I really wanted to love it. I like a SLICE of pie from a pie shop (more homey), not a mini pie in a small foil cup. This place only has mini pies and Large pies for sale. The mini pies were all refrigerated and were mostly cream pies (peanut butter, coconut custard, Key lime, etc) The whole pies for sale were more like pecan , apple and berry. We chose a mini key lime pie for $6 (which I thought was pricey for Texas). The only utensils they offer are wooden - and I have a real dislike of wooden sticks in my mouth (it's a real thing my friend make fun of called "xylophobia") I hate the taste of the wood and I fear splinters for some reason. Anyway, lucky my hubby had a plastic fork in the car. The key lime was tasty, but pretty small for $6. The counter gal was very nice and agreed she also didn't like wooden utensils! read more

See all

Yummy yummy yummy !! Love the pies and the people are amazing too! Keep up the good work and I will keep coming.

After my favorite location in Allen closed, I am glad that somebody bought a franchise in Forney. This location doesn't accept online orders ( maybe because of the holidays) but you have to go and check out what is left, no guarantee that they have all the flavors! Same quality, same taste. Will go back again. read more

I have not 1 complaint with what I purchased! The staff was so nice and patient (my 1st time here) and all the pies were fresh and delicious. I don't like overly sweet items and they made them perfectly. The restaurant was so quaint and inviting. I will most certainly be back. read more

See all

I went here after my dentist appointment as I really wanted to check this place out. Out on display they have the mini pies and on the counter the larger pies. I am sure the bigger ones are in the back in the refrigerator. So mini pies are 1 - $4.75 4 for $16 12 for $50 Large pies are - $26 I ended up getting the 4 for $16 dollars so we can try each of them. They do have a rewards program which is very nice and the cashier said they do add up really quickly and I was laughing at that part, but I understand why now as they were addicting. My wife and I ended up eating all 4 of the pies for lunch and then for dinner, it was that great. We tried the following 1. Southern Custard 2. Coconut Cream Pie 3. Key Lime Pie 4. Peanut Butter One My favorite one had to be the coconut cream pie, but my wife said it was very sweet, but it is the way I like it. I would definitely come back here again. Maybe I should walk here to burn off the calories. read more

See all

The pies are really good and fresh. The staff has excellent customer service, I recommend this place of your in Forney!

I've had the opportunity to get a pie from buttermilk Sky pie shop on three occasions now and they haven't let me down yet. The pies are always delicious but I would have to say my favorite is the I-40. I've also tried and liked the peanut buttercream, Nana's pecan, And Granny's Apple. They also have a variety of seasonal pies available throughout the year, for instance at the time of me writing this review I believe their seasonal pie is spiced pumpkin pie. The only downside is they are a bit pricey but for the quality, I believe it's worth the extra bit of money in this case. Food. Great Service. Good Cleanliness.Great Consistency. Great Variety. Good Value.Good read more

See all

Got a small apple pie. Hands down one of the worst pies I've ever had. The pie was not cooked properly the whole top of the pie was moist and goopy. There was flour or cornstarch still on some of the apple. I asked for a refund and the employee didn't even know how to refund or could get permission to refund me. I'm having to wait and follow up to be refunded which is silly. I returned the pie within a few minutes of purchasing it and showed the pie to the employee. read more

I ordered a dozen four inch pies. Including; cherry, apple, chocolate cream, key lime, snickerdoodle, and peanut butter. Peanut butter was the best! Light and airy peanut butter with a chocolate graham crust.... Chocolate cream and cherry were bomb too. Key lime lacked. Little punch to me, but it was still really tasty. My husband picked up the order with no issues and says the staff was very personable. read more

Oh My Goodness! It's so worth the trip over for this pie! Store front is cute and tidy. Workers sweet and efficient. We made sure to go early to get what we wanted but they had plenty. This trip we tried coconut cream pie, chocolate cream pie, and the I-40 pie. Delicious every one!!! We will be back soon. Thank you Buttermilk Sky!! read more

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Small I-40 pie. Warmed and then a scoop of vanilla ice cream!! Delicious!! - Bakeries Near Me - Forney, Texas

See all

A great place to get all kinds of pies. Went in over Thanksgiving and the employee, maybe the owner, was super sweet. Super helpful.

We ordered the key lime pie. It was amazing. Our son, who is a key lime pie snob said it was excellent.

I tried their key lime pie and it is perfectly balanced! It's not overly tart and not overly sweet either. The graham crust also tastes fresh and complemented the key lime! I cannot wait to come back and try their other flavors for my cheat day! read more

Say it slowly with me, "Key...Lime....Pie".... That's all you need to know/remember. It's not tart or mouth puckering like most. The lime flavor here is evidently present, but mild. Upon entering you notice the cute farmhouse, rustic decor (my home decor btw), but are immediately drawn to the euphoric smells of warm vanilla and sugar. Pure ecstasy; must be what heaven smells like. They also provide punch cards; beneficial for returning guests such as myself. Just left this place with a personal sized key lime pie and I'm already regretting such a minuscule order... "My husband ate it." Yeah, that's what I'll tell them. "My husband ate all of my pie." **Grabs Car Keys** read more

See all

Very tasty treats. I adore their mini selection of 4 pies. Each one is two servings for us so we get 8 desserts! Prior to getting it here I had never had Buttermilk pie! A must try, I get it every time I go in now. Their fruit pies are seasonal so call ahead if you want something specific, they may not have it. read more

After our Saturday night Cajun dinner, we needed sugar fix so Mr Google led us here. The place is small and located inside of a strip mall. The parking slots are small so heads up if you have an SUV with those doors. You enter and have small cakes running close to $5. The inside is small and really no place to sit and eat it. The cashier really didn't help just and just kept looking at us. The family each selected a different pie so we can see who's belly would be happier. The pies are the size of a frozen pot pie. Our selection included chocolate silk, pecan and chocolate, banana cream pie and chocolate chip. The chocolate silk wasn't that light but ok. The banana cream pie had a Great crust but average filling. The pecan chocolate was very good and well the chocolate chip one was my 2 year old so untouched. The cost was $17 and ok visit read more

See all

We tried the sampler and we loved both the strawberry pie (seasonal) and the apple pie. Those are the ones we tried and really liked. The other ones were meh. I don't even remember which the other ones were which says something. I would recommend this place for a special occasion or to bring to a dinner party. A little on the pricey side but worth it. read more

Great pies ! Great service ! Our favorite was the strawberry pie. Runner up and close favorite was the Coconut cream pie. The crust is a lovely shortbread crust, so it's not the flaky pie crust that most people expect. Don't let that deter you, the only thing you'll regret is not getting a full sized pie. read more

The pies are absolutely amazing! My husband moved down to Forney back in December, found the shop immediately, and raved about the pie flight. I finally got to try some recently and it is BEYOND amazing! I personally got the Coconut Cream Pie, which was delicious and the coconut on top was perfectly toasted. I also tried the Key Lime, and it was immaculate; probably the best key lime pie I've ever had. read more

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Coconut Cream Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Forney, Texas

By chance, I spotted this gem from the road, and made a stop here. Glad I did. Very nice boutique pie shop, bakery in back, and with Drive-thru window! Staff was awesome providing background & info, convinced me to buy a 4 pie deal. Regular sized pies, and 4 inch pies. Also catering order 2 inch pies. There are tags, cards, & labels for gifting. Wooden single use forks, spoons, & server too. If the pie is a gift to yourself, have a seat inside, or outside in front. You won't make it to your car. I ate the Southern Custard first. The crust seemed like a sugar cookie, light & sweet, and great Custard flavor filling. I have 3 more to take home, if I can resist. Parking here is the challenge, the parking lot dead-ends, if full, you must back-out. Better to park & walk a little bit, or use drive-thru. Other than that, a very nice place to make at least one stop in your life. Not far from US Hwy 80, or Interstate 20. Or drive down from Rockwall, Texas. read more

See all

Excellent pecan pie! I preordered online, and the pie was ready at my pickup time. I used the convenient drive-thru since it was a cold day. I am looking forward to trying other flavors next time. read more

Love this sweet locally owned store! I've been to the Forney location and the flower mound location and both do not disappoint. The pies are amazing and my personal favorite is the apple. read more

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - Coffee mug and dark roast coffee grounds - Bakeries Near Me - Forney, Texas

My apartment manager got these for the residents on Pi Day; original I know, but WOW these were so good! We received a chocolate cream & nanny's pecan. Jeeeeeez! I wish I had 100 more of them! You guys have a special product! Keep up the good work, and thank you to Nikita, the Property Manager at Bandera at Preston Hollow. read more

This place is absolutely delicious!!! My favorites are the chocolate cream & apple pies! My only complaint is they consistently close like 10+ mins EARLIER than their posted hours. It's happened to me several times, so if you're considering going close to closing, don't bother. Still giving 5 stars though cause the pies are amazing!!! read more

Pie was great. Space was cute. They didn't appear to offer exactly what was online but the gentleman working the day we went in made up for it by offering sister a free pie to try. Next I'm in the area I'd try again. read more

Buttermilk Sky Pie is located on a very busy street in Forney, TX. Be careful not to miss your turn into the parking lot. Aside from the logistic issues, this little shop is amazing to get your fat on. LOL. They even have a drive thru. The staff is friendly and nice! They even have a punch card that will earn you a free pie after so many purchases. Food Review: Southern Custard - smooth, creamy, sweet filling with perfect crust, is soooo yummy. It taste like a homemade Chest Pie ( if you've had one) Key Lime - perfect balance of tart and sweet filling in a graham cracker crust is terrific. It's my favorite, if I dare to have one. Chewy Chocolate Chip - it tastes like a chocolate chip cookie. It's ok and better with ice cream. Nanny's Pecan - sweet, sticky, gooey filling, overloaded with pecans will satisfy any sweet tooth. It taste like a homemade Southern pecan pie. Oh so delicious! Granny's Apple - perfect filling with soft cinnamon spiced apples in a golden crust topped with brown sugar crumbles is ahhh maze ing. *highly recommend to take a tower or two into the office in place of the boring routine donuts* read more

Incredible pies!! Perfect for holidays, celebrations or anytime a flavorful pie calls out to you, Buttermilk Sky is the place to go.

First thing that comes to mind: sweet The shortbread crust is a great texture, and a great pairing with the pie fillings. My only complaint is you end up with a sugar high with the level of sugar they put within the crust and filling. The sugar doesn't overtake the flavoring of ingredients but is a strong point where your teeth and heart hurt after. read more

Pies taste like sugar overload. Just was too sugary. Key lime pie had no lime flavor. They should call it a key sugar cane pie. Tried several pies and disliked them all. #dibetes. read more

OMG. If you want a homemade pie . This is the place to go! They have single pie for one person. Or you can always get a whole pie. Some of our favorites are Key-lime, Custard, Chocolate Chip pies, and at least 7 or 8 more pie flavors. They even have a drive-Thru. They have only been open about a year or 18 month's. The nicest folks you will ever meet. Y'all come by, you hear? read more

OH MY GOODNESS The pies.... The cloud cookies If you're looking for heaven you have found it my friend. read more

Great pies, so many flavors that I love the variety pack of a few flavors. Good was to satisfy the whole family. I just wish the pie shell had a bit more salt. read more

The shop is super cute. The pies are delicious. I love the chocolate chip one and my kids really like the key lime pie. Not only is the pie yummy, but they are also so supportive of the community. They were very generous to the North Forney baseball team, and their donations helped make our end of season banquet so much fun. read more

Amazing pies with delicious flavors for individual servings. I use them for family events and small intimate dinners and gatherings. It gives my guests the option to have an amazing dessert. They can choose to eat it all or take it home since it comes with its own top. The workers are always so nice and explain any new pie choice's available. read more

Y'all, they have a drive thru and mini pies! Their chocolate chip pie was delicious and chewy. Key lime was amazing. Customer service was very friendly, we'll definitely be back! read more

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - 4" pie - Bakeries Near Me - Forney, Texas

How do you not give this place 5 stars? Delicious! I mean my goodness! I especially love that they have 4" pies, just enough for a great desert without having a full size pie, imo a perfect portion. So far I have tried to key lime and the peanut butter pies and I cant figure out which one I like more. My wife had the blueberry and the chewy chocolate chip and she said the same thing, too good to decide. Give this place a try, you wont regret it. Also the younger girl that was working was super nice and helpful! We will definitely be back! read more

Ok!! This place has some of the best pecan pies I've ever had!! Also their "turtle" pie is amazing. I can't say enough about this place! Freshest ingredients..excellent pies! It's definitely worth checking out. Forney is lucky to have this place for sure!!! read more

They went above and beyond for us. We sure appreciate them and the pie was delicious!! The owner and staff were so nice and accommodating.

Price is high for the pies but it's worth it. Southern custard is a must try. They no longer do punch cards though.

This is a very cute pie shop. I love the mini pies that I can eat and not feel guilty about eating an entire pie by myself.