Interesting vibe, GREAT PIZZA! Must try the HUGE Pizza! Fun thing to bring to a party. I consider myself a pizza con-issuer and I sincerely love the taste of their pie. Interesting sports memorabilia of high quality worthy of checking out while you wait. The restaurant shows love of ones job and is family run. I have been a fan even at their prior location. They really put a pretty nice personal stamp remodeling the new location, its upper-casual in atmosphere, similar to a hipster populated-divebar. Its nice and trendy with updated furnishings and appeal, however if you look to close with the lights on, its not that clean cut,and has a slapdash attention to detail accompanied with a kinda-dirty bathroom. I recommend this one! read more

Not only was my food horrible, burnt to a crisp and my Stromboli had NO meat -- when I went back to the restaurant to complain the worker was so rude. Spoke extremely rude to me over an error on their end. read more

*Covid update* Here's the thing. You gotta let this flaming hot goodness sit a few before you dig into this bad boy. I ordered "well done" because I like a good crisp. This doesn't disappoint. Sauce has a nice subtle tang, and the cheese is on point. The pizza is bigger than the box, and that's always a plus. Slightest bit of grease, which I love. Crust is tasty, and crisp, even with delivery. Only downfall is a slight flop in the middle, because of how thin this pizza is. read more

Balsamo's Pizza and Beer - Best in the area. If you know pizza, this is it. Sauce has a tang, cheese is amazing. This was cooked perfect. Pizza is bigger than the box. - Pizza Near Me - Lindenwold, New Jersey

Ordered a chicken parm sandwich tonight. I took it home and immediately proceeded to eat, but the chicken was burnt. Badly. All of it. It was over-cooked and chewy too. Surely the cook noticed, unless they work with their eyes closed. So I'm pretty disappointed it ended up in my sandwich instead of the trash. It was ready really fast too. I'd have rather waited for something edible. read more

Balsamo's Pizza and Beer - Burned chicken parm - Pizza Near Me - Lindenwold, New Jersey

I have been getting deliveries from here often. Today, the item was wrong. I called to have it replaced. Was told to bring it in and they would make another. That is the whole purpose of delivery. TO NOT go in. I ended up hanging up after being put on hold 5 times and continuously told they did not make a mistake. Will never order from them again. DONE read more

This place is great!! Just picked up some food and it's awesome as usual!! Great people work there!! Great food and selection!! A+++++

The pizza here is just..... atrocious. I don't understand how they consistently make terrible pizza. We also asked for mild wings and they gave us fried chicken basically. read more

My go-to for pizza. Their sandwiches are so-so. Fries are solid. Dinners solid. Delivery is usually quick and hassle free. Reasonable prices. read more

This place changed hands and has gone way down hill. The only reason they got 2 stars is because the delivery guy was really nice. The chicken parm I ordered was burnt...very burnt. They gave a side order of garlic knots that were so hard they were inedible. One bite attempt and it was obvious someone tried to heat them in the microwave. The folks that answer the phone are not knowledgeable or friendly. When you order in person no one knows how to ring the order up, what food items they have and how to make change. It's obvious there are staffing issues just from the backroom conversations that were easily overheard. It's sad...this place used to be awesome.now it's just awful. read more

So... call to order dinner, get hung up on twice by some girl who was yelling 'Why would you do that?' at a co-worker... called back a 3rd time, started to place order... ordered 2 lg pizzas with extra toppings and was gonna order appetizers after ordering a burger... I ask for the lettuce, tomato and onion to be put on the side (warm and mushy veggies on a burger = EEW) and the nasty girl gave me an attitude telling me 'Um, no, we can't put that on the side'... I asked again, stating that I thought was odd and she said again with an attitude that they "don't do that"... WAY TO GO BALSAMO'S... YA JUST LOST BUSINESS OVER A SIDE OF LETTUCE TOMATO AND ONION!!! read more

Great food, great service!! The chicken fingers are made fresh and are terrific. I also love the panzarotti

This soggy disgusting muck cost me $7 from Basalmos on atlantic ave. I went in asked if they could replace the unediteble food! They said no you want it to not be like that you should have picked it up! I asked for my money back, no you get what you get no refund read more

Balsamo's Pizza and Beer - Supposed to be edible - Pizza Near Me - Lindenwold, New Jersey

See all

Horrible horrible management and customer service for wings that are extremely too salty and a sandwhich line up that incorporates a menusha of greasy appetizers mashed into a three day old hoagie roll accompanied by a side of soggy fries stuffed in a grease spotted brown paperbag...and that is just for delivery! No wonder they have to serve and deliver alcohol. If you are tipsy it is the cuisine of Kings. I approve this message as a CIA of NY alumn and certified Garden State Foodie. Yikes! read more

I drive by here all the time. I asked my friend if they serve good pizza and he said yes. He wasn't kidding when he said that the slices are big. Slices are very affordable when it's a cheese pizza. If you want 1 or more toppings, it will cost a little bit more. Service is good, no complaints. read more

See all

5 stars for customer service! I ordered a handful of panzarottis and a caesar salad for co-workers and me last week, but someone else picked it up for me and I didn't get to my lunch until after some meetings. I realized hours after my order that they forgot the dressing for the salad. I called to let them know and they insisted on fixing the situation, sending a driver straight to my job (even though we had originally picked it up and not paid for delivery). Just an extra call that took me less than a minute and within 10 minutes they saved my lunch. Of course the panzarottis were fabulous as well, but I'll definitely return and recommend for the excellent customer service! read more

Wow I honestly believe in patronizing community businesses...however the level of disrespect that was shown from the owner is unbelievable. This business needs to be out of the community. The owner called a woman a cheap Bitch in front of her child. It seems there was a dispute over a two liter soda. Now personally I believe if the female wanted to be smart with her money the two liter was the way to go... however rules are rules and I honestly understand that. But calling a female outside of her name in front of her child is just wrong. From my understanding this pizza shop does a lot for the area that he serves but what the owner must understand is one bad action will make all the good he has done in the community look like nothing. My suggestion is go to another pizza shop. Somewhere that will value all of their customers.#boycott read more

Balsamo's Pizza and Beer - Pizza Near Me - Lindenwold, New Jersey

Was a routine customer. However, the portions have become pathetic. Tonight, I ordered a cheesesteak and picked it up to find out half the sandwich was bare. Upon calling, I was told thats normal and theres nothing wrong. I offered to bring the sandwich in and was told it doesn't mean they would change anything and I shouldn't waste my time. Very unprofessional. read more

Balsamo's Pizza and Beer - Here is Balsamos version of a cheesesteak. Barely anything on it - Pizza Near Me - Lindenwold, New Jersey

They have phenomenal pizza, in a great spot for eat-in or take out. The pizza we ordered here came out piping hot, just the way I like to have it. The sauce was fresh, and its quality is probably never matched elsewhere in NJ. The smallest pizza provides the best price point, while the biggest "party" size pizza provides the worst bang for your buck. This defies the mathematical logic of 99% of pizza parlors. So make sure to get multiple smalls to fulfill your party needs, rather than the one super large pizza. In addition to the price savings, you can also benefit from multiple topping selections as well. The toppings, as well as the pies themselves, were priced much more favorably for smaller pizzas. Eat in service includes two rooms set up with plasma screen set to a sports station (there's a definite Eagles vibe in there). There are big windows for lighting, and very comfortable air conditioning. read more

Just ordered here for the first time! Got some garlic parm wings and dry hot wings with a side of honey BBQ sauce. Both were absolutely delicious! Also got a burger which was definitely higher than average for a pizza place. I'll definitely be eating here again! read more

Balsamo's Pizza and Beer - Garlic parm wet wings & dry hot wings. Both are delicious!! :) - Pizza Near Me - Lindenwold, New Jersey

I LOVE this place! Pizza is always delicious and hot! We usually get pepperoni and bacon, have sometimes gotten mozzarella sticks, wings, fries-all things have been good but the pizza is really where they shine. Sadly we live walking distance from a pizza shop but will take the extra step to order from balsamos. In my opinion, it's a little more expensive in comparison to other shops but it's worth it. Staff are friendly, and introduced me to one of my new favorite beers when I couldn't decide! Good news is if you get delivery and forget to run out for beer or wine, they will deliver:) read more

We have been here on Wednesdays for the $3.99 panzarotti day. They are excellent. Service was quick and efficient. No complaints, Give them a try! Also, it seems the owner does a lot for the community! read more

Has changed management. Menu is the same but quality has dropped and customer service is nonexistent. Too many alternatives in pizza places to need to continue to go here anymore. read more

This pizzeria is under new owner..unfortunately. The staff is really rude. They forgot our sauce for the wings. When we called to let them know and ask they they deliver it. We were told the owner packed the order himself and if we want it we have to come get it ourselves. We said we would come get it but we aren't paying extra since they forgot it. The woman said don't tell me what to do. Well, I went there to get the sauce asked for the owner. The girl went in the back to get the owner then came back upfront and was told he wasn't there that he went out on a delivery. We have people over nearly every weekend and order here all the time since it its close. We spend around $200 plus a month. With rude service like this we won't be back. There are plenty of other restaurants to order from with better service. Apparently the place can't even keep their help. Everytime we go in there are new people. It's a shame we loved this place but won't be back read more

I've been to Balsamo's several times and the food is great - especially the Boardwalk Fries and the Voodoo Chicken Fries. Their pizza is good as are their sandwiches. read more

This place is complete TRASH! They have no issue cursing you out or lieing to you! Over an hour and a half to get 2 pizzas and garlic knots! And after an hour lied to us about it being on the way (keeping in mind we live less then 5 minutes from the place). It really sucks cause they do have good pizza but not good enough to get cursed out over. Do not come here!!!! read more

I haven't been to its new location until last week. I was a frequent customer when it was on Emerson Avenue in Lindenwold. I stopped in for a turkey hoagie. The woman who took the order was friendly and brought the sandwich out to me from behind the counter when it was made which wasn't necessary. It was a big and delicious sandwich. I may go back and try the pizzas which looked tasty since I now know where the new store is. read more

Balsamo's Pizza and Beer - A turkey and cheese hoagie. - Pizza Near Me - Lindenwold, New Jersey

Pizza was disgusting. Staff was rude. The kitchen staff looked dirty, and not because they had been making pies all day..more like they didn't bathe. Or perhaps have a drug problem? IDK but it was suspect. The place was empty and we still had to "bother" the staff for a table...When my service is bad and the food is as terrible as it was here, I normally just do not return. Glad I did not choose to complain or have it remade, as I have since learned from a former employee that the owner (who apparently was the desheveled and drug addicted looking man who cooked our food) likes to SPIT IN THE FOOD OF COMPLAINING CUSTOMERS!?!?!?!. Just wow. Will not return and highly reccomend you avoid this place at all costs, lest you end up with Hep B read more

Only ever really ordered pizza, beer and appetizers from here. Love the pizza, it's always been hot and fresh. The beer selection is awesome, with a good selection of craft beers as well as your standard beer flavored waters and they are fairly reasonably priced compared to a liquor store. I don't mind paying slightly more for the one stop shop convenience. The best part is they'll deliver beer right to your door with dinner. Like all places, delivery can be a bit of a wait sometimes but unlike some places I've experienced you still manage to get hot fresh food. After reading another ridiculous review I just want to add that this place is in a perfectly safe residential neighborhood. I do not live in this neighborhood, but drive through several times a week. Anyone who says they didn't feel safe going here has never been anywhere near here and most likely has an axe to grind. In fact I almost bought a house a block from here but didn't only because of issues that came to light during the home inspection. read more

Most important thing to note is that it is a clean environment. Friendly service and good food. Large portions too in some cases (i.e I always feel like I get big pieces of chicken!) I would definitely recommend. read more

Customer service is horrible! If you're spending money to support their business, they should have more respect for their customers. Puellas in lindenwold is way better! read more

We ordered food from this place and they over cooked the food we called and were told the company changed the batter of the funnel fries so nothing can be done! Needless to say the manager I spoke to is horrible like their food please stay away! read more

I ordered vegan pizza from here and tasted like there was slime under the veggies and the daiya cheese. I got this a month or so ago but I forgot to post a review because I wanted to warn people to elsewhere. I came here years ago and it was amazing but it's kinda just disappointing now. Older woman at the counter was sweet though. read more

This WAS my favorite place to get a great salad. There was a mix up with the order. The (new) employee didn't have the authority to "make it right" and redo/resend the salad because the owner wasn't physically on site.......? (Huh?) I made a personal visit to the establishment to fix the problem. They got the owner on the phone and his sub-par customer sevice skills and nasty/condescending tone with me the customer, helped me make the decision to never, ever patronize them again. Maybe the owner forgot that it's the customers' who keep his business afloat. read more

Best wings! My favorite are the garlic parm wings well done with extra garlic parm sauce . So good!!! I definitely order from them once a month lol. read more

Someone dropped my pizza its not even edible. So i ordered from puellas i kno they dont play that at puellas. Balsamos sux.

My family orders delivery or fetches foods in some manner every single day. There are about 10 local places on our regular rotation. There are things on the menu that one of us loves and the other hates at every location. One of us finds it salty, the other finds it perfect. Some places mess up more than others, some almost never mess up. I will continue to try new things at Balsamo's. If they screw something up or forget something minor, I'll just take the tiny hit. No Biggie. If some place screws the same thing up over and over, I will remind them to make sure. If I HAD to complain about Balsamo's I would say that they don't carry swiss cheese for my turkey hoagies, which are the biggest stuffed hoagies I've ever seen. Flipping Huge. There are currently some bumps in the road with the change over to the new menu. Make sure you are on their website with the actual menu looking format with yellow background. Always be nice to people handling your food anywhere, and always over-tip a little if you can. These folks put up with a lot of grief. read more

The owner is really nice! I really enjoy the ghost pepper cheese! The staff is really friendly! I come in and I leave every time I order with no problems! As person who worked in the food industry. I would not trust some of these reviews. I'm sure maybe some of them had a bad experience. Maybe they did mess up but mistakes happen. However, I don't think that these people were rude! They seem pretty nice. read more

this place was a really good craving satisfier. I was craving a cheesesteak so I searched for the nearest pizzeria and this came up. Contrary to the popular reviews, the "bald guy" was not mean to me and service was nice. I really love the cheesesteak and I look forward to going back for more. my husband also really liked the garlic bread. read more

I am not from around Jersey, but I called Balsamo's with an odd request - I wanted a romantic pizza sent to my loved one with a special message made out in pepperoni. They easily agreed and did it for no extra cost. They delivered a great pizza with pepperonis in a heart shape. Too cute. Thank you! Great customer service. read more

Never ordering from here again! Order was wrong, burnt pizza & a crappy cheesesteak! They used to be good... Idk what happened! #neveragain