Very pleased with my visit today. Ben methodically reviewed all the coins I had and provided what I…read morefeel is a fair price. I felt very comfortable dealing with him. I recommend this place if you're selling (buying, too -- they carry a large selection of coins). If you listen to their phone message (aka phone tree), you'll learn that Tuesdays and Thursdays generally are better days to visit if you're selling coins.

Milwaukee coin in Brookfield could be a fun stop like the joke shop in Waukesha their purchasing…read moremethodology more closely resembles a small dank and desperate pawn shop like atmosphere than a serious purveyor of fine metals. Seems a quaint dysfunctional family owned operation that is willing to buy low sell high their methodology is absent any realistic expectation of equity and or fairness as established by authentic and time tested market values. Leading one to be suspect not only of their wares but their orgnizational integrity. If the plasma centers are closed and pawn shops scarse you need "fast" money then by all means this mom & pop will likely struggle to meet your needs however the serious buyer with a GED or better will travel a few extra miles to get much closer to actual value elsewhere..

Definitely see them. Before selling or buying anywhere else. Super knowledgeable, very friendly and…read morepatient.

This place met my expectations. I am an avid coin collector I had coins I wanted to sell. This…read morereview is after visiting this business two times in two days. Each time I was immediately greeted when I walked in. Keith, the owner, looked through my coins and made offers for the ones he was interested in, and gave concise reasons for not making offers on the others. Very trustworthy transaction. Store has no sign out front, but there is an illuminated OPEN sign in the front window. The inside is well worn...erhaps a bit gritty. But there are multiple display cabinets with interesting coins, jewelry and other interesting artifacts, if you are a buyer. The prices were fair and acceptable. I will continue to do business with them.

Didn't want to sell gold chain d cross gave good price so sold for 609$ helped with a billread more

If you are trying to get what's the worth of your jewelries. Avoid this place! I have never felt so…read moreinsulted someone trying to be smart about ripping people off! If you are damn and stupid then this is the location for you or just donate your stuffs in a goodwill than giving to these people. GIA certified diamond for $20 WTF!!!! Who gives these people a permit to operate a business like this! Asking my capabilities of knowledge in a very unprofessional and very insulting way! F.O!! Now because the fool can't fool the acting like a fool this guy is getting deeper of trying ripping me off! On their website stating the reason I came and check that they are buying gold and diamonds was now telling me that he will only buy the value of the gold of my ring and not the 61 pieces of natural diamonds with it and with appraisal paper that described every single details about the item. 18k gold for 73/gram? Does this people have internet connection. MF it's 2026 already! Check the market price!! The way I said everything here unprofessionally that's how that guy talked to me! So if you have a stolen jewelries this is the best place for you because I don't think so this location is following the 30 days hold that required by law with their purchases and sold them 10 times of what they paid for. Not mine! I just can't imagine those people who buy their memorable jewelries from this store!

Excellent service! Knowledgeable and professional staff. I will definitely be back. Amazing prices.read more

I went in there the other day to sell a roll of silver quarters. According to the Internet price of…read moresilver, they were worth $4.10 each. I walked in, showed them the coins, they checked on a computer and offered me $3.75 each. Done! $4.10 is the most they could get for them - it's a business that must make a profit. $3.75 was very fair. The whole process took about five minutes. The store is clean is well organized.

I love Kesslers, for example the one by South ridge is great and has great customer service. Always…read moresmiling, excited with me throughout the process offers drinks, makes me feel special. The one in Germantown has consistently been awful. Miranda has always been kind and helpful however everyone else I encounter always makes me feel unwelcome and uncomfortable. I have been there 3-4 times in the past few months and made purchases every time and have always felt unwelcome and not like a special experience at all(Miranda was always good). They never offered drinks when we would arrive, would hardly smile, seemed annoyed to assist us. We would always be happy as we were buying for special reasons and special people and never walked away like we were happily served, welcomed or taken care of. I wondered if I should review but after consistently feeling like an annoyance I had to make a review. I wish this wasnt the location I am closest to. I definitely would not want to buy a wedding ring here as I dont think it would be a fun experience at all at this location

Can't say enough nice things about Kesslers and the wonderful people that work there. I recently…read moregot engaged and my fiancé and I went ring shopping together. Mitzi helped me pick out my diamonds and design my own ring. She is a truly warm and sincere person. We made numerous visits to the store before we actually purchased. Mitzi was very patient and didn't push us at all. It really was a great experience. Even after I got my beautiful ring, I went back in because it was slightly too big and they had a table setup with glasses and a free bottle of champagne! So thoughtful!

Yes. Knowledgable and reasonably priced. Don't be thrown by the stores' dilapidated state…read more Eccentric owner, Jim is honest and knowledge. Brad, the son learned it all from Dad.

We received a quote from another jeweler of $150 to resize a ring. However, Barnes came in at less…read morethe $50, and he had it done the same day. Kudos!

I called this shop about selling silver jewelry and they told me for pieces they actually like,…read morethey will pay over spot price for the piece. While not expecting something spectacular, the employee weighs it, and it came in at just under 1 full ounce of silver. Spot price is 85$ as of writing this, and the old man has the nerve to look me and say "I'll give you 25 dollars for this, the rest I don't want. Every word out of his mouth dismissive, and condescending. If you know what's good for you, avoid this shop and its owner for any and all reasons.

Went in to get a few sets appraised. 3 employees in the store, no other customers. No one greeted…read moreme, almost felt like I was bothering them. I don't know much about coins but I went to a different coin shop (in cedarburg, who I recommend!) and that store gave me their appraisal which was $413.00. Shorewood coins offered MUCH less at $350. And Shorewood coins miscalculated one of my pieces and offered much less, till he asked another coworker. I would bring my business to the coin shop in Cedarburg, the owner is fair and honest. Would not recommend this place.

Their customer service and speedy response is exceptional, and I will never shop anywhere else for…read moremy jewelry needs. Not to mention the benevolent quality and value of a selection that they have at this location. I highly recommend this place to anyone who wants to get an affordable, amazing looking piece of jewelry and have a great experience.

My family has been coming to Kesslers for as long as I can remember and I cannot name one bad…read moreexperience. Today my husband and I had a different kind of shopping experience that we were not looking forward to. We needed to replace my wedding set that was lost. We worked with Jessica and I felt so at ease and not rushed throughout the appointment. She listened to what I wanted and didn't and we found a perfect set to replace what I had lost. I will forever be thankful for that. The store specifically did not carry a few options I was interested in and had them brought in from sister stores that did, but also had a great selection themselves. She priced out all different diamonds for us and helped us choose the best stone for our budget. Overall just amazing experience.