Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Buehler's Idlewild Inn

    5.0 (2 reviews)

    Buehler's Idlewild Inn Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Buehler's Idlewild Inn

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jay L.
    126
    1
    0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    The Mansion at Noble Lane - Welcoming Social, grab a glass

    The Mansion at Noble Lane

    4.5(49 reviews)
    15.4 mi

    It's a good concept and you can tell that the owners tried but I didn't see anything of…read moresignificance. I wish they would upgrade it a bit more. I wanted a little bit more luxury! Hopefully they can build on what they have a make it a desirable destination as for myself I would go back until and update.

    The Mansion at Noble Lane Bed and Breakfast will definitely be my annual retreat to treat SELF &…read morecelebrate my Birthday (11/11); thanks to my Beloved daughter Dr. DCB. MaMere s utterly proud of you, for seeing in heart to bless mommy with this incredible birthday gift. THANK YOU‍ From the time I arrived (3:20 pm), I was greeted by the beautiful & radiant spirit Ms. Vanessa, the Inn hospitality Manager. Her heartfelt words wrapped around my core; saying WELCOME HOME. Oh, and it was home at its finest. From the 4pm welcome social, that included delicious White & Red wines that danced graciously on your palate. Various delectable cheeses, crackers, olives & thinly sliced turkey meats. YUMMY, they were! Movie nights, s'more's & more libation at your choice. The next morning, a scrupulously delicious breakfast was served; with a fresh brewed coffee from Ethiopia & a freshly squeezed grapefruit hearty drink. Yoga awaits me at 11am. I'm now chilling at the warm pool ‍ until my 2:30 Swedish massage ‍. Tonight (11/8), Saturday with my incredible cousins and their lovely friends who joined us on a "Cousin's Girl Weekend", will be celebrating me & my birthday . I'm definitely going to post the pictures later on tonight. The Bed and Breakfast is only 2 hours from NYC (UWS) Manhattan, NY. You will not regret this treat to SELF or a love one.

    Photos
    The Mansion at Noble Lane - The entry to the Inn. Every single morning, I saw this view. Amazing.

    The entry to the Inn. Every single morning, I saw this view. Amazing.

    The Mansion at Noble Lane - This is us!

    This is us!

    The Mansion at Noble Lane

    See all

    Valley Rock Inn - View from the restaurant

    Valley Rock Inn

    3.9(127 reviews)
    56.2 mi

    We went to the Lodge Steakhouse for the first time after several wonderful meals at the Cantina…read more The setting was absolutely breathtaking. We felt like we were walking through a fairytale-like winter wonderland in Idaho or Jackson Hole. It had just snowed and truly looked magical. Perfect landscape design and and lighting. The dining room itself is equally elegant, decor is on point, upscale and super-tasteful, and atmosphere is fantastic. We were SO excited about the drinks, wine and food menus. Ordered liberally to try a lot of different things, and... womp womp. While the plating and presentation of all we ordered was perfect, the taste did not rise to the level of the presentation. The martini had a strange undertone, The Pinot was thin and underwhelming. The oysters all had pieces of shell in them from how they were shucked that then had to be fished out from one's palate (and there's no way to do that that's not awkward at a full table). The octopus was overcooked. They serve garlic biscuits, which were tasty but we didn't finish them bc no one was blown away. The duck - skin was scored properly but not given enough time time crisp or pan not hot enough, so served soggy, tho the meat was done correctly. All dishes sat upon a turnip puree, with the duck having additional (also soggy veggies), and the steak having additional shredded cabbage. French fries came out nearly cold but in a nice metal basket lined with parchment. They looked perfect and then the bite was, well, not hot. Mashed potatoes were good. Presented well. Perhaps the highlight of the evening? The service was very good, by the way. Staff was fantastic. It's just that something was a near miss on the food... very heavy handed, the unique tastes and freshness of the ingredients cooked out of many... a very different experience than had in the cantina, where the food has been perfect each time. 2 Coffees, 2 sodas, 1 martini and one glass of wine, 2 apps, 3 entrees, and one dessert with standard tip came out to just under $500. It's a lot for an underwhelming meal. Food wise, if I were to recommend a fine dining establishment where the food is superlative for the same price, I'd say Hudson House in Nyack, hands down. While they don't have the same ethereal setting, the culinary aspect cannot be beat. They do have oysters that are shucked correctly and a killer steak au poivre with pomme frites that's incredible. Perhaps we'll try this place again in the future. Not sure if it's new? Only just learned about the Lodge Steakhouse part, so who knows. Summary: Overall, gorgeous setting, food presentation. Staff service: lovely, actual taste of each dish: meh.

    Wow Valley Rock Inn is simply gorgeous! I've been meaning to visit here for at least a year and it…read morewas never in the stars for me. It's right in Sloatsburg tucked in behind another bar on Old Rt 17 - I've passed by and never realized it! We came to have Sunday Brunch/Lunch at the Cantina and were very impressed! It was the weekend of Halloween so it was still decorated with lots to look at. Drink-wise, we started with the Rose and the Pink Cobbler which was like a fruity twist on an Old Fashioned. We ordered the Shaved Brussel Sprouts pizza to share along with the Lobster Crisps to start. The lobster was YUM. It was a cold lobster served with house chips. The pizza was great! It wasn't heavy and included fall flavors such as butternut squash. For dessert, we shared the ricotta zeppoles which came with a chocolate sauce. Service was excellent. Valley Rock Inn Cantina is a little slice of heaven away from the noises of NYC and yet you don't feel like you're in Rockland County. It's hard to explain but it transports you to somewhere else. I can't wait to come back again for dinner!

    Photos
    Valley Rock Inn - Cozy bench

    Cozy bench

    Valley Rock Inn - Mimosa and Bloody Mary

    Mimosa and Bloody Mary

    Valley Rock Inn - The entrance

    See all

    The entrance

    Buehler's Idlewild Inn - guesthouses - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...