I was out on the Island running some errands when I suddenly felt a hunger. Since it was lunch time, I looked around and noticed Barefoot Peddler was steps away; it looked decent enough at first glance, so I headed in. BP is very much a no frills spot. We stayed in the bar area as that takes up the majority of the interior; there are, however, some booths and a separate room with tables. Decor was simple - typical bar/pub aesthetics. It wasn't busy at all when we arrived so we had our choice of seats which was nice. The menu was more extensive than I expected. There's a selection of apps, sandwiches, salads, pizzas, soups, fajitas, and burgers - with several sections having a "make your own" option. I decided to go with a sandwich - specifically, the chicken pesto was speaking to me. This was grilled chicken with mozz, pesto sauce, and roasted red peppers on a roll. The sandwich was good - flavorful with all the components marrying well together. The bread was also soft enough that it broke through my bites; I was concerned being a hard roll that it would be too tough, but the consistency was perfect. I opted for tots instead of fries on the side which were good as well. Service was good - our server was friendly and food came out at a good pace. Overall, I was pleasantly surprised with the Barefoot Peddler. The food was tasty, and I wouldn't hesitate to return if I'm in the area again. read more

See all

This pub has great food and is a lot of fun! We went with a group of 8 before going to an event at the Tilles center. We sat at a round table near the bar, which gave us a little privacy and allowed us to be a little loud which no one seemed to mind since everyone at this restaurant was having a great time. The bar was packed and the energy was awesome. We all loved our food and the service. I can't remember our servers' name, but she was amazing! We never had to wait for anything and she was also a lot of fun. This is a great place to go if you want a fun, relaxed place with great food. The bartender is also awesome. He's funny, attentive and you can tell he really enjoys hanging out with the people he is serving. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

I've eaten here a handful of times when I've been in the area. The food is consistently good. The atmosphere is fun and jovial- perfect for a pub setting. I love the memes posted throughout the establishment. They are great for a chuckle and create a friendly vibe. My recent experience was mostly good with the exception of a particularly long wait for our order. It was early afternoon on a weekday so I'm not really sure what happened. Also , why isn't the seal removed from the ketchup bottle before it's placed on the table? (See photos). All in all I do recommend. read more

Barefoot Peddler - So that's why the ketchup wasn't coming out - American Near Me - Greenvale, New York

See all

I must have driven past The Barefoot Peddler at least 100 times and have never been here. Shame on me. What a great night. Just 10 minutes from my home and a really easy drive. It was busy and parking was a bit of a challenge but having a small car always helps. We walked into a very comfortable bar / restaurant. It ws the perfect place to meet up with some friends and catch up. After relaxing for a bit, watching the game and having a few drinks we decided on some dinner. Appetizer: Wings - These were great and prepared exactly how I like them. Nice size crispy wings with the perfect amount of a mild buffalo sauce. Dinner for me and friends: Chicken Pot Pie - This was amazing. I have not had a Chicken Pot Pie in a restaurant for years and this was perfect. Plenty of delicious chicken in a wonderful tasty-savory cream sauce with plenty of vegetables and potatoes. The flaky toping was perfect. Fried Shrimp - A healthy serving of crisp tasty fried shrimp Grilled Chicken - My wife truly enjoyed the sandwich and I truly enjoyed the second half for lunch the next day. I am still not sure how I had never been here but it looks like I will be returning soon. KUDOs to the team at Barefoot Pedler. read more

See all

The food is very good. Good bar atmosphere. The menu is very diverse and the steak is fantastic and had some great sides. I would highly recommend for a casual night out. Service was very efficient read more

We ate here for the first time prior to going to a show at The Tilles Center. The atmosphere was great, especially the funny quotes that are posted throughout the establishment. The food was awesome! We had the crab cakes and the chopped steak (one of the best I've ever had). We also had the bread pudding for desert. It was delicious. Our only issue is that the side salad was priced a bit high ($8.50), otherwise everything else was priced fair. If we are in the area again, we will definitely return. read more

See all

I love their burgers and cookie skillets! The quality of the food is always great. The older male waiter is always great when he takes care of us but the younger waiters don't check in as often and sometimes I need a refill or I wait for a while just to tell them I'm ready for the check. If you want good food stop by! Just keep in mind the service can be a bit slow so maybe order two drinks ahead of time lol! read more

Best pub around. My two personal favorites are shepherds pie and chicken pot pie. I've always been partial to a place in lynbrook for chicken pot pie but I think barefoot peddler is better. Worth the drive. read more

the food is good but some of the servers and bar tenders are disrespectful and rude. they are visibly irritated when you order stuff and roll their eyes. very odd. read more

Totally the best restaurant ! Great food and drinks . Affable staff and owners . Kyle was on target taking care of our group. Right near Tiles Center when you see a show . A+++. Definitely add this to your go to places. read more

We absolutely love this place and will definitely be regulars from now on! We started our evening with a drink at the bar, where Tommy welcomed us with such warmth and friendliness--it truly set the tone for the night. Once seated, we kicked things off with what has to be one of the biggest pretzels we've ever seen, served with a deliciously creamy cheese sauce--an instant favorite! For our entrées, we ordered the steak fajitas and the sliced steak dish. Both were outstanding--the steak was incredibly tender and flavorful, and the fajitas were hands-down some of the best we've ever had. Highly recommend this spot--you won't be disappointed read more

I used to go here all the time--about 15 years ago! It was fun, sitting in the seats that looked like barrels, etc. The food was always okay--never bad, but never great. I recently went to the bar to hang out on a Friday night. The bar scene was lively, and quite a few people ate in the dining area. I ordered wings and other stuff from the bar with many people in our party. I should have stuck with the drinks because the food wasn't good at all. It was greasy and not fresh, yet the prices were pretty high. I probably wouldn't go back anytime soon. The parking lot alone is enough to make me NOT want to return. It is a NIGHTMARE, with only about 10 spots available. So you have to park around the corner somewhere or across Glen Cove Rd and play chicken trying to cross all the lanes! Not my favorite thing to do after a few beers! read more

food was horrible, super greasy and tasted like they haven't changed the oil in the fryer forever service was poor and had to ask the bus girl for more icetea and soda. The charge 3.75 per glass and no refills, this is outrageous !!!!! Do yourself a favor and eat somewhere else. read more

The first bartender we had, Tom was excellent. He introduced himself, was friendly and attentive, but at the shift change there were two bartenders who could not have been less attentive and one had to be loudly flagged down and then had a a sour countenance when we finally got their attention. For only 7 people at the bar and 2 bartenders to cover them it was pathetic. Sure bartenders can chat and visit with friends but they also have to check the whole bar and others besides whom they are speaking to. The food was a mixed bag; the fried chicken sandwich was very good, but the mussels were extremely salty and 4 of 20 were dead (who wants to gamble with bad seafood) when they were cooked so therefore inedible. We had to chase down some salt and pepper after our food arrived and were never checked on. Having worked in the industry I would recommended retraining the night bar staff. The bar was NOT busy but they were dreadful at checking on anyone but who they knew or were talking to. I normally tip at least 20% and we left 15% as it was so disappointing to have such poorly trained staff. They were either utterly disinterested or annoyed that we had inconvenienced them by being there. Having worked in bars for years when I was younger it was a disappointing experience and with prices being so high these days, you should get you something for it other than resentment for spending $100. Not a good way for the owner to keep their doors open. One of the three times we looked around to try and get service we noticed other patrons with empty glasses or not having been served. Granted, everyone has off days and maybe that was the case but then the other bartender should have picked up the slack, but neither seemed interested. I doubt I would ever go back and if I did only before 6. Money is too hard to come by for most of us to experience bad food and poor service when we finally do get to go out and treat ourselves. Oh and while clean looking, the women's room smelled like piss. Not a great addition to one's dining experience. read more

We have been to barefoot several times. But the last 2 times were not good. I had fish and chips. The fish was frozen and stale. Sent back and the same came back out. Several other dishes were also not to fresh. They should look at the quality of the food the serve. Not going back read more

We are here now. Worst service we have had in years. Spend half the time with empty glasses. Waiter is terrible read more

I did like going there until I had an unpleasant interaction with the owner. By mistake was given an appetizer that we did not order, told the waitress we did not order it as she was putting it on our table. Waitress said don't worry about it and left it. We started eating it. Then an older gentleman came to the table, took the appetizer away saying wrong order. I figured it was the guy that actually ordered the appetizer. We then asked our server who was that guy and the server says that's the owner. Server mentioned to the owner that we were asking about him so he came back to our table. We told him we started eating it and would have paid for it. He said he "threw it out". It was the strangest experience l've had at a restaurant. Missed opportunity for the owner to show some customer appreciation. read more

Went for a quick bite with friends after getting hair done and place was empty. Food was amazing. However it took quite sometime to serve it. Not sure if it's because my girlfriends ordered a sweet potato. My girlfriends both agreed they could not believe how amazing the salmon was!!! read more

Barefoot Peddler - Salmon. Really good My besties loved it - American Near Me - Greenvale, New York

See all

Amazing food, amazing atmosphere, amazing service! I got the South West Burger, it had the perfect ratio of onion rings, barbecue sauce, burger, and bacon. Well done to the chef! Our waiter was very kind too. The pub had a nice ambiance with decorations for the holidays. Would definitely come back here again! 10/10 recommend. read more

Barefoot Peddler - South West Burger - American Near Me - Greenvale, New York

Dying breed of pubs, Tommy is a great bartender, amazing Guinness, great atmosphere. Only critique is small glasses for the Guinness.

I've been coming to Barefoot on and off for the last 5 years and this place never disappoints! If you're sitting down for a pint to watch the game or sitting down for a meal with your family - this place has it all! The bar is pretty typical...lots of TVs and random bar games. Great local and craft beer selection. Staff is always very friendly and accommodating. The food is awesome here! Buffalo chicken pizza, wings, sliders, fried pickles and the burgers are some of my favorites. Any burger you pick here is prepared perfectly - I've tried a few of their burgers and have never been let down. It's a notch above regular bar food. For dessert, you MUST try the cookie. It's a chocolate chip cookie in a skillet with ice cream on top. DO NOT LEAVE HERE WITHOUT TRYING THIS!! Will be visiting Barefoot for many years to come! read more

See all

Two women out for food and drinks. Watched as multiple men were served first, both at tables and at the understaffed bar. No water, one menu, vanishing table service. First order of nachos liter last burnt black from being under the salamander, but then allowed to cool. This was delivered to the table with no drinks, no table settings. My wife had to go to the bar to re-order the drinks while we waited for nachos 2.0 Turns out we should have just refused them anemic cheese, canned chili taste, oddly sweet tomato... Sauce? With jarred salsa. Nothing fresh, no onions, cilantro, not even a single jalapeno slice. Drinks were fine once we got them But never again. read more

We came as a large group of four families after our collective daughter's gymnastics practice was over on a late Sunday morning. We arrived just as the Peddler was opening so sitting was not an issue. We joined a couple of tables together for the adults and the children sat in a large booth just next to us. A good space for the a larger group of friends to hang out and get a meal and a drink. We adults asked four a spicy Bloody Mary and received exactly that. In some places, the mix is not so good, but here it was delicious. We had all sorts of things from the menu and not one was bad. Favorites were both the pretzel and the inside-out burger. I also really enjoyed the French Onion soup. Parking was a snap with the lot adjacent and we had no problem navigating that. Overall, we had a great time, the food was good and our server was a trooper with all of the various foods we ordered and the way he took care of our children so well. read more

This place has been at their location for over 20 yrs. it seems. The food was always pretty good and then some for a Pub. It must be 15 years since I had been there, so yesterday we visited and found nothing had changed the decor was all the same, old but Pubby. We both ordered the Bison Burger and they were fantastic, a side of Onion Rings matched in taste everything was served in an appetizing fashion. Brian our waiter was personable, knowledgeable and very pleasant. Many years ago my Company had offices less than a mile away so we were regular customers and once a month when the Salesmen came for meetings than always preferred the Barefoot to most others in the area. It looks like I rediscovered an old favorite. read more

Never been to an establishment where the place takes it customers for granted more than this place. Being the only bar in town allows them to have average food and awful service. Food for most of the table eventually came out after 45 minutes. For fast food type cuisine, not sure what took so long in the kitchen. And then took 20 extra minutes for 2 of the dishes to finally make its way to the table. Owner refused to apologize (server told us he was "figuring it out" - not sure what that means - it's not rocket science to make the food and then serve the food) and owner argued with us when we asked to remove one of the items that we didn't touch given the wait and we were ready to head home. Told us that we didn't eat the dish since we "were too busy picking on other stuff". Well maybe if food came on time, person would have eaten it rather than picking on everyone else's food. When people go to a restaurant together the novel concept of eating together (or at approximately the same time) should try and be respected as best as possible. When we told the owner it was 20 minutes after the rest of the food - we were told it was "only 15 minutes". Owner could have just apologized and acknowledged that the waiter botched the order and forgot to put in the 2 dishes. Incredible that this place has lasted this long but when you are the only game in town, I guess you can treat people like crap and get away with it. I am going to "figure out" another place to go next time. Won't be going back there and wouldn't recommend it to others. read more

Driven past a 100x and really wanted to experience running "barefoot". Nice lunch crowd and extensive menu for that time of day. There is seating on the non-bar side that looks like you are in a giant Barrel. Too funny. Attentive server and reasonably priced lunch menu. One to satisfy all tastes and palates. Chicken street tacos were the call of the day and didn't disappoint. Would definitely come back to broaden our horizons and experience. Job well done. read more

Barefoot Peddler - To start with... - American Near Me - Greenvale, New York

See all

Absolutely love the food, drinks and company here! I stopped in for lunch had the pretzel, quesadilla and chicken sandwich. All amazing! For sure coming back! Shout out to Tom for being the best and answering all our questions! read more

Barefoot Peddler - Bavarian Pretzel - American Near Me - Greenvale, New York

This five is for Ed, not the bar. Ed is always one of the best! I recently left a poor review. When I went back and read it after the owner's response, I realized it sounded like it was Ed I was upset with. It was not! Ed is the only reason we would ever go back! read more

Food is great Service is great. Family owned an operated restaurant. The only local sports bar in the area

Fantastic! Great food and service highly recommend! Loved the fried chicken sandwich and the salmon

This place is a complete dump the food is all mediocre not fresh and the attitudes are the worst , coldest , rudest people who don't need customers !!!!!!!!!!!! The ambiance is loud screaming kids it is basically a dive bar with cheap food. On a Friday with almost completely empty its understandable that the food is garbage. read more

Barefoot Peddler - a view of a bar - American Near Me - Greenvale, New York

It was my second time at the Barefoot Peddler. My first trip was pretty bad. We sat in the restaurant section and paid way too much money for mediocre-tasting fancy bar food. My second trip was a whole lot better! My friends and I had come from taking our state ethics exam and figured we'd blow off some steam at one of the few bars open at 1130 AM. Our bartender was great. He checked in on us frequently without hovering, seeming to understand that our group was pretty self sufficient. Our waters were constantly refilled and he promptly refilled drinks when asked. We ordered cheese fries, mozzarella sticks, and fried pickles. I've never been a fried pickle fan but my friends liked them so I guess that's a good sign. They came with this nice orange sauce that cut the pickley taste. The fries and mozzarella sticks were delicious - bar food at its finest. Ordering at the bar also gave each food order a discount which was greatly appreciated. Our bartender took our group pic upon request, we paid, and were out the door around 130. Our 2 hours of fun cost 52 dollars for several drinks and the appetizers, so not a bad deal at all. The bar had several TVs playing various sports if you're into that sort of thing. Averaging out my two visits, the barefoot peddler is a fun bar (keep your shoes on tho!) but not a good restaurant. read more

Cool pub. Good wings. Crispy. Tasty. Covid safe. Socially distanced with partitions. Hand sanitizer available. Five stars for the bartender Tommy! read more

See all

Before there was Applebee's, before TGI Fridays there was the barefoot peddler. THIS OLD DINOSAUR ROARS ON ! Serving up great food, in a great atmosphere, with great service, and an great bar scene. No flair here boys and girls. You will find great and constantly updated American traditional good at a good price. This place has been around when my baby boomer parents used to go to nearby CW post. It's apparently still just as popular and has lost none of its character. The menu is always fresh, and evolving. The place is always clean and fun. You can sit in a booth shaped like a barrel for gods sake. Come on. Actually I have to admit, I often just go here bc I want to talk to someone privately, and calm down in one of these barrels with an alcoholic beverage. This place has all sorts of different specials on different days so it's worth it to give it a try sometime, even in the middle of the week. Also if your single it's one of the only options in town ; ) read more

See all

Good service, food & drinks Corn flake chicken sandwich was great. Add more margaritas!

This place is great for happy hour. Love coming here after work with my co workers before the weekend starts. Tommy is awesome and very attentive. Food is good and they have a happy hour food menu and $1 off drinks from 4-7 on weekdays. Very Covid friendly with dividers between each party and wiping down after use. read more

Barefoot Peddler - Bar - American Near Me - Greenvale, New York

I wasn't sure what to expect when I went in but my friend and I loved it! We went in on a Sunday for lunch and the game The bartender Meredith was awesome. She was charming and attentive We ordered the fried chicken sandwich and the wings were fire. They were awesome! The beer on tap has dedicated lines and the Yingling is great. Highly recommend! read more

The BEST service! The burgers,pretzels, quesadillas everything is so good! Tom at the bar is Amazing! Staff and Management the BEST on Long Island read more

Barefoot Peddler - American Near Me - Greenvale, New York

Worst place i've ever been to in my life lmaoo. waiter started off by telling us that if we misbehave that we'll get kicked out. that's the first words i heard from the bartender. after that, the bartender claims to have heard me say that my id is "real". what that meant, from me as a californian, was that my id was an official california state law real id. which meant the id could be used to travel. the bartender stated that "he heard me calling the id real, and he knows my type" . My id is a california real id, which is sanctioned in the nation and also used in the state to fly cross country? Sorry that the waiter was an idiot? but the fact that he wouldn't even look at my id? no need to show up to a rude ass establishment like that. save your time and save yourself from the bartender with glasses lol. he clearly doesn't know any ids besides new york ids. ps. to any workers who doubt this, please message me. i'll send a pic of my id to prove how much of idiots y'all are; the waiter didn't even bother looking at my id before he called it fake and dumb. read more

Explained to the owner that my fiancé and I had too much to drink and asked her if we could leave our car and take an Uber. She told me that we couldn't because she needed the parking spot. Absolutely unprofessional and negligent for a bar to act this way. read more