First time visit. Excellent ice cream. Top quality. Will be a definite return for us. Keep up the…read moregreatness.

Hartzler does its job well. If you want good ice cream and milk, you're going to get good ice cream…read moreand milk. With a strong selection of flavors in both categories, you're bound to be satisfied. Tip: Don't be afraid to try the discounted milk. Though it's closer to expiration, you could not tell via smell or taste. You can get great value if you're looking to sample different flavors (ex: chocolate, strawberry) or if you're feeding a family of thirsty lactose tolerants

Was down getting fence for my cattle pastures and wanted a milk shake. Found this place on yelp of…read morecourse. Really good chocolate milk shake and my wife had a Sunday. Service was quick and friendly. If you are in the Wooster area give the place a try.

Great place to pick up a quick dessert. The staff was helpful and friendly when we ordered. Liked…read morethe taste of the ice cream. Ordered a flurry and the ice cream to cookie dough ratio was great. I could taste both the ice cream and cookie dough. My friend ate a small chocolate hand dipped ice cream and said it was yummy.

This is basically your run-of-the-mill froyo joint. I really dig their name's wordplay though! Lots…read moreof Ohio pride there and makes it unique. For what I know in the froyo world they have about all the same stuff as you can get at most others. There are 12 different flavors of frozen yogurt and there must be at least 50 different toppings. I thought it was impressive they had so many different flavors of popping boba. And yet they didn't have my favorite - strawberry - at the time I came in. The prices are also what you'd expect. Be careful, that cup fills up quick and you'll end up paying $5+ at the register. It's usually run by a couple of high school kids. This actually sounds like a good idea for a small business in terms of cost to payoff, the more I think about it. Seating is minimal and there's outdoor seating for those warmer days. Worth a try if you have a hankerin' for froyo.

The food was very delicious and the employees were very efficient and nice to everyone. The…read morerestaurant was cute and spacious as well.

Review applies to pizza only…read more I really wanted to like this place and read every single review on here. Counter to one review, I did not find the pizza too salty. It was cooked to perfection and adequately topped with all the items I ordered, except for one: SAUCE. Every piece had about a teaspoon of sauce, leaving the pizza essentially flavorless. It wasn't BAD per se, but every bite left something to be desired. If you're still curious, get extra sauce and it might save the pizza. But in all honesty, the "Hunt Brothers" pizza by the slice that you can find at many nearby gas stations is significantly better than this.

My wife and I stopped at this odd little building out in the middle of nowhere, because at the last…read moremoment she saw a small yard sign that said "Ice Cream". So we pulled off and found ourselves on a weedy gravel driveway in front of an old English cottage looking house. We went inside and found ourselves in a cramped entryway with signs, trinkets, and just stuff. Directly ahead of us was a freezer with the "Homemade" ice cream logo, and on the right at a 90 degree angle was another ice cream case with a small square counter between them to place finished pies. It was very difficult to find room to place an order or even take picture, but his small company must do a tremendous amount of business considering the amount of pizza they sold while we waited to order, it was nonstop! My wife got two hard scoops and I an apple pie soft serve. Both were served in large white Styrofoam cups and the cost $5 each. This may sound like a lot for a cup of ice cream but it's actually a bargain considering a "large" is nearly a quart! We did not sit on their patio, but in our car. The respite was delicious! If you are out tooling around and feel the urge for some great ice cream, (can't speak for the pizza) be sure to make Lionsgate your next destination.

Always nice to go to Orr Creamery!…read more They have good ice cream, good food, and a welcoming staff and environment. Their buffet have lots of board games available to play, and outdoor seating as well. A great place to stop in for an easy dinner that's a lot like fast food, but better tasting and better quality. Also a favorite local ice cream spot

It was overall really a clean restaurant. Came here for the first time two days ago. I didn't know…read morewhat to expect. The person at the front was super helpful. I ended up getting a chicken panini and s'mores custard. Only thing I would say the s'mores custard was okay. Wasn't a fan but I should have gotten something different. The panini was bomb and I ate it all. They also had games for people to play and hang out. My brothers and I played sorry and hung out for awhile. I would recommend to anyone in orrville or going through orrville

Definitely a place to keep going to...Wonderful food, ice cream and service. You will experience…read moreice cream like you've probably never had before...The presentation is spot on as are the many flavors....Our favorite, their banana splits!!!

Awesome ice cream place. It's really nice inside and also has outdoor seating…read more It's a good value for your money It's ran by Amish so it's closed on Sunday. We needed other choices

I have been here a few times and have loved my food every time. Customer service is always…read morewonderful and the food is fresh and perfect. I love the portion sizes that aren't overwhelming-they're just right. I have enjoyed the cheese platter, the hummus plate, the chicken Marsala and the jambalaya. The desserts are lovely as well!

I want to start with our server, Natalie, was fantastic. Very sweet and attentive. The food is just…read morelacking. We started with the Pot Stickers. They were so tiny for $16. Hardly any filling. I got the Oriental Almond Chicken. It was very bland. The "sauce" was very soupy. Veggies were overcooked. And there were like three soggy almonds in the dish. Also a pretty small portion for the price. My fiancé got the Louisiana Shrimp Pasta. Again, small portions for the price. Shrimp was not great quality and way over cooked. The "sauce" was so runny with no flavor. Finally we hoped for redemption with dessert but were disappointed again. Bananas Foster is such a classic that shouldn't be hard to get right. Mushy bananas, cold and dry chocolate torte just did not mix well.

I understand they're busy.. especially on a Saturday night. But we ordered a small chocolate cone…read moredipped in the mint. They went to hand us a vanilla dipped in mint. I don't like their vanilla so we kindly ask for chocolate. This guy comes back with a vanilla cone dipped in chocolate. Face palm. We correct again and get the same one dipped in mint after being dipped in chocolate. We said it was okay bc we didn't realize it was vanilla ice cream. Usually I would think it's a funny mistake but i just really wanted the Chocolate ice cream. Almost cried

I ventured out for Turtle Pecan Blizzard, as I have done before--too many times to accurately…read morecount. I eventually pull up to the drive through window. As soon as this teenager picks my Blizzard up off the counter, I could see through the window that it was 'runny'. And she could see it too, because she didn't turn it upside down. I say "Hang on, that doesn't look right" She stands there looking at it. I ask her if she can turn it upside down, and she says "The ingredients,the pecans, make it more runny" Seriously? She then carries it to the sink and pours some off the top, (so now there's.....less of it?) then comes back and holds it out the window to me. I said "it's now dripping all down the sides of the cup" She's just standing there looking at the cup like an idiot. I say, "Can I at least get a couple napkins because that's going to make a big mess in my car" She wraps it in napkins and hands it to me. Ugh! I give up and take it home to firm up in my freezer for an hour. I'm a lifelong resident of Wooster and been going to this location since I was a kid. The crew at this newest build has sunk customer service to a new low.

Wow. The new owners have done an amazing job. The food is awesome and the Ice cream is amazing…read more Keep up the great work.

Stopped here to get something to eat for my kids. After a couple of bites of her sandwich, my…read moredaughter asked if it was supposed to look like this. As you can see in the picture, the chicken sandwich was not at all cooked. My daughter is now sick and we had to leave a special family occasion early, as she was experiencing symptoms of food poisoning. To make matters worse, I was not the only person who had come back to show them a raw chicken sandwich. Another gentleman was also bringing back his grandson's uncooked sandwich. Suffice it to say, I will never eat here again.