If you're looking for the best chicken wings, this is the spot. The BLACK BETTY 10/10 wings came…read moreout hot, crispy, and packed with flavor, with a sauce that hit the perfect balance of savory, spicy, and just a little sweet. Every bite tasted fresh, and the portions were generous. The service was friendly and quick, and the whole experience felt like stepping into a time warp in the best way--classic, old-school, and focused on doing one thing really well. I'd absolutely come back for the wings alone.

It was such a vibe the food was great music was great and the bartender was so sweet I would…read moredefinitely go here again

Stopped by Papa Tino's and had a great meal. The pizza was cooked perfectly with a crispy crust,…read moreplenty of toppings, and great flavor in every bite. The wings were just as good -- juicy, well seasoned, and cooked just right. The antipasto salad was fresh and loaded with meats, cheese, and veggies, making it a perfect start to the meal. Everything tasted fresh and the portions were generous. Great spot for pizza night if you're craving good wings and a solid salad to go with it. Definitely worth a visit!

Over numerous occasions, I have had to wait an additional 30-40 minutes for my order to be…read morecompleted for pickup. I have not been updated to change of time, if ever. The atmosphere is not inviting, whatsoever. The food is decent as I continue to come back but after this, I'm considering taking my business elsewhere. I have been a loyal customer since the doors first opened.

Our go to place for Friday night pizza night most of the time. Always delicious pizza and knots…read more Might be a little more pricey compared to other local spots, but worth it. Service is always good and delivery time is fairly good

Okay-ish pizza. My husband and I are used to real pizzeria-style pizza from southern NY, where "by…read morethe slice" actually means multiple slice options ready to go. They advertised slices, but when we got there, they said they were out and only had plain cheese available by the slice if they had any, which was disappointing. We ended up ordering a half pepperoni, half buffalo chicken pie. It took about 35 minutes, and when it came out, it just wasn't what we expected. The center was very soft and soggy, to the point where slices wouldn't hold up and the toppings kept sliding off. There was also a lot of grease. On the buffalo chicken pie they literally used boneless chicken wings instead of traditional chicken, which threw us off and not what I'm used to for NY pizza. If you're used to southern NY-style pizza, this probably won't hit the mark.

I ordered through the BWW website for my son on [insert date]. Our drinks were missing, so I…read morecalled. The manager was polite and said she'd remake the order and have DoorDash bring it back. We never received the remake. When I called again, staff were laughing in the background. A male employee answered and used a racial slur toward me, said "it's not going to happen tonight" and hung up. I did not expect to be spoken to like that. We're still missing our order and my son didn't get his meal. This is not the way to treat customers.

The seating time and cleanliness, Had a party of 14 for after graduation and over 23 open tables…read moreand still had to wait over an hour. Had to wait for to go orders to be done before even being seated. The tables we got weren't cleaned off, had crumbs on it and my seat had a sticky black spot stuck to it like gum. Wait time for food was good although my wings were a little cold even though all of are food came out at separate times and the waiter was friendly.

Pizza slices were big, wings were good, and the service was nice. Dining area was clean.read more

We just moved to Watertown a month ago and have been trying different pizza places in the area. We…read moreare on a quest to find a truly thin crust pizza so I was excited when I called and they said they could make one. I explained what I was looking for in great detail and the woman taking my order seemed really enthusiastic that it could be done. We ordered a large thin crust pizza and a large calzone. The thin crust wasn't that thin, but was definitely still tasty. The calzone was almost perfect. The crust was soft and flavorful, sprinkled with a light coating of parmesan cheese. You can request the sauce on the side, which I did. The sauce didn't really taste like much of anything, but the calzone didn't need it anyway. A little on the expensive side, but I would definitely eat here again.

The pizza here is amazing. The staff is as well. I'm visiting from Florida - and finally had a…read moregreat experience with a Watertown restaurant. I've been back 3 times.

OIP. It used to be our favorite pizzeria, maybe it was an off day but last week's pizza and wings…read moredid not bit the same. First the location, it seems odd for me as a person from the west coast but my east coast friends say it's not weird at all. It is attached to a laundromat and share the same bathroom. Free parking, and never full, which is great. Indoor seating is fine, nothing fancy, regular pizza shop. We noticed this time that it said "Tony's pizzeria" is that new? Service, the people are always kind. This last time, we decided to call in our order on a Friday night. They told us 30 mins until it's ready, we got there 20 mins early and their estimated time was exactly on the dot. So if you're planning to call, call ahead and trust their estimated time. The food, the pizza crust was different. It wasn't as chewy as usual. But the sauce and toppings were great. The most disappointing were the wings. I ordered a dozen medium Buffalo and the picture will speak volumes. No flavor. Dry, barely tossed in sauce. It had no spice. We will give them another try and hope they just had an off day.

OIP not in Pennsylvania.... This is a treat really. I noticed that there were no pictures of the…read moreItalian sub. I found that quite mind boggling. That's the best thing! My sub came with a bite out of it but I ate it anyway. That's how good they are! Just kidding about the bite. I'm not sure about the location as it's very busy at this section of the road plus they are doing road construction there. There's also a laundromat in the same building so " when in Rome " if needed. I did not see any potato chips out for purchase. That to me is a game changer. You can't eat a sub without chips.... Service was average but definitely friendly. Just add a rack of salty chips and stars will be added.

LOVE THE PADDOCK!! Food is always amazing and their service is always fast!! They have great drinks…read moreand the bartenders definitely know how to help guests have a fun night out! Would definitely recommend to others!!

I've been here a handfull of times since 2009, and it's pretty much worth the drive from rochester,…read moreny just to go here! I always have a wonderful experience at this place! Offering a cozy old-timey ambiance that you just dont see every day, you'll enjoy stepping back in time here. The Paddock Club has comfy seating and a chill vibe. I love it here and whenever I'm in Watertown it's a place I must go to. Hopefully I'll retun here soon. Great drinks and selection with unmatched service. This place is the place to be!