth watering. My friends like the meat options, so there is something for those who like meat on pizza as well. My experience over the years has been that the order is ready when they told us to expect it. So glad that this local pizza place makes such good food. Thank you Brothers! Happy to recommend you! read more

One of the best pizzas you will find in Crawfordsville wonderful staff awesome prices you rock Brothers Pizza. Never change.

Good place to get pizzas. Our like the supreme and the chicken bacon ranch. Wednesday's they have $10 pizzas so that's a must. Who doesn't like a good deal! Not a fan of their cheese for their breadsticks but enjoy their breadsticks. read more

As 30 somethings who haven't given up their college diet (Boiler Up), we consider ourselves pizza connoisseurs. We were in Crawfordsville for a short vacation and meetup with the in-laws and needed some food for everyone. Brothers pizza was quite the pleasant surprise. Everything was delicious and the price was so reasonable! We fed 4 adults and my wife's niece and nephew (11 and 4) for under $40 with lots of leftovers for us. I especially recommend the Cheese Boss Pizza. I ordered the 10" for mostly my wife and the kids, only for my father-in-law to fall in love with it. read more

Great tasting pizza. Ready when we l arrived. Great service. We ordered two 14" pizzas. Staff was wearing masks and taking proper precautions. read more

The stuffed breadsticks here are so good I rarely ever have room for pizza that the family has ordered. Employees are friendly and it doesn't take too long to get food. Will be back! read more

My wife and I picked up dinner here tonight. What we got was one of the best sausage pizzas we've ever had. The crust was crispy on the outside, soft and fluffy on the inside. There was plenty of sauce, just the right amount of sausage and cheese, and it came out of the box piping hot. Can't wait to come back. Well done Brother's Pizza!! read more

Really good pizza- I would say its more like 4.5 stars but that's not an option. Family got pepperoni, chicken BBQ, and garlic Parmesan chicken. All great. Bread sticks great, breadsticks cheese was the good nacho cheese not the plastic looking stuff. Only reason it's 4.5 starts, not many topping choices. Staff super helpful and easy to work with. No pictures because the family was crazy hungry! read more

Delicious pizza and $10 pizza on Wednesday is an office favorite! Have loved every kind of pizza they make. You can't go wrong with Brothers Pizza! read more

Good pizza, sauce is a tad sweet so I really liked it. Had all the toppings. I love the bread sticks with the garlic butter instead of cheese. You get real plates and silverware to eat with. read more

Asked many times for them to get gluten and dairy free options so the whole family can eat there . Never happened.

Fast delivery to hotel. Good pizza. Will actually go to restaurant next time we're in town.

This one is hit or miss for me. I know they are busy a lot of the time, but to forget my order entirely is pretty bad.

The pizza was really good. I ordered the meat pizza. Could've used a little more cheese as there were some bare dough and sauce spots. But the pizza was delicious and that was easily overlooked. Delivery was surprisingly fast for 6pm on a Friday. I will order from here again next time I'm in town. read more

Was very good pizza and everyone was very nice and helpful. You can do thin or thick and they make it quick. Definitely coming back again! Would recommend to anyone who is in the area! read more

Great pizza and homemade quality. Delivery is the way to go here, inside the restaurant is pretty rough and not great atmosphere.

Our favorite pizza place in town. Never been disappointed. They have the best breadsticks and great prices! We never order form chain pizza places anymore. We'd much rather support a local hometown shop, especially one THIS good! read more

We're from out of town and were passing through on on our way to Indianapolis. I found this place on maps. The reviews were great, so we ordered some grinders and pizza to go. Everything was awesome! The employees were friendly, the food was ready and still piping hot when we got there, and the food was exceptional. We will definitely be back. I wish they had Brothers in Iowa. read more

Last night we finally had an opportunity to visit Brothers Pizza in Crawfordsville. Part of the reason for our delay has been that pizza and weight loss are not very complimentary. Upon hitting milestones, we decided a night of pizza, coupled with the comedy show hosted by Brothers, would be a great way to celebrate our success. We started with a order of stuffed breadsticks. The waitress bought out 4 sticks that were a good 10 inches long and probably 2-3 inches in diameter (BIG). They were stuffed with pepperoni and cheese, served with marinara and nacho cheese sauce. Seriously, an order could easily be an entire meal and were flat out delicious! Brothers offers quite a few signature pizzas as well as grinders, but we opted to create our own pizza. The pizza came out hot and had loads of cheese. The crust was a medium thickness, with the end tasting like a mini breadstick. The ingredients were very flavorful and we both decided this was a great pizza! They do serve beer, including several craft beers from SunKing and Three Floyds breweries. If you are in Crawfordsville and craving a good pizza, Brothers Pizza is definitely a winning choice!! read more

One of the best pizza place ever. The owners know their business. Ask for the baked potato pizza not on the menu but one of the best pizzas there read more

Brothers Pizza - a dining area with a table and chairs - Pizza Near Me - Crawfordsville, Indiana

Food - delicious. Restaurant - needs some work! My mom swears by their pepperoni stuffed breadsticks - I agree that they are delicious and have enjoyed them, but always via take out. We went in to eat two weeks ago, and again, delicious food. However, the ambiance leaves a lot to desire. Our server was very nice but many of the booths are ripped and the rest of the furniture is past its prime. I'm pretty sure that they bought the old Pizza King and did a whole lot of nothing. We were the only customer there the entire time we were sitting in there (though my mom said that it was unusually quite). So come for the breadsticks, but get them to go :) read more

I work in Crawfordsville, and to say lunch options are limited is an understatement. I had a pepperoni pizza with breadsticks. Pizza was delish. Breadsticks were fresh and great with the cheese sauce. AND unlike Arni's, they deliver!! Best pizza I've tried in C-ville to date. read more

Found myself in Crawfordsville one evening and decided I would go to Yelp for assistance on what's a good place to try. Brothers Pizza had some decent reviews so decided to go! Oh my goodness very very yummy! The loaded breadsticks are Amazing I loved the pepperoni the bacon was just okay but others in my party enjoyed the bacon ones! I'm a bacon snob so it probably was just me! The pizza was equally enjoyable perfect combination of toppings and crust was amazing it was the bottom it was cooked and not soggy! If I lived closer I would frequent more often. read more

Solid pizza place for Crawfordsville with carry out and dine in options. We were able to order food for our whole family for less than $20. Pizza was full of flavor and dipping sauces are also tasty. Staff was excellent as well. We came in on a Saturday and got right in. Decor and styling is a little dated but easily over looked by the effort in all the other areas. read more

Very good pizza, especially for the price. Fed 2 15 yo boys who played baseball all weekend and 2 adults for $40. The Meatzza rivals Pizza Huts for sure read more

This place has got to have a secret!! We will no longer order pizza from anywhere else in town. Everything on the menu is beyond amazing! The Buffalo chicken pizza is AMAZING, the Black&Bleu is GREAT! Even the sauce and cheese on a cheese pizza is addicting. We have not found another place that even compares. Keep up the great work,Brothers! read more

Fantastic calzone!! Way to go guys!! Thank you for a fantastic dinner! Keep up the good work!!

Placed an order for my daughter's wedding 2 weeks ahead of time and when it was time to pick up they claimed they had no record of the order even though it was the same person who took the order that claimed this. After demanding, they did agree to deliver the pizzas no charge and gave a very small discount. The pizza was awful which I was told was not normal from them. If you have a big order, you might want to go somewhere else. Would not recommend. read more

Restaurant was dirty- we had to clean our own table off and there was crumbs and left over trash on basically every table. Pizza- was basic at best Probably wouldn't go back. read more

This Brothers Pizza restaurant is my favorite pizza ever! I love everything they serve. Their pasta is amazing, their salads are fresh and the stuffed sticks are the best. Their pizza has an amazing flavor and I love whatever they do to make their pizza dough so perfect. Also, if you have allergies they are happy to accommodate. My daughter is allergic to dairy, but she loves Brothers because they will make her a special pizza just for her. It has sauce and olives only and she likes thin crust. They go out of their way to make her this off the menu item and they charge me a very fair price. read more

Pizza and breadsticks and brownies were absolutely outrageously delicious, highly HIGHLY recommend!!! 11/10