First time visiting to Gyp's Tavern for lunch today. Christina was working the bar and gave us the…read morestory of Gyp and Babe Ruth, nice photo tribute on display in the back room. The food truck today was Smokin' Mo's BBQ which provided excellent chicken sandwich, pulled pork, both with sides of Mac n cheese, coleslaw and cornbread. Yes, we ate to our fill! Even had enought of mine to take home for later. Very nice to sit on the back patio looking over Kittatinny Lake, perfect!

I had this placed booked mark for some time now. Finally made my way here on a sunny afternoon this…read morepast summer. Once you enter, you can place your food/drink order at the bar. If you order food, they give you a buzzer so you can pickup your food from the takeout window outside. Outdoor dining is first come, first seated. Ended up taking seats with the water view. Ended up ordering wings ($14) which was crispy and tasty. For my main, got the bacon cheeseburger ($13.50) which comes with fries, was solid as well. The views and good food were such a nice vibe. I highly recommend this place if you are in the mood for chill vibes with good food and drinks for a fair price. * Cash only * Pool table * Parking on premise * Outdoor dining with nice scenery

great sound, people, and best for the outdoor fundraisers, events. Great vibe overall.read more

Great dive bar! It's pretty big with a nice large stage for bands. Plenty of tables for you to…read moresit at for when you want to see a band. The bar has a good variety of alcohol & is a great place to stop in for a drink. No idea if they serve food or not but definitely a great place to stop in for drinks or to see a great band!

The food and service were great, especially Ashley the bartender. She was on point with her…read moresuggestions. My only complaint was that it was too loud for my taste. Maybe due to low ceilings. I would go back earlier when there's less people.

Good roadside joint for cold beers , friendly people and relaxing . It's nothing fancy but gets the…read morejob done . They serve a food but I have yet to try it , it does look appetizing and have heard many great reviews

We have three months to complete the 2026 Tri-State Stamping Tour with American Legion Post 289 in…read moreWest Milford, NJ. 158 places across NJ, NY, and PA to visit to support the Veterans and those who support them and get our books stamped! This is stop 22/158. Very nice tavern. Darts here. Nice set up two boards. Great bar area. Large. Comfortable.

Stopped in today while doing the 2026 Tri-State Stamping Tour with American Legion Post 289 in…read moreWest Milford, NJ. 158 places across NJ, NY, and PA to support the Veterans and those who support them. This is stop 22 of 158. What a fun place!!! Dart boards but no time to play. We enjoyed chatting at the very large and clean bar area. Comfy and such nice folks. Our bartender was a delight. Definitely will find time to stop by again.

Nice little bar. Great prices. It has a comfortable atmosphere, where all can have a pleasant…read moreexperience.

Wow I wish I can give this hunk of junk a negative star. Wow second time I tried to go here sat…read moredown for over 5 min not even a hello. This place is a joke. Girls went outside to smoke instead of help me. What service is this. Someone fire the owner this guy has a joke or a place

A cool little dive bar. Alot of ex-military police and firefighters seem to go here. The bartender…read moreI had was nice. 2 tv's at the bar which seats at least 15 people. They take cash only but have an ATM in the building. There is a back room with a few dart boards and there were some tables set up that kinda looked like they were setting up for a buffet. Very old school vibe and nothing pretty. Standard beers on tap (Bud, Michelob, Coors, etc) and a fully stocked liquor section. The 4th star goes to the people. Friendly, funny, and the bartender, stephanie, was down to earth.

Amazing cash only bar. Please don't forget your cash or atm card. That's the only place you find…read moreamazing prices for drinks. The Only place that can charge low pricing for drinks only because they save on credit card fees. The atmosphere is grand and very low key. If you ever seen the show Cheers this is the place to go. Everyone is so friendly and you won't be let down! Players is the place to be!! First time ever being here and will be back again! Rated A++++ come stop by Joe here hope to see you here because I'll be here!

A quintessential dive bar of the best variety. Don't feel shy walking in; you'll be looked at, but…read morethen made to feel like family. Service is friendly and efficient. I forget our bartenders name but she's of the same essence as Stevie nicks. Frozen Feds pizzas are offered. Beer of all types. Pool games, great music & even better conversation--what's not to love ?

FARMINGDALE: Tom's Tavern is a great locals bar and dogs are allowed inside!…read more It is a small place with a full bar, small food menu with specials, a pool table, and friendly people. Don't be intimidated by any motorcycles parked outside. We thank somebody we met in our travels for telling us about this place. It has a great hometown vibe and inexpensive.

If you are looking for a bar and nothing but a bar, this is the place. You can chat with the…read morebartender or just sit and stare at your drink. The beer prices are the best I've seen and the bartender knows how to pour a Guinness.

One of the bartenders (i believe her name is britney) was extremely rude and offered minimal…read moreservice. It didn't help that she was taking shots with other customers all night while many people were waiting to be served. The other bartender Eddy was great, I quickly learned to stick to his section of the bar. The bathrooms and floors are absolutely disgusting and based off that I would not recommend getting and drink that requires a glass, stick to canned beverages. Besides that, the prices were cheap and the music was ok.

Great dive bar. Great burgers. Cold beer. Friendly service…read more Went there on the bike with couple guys. Very welcoming spot for bikers.

Great place. Old time charm. You have to look at the register when it was operating as a hotel…read more Some great old names!

I believed going into this place that it didn't seem highly rated for food, but seemed to be more…read moreof the location and aesthetic... I feel that I was pleasantly surprised. First off, this is truly indicative of Sussex County--off the beaten path, luscious, green... a dining experience that is elevated because of its location--if you are able to request a window seat, I would advise in doing that because we definitely enjoyed the beauty of the mountains and were entertained by the deer that came to graze right outside of where our table was located. I appreciate the history.. location.. service was quick and pleasant (Tina was our server). Food was decent enough.. we enjoyed the bread--though some parts seemed a little hard--and I recommend putting out salted vs non salted butter. Salad bar has a decent variety. My New England clam chowder was really good. My seafood platter with salmon, scallops, and shrimp was ok. The seafood was a little fishy for me. The cook said he tried his best to get my salmon to medium, but it was more well done. I appreciated that they informed me of their efforts. The shrimp were well done. We skipped dessert.. Would I return? It is super far from us at about an hour and forty minutes away, so because we weren't wowed by the food, it was nice to visit once.

Today is July 26, 2026 and we just had dinner at Walpack Inn and I gotta tell you the food was…read moreamazing. Tina was our service server and she was incredible the view the atmosphere and just all around Great experience. The Walpack Inn never disappoints and their food is just amazing