Wonderful small town cafe in all the best ways! Stopped in for lunch - got the cheeseburger sub,…read morehubby got burger and fries. Both were good, hot and service was friendly and attentive. Was our first time but won't be the last!

We were not greeted when we arrived and no signage about seating, so we just found a table & sat…read moredown. This was our first and, most likely, last visit. A server, after a short wait, finally came to our table. I asked if the tea was very sweet. She said, "We put a cup of sugar in it." Before I could give her my decision she just turned and started to walk away. I called after her and requested water. I ordered the pizza burger and fries. I used to get the best pizza burgers in my hometown and was hoping for similar. Well, what a disappointment. The burger, (not really sure it was actually beef) was so dry and tasteless. I believe it was taken out of the freezer and tossed on the grill. The fries were typical frozen fries. Our "server" never came back to check on us. My dining partner ordered the meatloaf, "mashed (instant) potatoes and green beans. The meatloaf was awful. No seasoning and very dry. The beans were not seasoned either. The atmosphere is loud and not well decorated. We will not return.

If you blink you'll miss this great place. From the outside you don't think much of it. Once you…read moreenter, it's clean, it feels at home, the staff are great. We were told to sit wherever we like and a server was there fast. I'm new to the area and I've been skeptical to try this place. I'm glad that I did go in. The food was delicious. Fresh and hot. It tasted like the ingredients were made there in house. Definitely going back soon. I only gave 4 based upon the first visit. It'll change if they remain consistent I don't think they will fail me

Have never felt so unwelcome and disrespected in my life. Our server was sweet but the old couple…read morethat literally sat at the bar directly in front of us giving dirty looks for over a half hour even boldly coming to our table taking plates pushing us out the door (assuming owners) if not even more alarming it was out of control. Can only ignore so many eye rolls and dirty looks right in our faces no hiding it. We spent over $400 dollars this weekend Friday stopped and tonight went back. What a terrible experience. I've worked in the industry for years have a pretty tough skin. But sad to see a local business run like that. Do better for your community and staff.

Pleasantly surprised to get such great seafood in Garrett Co. I generally tell people the this is…read morenot the part of the state to get seafood. My mind has been changed. First time there I just wanted to check it out, bought some of their oysters to eat raw, they were excellent. Very fresh. Seafood selection was terrific. A few days later hubby picked up a dozen large steamed crabs. They were wonderful. I was in Baltimore a couple months ago and Trouts prices were actually cheaper, as far as MD blue crabs. Quality was just as good. Can't wait to return. I did buy some cream of crab soup and crab cakes but have not eaten them yet. Please please please get some T-shirts to sell!!!

We were looking for steamed crabs last minute but unfortunately they were out so we settled on crab…read morecakes which were completely amazing - no filler ALL crab - they were the crabbiest crab cakes I ever had and were delicious! We called after we left to ask how to prepare - "just pop them in at 450 for 15-18 minutes - don't touch them" and they were perfect! We'll be back!

I do not say this lightly: this was best fried shrimp I've ever had. Also the best crabcake and…read morefried catfish that have ever graced my palate. The sides were perfection. Just look at the photos- you can see the perfection. Family owned- there were three (maybe four) generations behind the counter and we watched them bread and fry the shrimp and cook everything on demand. Nothing is frozen or pre made. The guys were friendly and fun to chat with; felt like you're at home. This is by far the best soul food seafood restaurant I've ever been to, and besides one other place in Front Royal that offers very different fare it's the best place to get a meal. Please visit this establishment so they stay in business forever. This is the food we all deserve.

Amazing food! Some of the best crab cakes I've had! Worth the stop! Potato salad and Smoky Mac &…read moreCheese on point as well!

Primarily to go only. Friendly, reasonable and very accommodating. We make a point of getting some…read morecrab legs & shrimp every time we camp at Endless Caverns or Shenandoah Valley Campgrounds

Stopped by after Fall Festival in Broadway. Order at window…read moreservice - quaint seafood market with some outdoor seats. reasonably priced - love ending the season with some cheap crabs (@$35/doz). Pre-steamed so super quick pick up. Ice cream shop next door but we didn't try (stuffed with apple fritters fm festival).

If you are looking for a place to eat in the area, stop reading reviews, get in the car, and head…read morestraight to Crabby Maggie's! Five enthusiastic stars up for everything! We had to drop off some items in the area and wanted to get dinner before heading back, so we looked over the menu and reviews. It seemed like it would be perfect for seafood lovers, and we were able to snag one of the last tables available. From the time we walked in, the service was amazing. The staff made great recommendations, checked on us frequently without being intrusive, and made sure we were enjoying our first experience there. Even the other customers were super friendly and told us they had been coming back for years for the great food and service. We both loved our meals. The breading on my fish was really crispy (a recommendation from the server), and the hush puppies were delicious. The portions were very generous, and I really enjoyed my leftovers the next day! The decor there is also super cute. They have several old soda machines outside and adorable crab-themed items inside and outside. Even though it's a bit of a drive, we both agreed that it will be well worth another trip in the future!

The server was extremely tentative and nice. The place was very cute and cozzy. The bathroom could…read moreuse some attention, the sink is like a power washer and a bit aggressive. Regretted getting the crab cluster as it was only one crab when I could've gotten a pound for $5 more. The crab is also cooked plain with an old bay shaker at the table. The bang bang shrimp was very good. My boyfriend got the "crusty Mac" and said there were shells inside the crab cake, wasn't a fan of that and the amount of crab cake in it.

We had crab legs and shrimp as part of a birthday celebration. These were by far the best crab legs…read morethat my husband and I have ever eaten. They were huge, had a ton of meat in them, and were cooked to perfection. We are seafood people and have eaten in several places along the eastern coast, and Captain Billy's far surpasses them all. The shrimp were great too - not over done, large, and had the perfect amount of seasoning. We will definitely be ordering from here!

Friendly service and the food is always top notch. Capt. Billys is our family favorite place to get…read moreseafood here in the valley.

First time in DCL and we wanted a dinner that was light and enjoyable. Thanks to Yelp I was able…read moreto survey the local food scene and this was one of the ones that I tagged. Well we are glad I did, first the location is a little off the main road but up atop a small rise. Outside tables and inside greet you at this great little restaurant. We had Calamari appetizer that was lightly breaded and served with sweet chili dipping sauce very good. Then main courses included Crab cake sandwich NO filler most crab, fish and onion rings (yep), cod sandwich and seared ahi tuna (seasoned with old Bay and Blackened seasoning). All members throughly enjoyed dinner and would go back. So if you are looking for a seafood restaurant in DCL here you go. Sorry no pictures as we were really hungry and ate the food immediately. Next time.

Had the blackened Mahi mahi tacos. Absolutely brilliant. Can't wait to try the dinner…read more Friendly and professional staff,

Wow! This is a must visit if you're at Deep Creek. A local establishment with plenty of room for…read moreindoor or outdoor dining. Honestly, Dutch's exceeded my expectations, as the fine dining options in the area are limited. I got the pork chop with apple crisp and it was delectable! Thick-cut and juicy, which are hard to find. Others at the table got the salmon and they liked it. You get bread, salad, and a side with the entrees, so come hungry! Our waiter was attentive and very professional. Look forward to the next visit.

We arranged to come here for my friend's bachelorette dinner. The restaurant is beautiful just like…read moreits sister restaurant in Frederick, Dutch's Daughter. The food was delicious as expected. The service was amazing. Not only were all the staff friendly but our server in particular made our bride to be feel extra special. We still talk about that dinner years later!

Friendly service, nice portions and everything tasty! Very reasonable prices too! Will visit again.read more

This place is a sold three and a half stars but I'll give it four because the half isn't an option…read more I'll be honest and say that we were not expecting much and in a way that is what we got. It obviously is catered to an older crowd, which is fine, and other places do that way worse. We walked in and were greeted by a very cheesy Elvis statue. So that set the tone as we half giggled and cringed. The wait staff was very friendly and allowed us to choose where we wanted to sit. The table and light fixtures seemed clean enough but the floor has definitely seen better days. We were handed a menu that was much smaller than I expected and I was very happy for that. We ordered our food and in less than ten minutes we had it. The food was served nice and warm-hot. We immediately felt that it is a comfort food. The taste was fine but improved after we added salt and pepper (most places that cater to elderly tend to not season their food a lot) and we were more than pleased with the meal. The serving size was spot on for us and the price was more than reasonable. I was not expecting to like it as much as I did and as a result will definitely go again next time I'm in the area and feeling hungry.