I really wish I liked their sandwiches... The service is friendly and quick, even during peak hours. The dining area is welcoming but nothing special. I have gotten sandwiches a few times from this spot, but each time I find the same thing: I don't like their bread. The ciabatta is crackly and hurts my mouth. The focaccia is just so much bread for a sandwich. Often I find my sandwich is just dry and not as flavorful as I'd expect for a spot that seems to be innovative and thoughtful about their rotating sandwiches. Every time, I read the description of the sandwich and think it'll be great, but every time I'm disappointed. It's dry and bland. I'd rather spend my money on food I enjoy, which is a bummer because I'd rather support local businesses, but I'd say save your money for Jimmy John's or Jersey Mikes.... But who knows, maybe I'm just not ordering the right thing. read more

Yummy sammies - be warned that they can easily feed two. Cute as a button inside and friendly knowledgeable staff. Nice outdoor seating, too. read more

See all

You will certainly wait a little longer than a normal sandwich shop, but it's worth the wait. I always have tried one of the specials and it's never disappointed! But the tiramisu.... Ughhhh it's so good. Horsey was so good read more

See all

Wow! Stopped by at 2pm for lunch on a Wednesday. A couple people inside. Explained the menu and the staff and family favs on the boards. I got Caddies fav and added salami and it was AMAZING! They make fresh focaccia for the sandwiches and press all of them like a panini. Sooo flavorful and yummy! Also huge! I ate one half and i was full. So it's two meals for a great price! Would definitely come back again, and the dessert menu was also tempting. Can't beat great sandwiches. Will have to try different toppings next time too. read more

Arrosto Delicatessen - Delis Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

Found this place while passing through. Sandwich was amazing and the interior had a great vibe with good music. Latte was just right to complement the meal. Service was first rate and very friendly. Exterior entrance was very warm and inviting, well-maintained. I'll be back for sure. read more

See all

Small NY style deli with amazing bites! We (and all customers) were greeted immediately and welcomed! Counter service with small tables inside and outside, weather permitting. Ordering seemed overwhelming until we realized there was a menu with staff favorite combos. You can create your own DYI sandwiches or staff favorite paninis, soup, bowls or salads. All customizable and made in front of you. Come hungry as the sandwiches are big! All of us only managed to eat 1/2 of our sandwiches, including the teenager! We tried Paul's, Emma's and Kristi's plus a DIY - all delicious! Despite being full, we couldn't leave without sampling some of the sweet treats. We purchased some raspberry macarons which were full of flavor and beautiful!! They were also sampling tiramisu and cannoli cakes that they are offering for the holidays. If we lived closer I would definitely order the tiramisu cake! If you are in Sheboygan, this is a must stop! read more

See all

My sisters and I stopped in on a Thursday early afternoon and ordered the Megan and the Carson sandwiches to share. The staff was very accommodating to cut the sandwiches in fourths. I would recommended ordering any takeout sandwiches in advance as all the paninis are made fresh. It took at least 15 minutes for the sandwiches to be made as there were multiple online orders in front of us. I am glad we shared as the sandwiches are extremely filling. I was full after eating only a half of a sandwich. The sandwiches were very good, but the types we got will make you thirsty so make sure to have a large drink on standby. read more

Came here after looking on Yelp for good sandwich shops in Sheboygan. Ultimately ended up choosing Arrosto's because their sandwiches looked full and they have a lot of great options. I got a full Carson Sandwich (a staff favorite) and my boyfriend got a full Cadee sandwich (also a staff favorite). With 2 bags of chips our order came out to $28 and some change. A little on the expensive side but we were completely satisfied as our sandwiches were hot, fresh and tasty. The restaurant was clean on the inside .The staff are nice and friendly and I was served right away. The wait time was about 15min. Overall would recommend this place! read more

See all

A deli shop that is simply delish! It's sun filled room has the slightest pale of smoke From the busy panini machines! Just awesome! Caveat: don't be in a rush as the food is all freshly made. It is not served in a "New York minute" like a fast food restaurant so set your expectations accordingly. The food is all worth the wait tho! :-) The staff were friendly & welcoming and busy cleaning when not food prepping so the place is lovely & clean! We 4 ordered 4 different sandwiches and we all thought each of ours was the best. They have a nice selection of coffee and macaroons. Best part? The sandwiches are wrapped as perfectly as a gift from Marshall Fields at Christmas! Just beautiful! Thank you! Patrick Shaughnessy, Chicago, IL read more

I enjoyed a delicious a veggie bowl for lunch today. mmmmmmmmm. We ordered it to be delivered and it was on time and was very fresh tasting

GREAT BYOSandwich shop with homemade fresh ingredients and every sandwich lovers dream place! Will go back everytime I go into Sheboygan. Sandwich was 12-13$ but worth it if u want to be stuffed! read more

Arrosto Delicatessen - Must try Basil pesto homemade - Delis Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

Expensive, but delicious & fresh! Staff was very friendly. My only complaint is the tiramisu. I was not a fan. read more

Arrosto Delicatessen - Chicken panini - Delis Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Wow what a find on Yelp! Delicious, huge panini sandwich, Italian cookies & more! Friendly owner and staff, catering looks fantastic! Will be back! read more

Im from ST.Louis and I was on a work trip and found this place through the locals, anytime I'm in Wisconsin I look and see how far this place is from where I'm staying! I drove an hour one time to just get a sandwich couldn't recommend this place more!! read more

Arrosto Deli is such a great addition to the Sheboygan food scene! They offer high quality sandwiches with generous portion sizes. I love that every part of the sandwich is handmade, down to the bread. Every time I go, I receive great customer service and my order always comes out perfectly. Never leave here without trying the cannoli, either! I look forward to eating here every time I come home for the holidays. read more

An awesome deli with great sandwiches. The cannoli are also great. I'm glad the owners moved to WI. The new parking lot is a plus.

Cute small place that had about 6-7 sandwich suggestions on the board. You can also create your own sandwich. Definitely try and split a sandwich with someone as they are big! We also had the cannolis which were tasty. Friendly helpful staff! The grilled veggie sandwich came with warm sweet potatoes on it which was a nice change. read more

We've patronized this restaurant since they opened and have never been disappointed. Bland? Absolutely not. They're only as bland as the ingredients you choose from the extensive lists of options. I'm a person who loves, loves, loves sandwiches, and the infinite variety of choices in creating your own panini makes the deliciousness so much fun. Whenever we have summer houseguests, we'll pick up orders for everyone for an instant picnic! read more

Love the paninis and grain bowls. Their focaccia bread is really good. I also like their chip and drink selection. In the fall they had a delicious soup- veggies, potato and bacon? It was a winner! Don't love the desserts for some reason. Have tried the tiramisu, cheese cake and cannoli but none of them were worth the calories to me. I'd rather have more focaccia. We will keep coming back :-) read more

I'm not a Sheboygan-er (Sheboyganite?), so I did a quick Yelp search to find a place that could accommodate a diabetic carnivore, a gluten-intolerant vegetarian, and a vegan. Lots of options, especially with the build-your-own salad and sandwich choices. Food was really good, and my sandwich was so filling that I saved half for lunch the next day. And it wasn't even soggy! If I lived in town, I'd probably be a regular. My only complaint is that our order took a lot longer than I expected (over 10 minutes), and we were the only ones with an order in--just two sandwiches and a salad to go. So I would definitely plan for that, especially if they have a line. read more

Killer sandwiches. I can't stress enough how delicious our sandwich and thicc cut the chicken was. We added prosciutto, red peppers and their house made olive tapenade on focaccia. They offer gluten free bread and a ciabatta options. Lots of house made toppings, I can't wait to make a trip back up to try their porchetta. Pro tip: sandwiches are shareable but I suggest ordering two and saving them for another meal. Would highly recommend! Support your local community; especially when it's this darn good! read more

Arrosto Delicatessen - Pistachio cannoli. There's chocolate chip surprises in there that can only be experienced when taking a bite - Delis Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

When I first saw the ad for this restaurant, I was excited about eating there since it's supposed to be a New York deli. It has been a long time since I visited New York Deli, and I miss those incredible sandwiches. Ok, that said, this restaurant is disappointing; I guess it's "good enough" for a Sheboygan. Arrosto does have that New York "deli" look, and its interior is very appealing. I wish the sandwiches lived up to the atmosphere. So, let us talk about my order; I had the roast beef sandwich. The beef was not cooked with any seasoning, and the texture was rubbery. I don't know any roast beef recipe that doesn't season the beef; for heaven's sake, use a little salt and pepper. The garlic herb aioli that came with the sandwich was just plain lousy mayo with parsley, which added no flavor to the overall sandwich. Even the cheap "deli" mustard was disappointing and added no real flavor to the sandwich. Come on, you are supposed to be a New York deli; buy some decent mustards. The only saving grace of this sandwich was the fresh bread, which was exceptional. Unfortunately, even the delicious bread could not save the sandwich from being plain bland. I also ordered the chicken sandwich, which suffered from the same thing as its beef counterpart. Once again, the bread was fantastic, but everything else was plain bland. Once again, try cooking with some salt and pepper, and your meats will have some flavor. I wonder if this place should be a bakery and skip the whole New York style sandwich concept. Oh, one more thing: what kind of New York deli doesn't have pastrami, corn beef or tuna? It's sad when Panera Bread makes better sandwiches at a better price than a self-proclaimed New York deli. Remember that Arrosto is in Sheboygan so most people will settle for an overpriced bland sandwich. read more

Was shocked at how blah this was. Sandwiches were so dry and so minimal on the toppings. We had a Thanksgiving sounding one and it was the finest little speck of cranberry, no stuffing, and just a heap of dry turkey. Tried 3 sandwiches and all of them had the same issue. Incredibly disappointing and not worth the price. read more

Amazing sandwiches! Great desserts. Everything tasted homemade and fresh. Definitely will be going back!

The food is excellent and so is the dessert. The prices are a little on the high side but the food is well worth it. The workers are very friendly read more

Used to be great when they first opened. I ordered a sandwich and two ingredients weren't on there that I paid extra for. Cut in half, the other half was clearly lacking ingredients. I picked a couple of ingredients off, but not worth eating just cheese bread. Disappointed. read more

Arrosto Delicatessen - Delis Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

LOVE THIS PLACE! We have gotten sandwiches from this place probably 10 times already. Every time the sandwiches are huge and amazing. Love that they have a feature sandwich of the week that usually incorporates ingredients they don't normally have on the menu. I also love that they've been slowly over time adding side dishes and desserts etc. to the menu. Keep it up! Pro tip: sandwiches are shareable but I suggest ordering two and saving them for another meal. Would highly recommend! Support your local community; especially when it's this darn good! read more

Insanely huge sand which. Made super fresh and great taste. Half sand which is plenty or sharing one is a good idea because you will have left overs. read more

Arrosto Delicatessen - The Kristi - Delis Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Really bad. I'm not sure what NY deli this place thinks it's mimicking. Even a bodega in Poughkeepsie, near the metro North station, selling Boars Head and cooking bec on a toaster does a better job. I will accept some level of blame. I didn't understand that every sandwich is a panini. These sandwiches should not be paninis. Unless you are making salami and eggs, no one wants salami or mortadella heated. How about a simple roasted turkey, sliced thin, piled high on a good wheat bread. Lightly toasted with crisp lettuce and tomato. You want to make a sandwich with salami, mortadella and provolone? Okay, but don't stick it in a panini press. Use the focaccia or a ciabatta or a hard roll. They bake them right across the street. I'm not really interested in picking apart every misstep. The bottom line is, it's not a NY Italian deli. It might work in Sheboygan, WI, but this show couldn't travel. read more

Excellent food! We two 9 inch sandwiches on the focaccia bread, and it fed two adults and two children. One was roast beef and cheddar and the other was turkey and provolone. They make the sandwiches to order. Took them down to the beach for lunch yesterday. Everyone agreed that they tasted amazing! Highly recommend this place, worth the drive from MKE! read more

The best part of Sheboygan! Food is delicious and large portions. The paninis are to die far as are the bowls- they also have really incredible dill pickles. The staff and owner are incredibly friendly and I will really miss it since I've moved away. The very cute restaurant atmosphere is very casual and in an old historic bldg. read more

Unique, fresh, delicious delicatessen...large enough to split! Great to take to the beach for a picnic. We will come back before our vacation ends with our vegan daughter!! read more

See all

I really enjoyed my sandwich from Arrosto! Homemade focaccia, quality meat options, highly customizable. I opted to get mine unheated by the panini press, as I prefer cold sandwiches. They had run out of cannoli which was a bummer but will be back to try! Only complaint was the sandwich was light on mustard. Will be back! I suggest sharing if you can't eat a 7x7 square of sandwich alone! read more

Arrosto Delicatessen - Turkey, mozzarella, arugula,tomato,pesto sandwich on focaccia - Delis Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

I am not a huge sandwich person (or didn't think I was) until I tried Arrosto. I had Teddy's Sandwich, which is their focaccia with mortadella and salami, provolone, artichoke hearts, spinach, balsamic vinegar and olive oil. The bread was some of the best I ever had -- a delicious sour dough with a great consistency to soak in the vinegar and oil. The meats paired perfectly together and were out-of-this-world in flavor. The portion size was also extremely generous. I can't wait to go back! read more

Arrosto Delicatessen - Teddy's Sandwich - Delis Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Wow! What a place! Everything is homemade including the focaccia and ciabatta. We had the nine inch focaccia with prosciutto and fresh mozzarella it was outstanding! read more

This was a tasty little spot to get sandwiches before a trip to the beach. Delicious GF bread that is much better than the normal options.

I went into the deli to order.i waited 20 minutes for my order. I ordered a focaccia and a ciabatta. Both were tasty. But one would have been good for both of us. read more

Awesome panini sandwiches at a good price. Different sizes for how hungry yor feeling. read more

This is by far the best sandwich I may have ever had. The special panini was the pulled pork and Mac n cheese was phenomenal. Wife got The Paul and that was even better than mine. This is easily the top sandwich shop in the area and arguably a top 5 food place entirely. Will be back quite often. read more

Amazing sandwiches made fresh right in front of you! Went for my first time on Monday and it will not be my last! The staff was so friendly and helpful. I had a 9" focaccia with roast chicken, swiss, roasted red peppers, artichoke hearts and the house made spicy giardiniera and herb mayo. They have a few pre built sandwiches on the menu or you can build your own. I also really appreciate that they are taking the covid guild lines seriously and felt very safe while I was in there. Cannot wait to return and try a cannoli or cheesecake with my order read more

Arrosto Delicatessen - Delis Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin