Great food and family owned. Pizza with white sauce is awesome! Most all of the pasta is great as well. Hidden gem for sure, gotta love the small town feel read more

What the absolute f***. I just saw a rat and a snake have intimacy on my pizza the service was awful too. A little Asian boy came and dropped my pizza licked the mess off and handed 3 slices to me. The ambiance was awful too. Flies were everywhere and rats were having say hex in the corner. I hate all these fake restaurants read more

Atmosphere is cozy and service friendly. Food is mediocre. Nothing special. I had spaghetti and meat sauce. Soft white bread was warm but nothing special. I'd prefer chunks of crispy bread. Small salad was large but just iceberg lettuce a couple of cherry tomatoes and a sprinkle of shredded cabbage and carrots. Lot of cheese. read more

We had breadsticks, served with meat sauce for dipping, salad, pizza, red velvet cake and cannoli. Everything was very good. We got 2 red velvet cakes (cupcakes) to go. The prices were very reasonable. I'd recommend stopping if you are nearby. read more

We decided to try Bella Trattoria on a friend's recommendation. We had big expectations and they met our expectations and then some. We tried the Italian beef pizza and it was delicious! We also tried the butter, oil and herbs penne and that was great too! The chicken and broccoli fettuccini Alfredo was really good as well. We topped off our meal with Cannolis and Tiramusu, which were also very good. The meals were huge portions, the deserts were small in comparison. We were very pleased with what we ordered and will be back to try some of the other things on the menu that looked tempting. read more

This was my first time here, we were celebrating a large family birthday dinner. It was delicious! The owner and bartender worked well together to make sure we had drinks and food promptly. Pizzas, pastas and salads were all wonderful! We will be coming back! read more

As travelers we stopped here heading back from Chicago. This place is fabulous for many reasons, it's a cute historic downtown, the service is top notch, and people couldn't be nicer. Doubles as a bar to watch sports. It's a place where locals hang out and get takeout. The problem is the food and that's a big problem. The pizza is terrible, the sauce has no flavor and the cheese I don't even know what it was, the crust is like bisquick -they did have fresh mushrooms and the sausage was pretty good for toppings. Italian beef what a disaster, I don't know what that flavor was but even with the a jus and peppers it couldn't be recovered. Antipasto salad had lots of olives that's a plus but it was that low budget lettuce with the cabbage and carrots and there were some brown spots too. 2 pieces of salami and 2 provel slices cheese. The Italian dressing was okay. Overall just get a slice of pizza at Casey's because we left hungry. read more

Food and service are great! Love it here. Always try to stop in when in the area. Pizza is exceptional.

GREAT PIZZA. Wonderful thin, crispy crust,plenty of cheese and good tasting Italian sausage. A side salad big enough to feed two. Fast, friendly service. Best pizza I have had since I left Chicago. read more

I have always liked the food and the atmosphere here but if you are trying to stay safe from COVID, this is not the place to go. Went here for dinner tonight and absolutely no one working there was wearing a mask. The waitress had a mask on but under her chin when we first arrived but after that she just removed the mask. Probably won't go back read more

Love the small town feel of this place, cute restaurant for a date or just a Saturday night pizza outing. Food is very good, pizzas are great. Only complaint: the salad needs some serious love. :-( Iceberg, one tomato, some shredded cheese. Amp up the salad and this place is perfect read more

I am local, grew up in Williamsville and have been eating here for years. It's family owned and ran and it has absolutely fantastic food. Great talkative people, the only thing I will say, it's hard to eat there on a college budget, but I sure do when I can. read more

My family and I ate at this establishment tonight and all I can say is wow and not in a good way. We were the only people in the restaurant. The son of the guy working, looked to be 9 or 10 years old, served us. At first I thought it was cute. That he was just helping his dad until I watched him not only bring us our menus but take our drink order, which he got wrong, and bring us our food. I also watched him run in and out of the kitchen to get to go orders all while his father played on the slot machines. The only thing the regular server did was take our actual food order and bring us the check. Needless to say he got a piece of my mind when he brought me the check. This is the 3rd time I've been to this establishment and the first 2 times I was not impressed with the service and that was from the owner! He acted like I should be thanking him for allowing me to eat at his establishment instead of the other way around. The only positive thing I will say is the pizza is good but I will NEVER eat at this restaurant again! read more

Poor service- food ok, TV blaring Big Bang Theory- salad lettuce only w/ 1 cherry tomato. Quaint town. Friday night at 6p no reservation needed place was half empty read more

Great for takeout pizza! Super cute historic pizzeria in the downtown of cute Williamsville. Friendly people. I agree with the other review that when we got a side salad there last year it was pathetic. Definitely needs work. But we love getting cheese pizza for takeout. Good sauce, sweet and spicy. read more

Great family owned place! Welcoming and warm environment! The Cassons' are fantastic! Best Alfredo sauce I've ever had!

We found this nice small town quiet place to eat on our way to Kansas City, MO. The food was great and so was the service!

Stopped on our way to Chicago during a snow blizzard. Felt we found a hidden gem. Great service and great pizza. Will go again next trip between St.Louis and Chicago. A family owned place, not just another chain. read more

My husband and I had dinner @ Bella this evening based upon a recommendation from a friend. We ordered mixed green salads and a veggie pizza with ham. The "mixed green" salads were predominately iceberg lettuce containing multiple pieces of the core, wilted, and appeared to be past the expiration date. Neither of us finished the salads and voiced our concerns to the waitress. She apologized however offered no solution. Our first inclination was to pay for the salads and beer, cut our losses and leave however the pizza came highly recommended so we decided to stay. The pizza didn't disappoint but honestly it wasn't anything unusual or special. The toppings were well balanced and flavorful however the crust did not appear to be home made. The fact that the restaurant was barely half full @ prime time on a Saturday night should have been a clue. I'm disappointed the restaurant chose to ignore our concerns and because of this we won't be back. read more