We are visiting from out of town and decided to come here for dinner. The food was amazing. The pizza is insane. So delicious and great amount of food for the price. My husband got pepperoni, and I got the Buffalo chicken. Wings were fire. I also enjoyed the fries off my kids plates. The service was kind and on top of things. Clean and cool environment. Locally owned. Definitely worth the stop! read more

Brickyard Dining Co - Buffalo chicken pizza and pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

Great pizza fresh ingredients the dough is perfection, the pizza cheese sticks were amazing, crispy, flavorful and the dipping sauce compliments the flavors. Service is okay and when the restaurant gets full you will wait for your food longer than usual, however it's worth the wait. read more

Brickyard Dining Co - Cheese sticks and fresh pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

See all

The great food at Brickyard redeems it from its downfalls. For an appetizer we ordered the loaded chips, which I cannot recommend enough! They come with the perfect amount of melted cheese and bacon, and there's plenty to go around for a group of 3-4. For my entree I ordered the Hawaiian Philly. As you can see from the photo it came fully loaded as well, but it wasn't too overbearing as some restaurants tend to do. If you love pineapple and cheese then this sandwich will hit the spot. As mentioned, everything else about the restaurant could be majorly improved. Every time I've gone to Brickyard I've had to wait a significant amount of time for my food to come, and this past weekend was no different. We waited around 30-40 minutes for our food as a party of four, with our appetizer taking around 20-30 minutes. And this is without it being too busy - we didn't have to wait for a table. Our server did come back frequently to refill drinks and check in. The restaurant was also extremely stuffy (and I am typically always cold!) So if I'm starting to sweat while sitting, especially in the middle of March, you know it's hot! All in all, if you're looking for good pizza or sandwiches, Brickyard is a great place to go. Just be prepared to get comfortable as you might be there for a while. read more

See all

We ordered delivery. The delivery time was faster than was predicted which was fine. The pizza had a lot of extra crust with no sauce/toppings. I think 2" of untopped crust all Around is far too much. It was fine but not mouthwatering. Ordered the Pickle yardsticks. I did not see any ranch spices sprinkled on top and instead of the spicy dipping sauce we were given ranch. Pretty bummed on that. We are not from the area do wont be returning ... if we were we might give them another shot but wouldnt be running to get in read more

See all

This is not the place to go to for pizza. We got the pepperoni pizza and the sauce is a salty sour taste. But the burgers are awesome and the fried pickle sticks were beyond amazing! The burgers and pickle sticks were so good I feel bad giving them a four but the pizza was terrible lol. So that tells u how good the burgers and pickle sticks were. They have a few beers on tap. The place is really nice inside. I will for sure go back often! No bar seating. read more

This is our go to when we can not decide what we want. Food is excellent with a medium sized menu but something for everyone. Staff was great. read more

Unfriendly service food isn't that great especially for the price ... The place is dirty... It smells of sewage. I haven't heard much good from past employers.. read more

The taco salad at the Brickyard is AMAZING! In fact, everything we ordered was delicious! Service was fast and friendly. Prices are very reasonable. We highly recommend! read more

Brickyard Dining Co - The taco salad at the Brickyard is AMAZING! - Pizza Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

Great Food and Service! The homemade chips are so good and their homemade ranch dressing is perfect

I went here tonight with my grandmother and right off the bat the service was incredible! The hostess went above and beyond to be kind and considerate to my grandmother and make sure she was comfortable. I ordered the Hawaiian Pizza. The wait time on the food was very short, no more than 15 minutes. The pizza looked phenomenal out of the oven, and tasted just as good as it looked! There was an explosion of flavor with each bite. Only complaints would be the prices being kind of high for the amount of food you get and I wish the menu had a bit more variety. Great experience! read more

Brickyard Dining Co - Hawaiian Barbecue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

Stopped here on our way through New Philly...we were 1 of 2 tables in the place. The service was quick and friendly. The food wasn't anything to write home about (or Yelp). I got the burger and my hubs a pizza. I need a little more seasoning in my life to enjoy the food at a 10. Beware if they turn the AC on you will feel like you are about to blow away. Iprobably won't be back anytime soon. read more

Came here with some friends and sat ourselves as there were no servers in sight. Once seated, they appeared and helped us move tables around, as we were a fairly large group. We started off with some drinks and shared the boneless sweet bbq wings. Let me tell you! They were tender, juicy, sweet glorious little wings. We ordered a few more of that to share because of how great they were! I had the steak salad, which should probably be named a burger salad. The shredded beef, topped with fries salad made me regret getting a boring dressing. I kind of wish I got thousand island or something you put on a burger because that's what I felt like I was eating! Minus the bread. Definitely a place to come hang with friends or even family! There are great menu items for the kids to choose from. And you'll definitely be satisfied. Try the boneless wings! read more

Atmosphere is OK. Got the house salad that cost $4.00 and it was only worth about $1.50. Got the 11 inch supreme pizza, had good potential if it would have had more sauce on it. We gave it 2 stars because the prices were way too high for the quality of the food. read more

Brickyard Dining Co - Pizza Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

Our family has enjoyed dinning here on several occasions. We have always enjoyed the food and the atmosphere. Food: From sandwiches to hamburgers, from pizza to dinner platters we have found the food to be fresh and portion to be appropriate. Atmosphere: The restaurant is warm, inviting, and relaxed. It is perfect for a dinner with the family, a night out with friends, or a relaxed lunch time business lunch. read more

Excellent service food and atmosphere great waitress Laynie. We went here for a girlfriends birthday dinner and it was perfect. read more

Brickyard Dining Co - So yummy gotta have more - Pizza Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

See all

The food was fine, but during our meal we overheard our waitress being screamed at in the back. (by the owner i'm assuming). He spoke to her in the most unprofessional way. So if you want eh food and poor management eat here! read more

Meh.... So much potential... This place was good but it could've been much better. First the positives... Nice place! Very warm feeling and the staff was super nice... Lots of choices on the menu. Needs improvement... Mac and Cheese Pork needs some attention. Great potential on the dish but with very little cheese sauce it leaves much to be desired. Burger was good but a little dry... S'mores skillet was off the chain amazing! We will return to try again and see if the pizzas will impress. read more

We went around 6:30pm on a Monday night and the place was practically empty, which was surprising because the restaurant looks nice - brand new with modern furniture. Because of this we got seated quickly and the service was very fast and efficient. I got the phila cheesesteak sandwich with french fries, and a side of mac and cheese, which were all good tasting at best. The french fries were good sized and tasty and they provide ketchup and vinegar to dress them with. A small portion of the steak on the sandwich had obviously missed the seasoning, and tasted like nothing. The macaroni noodles were big and tasted kind of smoky. I live a ways away and I don't think I would go back just for the food, but not a bad experience overall. read more

Don't come for the Pizza, try something else here. The sauce reminded me of Spaghetti-Os. Scant ingredients. Thin crust (fyi). Chicken Tenders very good. About 5 beers on tap. Service was sketchy, after 20+ mins I had to go find our waitress to place an order, they didn't check on us afterwords, brought the appetizer & sometime later tried to give us someone else's bill before we had even gotten our food, we had to ask if our pizza order got placed & for a minute they were all confused like it had been lost, so finally they started making it. They needed way too much prompting, wonder if we'd still be there waiting to order or waiting on our pizza if I hadn't said anything? Will return to try burgers, salads, etc. read more

Took over an hour to get our food. Waitress was new and apologized for the delay. When we finally got our food, everyone was pretty impressed with the food. The Hamburger and the cheese sticks were great! The low Rating is based on service. Food was a 5!! Whoever was training this new server should be held accountable. read more

This place was great! Friendly service, delicious food! My husband and I both got the stuffed pizza burger and fries and we were not disappointed! Will definitely go back! read more

I tried the Sunshine burger and the egg was overcooked and the burger itself was pretty bland. Not terrible, but you can get a much better burger for less money somewhere else. read more

Food was really good. We waited over 10 minutes for our drink orders to be taken. Then another 30 for our meal orders to be taken. I ordered the grilled chicken blt sandwich, which was really good however the chicken was super small and only covered half of the regular sized bun. Took just a few bites to eat. Service was slow and no apology. read more

First visit. Ordered chicken wings which at $1.20 a wing seems a little over priced, but the size of them almost makes up for it. Also ordered a pepperoni and cheese pizza. Again a little over priced at $9 for what is essentially a small pizza, but none the less a tasty little pizza. Overall good experience will have to try again soon read more

Brickyard Dining Co - Pizza Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

The food was excellent, the problem was the service. We were greeted right away and ours orders taken, but then we were only visited when there were dirty dishes to be picked up. I really wanted to get a refill on my coke but the server never asked if I wanted one. She did, however, ask if my wife wanted another beer. I did finally get one from a different young lady who brought out my wife's dessert (maybe our server relayed that I was out). Like I said, we enjoyed the food very much but the service could be improved. read more

We went on a Thursday wanting to try somewhere new to us. Were greeted promptly. They weren't to busy at the time. Tried the yard sticks. These were cheese sticks but not your normal breaded ones. These had a bread like wrap around them. Were very good. We also bought a Pizza now if your with more than 2 people I would suggest 2 its 11inches but we could have ate a couple more pieces. All in all service was good and no complaints. We will return. read more

Best pizza in New Philadelphia! We have been here a couple of times. It's out of the way so I hope they make it as it hasn't been very busy either time. Service was great too. read more

Nice clean place, inviting atmosphere. I've eaten here multiple times, for both lunch and for dinner and the food is great! (with one exception, which I'll describe later). The portions are generous, the fries are good, and the burgers and sandwiches even better! Seated right away and service was acceptable. My only complaint was the flat iron steak. It was TOUGH. Flat iron is one of the most tender cuts available, but this one was tough and flavorless. Unless they change their steak provider, I suggest one of their other menu options. I would definitely eat here again. read more

Meh... I had hot wings for appetizer, decent but fatty. Iced tea is not brewed, yuck. Phila cheese steak wasn't bad, not enough peppers or onions to even taste though. Fries are a dark deep fries greasy mess. The wife had Roasted Vegetable Penne that was as bland as all get out. Said her salad was good. Bottled beer is not bad priced at $3 but soft drink was $2.50. We won't be back and I don't foresee them being around a year from now once everyone figures out they're being taken. read more

We are addicted to this place! We love the yard sticks! Great food, fast service, incredible prices! Clean, spacious bathrooms, TVs throughout the establishment. Family atmosphere, and relaxing. read more

Enjoyed our first meal at this establishment last evening. Service was great as was the atmosphere and the food. Only downside was the stools at the table we were seated were not comfortable. read more

It looks like I am the first to review this restaurant and I am glad to do it. I ate there with a friend last night (Saturday) and the restaurant was full but we still got a table right away. We both ordered the penne with sausage and peppers and it was delicious. It came with a salad and garlic bread. Plenty to eat. Another friend came over and said the Monterrey Chicken and the hamburger her husband ordered were also very good. They serve a thin crust pizza baked in the brick oven that looked wonderful. I can't comment on the dessert as I was full and didn't order any. Our server was very friendly and quick to get us our meal. I will definitely be back. read more

This place has such potential. I want to love it but this was my third visit and its just underwhelming. The decor is rustic and fun. And it is clean. But staff acts bored and more interested in chatting with each other than the customers. Very little in the way of healthy options on the menu. Food is average at best and very salty. Home made chips are good but super salty. Not a fan of the oldies music playing either. Doubt I will give it a 4th try. read more

I really wanted this place to be good, but after three visits it has missed the mark. My first visit was just after the place opened. There were four people in my party and they forgot to make a pizza for one of us. Also, the service was extremely SLOW. Because they had just opened I was willing to give them the benefit of the doubt. My second visit, sadly, wasn't much better. They were not busy, but once again the service was extremely slow. My friend and I both tried the pasta. Mine was okay, her's was cold. Not luke warm, COLD. The waitress didn't seem overly concerned about it. She did take it back to have it warmed up, but it was not much better when she brought it back out. My third visit, they were again, not busy, but once again the service was not good. It feels like the wait staff has better things to do. The food is nothing to get excited about. It isn't bad, but it isn't amazing either. If they had something on the menu that was unique or fabulous, I would consider returning but the fact is they serve burgers and pizza. I will not be going back. read more

Great pizza! We split the Supreme. Tender crust, generous toppings, and the sauce was awesome! Service was fast & good. Great atmosphere too. We'd definitely come back. read more

I am surprised to see some of the negative reviews. I have visited on multiple occasions, and each time the food and service has been great! Maybe they have hired some better employees since opening? So far, my favorites are the strawberry lemonade, yard sticks, pizza, and all of the desserts! read more

So, this is a newer place in New Philadelphia so I've only been once. First visit wasn't the best. Small portions and a little pricey for the amount you receive. The top odors were fryer and brick oven, a little overwhelming! May try it again, but probably not. read more