Best kept secret in Silt, Colorado! Food is excellent with a large variety from salads to pizza to subs. Bakery items are fantastic as well, cookies, pies, mini cheesecakes, brownies and more. Service is down home friendly, prompt and efficient. Clean, comfortable and family friendly with a full bar as well. Conveniently located just off I70 about 3/4 of a mile. Plenty of parking as well. If you're in the area don't miss it read more

See all

Great crust on the pizza! Amazing bakery items! I love the cream puffs. Cute little place and staff is patient and helpful! read more

Burning Mountain Pizza & Subs - Bruschetta Pizza, so yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Silt, Colorado

Made daily-Pastries are amazing as always. You can't go wrong when choosing one, or two, or three! read more

Burning Mountain Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Silt, Colorado

Seriously one of the best gluten free sandwiches I've ever had. I actually asked to make sure it was gf. I'm very sensitive to gluten and didn't get sick as well! read more

Burning Mountain Pizza & Subs - Gluten free Turkey sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Silt, Colorado

We this is my favorite gem of a restaurant/bakery here in the town of Silt, Co. it's got everything you need small town country vibe with delicious bakery items, to delicious pizza and sandwich items and great wings to. My favorite menu item is their arugula salad, by far the best honey balsamic dressing on the western slope of Colorado. The service is good and the food is fresh, lots of people in the community come here daily for gathering and that's nice to see. See you next time read more

Burning Mountain Pizza & Subs - Buffalo Chicken Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Silt, Colorado

See all

This is a really great place to eat. I've had a number of their menu items besides their pizzas, they are always top-quality. The desserts are incredible as you are able to see all of them as you walk in the door. The ambience with two separate dining rooms along with a bar atmosphere on one side with big screens... Not to mention the live entertainment on some nights, this place truly has it all and the employees are just as awesome! read more

We always stop here in our way through Silt. Pizza is always good but their baked items are really where it's at!

The food was delicious, best pizza I've had in a while. We also picked up some Cream Cheese pastries for breakfast in the morning. The waitress set aside the ones we wanted until we checked out because they were running low. The waitress was very friendly and attentive. The establishment was very clean. The only negative was the music was a little loud, but it was a good variety of music. read more

Great pizzeria and fair prices! Awesome gluten free pizza. They also have a very good bakery and even gluten-free items as well! read more

Pizza is paper thin, nothing but grease, as little cheese and toppings as possible for way too much money. Sandwiches are 80% bread for, again, way too much money. Food was 30 min late. No apology, no compensation. Terrible place. read more

If you are planning to eat in, it's possible, but certainly not a five star for an eat in. The ambience for an eat in was lacking. On the other hand for takeout my wife and I loved the pizza. And let's be clear their primary business is takeout. Their website says they make their own sauce and dough each day onsite. That was obvious. The crust was fabulous and I really liked their sauce. Also, I read some comments on other Yelp reviews about the staff being rude, but I beg to the contrary. The reception was topnotch. Extraordinarily friendly. read more

This place is a keeper! We were passing through headed back to Florida when we decided to stay the night in Silt, CO. After looking through the selection of restaurants we decided to try Burning Mountain. Wow, good choice as it turns out. Probably the best pizza I've had in years. They make everything fresh each day including the dough and sauce. I had the Honey Badger individual size and enjoyed every bite. We finished with a coconut cream pie slice, amazing flaky crust and not too sweet. I only wish they were in Florida. I left without my hat, when I realized it I returned to recover it. The waitress had kept it for me. Nice folks. read more

This place is not on the beaten path. We found it when searching for a place to eat on our trip from Glenwood Springs to Rifle. It took a bit to get waited on as the staff seemed to be interacting with the regulars there. We had pizza and salad. The salad was very fresh and loaded with goodies. The pizza was topped well and the red sauce was well seasoned. They had a pastry case that had lots of options like cookies, lemon cheesecake, Raspberry brownies and peanut butter fudge pie. We took a piece of the pie to go and it was very good! read more

We were in the area so we ordered take out. They do have a drive up window which is a nice option. I ordered a Rueben sandwich and it was decent enough but not a standout. There was a fair amount of meat but the dressing was minimal. On the plus side it was a good sized sandwich. We also ordered a cheese pizza which looked good but was not very tasty. It certainly had a decent amount of cheese and I had a couple of slices but the flavor was just not that exciting. It was palatable but seemed flat to me. I'd rate this place as acceptable and with the drive through it is a place to consider when going for take out. I have no idea what the inside looked like so perhaps another time we'll give it another try. read more

They have vegan cheese! I have always loved their pizza but ordering a pizza without cheese always made me sad. I I can enjoy these amazing pizzas they way god intended - with cheese! The staff is also super friendly and we feel like family every time we come in. read more

Holy crap!! Okay...so I've been staying at the Holiday Inn Express here in Silt over the years on my way to visit family...however this was the first time I've eaten here and it may have just been the best pizza of my life! I was able to visit with one of the owners and she told me about all of the handmade items and the flour from Italy ...OMG...this little town and this restaurant are now a destination!! Eat here!!!!!! read more

Being a local, I love the idea of having a small joint to have drinks, apps and desserts nearby. I honestly like this place but over the past couple of years, the food has gone WAY up and the service has been just terrible. The owners have been nice and friendly over the years but FOH has be dismal to say the least. The past few visits have been pretty bad but the last one did it for us. We sat with 6 people waiting to be acknowledged and for 10 minutes, the server just walked passed us. She did finally say "I'll be right with you" and then walked to another table who walked in 5 minutes after us and took their order. As we walked out, the server was snotty and said "Bye" with a major attitude. Maybe we will go back but only after they get better help. read more

Really great pizza joint with an amazing and somewhat surprising made from scratch gluten free crust. My wife and l loved the food and the staff was so great and friendly. The atmosphere is pretty great also, with a wide variety of offerings from the bar to tables and booths. A definite must while in Silt. read more

Update to past review. What happened to Burning Mountain? They used to be a 4-1/2 to 5. Now it doesn't seem like the same place. My husband brought home 2 XL pizzas for Avs game for us, my daughter & son-in-law. We were all sooo disappointed! Two pizzas (at $33 each) that we would've been better off buying from Costco. Usually I am filled up with 1-2 pieces. The margarita pizza was see-through! Both crusts were thin & not what we are used to from BMP&S. I was glad I made an excellent salad to accompany & we had desserts, which they still make well. read more

Burning Mountain Pizza & Subs - See through pizza. Used to be my favorite pizza place. So sad now... - Pizza Near Me - Silt, Colorado

See all

Both owners as well as whichever ones daughter working here are absolutely obnoxious. It started out as an OK place to eat, then steadily it went downhill from there. It takes forever to get any sort of service from thier staff, the pizza and pastries are incredibly overpriced, and the owners and thier daughter(s) are some of the most rude and demeaning people we've ever met. It's common to talk with other locals and hear the exact same sentiment regarding Burning MTN Pizza, so we all go to Brickhouse or Hogback Pizza instead where they're much more attentive, the pizza is 10x better, and service is always friendly. I could never suggest this place. read more

We were looking for a quick lunch stop not too far off I-70 and Burning Mountain fit the bill. Our BLT sandwich and pesto pizza were both tasty as was the brownie from the sweets case. Lunch came out quickly and hot. Service was good. Pleased with this stop. read more

Burning Mountain Pizza & Subs - Pesto pizza - Pizza Near Me - Silt, Colorado

See all

Great meat lovers and cheese pizza, buffalo wings, and desserts. Whole family loved it!

If I'm going on a road trip and I-70 is the slightly longer route, I will still take it because that means I'll get to stop and eat here. Every time I come in, the pastry case is filled with decedent desserts that will tempt even the most stringent health nut. The only negative I can say is their cinnamon rolls have ruined most cinnamon rolls for me because I always compare them to Burning Mountain's cinnamon rolls and every where else's always fall short. The pizza is delicious and their breakfast sandwiches melt in your mouth. The atmosphere is friendly and sitting at the bar and enjoying a drink, you can experience all the hospitality and community of a small town. I always recommend Burning Mountain as a stop when road tripping on I-70. So far no one I've recommended this gem to has been disappointed. read more

Burning Mountain Pizza & Subs - Pizza Near Me - Silt, Colorado

See all

not easy to find a good Buffalo chicken sandwich In Colorado. These guys nailed it! great bread, good spicy chicken- lettuce tomato and provolone. All you need. quick friendly service. thanks! read more

Great restaurant! I've been told many times to go try this place. I finally got there with my husband. It was so tasty and the service was top notch. Our server was very courteous. It's your neighborhood local pizza joint with extras. We got the spinach artichoke dip and the hot honey pizza. The dip was yummy, the pizza was memorable (sauce was tasty, and the crust was fluffy, and the beer selection (especially during happy hour) were great. We'll be back. Thanks for a great meal. read more

I stayed night at a motel in this small town of Silt on the way to Denver CO in August, 2019. The lady at the front desk told me this place, and I found the Arugura pizza my favorite!!! I will come back there for the pizza next time I go there, for sure. read more

Burning Mountain Pizza & Subs - Arugula Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Silt, Colorado

We were given a gift certificate to this restaurant and was our first time dining here. What an amazing place. The food was amazingly delicious. It's difficult to find places with gluten free options and was surprised that the owner's make their GF bread on location. The pastrami sandwich was my choice and my daughter had the meatball sub. We topped it off with the GF cheesecake. If you're looking for somewhere to eat other than fast food, you need to try Burning Mountain. read more

Sandwich's were bigger than I expected which is always a dub in my book, the service is quick and friendly and the setting is peaceful and calm love it ! read more

We are working in the area for 6 months. Usually a "pizza place"'isn't a place I'd go to multiple times it their menu is such that you can go multiple times and eat different each time. I've had pizza, salads and sandwiches and they have all been good. This caprese salad is one of my favorites. Service can be slow which is the only reason for the 4 rating instead of 5 read more

Burning Mountain Pizza & Subs - Caprese Salad - Pizza Near Me - Silt, Colorado

I got the pesto, my partner got the Hawaiian pizza. Both were delicious with a true Neapolitan-style crust. But, seriously, the pies and sweets are the star of this place. Coconut cream pie and cookie were truly scrumptious. The full bar rounded out our lunch and I will return again. Recommended. read more

Awesome place with oodles of gluten free options. Friendly service, clean and inviting environment. The pizza was delicious and the hubby enjoyed his rueben. Would absolutely stop here again. read more

Burning Mountain Pizza & Subs - Arugula pizza in gluten free crust. Divine!!! - Pizza Near Me - Silt, Colorado

My husband and I came here on a Sunday evening, and were immediately seated. There is a sign on every table warning of longer wait times due to being short staffed, which is understandable. My husband and I ordered some cheesy garlic bread, as well as split a personal sized Colorado Hawaiian pizza. Everything was super well prepared, the portion size ended up being perfect for the two of us to split and still be able to get dessert afterwards, and we just had a great time. I would definitely come back here. read more

We got lucky and stumbled onto this place. Fantastic little restaurant with pizza, salads, sandwiches, and desserts, plus a full bar. We had a garden salad, buffalo pizza, and regular pepperoni pizza. All were great. Service is good and food came out quick. read more

Pizza was good, but nothing special. The desserts were a different story... super terrific!

Pizza, and subs, and desserts... OH MY! Delicious food and sweets! And... what a surprising fun spot for a cocktail! Ask for the Cherry Bourbon Smash! ; ) read more

After my 1st visit, following day at 2pm... pizza ovens were down until late evening or perhaps tomorrow (which is July 4th, so it's doubtful they'd be open). I could have had a cold sandwich or deli salad, but after being on the road for months, if I eat another of either, I'm gonna scream, cuz I like neither but have had far too many of both. I get it, things break, but the day before I had weak coffee & today, couldn't get pizza. I wouldn't bother again. Downgrading to 2* out of 5. read more

Just moved to the Silt area and this will absolutely be my go to pizzeria. I grew up in New York, as did my husband, and we both agreed that this pizza is one of the best we have had in the 6 years we have lived in Colorado, and the best we have had on the Western Slope. Not to mention, the wings were stellar! Will make this a regular spot! read more

Driving from LA to Greeley and starving, we stopped at the best pizza place! Had a Caesar salad to start, home-made dressing... yum! The pizza was amazing. Great flavor and terrific crust. Now desert, their cream puffs are delicious and the key lime pie! I got a cookie to go. This place is worth the stop. read more

I try so hard with this place but the service always proves to just be just silly. This particular experience I started calling them at 715 on a Thursday evening to hopefully get dinner on the way home from Rifle. The auto attendant was 'not taking orders'. When I bypassed it to hopefully get someone, no one answered. I tried three times on our way there. No out going message or anything. We still drove by and saw the open sign and started looking forward to our order. Place was fairly busy and no one came up to us. I grabbed a menu and then a young lady came up and looked at me like I had three heads. Once she learned I did not have a call in already, she said we are closed. It was 7:55. I tried to get service for over 45 minutes. We LOVE pizza and the likes and spend a lot of $ monthly on it and it is just so bizarre to me how hard it is with this place. The prices for what you get kind of make me twitch but I was always willing to if it was good. I don't think I will be able to talk m y husband into going back for yet another try. read more

We stayed in so were the night on a work trip and needed to grab lunch to go but didn't see any delis that were open. Found the spot and we were able to get delicious lunch sandwiches and to go cold sandwiches for lunch. The breakfast sandwich was so delicious. The lunch sandwich I think had a little bit too much bread the bread to tutor ratio wasn't the best but overall definitely still get this place five stars. read more