This was my second visit here and the burgers and service are consistently good. I built my own burger this time around and we shared onion rings as an appetizer. Onion rings are great, actually my favorite of the ones I've tried in Pittsburgh. Burgers are sinfully delicious. While this location is a little hidden in the shopping center, it's worth a visit! One of these days I'm going to try the boozy shakes. read more

Burgatory - Fox Chapel - Build your own burger - Burgers Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I'm a big fan of burgatory because of the ability to customize your burger from type of meats, cheeses, toppings, and seasoning. I got a custom wagyu beef burger with fries and it was made in about 25 minutes. The staff however seemed a little irritated when serving my table as she was very slow at checking in on us during our initial order as well as refills throughout the meal. (It was also not that busy). The overall experience was good food wise, but kinda of a letdown service was. Hopefully a one off, but unfortunate for me. Food(50%): 7.7 Staff/service(25%): 3.0 Value(25%): 7.0 Overall: 6.3/10 read more

Burgatory - Fox Chapel - Burgers Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

UGHHH SO FREAKING GOOD! But pls we have to stop with the metal chairs, they are super uncomfortable, especially for women with hips, like they actually hurt. read more

See all

Definitely the largest smash burger I've ever had! Almost a little too wide for my preference of smash burgers, but still very good. I always prefer fries to chips, especially with a burger, so I wish that was different. The menu is incredibly large and inclusive to different dietary needs which i loved! I had the peanut butter Oreos milkshake, which was good, but could have been a little better. Maybe it was all the cream on top the mixed in, but it wasn't quite what I was hoping for. All in all, would happily return! read more

See all

Out to dinner with the whole family and chose Burgatory because they have gluten-free options. We were seated and served very quickly. I love how you can customize your burger. Cool restaurant that sources their ingredients locally. read more

See all

First off, the burgers are HUGE. If you can finish one, good luck staying awake. We came in a group of 5 on a Monday for lunch, fairly empty. Our server (Elijah?) was so nice and super attentive. The onion rings are phenomenal. One plate comes with 5-6 LARGE onion rings. The burgers are delicious and so are the fries. I was thoroughly impressed. read more

See all

I was looking for late lunch options when I remembered that Burgatory is running a new $5 Menu on Mondays. Of course, I had to check it out . We ordered the Margarita, which was perfectly balanced and refreshing. I've had many BYO burgers here throughout the years, but this was my 1st time trying their smash burger. It totally is a smash hit!! The toppings were fresh and crisp and the fresh cut chips added a nice crunch. The burger sauce is always yummy. I thought the bun was good on its own, but maybe a little too big for a single smash patty. The chocolate shake hit the spot for dessert. The wide straw works great. I love that they provide the leftover milkshake that didn't fit into the served milkshake glass. Burgatory has me looking forward to Mondays with this $5 Menu! read more

See all

Stopped by early after noon....spicy Bloody Mary....huge onion rings...Gorgonzola fries and medium rare (ask for rare) Supreme Deluxe Burger and house made chips....fast and friendly service... read more

See all

We really enjoyed the food here! The service was terrific as well! We did not get any drinks-but the menu looked great! We are planning to come back again! read more

See all

Went here with the wife and some friends after a day in Downtown Pittsburgh. I got the Elk burger the wife got Angus. Both were delicious and good as requested. The waitress was awesome and very thorough. read more

Had a pretty decent lunch here! Seated quickly in a comfortable booth. Ordered two apps, onion rings and fries with garganzolla, and a standard burger to split. The food was delivered soon after and everything was fine. The server check in on us. Price was reasonable. A good stop. read more

Great burgers and everything that goes with them!! We had an awesome night here. Big, fresh, juicy, burgers with lots of options and highly customizable. We had delicious shakes, WITH the leftover! Exactly what we were looking for in a family burger night. The salad was our only disappointment, as we were looking for a healthy "offset" but it was drowned in onion strings. read more

See all

We went on a Sunday afternoon and immediately got seated! It wasn't crowded and there was no wait. We absolutely loved our server, Kathleen, who was the nicest and always checked in on us. She also gave us awesome recommendations. We will definitely be back just because the staff here is so nice!! I love that they have vegan shakes here. They are so good! I think they even make their whipped cream out of Aquafaba, it is soooo delicious and more importantly, won't hurt my lactose intolerant digestive system. They have a large menu of drinks and food. There's something for everyone here. I love the vegan and vegetarian options too, there's veggie burgers and salads available. I liked their chicken sandwiches too. They have amazing onion rings they batter in house and the sauces are made in house too- spicy ketchup and horseradish Mayo. They make everything from scratch here. They are known for their burgers. We had the Morty's Steakhouse which was really good. We loved their herb and sea salt fries too! Overall, pretty decent spot for lunch and dinner. We went for lunch so we didn't order cocktails but they have an extensive drink menu. We heard the sangrias are amazing. They also look like they have a decent happy hour! read more

Burgatory - Fox Chapel - Morty's Steakhouse Burger - Burgers Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

This is a local Pittsburgh joint that does not disappoint. The burger choices are to die for and affordable. The dining area reminds me of a dive where it's dark and dingy but it was somewhat comfortable. The servers were very attentive and knowledgeable about menu and the types of burgers. I'm glad they made recommendations that I really liked. I went with a customer here around Thanksgiving and they had a turkey burger that tasted like Thanksgiving dinner. Definitely worthwhile visit and looking forward to coming back. read more

See all

Yummy and substantial burgers with a ton of options to customize your sandwich. I'm a plain Jane when it comes to my burgers...I typically only do cheddar cheese, pickles, and mayo. But you can go crazy on the toppings and customizations. I normally order takeout, but I always get friendly waiters when I dine in. The restaurant is dimly lit which makes it cozy. Can't go wrong with this restaurant! read more

Burgatory - Fox Chapel - Burgers Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

cheeseburger and the lettuce look like it was two years old tomato get into it. The outside the tomato was peeling out around the tomato sandwich. It was terrible. When I walked in, it just smelled so bad. read more

The food was delicious, and there were only a few minor mistakes with our orders, which were quickly fixed. The atmosphere was super relaxed, and it was a great overall experience. read more

Made a reservation thru Yelp for this location this past Saturday evening. We arrived a bit before our 7:15 resy and was seated right away. This place is in a very large shopping center, so it is very busy inside and out. It's a tad dark inside with tons of TV's to watch your favorite game. Our server was super nice and gave us the rundown on how things work. I love the form you can fill out yourself for a build it yourself burger. You fill in everything you desire with add-on prices clearly marked along with the free toppings, then put your name on a tear off tab and when the meal is delivered, it has your name from that tab right there. Super cool concept. My wife and daughter also ordered up shakes. They were real thick and a bit too much heavy whipped cream. They said it was a bit too much. More shake, less cream. Still very tasty. I had to dry their 13 spiced dry rub wings with hot honey. Haven't had a wing since January and there were cooked perfectly with an incredible spice flavor (cinnamon, 5 spice, etc). That hot honey addition was to die for. For my meal, I had the ground chicken burger and it was juicy and not super messy. They have a great tap list too for beer lovers. Everything was reasonably priced and service was great. Would gladly return. read more

Burgatory - Fox Chapel - Dry rub 13 spices and hot honey. - Burgers Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Great food. Top 5 in my book. Great personable service. Cool place love the play in good fun. read more

See all

I was so excited to try this place! Its keto friendly with a lettuce wrap option but I was so disappointed! The lettuce wrap was quite brown and my burger came out raw! I built my own and circled the "no pink" the waiter took it back said he would fix it but i just wanted it off my bill. When he returned to check on the table he said he should have explained that the 50/50 burger comes that and that it wasnt raw! Absolutely not! The outside if my burger was crispy but the inside was almost cold and VERY raw! read more

Burgatory - Fox Chapel - 50/50 burger lettuce wrapped - Burgers Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Worst service ever! Waited to be seated, no one was around, front desk empty Waitress was horrible served me cold and I mean cold coffee had to go find her if we wanted something Won't bother going here again! read more

The wait staff and other employees were great. But you would think a burger place would know how to get a proper/requested cook on the burger. Come on it's your mainstay. read more

Food was good, server was good...no complaints about either. However we went on a Saturday afternoon (the restaurant was not that busy, we did not have to wait for a table). My husband and I were there with our 6 year old and 8 month old. When we checked in the hostess told us they had no high chairs. We asked if one would be available soon and she said no and that there were already people waiting in front of us. It was incredibly hard to enjoy our meal with holding a baby and trying to keep him happy, entertained, and from grabbing our food. If you've ever been around a wiggly 8 month old baby, I'm sure you understand. I even mentioned being able to be seated somewhere where we could grab our stroller from the car so he could sit, but that comment was ignored by the hostess. If you have a baby needing a high chairs, I would only come here if it were a time when the restaurant was empty as you will be holding your baby the entire meal. read more

Getting a bite to eat, I got to try one of their hard shakes for the first time, it was pretty good. Our waitress was lovely, super patient and good with my food allergies. We got a seat at a nice booth. read more

Burgatory - Fox Chapel - Create Your Own Burger - Burgers Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

We have been to another Burgatory location in Cranberry, but it was our first time visiting this one. It was about 3:30pm on a Saturday so there was no wait and we were seated immediately. Our server (Kathleen I believe was her name) was very nice and helpful. She took our daughter's order first so she would get her food quickly and was very accommodating and made some great recommendations. So 5/5 for service! We both got burgers and our daughter got grilled cheese with chips. The chips were a bit on the hard side, but the rest of the food was hot, fresh and very good. None of us took advantage of the "build your own" this time, but there's a huge number of options to choose from so you can definitely build whatever type of burger you'd like. The total was about $50 for the kids meal and two burgers/sodas and the change from chips to fries ($4 total). So really not bad for the amount of food that you get. I'll definitely continue to visit Burgatory whenever I'm in the mood for a good burger! read more

(4) ~ very good overall food & service. Note: Plenty of parking. DRINKS: ** Water (tap) = (4) very good, must be filtered;) ** Campfire S'mores Milkshake = (4) very good, but the toasted marshmallow was "pre-toasted" so room temperature...would be better if it was still warm / toasted right before getting;) FOOD: ** Create-Your-Own-Burger = (4.25) Very good, but the pretzel roll is too hard for me, will get the Brioche next time;) Got mine with Beef(pink); White American Cheese; Whole Grain Mustard; Sunny Egg; Grilled Onions; Avocado; Sliced Tomato & House Pickled Jalapenos (which were great!:) * Sea Salt & Herb Fries = (3.75) Good, but not great... read more

Most excellent wagyu burger! Anna was an amazing waitress at the bar. Food was great! Highly recommend if in the area.

Our meal was absolutely amazing.. as always it was clean and I like this location. It's located on a little plaza with a bunch of other places to adventure. read more

See all

I'm in town this week for vacation and when I saw a restaurant with a name like Burgatory I had to go. As out of town-ers, the name and concept immediately made us want to give Burgatory a try. I read a few reviews and looked at some mouth watering pictures. Now I'm amped up and ready to go. So I set out to give these guys a try and they did delivered. I love the customizable options here! There are dozens of different choices to build your own burger, including vegetarian/vegan options, or interesting proteins like bison or 50% bacon burger. The number of choices on the list might seem daunting, but it's all part of the fun. The restaurant is clean and tidy. The staff is friendly and helpful. There is a full service bar, it has flat screens above the bar seats. It has a small sports bar feel to it. The complaints?   One, the food took a really long time to come out.  They were busy, but it was an exceptionally long time. Overall great food and atmosphere. Delicious burgers. The beer selection was good. The burger options were vast. I had the make your own burger and that was fantastic. You pay more for the food but the environment is great. read more

See all

Can't go wrong with the Morty's Steakhouse burger. Usually cooked spot on. Only downside is the wait. Not a large seating area, so get on the list early. Smores and birthday cake milkshakes were good as well. read more

Fantastic experience for the 5 of us. There was a bit of a wait and the hostess was kind enough to call and alert us as well as call to notify us when our take was ready. I built my own burger and chose a local, grain bun with the elk burger seasoned with black peppercorn. Topped with a garlic/mayo sauce, cremini mushrooms, arugula, sliced red onions and sliced tomatoes... everything was delicious. Jessica was very attentive and a great server. We'll definitely return! read more

See all

Wow ... Good food here! Trippin' Chicken is always a favorite, it comes on a Pretzel Bun! However, what's really impressive for what you would think as a Burger join is the awesome salads. The Green Apple and Quinoa Salad was fantastic! read more

See all

Ordered takeout from this Burgatory location last week. I'm rarely disappointed in Burgatory...but what happened to the crab cake??? Its my favorite. This was the first time I ordered something new. I created my own burger and fries. It was delicious but I still want that crab cake. My daughter always gets the chicken tenders and devours them. My husband gets the impossible burger creating his own combo. He loves it. So easy to order online and pick up at their back door. You do not even need to get out of the car. I will be back! read more

I haven't been to this Burgatory before but it seemed every bit as great as the one in Murrysville. This time around I used Google assistant to create a reservation but from the looks of things, we probably didn't need it. Service was good ... somehow the bar tender ended up waiting on everyone at thr bar, our table, and at least two others, but she handled it well and was friendly and attentive. The beer battered onion rings are among the best rings I've experienced and are HUGE. We also had some kind of loaded nachos and they were good. But the burgers were great. Overall, a nice evening out with friends and I'd go back anytime. Thanks !! (I gotta get better about pictures -- those onion rings were GIGANTIC !!) read more

I had a really disappointing dinner here last night. I used to eat at this Burgatory very often, but haven't in about a year. I order it on Grubhub sometimes, but it comes from the North Side location. I am usually a big fan! Last night was just all around bad. My dad and I went around 5:45 for a quick dinner after work. We started with chips and guac (the Holy Mole) and the guac was good! I don't remember it having olive oil poured on top before, but it was good once mixed together. We each made our own burger. I pretty much always get the exact same thing, the vegan veggie burger (thank goodness they brought it back!!), with sweet onion rub, whole grain mustard, and lettuce, tomato, onion, and pickles. The veggie burger looked good when it came out, but I noticed it was very red. I bit into it and my whole face turned red. It was SO spicy! I didn't order anything spicy on it, so I thought maybe they put the buffalo rub on instead. I tried to eat another bite (and I do like spicy food), but it was too hot! All I could taste was cayenne pepper. I had to ask our waiter about it since I literally could not eat it. He informed me that they started adding Frank's Red Hot to the veggie burger recipe. He also said another customer complained that it was spicy. That was disappointing that the recipe had changed so much since I used to really love the veggie burger. He asked if I wanted something else, so I ordered the impossible burger since it's the other veggie option. I ate my side salad while I waited which came without cheese even though I marked on the sheet "cheese is ok" since they usually think I'm vegan from ordering the veggie burger. My impossible burger comes out and I cut into it only to see it is pink! It's obviously not a real burger, so I still bit into it. OMG it was ice cold and not cooked! The top was brown, but when flipped underneath it was totally raw. I was so disgusted at this point (and hungry). I felt so bad, but had to tell our very nice waiter again that I couldn't eat it. He offered to put it back on the grill, but I told him it was okay since my dad was basically done eating at this point. He asked if there was anything else he could bring me like a milkshake. I agreed and got a chocolate milkshake, expecting it to be complimentary for the negative experience. Nope- the milkshake was on the check still! I probably will not go back since the two vegetarian options were both bad. I hope that things change here since we used to visit about twice a month. read more

Burgatory - Fox Chapel - Holy mole - Burgers Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Mmmm! That place is always consistently delicious- even if you dine there or order to go!! My most recent visit, I had the order to go! I had a customized burger. I had mine with horseradish cheddar cheese, (spicy) honey, avocado and pickles! Oh my! This was sooo tasty!! Also, I highly recommend the horseradish cheese! It gives your burger a nice kick without being overly spicy! I also got an order of fries with my sandwich. One thing I did notice, I portion of fries didn't seem consistent. We ordered three burgers with fries and each burger had a different amount of fries. Oh well, they were still yummy though! Finally, did you even go to Burgatory if you didn't order a shake???? I ordered the peanut butter Oreo one! And they give you a thick straw so that you can actually drink the shake! Mmm. Highly recommend! I can't comment on their covid precautions since we got ours to go! If you're in the area, I'd definitely recommend trying this place out at least once! read more

TAKEOUT Experience. I really want to note that this was not customer service related whatsoever but this was a really disappointing quality of food. I also want to note that with the impact of supply chain etc I totally get that places are hurting for quality products. With that being said we ordered takeout and I actually got there before the food was ready since we live about 5 minutes away. We both got chicken burgers and they were just really really bad. Dry, severely over cooked, and burnt. Despite being 5 mins away both of our orders were cold and I'm assuming our fries/chips hadn't been freshly fried. My boyfriends bun was completely stale and I was missing my side of sauce. I wouldn't be as pressed if this was McDonalds but for 30 plus dollars you expect slightly higher quality. read more

See all

This was my first Burgatory experience, so I have no other locations that I can compare it to. That said, the elk and the bacon were superb! I asked the people next to me at the bar what to get and they said the Elk Gone Wild, so I followed suit and ordered it. I slurped down a pint while waiting on my burger, but when it came, oh it was such a beautiful thing. Way too much food, but I certainly didn't mind having leftovers. The elk really wasn't that "game'y", just meaty with a little extra kick. The bacon jam was my jam! I didn't need anything else, but I sure saw other things that I wanted to try. I'll be back, but will probably try a few other locations first before I end up back at this particular one. read more

I do love it here. It's just so expensive. The fries are worth the upcharge though and the hard milkshakes are a treat. Many vegan options including some shakes. read more

This is probably the worst experience I've had at a restaurant so far. 1. My patty came raw (photo attached). I kept tasting blood and feeling nauseated for a good while even after we left. When I told them, she wanted to just reheat it instead of replacing. I asked for it to be replaced. 2. Another burger we ordered as wagyu came as literal white meat chicken. How do you even mess this up?? 3. Waitress was gossiping and explaining what happened to our order to another customer near us and it made us really uncomfortable. 4. It was rather hard to get any staff member's attention and some even saw us raising our hand but blatantly ignored us. 5. No water refills, no cutlery, no napkins For the actual burger review: 1/5 It was very dry, unseasoned, barely any sauce or condiments. They did give us a discount however I still wouldn't recommend this branch or this brand for that matter. read more

Burgatory - Fox Chapel - a hand holding a sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania