Stopped for the night in town, our first choice for supper turned out to be takeout only and the second was unexpectedly closed due to a burst pipe! They were kind enough to recommend Brewhouse. Glad they did. It's open every day. Big place, high ceilings, barroom, huge dining room, giant TV screens everywhere. It was late Sunday afternoon and still pretty busy. Cleveland Browns fans in abundance. It was very loud in a stimulating way. We and the waitress had to yell at each other. She was very busy but on the ball. She let my husband sample a couple of the many beers to make up his mind. The portions are huge. The nacho chips were hot and fresh, the seasoning was interesting and the cheese dip was great. I had the roasted turkey avocado BLT, all the ingredients came together like a symphony of taste and lovely contrasts of texture....and oh, that grilled Italian bread. BIG oval slices from a round Tuscan loaf. It was heaven. Honestly this was one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. As an added bonus it was enough for two meals. I liked the place and would return. read more

See all

I see nothing has changed in this dump. 2nd time here for lunch, sat at bar and waited for 10 minutes with nobody present to serve. Others were there already so one would think someone would be around to at least check on them. Nope. My first bad experience here was the server palmed my credit card to another patron when going to pay my bill. Watched her do it and they both looked right at me from across the busy room after the fact. Good luck. read more

We were on road trip and looking for place to eat glad my daughter found this...everything was amazing. Our server was a delight and the place was great with such a large menu. We started with pretzels and mozzarella sticks, so tasty but filling. The sandwiches were so large we had to take them home with us but very tasty. We will be back if ever in area again. read more

Broadway Brewhouse - Sports Bars Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

I've seen quite a few complaints about the service but I did not experience anything close to that. Server was prompt in delivering our menu and getting our order. Burgers were great as they always were when my wife and I used to frequent this place. A lot of different and interesting options as well. Might be understaffed when it gets busy but was very pleased with my experience. read more

Tony and I stopped here for lunch and to catch the Browns vs Benegals game. This place is definitely bigger inside than what is projected by outside. Our waitress was young and sweet We ordered a Pepsi for me, a Bud Draft for my man and we shared a Buffalo Chicken Flatbread ....pretty good, very spicy read more

Broadway Brewhouse - a brick wall with the word brewhouse painted on it - Sports Bars Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

See all

This used to be my favorite place to eat in New Phila, however it has really went down hill. My family went yesterday and waited over an HOUR to get our food and it was nearly empty inside, around 1:00 in the afternoon. Then when we did get our food the simple hamburgers that was ordered went half way not heated due to them tasting funny, my 18 year old grandson said his tasted like it had sawdust in it, it was so dry, and this kid never leaves a burger on a plate, my other 23 year old grandchild only finished half of hers and said it tasted funny, our brother-in-law could not eat his either, my avocado salad was not good, I couldn't eat the sliced avocado, they were hard and not ripe. Then when I looked at our bill the "tip" was already added, needless to say we will not be back ever, we deserved a lot better for meals that cost over $200.00 read more

This place is a hidden gem! We hit this restaurant every single time we are close and we live 2 hours away. The food is incredible! I love to try Philly Cheesesteaks at different restaurants and this is by far my favorite anywhere. The Ultimate Philly is crazy good! The BBQ Philly is also amazing! The burgers, specifically the garlic burger, are great also but the Phillies are worth the drive! The house chips and seasonings, the specials they run , and the hand cut fries are all highlights of this place too! Great draft choice too! This is a must stop if you are close, or even if you have to drive. Try this place, you will not regret it! I have been here many times and never left hungry and I always leave happy because the food is consistently amazing! It's a cool bar with great ambiance and lots of televisions to watch sports! Service is good but not great but the food makes up for it. read more

They get one star for being open and providing service. Otherwise, save your time and don't go there. The only bartender/server was hanging out with her boyfriend and two kids the whole time, so much for getting some good conversation about local events. I asked for a water & menu to start. it took 15 minutes for her to return and take my order, I order a beer and some "pizza bites." She puts in my order and walks back to her boyfriend. 10 minutes later my beer shows up with my food. Nice. Finally. Could've poured the beer when I asked for it but nah. Then the "pizza bites" came. They are just (the cheapest) fried cheese balls you can imagine. No pepperoni, even though it's in the description. Then she tried to charge me for the bites after I complained and told her I could make them for 50¢ at home. She's lucky I gave her a dollar tip to support the kids, who spend their day at the bar with mom. read more

Supervisor blocked the way of my 12 year old niece and me after being served a meal that was served 42 minutes after we ordered it with cold fries and no server checking in to alert them to our problem. I have never had a restaurant server react in such a physical and boisterous way when letting them know a meal was sub par. I called New Phila police to have her move out of the way. Told officers I preferred to pay 1/2 but would pay all if I had to. Bill was $23 and Supervisor accepted $20. I was told not to return. Poor service, long wait, cold food, poor customer service from manager who pressed her breasts against me as I tried to leave, then she blocked the door. I called the police to settle the situation. The managers behavior was over the top and very upsetting to my 12 year old. read more

Broadway Brewhouse - Supervisor allowing patrons to leave, but blocking our exit. - Sports Bars Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

See all

First time visit. Service was slow, food was mediocre and I was unaware of the hidden prices. I would have licked my plate clean if I had known that it would cost me $13 for just a sandwich. Very disappointed. I will not be going back. As they say, "Been there, done that". read more

Best wings I've had in a long time! Try the applewood dry rub! Service was fast and food was great! Tuesday wings just .99 each!

I have been going here since 2012 and I still believe they have some of the best wings. Are here a couple weeks ago and service is ok, but the wings were great. read more

Don't go to this sh*t hole. Bartender wouldn't take my ID because I'm from texas and I'm 23. Very dissatisfying after laying over 4K ft of fiber. read more

Love this place and the servers. Amazing food and atmosphere 10/10 Love the beer selection and the food specials. 10/10

One star only because it won't let me do zero or even negative.. We have been coming to the Brewhouse fairly regularly for years. We won't ever be back. We went before a football game with several families from our community. We told them from the start that we had a large group coming, about 20 people. AFTER we ordered, they informed us that they couldn't split our checks. We said that if they would have told us that from the start, we would have gone somewhere else because every other restautant can figure it out. When we asked to speak to the manager, she brought our check and asked us to leave. Gladly...we can go to the freezer section of the grocery store and heat it up at home from now on, that is all their food is. read more

Hot cheese bites are amazing & my husbands bacon burger was descent. However, the chicken on my Cobb salad was like eating rubber. It was so rubbery that I could barely cut it & I have never bit into any food with that texture. When I mentioned it to the waitress, she went back and told the cook. He told her that he realized it wasn't a great piece of chicken, so why he went ahead and served it is unsettling. And very strange that the waitress admitted it. This ruined the meal for me. They comped our meal $5, but as a business owner, I would have comped the whole meal. The waitress was not very friendly either. We definitely will not return. read more

Seems like a fun place to be for a weekend. Stopped by on a recent business trip. Excellent draft choices! Got a Goose Island Winter for $4! CHEAP! They also had wings with different sauces.. 40 cents per wing. Not bad at all. read more

Broadway Brewhouse - Sports Bars Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

Recieved very rude manager treatment last night! Went into this establishment many time pre covid and must say it has indeed changed! Will not be going back with Managers they currently have that #1 do not share true facts concerning customer concerns with owners! Evidently they don't value the Customer patronage anymore! read more

Highly recommend! Friendly, great atmosphere & food was delicious! Best potato soup around!

Broadway Brewhouse is an oasis in the booming town of New Philadelphia. Here you can meet great people near and far. I met a British guy once. I also met a Turkish guy once. The bartenders are also like super neato. Especially Laura and Lisa. It must be an L name thing. read more

I can only comment on the bartenders and drinks. They were nice, not overly nice, but okay. we got shots so no way to mess that shit up. The live music sucks / but probably just me because i don't care for country. Did I mention we are in the middle of no where Ohio? read more

Broadway Brewhouse - Live music on Saturdays - Sports Bars Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

I'll start off by saying that they had one waitress for the entire restaurant. So the service was very very slow and the waitress seemed like she had a bad attitude. Made us feel very uncomfortable. Pictured is the nacho chip basket we got and the cheese tasted like cheese from a can and the salsa was pace salsa. We waited for a good while for our food but when we got it, it tasted very good. The fries are great (fresh cut), and the wings are crispy and very tasty with lots of flavors to choose from. I got a burger, and it was very good and cooked perfectly. There are lots of burgers to choose from, actually the entire menu has something for everyone. There are also tons of different beers to choose from. All in all, I'd give the food a 4/5 and the service a 2/5. read more

Broadway Brewhouse - This tasted exactly like nacho cheese from a can and pace salsa. Very very underwhelming - Sports Bars Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

This place is pathetic. Every TV is on the same game and they claim they cant change a channel. They claim they dont have Sunday Ticket, yet they just advertised a game on Prime. Add the fact that Ive been waiting over 1 hour 10 minutes for a salad, this is a pathetic excuse for a restaurant. And, when we asked for the manager, they sent the town drunk lady over to talk to us. She almost was thrown out for bringing a yeti in. I have never been more disappointed. Will NOT go back read more

I can truly say that the only downfall of this trip to Brewhouse was realizing I tipped the waitress WAY less than I meant to on accident. I can truly say this might be my favorite place in town. The food I so cheap, but the quality is amazing and the portions are huge. The selection of beers is incredible, and the servers are beyond kind. I can't speak highly enough!! read more

the waitress and service was very horrible as it will cause me to never go there again. she refused to serve us because we were sitting upstairs. someone from the group of people i was with had to go get a waitress to come and serve us. she came up 15-20 minutes later and then told us she wouldn't take our order. read more

Only reason why I gave it one star was because the waitress was nice. Went there on 50 cent wing night and was there for 90 minutes before we got our wings. There were 4 of us and we each got 20 Wings. A sizeable order but nothing crazy as it wasn't too crowded. Waitress came back with the WRONG order. So we tipped her and left. Never going back. read more

fries weren't too terrible. lemonade was phenomenal but the waiter was absolutely terrible.

There aren't a whole lot of bar options in New Philadelphia. I guess this place is ok. Good if you want to watch sports as there are lots of TVs. However, there is usually some random nasty smell permeating the entire place, which I really don't appreciate. Makes me avoid this place if possible. Drinks are kind of overpriced here, especially if you get liquor. Also, drink prices are really odd, by this I mean that lots of times you get pennies back for change if you pay with cash. I don't want pennies back for my bar change, I don't want anything smaller than a quarter. They seem to have live music pretty frequently so if you're into that I guess it's worth checking out. I'd be more into this place if they got rid of the random gross smells. read more

You go in and order and it takes 2 hrs for the order to come out and they forget you have a table of 15 and nobody got a refill was almost tempted to walk out of go to Buffalo Wild Wings won't be coming back and this isn't the first time this happened read more

Wings are good and the beer is cold! Service is somewhat lacking.

We ate at Broadway Brewhouse today and won't be going back - they had bluegrass music blasting the entire time we were there - the volume was so high, we gave up on trying to have a conversation. We asked the waitress to turn it down, but nothing happened. Our MLB team was playing and we would have liked to enjoy the game with the broadcast, but they left the horrible bluegrass music on - fiddles and crooning so loud. This is supposed to be a sports bar, not a bluegrass festival. Food was so so and took forever to come out. read more

Went in again last night, still smelled like sewer. I guess it wasn't a fluke. I'm not returning again. Enter at your own risk.

Do not bother going to this bar/restaurant. The service was good, but the kitchen screws up your meal every time (I've given it three chances). This latest time, a friend and I ordered a dozen wings, extra crispy, extra wet. They came out in 45 minutes, bone dry. We asked the waitress to take them back and she did. They came back with them literally drowning in sauce. Obviously the kitchen had a problem with our request. The wings were uneatable. I repeat...... do not go to this establishment read more

Broadway Brewhouse - Sports Bars Near Me - New Philadelphia, Ohio

I moved back down in area about 5 years ago and wanted nice evening for brother-in-law and sister that came up from Texas so wanted nice place for them. Not sure what happened or why this time but service was horrible. Bar maid was rude and I waited to get served all the while she served others ahead of me that came in the door. Once she did serve me I asked why she kept on skipping me and was told they wait on customers first before pull tabs? Funny thing was we all ordered food and drinks and had at least two other drinks and I was planning on ordering more till she was rude. I wasn't just playing the pull tabs I was trying to enjoy an evening. I gave them 3 stars because it was first time ever experienced that service and have eaten there and had wonderful experiences. This happened 2 years ago and haven't been back. I can cook as well as anybody but go out for an experience and service, if don't get that why even go out. I'll give it another try sometime but missed loyal customer that would have came in regularly. I hope this was a exception. Also the waitress we had done fine job it was only bar maid had issue with. My wife waitressed for years and understand what good service is all about. I know I can't be alone on this one. read more

I wish there was an option for 0 stars! Holy smokes that was the WORST service I've ever had in my life and I've worked in the industry for 5 years. I'm not sure who our male bartender was but man talk about unprofessional literally unreal. After handing us our checks he told us if our food wasn't good that he didn't care that wasn't his job.... really man it's called costumer service! What do you think your job is? And messed up all three of our orders and said it was the kitchens fault!? I doubt that... I mean it wasn't Like it was packed there was 8 people in there and took 35 mins before asking if we were good can honestly say I'll never be stepping foot in there again! read more

One of the best cheesesteaks I've ever had was in this random-ass bar in random-ass New Philadelphia, Ohio. I don't mean to demean this fine burg in the eastern end of Amish country. I just mean to say that, like my own hometown, there's absolutely no reason to be here unless you're from here. The area is beautiful, this place has Woodchuck Cider on tap, and the bartender (at least when I was there) was a huge Ween fan. That's pretty boss. read more

Simply put, never going back to this place. Me and four friends ordered sodas. Received drinks that can only be described as flat carbonation, some gross syrup, and some sugar. Disgusting. I asked for something different, a Sprite this time. Straight up soda water. Mentioned it to the server and she smiled and said that their machine had been messing up. Couldn't have told us that before we all ordered? I asked for a water. Didn't receive the water until I got my bill. Then the Hot Wings we had ordered could barely pass as a Mild. I politely asked for more sauce, maybe it would help. Nope. Then after a long wait and the server forgetting my water, I got the bill. I was charged for soda I couldn't and didn't drink, and extra sauce that should've been on the wings in the first place. On top of all of this, the server didn't give correct change at all. She kept a dollar from two of my friends. Worst experience ever. read more

This place needs a bar rescue. Could be a great place but the service blows, they are rude, very slow. Mike is the only good bar tender there. Save your money this place needs better management. read more

Nice atmosphere but TERRIBLE service. Had to wait over 45 minutes for food. We thought it would be a fun place to try before a football game. We definitely will NOT be going there again when we play in the area. Slow food, less than mediocre waiter. read more

I'd call it a bar. Not a sports bar. Went here to watch an Ohio State basketball game. We called ahead to make sure it was going to be on. Then when we asked if they could play the sound on the game, they said no. They proceded to play some shitty rock music instead. Don't call yourselves a sports bar...you're a bar with a few TVs. On the up-side the wait staff was very polite and attentive, and they had a fair beer selection. read more