This is the 1st pizza I had when my family and I moved here from Philly over 50 years ago, crazy. Anyway, the people are great, there is still a sense of family there and that's a rare thing these days. I know it's not the sexy review , but I can honestly say, and I've been around, that the plain pie (don't know the secret ) meets and exceeds all the "famous" spots around! Definitely worth a visit! read more

Food is fine. We had a what we thought was a minor issue. We asked for no lettuce on two subs. They had lettuce. My wife called to resolve the matter. The older gentleman who is often in there gave my wife a hard time on the phone. Telling her that's not what she said. She always says no lettuce. Eventually, they agreed to make the replacements. I went to go pick them up. When I got to the counter he, also gave me a hard time. Telling me my wife didn't say not lettuce. He grabbed the sandwich bag out of my hand and took it back across the counter. I said "dude are you serious right now?" He threw the bag back on the counter saying "take them." We live within walking distance and ordered from here on a weekly basis. Never again. Even the Golden Arches has better customer service. read more

Ordered a drunken vodka parm sandwich from a post I saw made from this place. Waste of time and money. Sandwich didn't look anything like the post. Very dry, barely any flavor, burnt bread. read more

See all

I've been eating food from Johnny's for well over 20 years. I still have some sandwich coupons they used to give out - get 20 coupons and you get a free sandwich! While they no longer give out those coupons, not much else has changed with Johnny's. Food-wise, you'll always get a solid meal for a decent price. It won't blow your mind and it won't make you say "why did I get this" but when you get your order, you won't be disappointed. The pizzas are solid and well-portioned - no tiny pies here. The cheese is mozzarella and the sauce is not sweet, as it should be. The hoagies here are generously portioned as are the triple-decker club sandwiches. Cheesesteaks? Go for it - they're also solid. I'd say Chick's is better then Johnny's but if you don't want to travel too far or want a quick delivery, you can't go wrong with Johnny's. read more

COVID19 Quarantine Review (Pick Up); Johnny's is one of my favorite Pizza places, so of course I had to grab a pizza during this crazy Quarantine. I called in an order on a Friday night, and was surprised to only have a half hour turn around. One of the things I love about Johnny's is their localized personalities that make you feel a regular the minute they answer the phone. I opted for a custom pizza - white sauce, bacon, onions & broccoli - sounds a little weird, but it was delicious! I also ordered a bag of their homemade chips, these things are DELICIOUS & a MUST with any Johnny's order! Pick was was easy and the food was hot. read more

Johnny's Pizza - Home made chips, a must with any order! - Italian Near Me - Cherry Hill, New Jersey

I was at home congested and sick. I didn't feel like making dinner or going out or making dinner. So I called to order a plain cheese pizza. The problem, I called five times in a row and they didn't answer. I then wait over 45 minutes to call again and they still didn't answer. read more

This is our neighborhood pizza place and we have gotten their food for years. Pizza is always delicious, service is friendly. Can't beat it!

Good pizza. Small place by dollar general. Across the from gallos bakery. Bagel spot.

This place has my FAVORITE gluten-free pizza! I get the cauliflower crust with pepperoni!! Love it!!

Johnny's is the place where "everyone knows your name." I've been going here since 1987. I used to work nearby and go for lunch with co-workers. The pizzas are generous and flavorful. I've only had favorable experiences at Johnny's. I would recommend them to anyone for pizza or a sandwich. I live near about six pizzerias (who doesn't) and would suggest they're the best of them. read more

Covid-19 Review: Over the weekend I decided that I wanted to order a pizza for dinner since I couldn't go out to eat. After searching online for the best and inexpensive pizza in my area, I came across Johnny's Pizza. They had a $19.99 deal for two large pies which they run all the time. The reviews were mostly good so I decided to give them a try. JP was the typical pizza place and I would say the pizza wasn't bad. The pizza had flavor and wasn't greasy. I'll definitely be back and recommend JP if your looking for quality pizza for a good price. read more

Friendly owners, great hoagies and cheesesteaks. A local gem! I've been a customer of Johnnie's since moving to Kingston over thirty years ago. read more

Poor service. Horrible service I wrote this review about 2 years ago because I don't like to talk bad about anybody, but now that I'm in the never come back again list here we go. Their cheese Pizza is tasty but their customer service is horrible, it almost feels like dealing with the Mob. Enough said. read more

A neighborhood classic, Johnny's pizza has always been there to support the local community. BBQ chicken pizza is one of my favorites among many. The staff is great, and service is top notch. Intimate setting inside, but my go to option for pizza and food ordered to go! read more

Another visit and another 5 stars, have to try to the chicken bacon ranch pizza/slices can't wait to go back again soon

Great gluten free pizza. A bit pricey ,Also small. Regular pizza is good. Good size menu if everyone in your family wants something different. A lot to choose from. I also want to suggest adding a bit extra for the driver Since gas has gone through the roof Which I did . We will be back Johnny's has been around a long time read more

Called to place order for delivery 1.5 miles away as we have done several times over. Was told delivery time was one hour. Okay, no big deal as we love their pizza and sandwiches. Was then told to hold on by the woman who answered. A man then came on the line to say they do not deliver to us. When asked why, that we have always had delivery from them, and as recently as a week ago, was told very rudely that I am too busy to deliver there and then was hung up on before a response could be given. Called back and asked why he hung up on me and was told because people like me (not sure what kind of people he was referring to) are the reason why he hangs up on customers. Damn shame they hire ignorant SOB's that cannot handle a busy business. I'll miss the food there, but I'll be spending my $$ elsewhere until that clown is gone or is taught how to speak to the customer. Pizza shops are a dime a dozen. read more

Love this place, tried johnny's out on a wim with my wife tryed when we came to cherry hill looking for a home to buy. 2 years later and we eat here atleast once a week. pizza is bomb and the garlic wings are everythingggg read more

My stepdaughters like it. Works for me. My little cousin loves the pizza so much she makes us bow when we first walk in lol. read more

Johnny's Pizza - Large half pepperoni. - Italian Near Me - Cherry Hill, New Jersey

See all

Ordered a pizza with the works...I don't understand but it lacked flavor...the plain was better. We didn't like the crust either. It's not a place we will use for a pizza fix again read more

My girlfriend and I are huge pizza lovers, and try new pizzerias all of the time. We tried Johnny's last week, but weren't too impressed. We placed an order for a chicken bacon ranch pizza, sweet potato fries, and cheese poppers. The sweet potato fries weren't very good; overcooked and tiny portion- the menu listed only one size. The poppers were very well fried, cheesy and delicious. Highly recommend. The chicken bacon ranch pizza wasn't cohesive- very strange combination. It was literally ranch dressing, very little cheese, and bacon. There wasn't much chicken at all. The upside was that the bacon was actual bacon strips. I'd go here again for the poppers, but not much else. read more

The fact they their slogan is "The best pizza in cherry hill" is joke. Who the hell deemed them that? I ordered a plain pizza last night first time ever trying Johnnys. Couldn't have been more bland. No taste in the sauce...I wouldn't even say it's an average pizza. Live and learn. read more

This place is a must try! Definitely my new go-to pizza joint. I had a cheesesteak and a couple of plain cheese pizza slices. I highly recommend both. Also, the guys working there were friendly and seemed to know the customers that were coming and going while I was there. I really liked the local neighborhood vibe of this place. read more

Just waited over 30 minutes for 2 slices and a pasta to go. Walked in. It was not busy. There were no tickets flying out of the machine. Owners sat at a table with masks half off of their faces chatting away and got indignant when I started to get curious about my order. The owner said I "should have called ahead". Right. It's my fault. Got home and the slices are cold. One Star for the cashier. She is sweet. She understood the issue. Maybe they should pay her well to manage what they obviously cannot. read more

I tried to order a pizza from here for delivery, and (I think the owner) was extremely rude. I live less than 2 miles from this place, and apparently they won't deliver to my apartment complex because it's to much of a headache. I could understand if it was a dangerous neighborhood but it isn't. Only reason I didn't pick up is because I have young children with me. The tone that I was spoken to left such a bad taste in my mouth that I will never try their food read more

These guy's get it right every time! Great pizza! Panzarrotti's that are to die for and sandwiches made to order. You cant go wrong. Whether I'm just stopping in for a slice or getting dinner for the whole family, they always go the extra yard. These guys are 100% authentic comfort food kings! read more

Johnny's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Cherry Hill, New Jersey

The owner has been a great supporter of the local schools. The pizza is solid with good sauce. I'd like my crust a bit thicker but otherwise very good. The cheesesteak here was also very good for South Jersey. Finally their grilled cheese varieties are very tasty. Johnny's is definitely a solid go to neighborhood pizzeria. read more

My favorite place in Cherry Hill for a casual lunch or to bring home awesome pizza for the family. Delivery is quick! Johnny's makes everyone feel welcomed. The food is fresh and fantastic. I couldn't recommend just one dish because they are all good. read more

Is it just me? I know it's tough times,but I think Johnny's has jumped the shark. Got my order wrong, on pickup, no problem close enough. The pizza is not the same, what happened? I apologize, my bust. Wrong Johnny's. Sorry read more

Very dirty location. Pizza arrived cold, rather soggy. I did not call when it was busy, still took about an hour, the way the girl took my order was also very condescending and apathetic. Won't be ordering again. read more

I like this place. Good pizza at a very reasonable price-- the people are friendly and helpful. They don't stare at you if you buy a slice and a coke and use their restroom! Parking is right out front and you can even eat your pizza in one of their booths. read more

The food actually isn't bad at all. But here is why it gets 1 star. My mother and I decided to order delivery one day. We live in the neighborhood and have been customers for years. We call and order one pepperoni pie (pretty basic) and fries. The man on the phone gives the total. We ask if we can pay by credit card. He takes our credit card number down, and then informs us that they lost electricity earlier in the day (this happened sometime in July), and that they were unsure if the credit machine would work. I asked him to call back and let me know because we didn't have cash, credit was our only option of payment. We hang up. 10 minutes go by with no phone call. I call HIM back, and he says it didn't work the first time so he asked for the credit card number again to try a second time. This time, I stay on the line while he tries again. It doesn't work. He apologies, and so do I. I ask him to cancel our order then because we do not have any cash. He then grows angry because he apparently already has the pizza cooking in the oven. I then proceed to ask him why he would start to cook our order when he knew our only form of payment is credit and his credit machine wasn't working? Mind you, it's a simple pepperoni pie that I'm sure another customer would order, as it being a popular menu item. His response to me was verbatim, "Don't you ever f**king call us again". *click* Don't worry, we won't. read more

Well, I'd like to be able to say the pizza was horrible, but alas, the crappy customer service kept me from even tasting it. I called at 8pm to ask if they deliver to my address. Curtly, the man on the phone says yes, but not for just one pizza. So we decide to order two, visit the website, pick out the toppings and call back at 9pm. Same man on the phone says, sorry, he's too busy to deliver to me. And I reminded him that I called earlier in the evening and he said it was okay as long as it was more than one pizza. So he says he wants to close and that he never said that. Do I have to beg this guy to give him my business? I gladly took my business elsewhere. Vitarelli's was happy to take my order. read more

I changed my original review from 3 stars to 5 stars. I recently revisited this place and the staff was friendly and accommodating. A major change from my previous experiences. The pizza is good and you can't beat the 2 pizza lunch special. Additionally, their delivery service is great. They are your friendly neighborhood pizza place. read more

The only pizza I will order in this area. I love their pizza. Perfect in every way. My favorite is the special white. Super good. Also, always great service! read more

OMG!! Usually get pizza here and it's food not great but today I ordered pasta and meatballs. I know there was going to be plenty from the weight of the bag but sometimes that's not a good sign. Well it was awesome. Pasta not pre-cooked because of the el Dante firmness. The sauce was excellent with a little spice. I usually put red pepper but none necessary. It came with a loaf of garlic bread. This dish easily could serve 3 people. The salad crisp and fresh a meal in itself. The meatballs were good not Mamas but good. Could not have made this meal for $12! read more

This is the best pizza place around! We used to go somewhere else in the neighborhood and even though it was meh, we were creatures of habit until we were done. We've been ordering from Johnnys for a few months now and it's always delicious and delivery is always timely. Tonight we had white pizza with ricotta, loads of ricotta and so yummy. And I had a chicken Italiano sandwich, grilled chicken, spinach, roasted peppers and provolone. And they made it on a wrap at my request. Omg, it was so delicious!! And they're very nice:)! read more

Johnny's is under new management. The place is cleaner and brighter and the food was excellent. I got a Italian hoagie with their homemade chips. I've also had their pizza and that was excellent to. read more

This ex-NYer loves real pizza. South Jersey lacked real pizza; until Johnny's came to town in 2010! Now I get the best pizza and Italian sandwiches whenever I want. The owners Johnny and Rocco treat you like family. Food is delivered to your table, it is always hot and delicious. They are also very community minded collecting for local cause's. Run to Johnny's for your Italian fix today, you won't be sorry! read more

Friendly staff, consistently fast service, and the best pizza in the neighborhood. They seem to be a big hit with kids from the local elementary school. Our daughter came home talking about them after a classroom pizza party, so we decided to give them a try. Glad we did, they're now our new favorite! read more