We came by on a Saturday afternoon for lunch. They were not very busy and we were seated at once on…read moretheir patio. I chose the Irish stew, which has pot roast, red potatoes, peas, onions, carrots, celery, and gravy. The meal was very good, and I only ate half of the portion. My wife got the Trinity sandwich, which contains grilled turkey, corned beef, pastrami, and swiss cheese, which she was also very pleased with. My pint of Guiness came with a shamrock in the foam. This is a good place to try if you are looking for an Irish pub in Batavia.

Stopped by per the recommendation of my daughter. I had the Trinity sandwich with turkey,…read more pastrami and corned beef...it was delicious !!! Outdoor seating was available which worked out perfectly for the day we were there. If in Batavia again I would definitely go back!!!

Tully's is a classic spot from my childhood that now I can enjoy as an adult. My son also loves…read morecoming to Tully's to play the arcade games so it's a win-win. Our server was great here and made sure our order was sent in quick since we were in a bit of time crunch. I usually get the tenders or the burger whenever we go to Tully's. The tenders are famous so why wouldn't you get them?? This time we opted for the Buffalo tenders and a burger. The tenders were sauced perfectly. They were so good and the burger was cooked perfectly too. Between the popcorn they bring to the table, the sports bar vibe, the arcade games, and obviously the food, this is a spot with something for everyone.

I came to Tully's to watch game 4 of the Sabres series against Boston. The place was busy, but not…read morecrowded, and I got a seat at the bar. It is definitely a sports oriented ambiance. There are literally dozens of TV's all around. The barmaid was friendly and brought some popcorn. I ordered a 22 oz. glass of Tully's pilsener which was only $5.50! The beer was good. I had heard that their chicken tenders are their go-to item, so that's what I chose, and I was not disappointed. There was a choice of dipping sauce and I went with their standard honey mustard, which I enjoyed. I can recommend Tully's as a good place to come to watch a game.

ZERO STARS!!! Waited…read more25 minutes for a table. Sat for 20 minutes and no one even came over to ask for our drink order. Two tables that were seated after us got their drinks and ordered their food. We walked out.

Recently visited for the first time for trivia night. I punched the address into my GPS, and it had…read moreme park behind a building next door. Because this place is tucked back, I couldn't find it to save my life. You actually want to park and enter through the Batavia bootery. This info is just to help other YELPERS. Once I found this place, we were immediately seated, and were waiting on a 4th person. We were sat, and probably waited 30-40 minutes for someone to swing by and take our drink order. If we weren't there for trivia, I'm confident that we would've left. All of our drinks (lemonade and soda products) tasted off, and we all sent our drinks back. My lemonade was WAYYYYY TOOOOO sweet. We got water, and ordered food. Food was okay. I ordered loaded fries. They were okay, but those tasted off too like they were fried in old oil maybe? Waitress was nice and apologetic. I don't fault her for anything and felt a little bad for her. Not sure if I'll be back outside of trivia

I am updating my review because the food quality has gone into the toilet since new management took…read moreover. I have eaten here several times in the past and ordered the exact same thing every time. I always order the Philli Cheese Steak Sandwich. This is the first time eating here since the new management took over. It appears that besides turning the hotel into a one star hotel, they have really messed up the food in this restaurants. If you look at my original photo of the sandwich, envision the sandwich with a reduction of the meat of about 40%, hardly any peppers abd onions and the cheese sauce is now like watery cheese soup and there is 50% less than it used to be. With the food and hotel are really bad now and the minimum bets on the penny machines jacked up to 80 cents from 40 cents, this is the last time I will ever go to Batavia Downs for the food, gaming or hotel.

Service was excellent with Shannon as our bartender. She was fast and friendly. Food was ok. Nachos…read morewere soggy.

We stopped for lunch after a fantastic motorcycle purchase at HD. We had the loaded waffle fries…read morewhich while not fancy we great nacho cheese and some bacon on waffle fries!!! I mean winning. We had the signature Kentucky whisky burger and it was absolutely delicious!! The fries are amazeballs and over all a very good lunch stop. The waitress was very attentive and we highly recommend lunch here!

Amazing food, everything was homemade, I did a build you own burger with a veggie patty and it was…read morethe first homemade veggie patty I have had. My partner got the cowboy with a veggie patty and loved it. We got the fried green beans as an appetizer and it was perfect.

The food is delicious cuz it's all homemade and the service is wonderful the girls are very…read moreattentive and polite

Good wings, good service and down home ambiance. Always enjoy our overall experience…read more Unfortunately I felt obligated to modify my review due to extremely high charge on a pitcher of Sam Adams. Ridiculous amount.

Great food and atmosphere! The Staff are very courteous. Prices are reasonable as well. I would…read morehighly recommend!

As far as sports bars go, this one has it all. They have indoor volleyball courts, lots of TVs with…read moreall your favorite sporting events, and live music. We came here on a Friday night specifically to hear a live band, Kickstart Rumble, and there was a Cinco De Mayo party going on, and it was only May 3rd! They had a free nacho bar and Corona specials. There were colored necklaces and mustaches on the tables for customers to wear. The bartenders and wait staff were dressed in Mexican attire.The band was rockin' and the dance floor was crowded all night long. What a fun place!

We love Rookies!! The bartenders, servers, the whole staff is very personable and quick to…read morerespond. They even noticed our dog was panting and brought him water right away. So nice!! Thank you Griffin! We keep coming back for the good food and drinks. I haven't had a bad meal here. Highly recommend this place!!

Awesome bar/casual restaurant. Had happy hour special beer…read more(3 domestic draft) and roast beef sandwich. Holy crispy fries Batman! They were very good. Good space inside and outside tables too. Decent crowd even during Thursday lunch. Highly recommended.

Went around 1pm and sat in the bar. Seemed like a lot of business people even until after we left…read moreat 2.. kudos for capturing late lunch business! The staff was super friendly, perfect amount of attention. The prices seemed a bit high for the sandwiches so we decided to split and it was absolutely perfect. So with that, well worth the price per plate. The music was perfect for the crowd. 70s classics i think. The bathrooms need attention to the floor but was still very clean. I would definitely return! Oh also, it sounded like the crew was having fun in the back which made my heart happy.

I met my family here for birthday dinner and to watch a Thursday night Bills game as they were…read moreadvertising the game and an event that night. The service was inattentive and food was mediocre. Everything seemed previously frozen. When the Buffalo Bills came on at 8pm, all the tables tried to get closer to their small outdoor bar with a few extra high tops. All the waitresses left and those of us left outside were asked to go inside to order. The outdoor bartender was also inattentive and planned to leave shortly after the game started. I would suggest not advertising yourself as a sports bar or having Bills events if you're not going to staff your outdoor area on a nice summer night

What a wonderful spot! From the moment I walked in Olivia and her team took the absolute best care…read moreof me. The prices are very reasonable. The food is great. They have a massive assortment of video games and one of the most unique & comfortable bar set ups I've ever seen. If you like gaming - THIS IS YOUR BAR. I will absolutely be coming back.