A few weeks ago my serpentine belt broke and I was stranded at night in Newcastle. I was right by brotherhood garage and they took 3 days to tell me their diagnosis of it. First they told me my engine was knocking and that I should prepare for the worst. Then their master tech looked at it and said it was just the belt. They fixed it got it to me and It was very overpriced but you know you got to do what you got to do. Last week I was on the highway going 75 mph and my car just dies. The engine won't start again and my dash is completely black. The speedometer was at 0 when I was just going 75. So now I was stranded in Edmond and come to find out there's a tensioner on the alternator belt they didn't bolt back up so the belt wasn't tight enough to spin the alternator so it wasn't charging. So these "mechanics" need to get some actual training. Their work isn't safe and it could have been a deadly situation if I hadn't responded the correct way on the highway. I don't advise going to brotherhood garage if you value your safety. read more

I was sent to Brotherhood garage by Discount Tire in Moore due to a employee damaging a hub and a lug-nut during maintenance work. They were fairly easy to schedule and accommodating though I was told the appointment would be quick -and they would know if they could fix it or not -but alas this appointment took an hour and a half and they were unable to repair it. Upon completion of the appointment they emailed me a inspection report for my vehicle which I DID NOT give them consent to do. I made it very clear when I came in that I was only there because of the Discount Tire issue and I did not want to authorize ANY OTHER work to be done on my vehicle and only was authorizing the Discount Tire possible repair to be done on my vehicle. They asked if I needed an oil change, I told them I had it done last week and they asked if I needed an alignment and I told them I got it done on Saturday. I made the statement in front of two employees and my son. So for me to get an inspection report that shows three "requires immediate attention" issues that need to be taken care of was a slap in the face. They did not even listen to me. 1) air filter that needs to be replaced (The new one was sitting in the seat) 2) that I have a possible oil leak because there is visible oil on my pan below a gasket. This was a repair that my car had received at the MINI dealership and there are no active leaks. This is also mentioned in my MINI dealership inspection report that I received one week prior that states "no active leaks" but shows the same image. Brotherhood would like to clean The area and add dye to see if it is currently leaking. 3) the damaged hub that needed to be retapped None of this was discussed to my face except item #3 & it was just sent to me via email. Lastly they checked all my fluids, they opened every reservoir to check my fluids. I did not give them authorization to do this. Also my car (a MINI Cooper) is notorious for having the dipsticks break when being checked and are basically useless because they are not very readable. When I asked how they checked my oil life since all they showed me was a color comparison I asked if it came from cap or the dipstick. I was told the dipstick -because that's how you check your oil (duh). I am fully aware of how you check your oil. I am also aware my car burns oil like a MOTHER (it is a MINI thing) and there was a fresh 5w-30 sitting in my passenger side. I got this!! I also asked this gentleman if he was aware that MINIs dipsticks are known to break --he told me "no he was unaware". I informed him that I will be taking my car to the Mini dealership to perform the hub repair that is now needed and at the time I will have them check my dipstick. If there is any issue I will be following up with this location. He apologized for the inspection that was done that was NOT authorized but you cannot undo what has already been done. It felt like my car was a novelty to them... They kept me there for an hour and a half and suggested work that did not need to be done. They were unable to do the work that was requested of them by Discount Tire and they still pushed to be the ones to replace the hub admitting that they would be using an aftermarket part unless discount tire approved using OEM. At that point again I reminded him that if a repair was not possible I would not be taking my car back to them and I would be taking my car to the MINI dealership. I get not everyone takes care of their vehicles and does the property maintenance but I do... the inspection was unauthorized and invasive. I know MINIs are weird and a pain in the rear and have very unusual qwerks--- I am very particular who works on my car and all work has been limited to Discount tire (moore) for wheels and tires, Firestone (s western) for alignments and MINI dealership (edmond) for all other work. **I have been looking for a secondary garage to trust my vehicle with when I am unable to go into the MINI dealership. But between the past reviews I have seen on this business at all 3 locations and my first hand experience I can honestly say I will never be back. read more

They do price gouge. I needed my injectors replaced on my dodge and they quoted me double what another garage did it for. Plus that other garage turned my rotors and replaced my break pads, I have attached phone messages between me and brotherhood garage just to prove I was a customer. read more

Brotherhood Garage - Auto Repair Near Me - Newcastle, Oklahoma

MJ @ Brotherhood Garage was very kind and helpful when my car was towed to their shop and helped me find out that my motor was under warranty and sent to Kia for service!! read more

They had my vehicle for over 2 weeks and hadn't fixed any of the things they had promised, when I called they continued to claim it was bc they were waiting for parts. Promised it on a Friday after 2 weeks and finally the next Thursday (3 weeks in shop) I get it back and my issue is still not working. Check engine light came back on 24 hours after pick up and $1,800 spent. Disappointed and frustrated. Oh and so you can't claim my name isn't in the system we have a 2014 Chevy Traverse, Thomas dropped off. read more

Best place to get your vehicle diagnosed. Never have I been provided such a detailed report and with pictures attached to show what they found via diagnostic tool readings and of the faulty component. The best part is they are veteran friendly with great customer service! Only suggestion I have is it would be nice if they offered a lifetime alignment program. read more

Do not go here! My dad paid $3800 for a new transmission for his Jeep and they have had to replace it 3 times because the new ones keep messing up. He asked for a refund and his Jeep back so he can go somewhere since they still have fixed it and they told him a new owner bought it and took over the garage now so they don't have to give him his $3800 back. read more

I want to let people know how great it was to get referred to Brotherhood Garage for my classic car repairs. These guys are leaps and bounds ahead of any mechanic shops on communication, honesty and timeliness. I would recommend them to anyone. Brandon (the gentleman I was referred to contact) has been more then helpful on picking up cars and dropping them back off due to my busy schedule and his team follows through with what I was told on communication and fixes being made. These services are not common in their industry and I am very appreciative for the services I was provided. They have for sure earned a customer from me!! Highly recommend!! read more

These guys were fantastic! I have a ford flex that I bought used and was having trouble with what I thought was the alignment, they took it out for a test drive and out it on the rack. They found a lot of fishing line wrapped around the front axle that they cut off but what the issue was, was the rotors, I had no clue they could make the car act like that but I had them change them out and put new brakes on and it drives like a dream now. They also gave me a loaner car so I could run my errands while they tried to figure out what was up with my car! I mean who does that!? The costumer service here can NOT be beat! read more

Just moved to the area from the Pacific Northwest... The guys did full diagnosis of my vehicle after along drive down to Oklahoma was impressed with their work and people skills. Look forward to there business in the future. read more

Very very very very bad,and very pricey,the most ridiculous pricing system I have ever seen when it comes to fixing a car...if you have money to flush down the toilet without any result,or progress,then go ahead and take your car to them,bad service,no star deserved... read more