I want here for the first time after hearing good things about it. The bartender was very attentive. The bruschetta was fantastic and the best I've ever had. The tortellini with smoked ham and peas (with vodka sauce instead of creamy white sauce) was excellent. The Cosmo martini was very good too. The ambience is very nice and the owner spared no expense. This is a great date place! I will definitely be back. read more

Cafe Pomigliano - The tortellini with peas and mushrooms - excellent! - Italian Near Me - Green Oaks, Illinois

See all

Not our style but great for families bar friends or large meetings. We kinda came in after hours for a meal and it felt rushed. Huuuuge conference/open area in the middle. read more

We went as a family group of nine, three children and 6 adults. We were celebrating my wife's birthday and this was a great choice. Salads and appetizers were great . Everyone enjoyed their meals , and I specifically want to rank mine as 5 stars! I had the spaghetti carbonara and it was as good as you can get in Rome ! Made with guanciale and a proper pecorino Romano sauce ! This is as good as it gets. The tiramisu and cannoli were top notch dessert choices . Service was very good , and we will definitely be back. read more

Service was wonderful. We were a large group and had to get our son back to the naval base and so the server kindly served quickly. The food was hot and everything was wonderful. read more

Good food revised name and new location. Service was excellent. Ambiance was good. Love the angel hair pasta. Miss the clams.

Dee at Cafe Pomigliano was fantastic. We had hosted a shower at the restaurant. The food was delicious and the venue was so warm and inviting. Dee was so helpful in making sure we had everything we would need and very easy to work with. The staff was also polite and made sure that the guests were taken care of. I would recommend this venue . Truly authentic Italian meals. Thank you for making our day so special and memorable. read more

We thought we would try the new location since their move from Libertyville. I think they forgot to bring grandmas recipes with them. I had the spaghetti and meatballs. The meatball was incredibly dry. Noodles were cut into pieces. The marinara sauce was bland. I've had better store bought sauce. My husband had the braciole with gnocchi. He felt the whole thing lacked flavor and the gnocchi was barely cooked. This makes us really sad. Knowing that for years they were one of the best. Can't say we will ever be back. Our waiter was great! Danny was attentive and responsive . Unfortunately he cant fix what happens in the kitchen. read more

Cafe Pomigliano - Spaghetti and meatballs. - Italian Near Me - Green Oaks, Illinois

We came here for a family event. The space is great, service was very attentive, and the food was delicious! We were very happy. Would definitely consider for an intimate meal or a big party. Plenty of parking, too! read more

Cafe Pomigliano - Eggplant parmigiana - Italian Near Me - Green Oaks, Illinois

See all

We went last night with a very dear friend to dine at this fine resturant! The owners are Nick and Patty! We sat under a covered patio! They served bread with oil and cheese ! I had a house side salad very good quality greens ! We had bruschetta first a starter ! It was fine! The egg plant was tender and delicious ! The side corkscrew pasta was ok! My daughter and I shared cannoli lots of pistachios yum! Our friend had tiramisu which he loved! It was a lovely time ! I recommend giving this family owned resturant a try! read more

Cafe Pomigliano - Egg plant parmigiana Side of pasta - Italian Near Me - Green Oaks, Illinois

Came in when I was in the area for business at the recommendation of my manager, who is local to the area. When we arrived at 5pm on a Tuesday it was pretty empty with the exception of a few people at the bar. The parking at the time was plentiful as it has its own parking lot just off the downtown strip in Libertyville. There is a nice patio area with a fire pit that I would imagine would be great during a nice spring evening. The service was decent. Could seem to be a little slow if I you arent engaged in good conversation (i.e. if you had a bad date it would seem slow). I ordered the Tortellini Carbonara and finished with Spumoni. I also had a glass of Brassfield Pinot Nior, which was a decent pour, and a nice flavor. The pasta was great, and enormous. It would be great to share a plate to try different ones or to have almost 3 meals worth for the cost. The Spumoni serving was also very large. It was very good as well. Prices were decent (although, I come from Orange County, California, so I don't have a good grasp on what local food costs in this area). Overall, it was a great little place i wouldn't mind revisiting when I am back in Illinois for business. read more

Cafe Pomigliano - Tortellini carbonara. Recommend! - Italian Near Me - Green Oaks, Illinois

This place is in a sports bar with big screen tvs everywhere. We were hoping for a real Italian experience but this was far from it.

A crowd pleaser of an Italian restaurant! Definitely a good place to take visiting family for a Nice but not Fancy dinner. The ambiance and service were both superb. The dining area was very big and open, with lots of windows letting in natural light. Our server brought out extra portions of bruschetta (we had five people, bruschetta usually has four pieces), they helped us cork our wine bottle and wrapped it up nicely for the drive home, and generally were very friendly and attentive. The food was good! The bread was some of the best I've had in a while. No complaints on the entrees - I got the salmon, which had a nice crusty sear on both sides. It was cooked well, if a bit salty. Others at my table got pasta dishes, which were all delicious. There was a good variety of entrees on the menu, and the portions were incredibly generous - easily enough to feed two in my opinion. Everything came out of the kitchen fairly quickly. Overall, I left incredibly full and satisfied - exactly how I want to feel coming out of an Italian place. read more

See all

We have tried Cellar 26 before and I have to say this probably will be the last We did the prefix meal, the food and the most part was horrible and cold. The service was lacking in every respect a meal that should only take maybe two hours to 3 1/2 to spend $200 and to get cold food that's horrible. read more

If I had an option, I would give this place a 3.5 rating. The fire pit located right before the main doors is a great idea, specially for a cold evening. The interiors are sleek, and the overall service was attentive and efficient. On a Friday night, the place had a lively and happy vibe. We were seated on the patio which was covered and heated (hence, the pictures that I took looked dark red from the red heaters:). Foodwise, my friend and I were able to try the SKIRT STEAK VELASCO and the BRICK CHICKEN. The chicken was cooked perfectly, crispy skin on the outside and juicy meat inside. The spicy lemon sauce was light enough not to overpower the dish and I also loved the brocollini. Unfortunately, the Skirt Steak was a complete disappointment. Besides being cooked right, the dish was bland. The meat did not have any seasonings and we could not taste the white wine garlic sauce at all. The roasted jalapenos gave heat to the dish but that was it, just heat and no flavor. This was a pleasant experience for my first time trying this place out since I have only tried the places along Milwaukee Ave in downtown Libertyville. I like that this is kind of hidden from the town's busy business scene although it is only open until 10pm since the dinner crowd would usually go to the bars or other places down the street (accdg to the bartender). I'll probably come back to try other menu items and sit at the patio area when it gets warmer...probably:) read more

See all

Great Libertyville location off the strip and with its own parking lot. That's unique in Libertyville and worth a star at least. Inside is nice and cozy, bar is well stocked and comfortable. The table service was a little slow considering the volume of customers. Had some calamari to start and that was good. I had the chicken parmesan with a side of spaghetti. The red sauce was thin and bland. The chicken was two thin breaded filets with sauce and a barely melted square slice of cheese. This too was bland and not the most robust presentation. There are other Italian restrauants in the area I prefer. read more

Cafe Pomigliano - Italian Near Me - Green Oaks, Illinois

Situated just off the main drag in Libertyville, "Cafe Pom" is a delight and a gem. My husband and I have gone here for "date night" several times as well as taken my parents and friends. The food is always fresh and well prepared. We love the calamari and I've had the fried brussel sprouts recently as well. The eggplant stack is amazing with the reduction of basalmic vinegar. My favorite dinner dish is so good that I can't stray - I get the eggplant parmesan on almost any visit. They have a pretty decent wine selection as well! read more

Very friendly restaurant and beautiful interior. They do absolutely everything right except the food. It was around $25 for every plate of pasta and all of our food tasted so bland. Herbless, spiceless, and definitely undersalted sauces on top of overcooked noodles. If you want a nice night out, this is a nice place; if you miss Italian food after a recent vacation, this will not hit the spot. read more

We returned after an absence dating back to pre-Covid. This was a fave of ours, but no more. The service was spotty, the quality of the food was definitely a step below previous experiences there, and the 'vibe' just wasn't there the night we were there. Overall, our venture back was sub-par. And we're likely not going to return for quite a while. read more

so disappoisted in the new location. they've not only lost the ambiance they only had the food has also lost its appeal. ordered the chicken Marsala and it was like eating chicken with brown gravy. probably will not be back and we loved them since their oroginal Libertyville location. and the place was empty. the kitchen needs some help read more

They're open now and they are AMAZING!! The inside is modern and earthy. The staff is very friendly and knowledgable. This is a very traditional Italian restaurant that made my Italian in-laws very happy! The water glasses are cut wine bottles. So cute! They serve bread with a side of Parmesan cheese and olive oil. The olive oil they serve is very light. We went through a TON of cheese and the bread was very warm and fresh. The Chicken Marsala I ordered was fantastic. So much flavor, and I was forced to share since it smelled so good. It came with a side of pasta with marinara sauce. The sauce was spicy and full of flavor just like I like! My husband had spaghetti and meatballs and the meatballs were very spicy. Lots of pepper. The Parmesan fries that came with the veal Parmesan sandwich were savory. We were all incredibly impressed and cannot wait to return! read more

See all

I can't bring myself to give this restaurant more than three stars--it is a mix of upscale sports bar décor, a very positive alert wait-staff and, from my perspective, ordinary food. As to the food, I ordered the lasagna, finding it to be overcooked with a tomato sauce that was plain. We waited at the bar before we were seated. I ordered a specialty cocktail--nothing special except the prehistoric cherry that capped off the drink. One very positive note is that they have a strong gluten-free option. My partner was happy to make the selection and very positive about her pasta (al dente) and the sauce that accompanied it. So I have a mixed reaction, clearly. I'd say take the winning ingredients (staff, an abundance of smiles, a positive atmosphere) and punch up the style of the servings--traditional is fine, an uptick on traditional seems in reach. read more

The food was delicious and the service was outstanding. I often forget about this little gem since they moved off the main strip. Can't wait till the weather gets warmer to sit out on the patio. read more

Cafe Pomigliano - Tortellini Carbonara was delicious!! - Italian Near Me - Green Oaks, Illinois

We were very excited to go to this restaurant. Me and my wife went to the front and asked for a table. We were told no tables available. We understood and we said we'll come back another time. When we were leaving another restaurant worked said we could seat outside. We came back to the front and we were put in a very uncomfortable position. The older lady at the front got angry with the restaurant worker. She started talking to us like we did something wrong and we just wanted to eat dinner. She was angry, running and asking other people, that came offer us where they wanted to seat. We left and went to Milwaukee Taco- strongly recommend! read more

Really wanted to like this. Early reservation at 6, seated quickly (although no hostess and we gave up waiting so we seated ourselves) Pleasant server who had to be asked three times for bread/oil (which came mid meal) She was completely rushed and didn't listen to a word said. Dishes took over 50 minutes to arrive, drinks weren't refilled with out asking multiple times. Brick chicken topped with completely over cooked broccolini, complete mush and wilted soggy onions and sauce took all crisp from the skin. The crushed red pepper for the spicy lemon sauce arrive as we were putting uneaten food in to go containers. Not enough people to remove used dishes from the table so had to literally hand the server the dirty plates multiple times. One time she said it wasn't her normal job to do. Understandable. But then please make sure the bussers do theirs. Spent the remainder of the evening visiting the porcelain god hourly. Huge disappointment not only from service to food. I don't imagine we'll ever go back. Not impressed, in fact quite turned off read more

Friendly greeting, nicely decorated and tables nicely spaced apart. Very disappointed with entrees. All meals served not hot. Chicken Franchese sauce was more like cream of chicken soup from a can. Marinara sauce was very salty. Ordered baked ravioli, cheese was melted, not baked. Meatball cold in middle. Coffee served not even hot. read more

Beautiful decor and high class look and price. Taste is so so. We were party of five, server forgot to bring appetizer, we let go because we did not realize we ordered more food than we need. Eggplant Parmesan was not on the lunch menu, but they made it for us, but they charged it up, it was expensive than the fish Parmesan we ordered. Best dish out of all was the dessert Tiramasu rest I will skip. read more

The most charming family owned business with the most delicious meals and high quality service. A "go to" location for every special event.

We hosted a bridal shower here and it was the best choice we could have made!! Patty, the owner, was so attentive to our needs and made sure our event had a personal touch. Also-the food was top-notch! We had a lovely time and would highly recommend this restaurant. read more

They have completely brought out a frozen pasta that might of been microwaved for maybe 3 seconds. I'm completely disgusted with this meal. read more

Cafe Pomigliano - Got my whole lasagna the restaurant had great energy, but my pasta was frozen. Seems like their microwave didn't work to their standards. - Italian Near Me - Green Oaks, Illinois

I went to have dinner here with my birthday twin/ bestie. This place is hidden in the side streets of downtown Libertyville. The outside is very cozy with a fire pit and some wicker furniture. The inside waiting area is a bit small but we were greeted and seated right away. The lighting is low with these amazing glass bottle chandeliers. The decor is simple but clean. The menus are on these wooden tablets. Our table was a table for two in a cozy corner of the restaurant . We were sitting between a mom and daughter and a couple. It was tight seating but the space between the tables was close. Honestly a lot of places are set up this way now so it didn't bother us. There was a lot on our small table though. A carafe of water, salt and pepper shaker, a bottle of olive oil, and our glasses of water. Then we ordered a bottle of Riesling, so now we had our wine glasses, and the bread platter added to our table. Needless to say it was a little tight. The food was delicious! We ordered a Brussels Sprout salad that was amazing and a crab cake for appetizers. My friend had fish and I had scallops. She didn't care for the skin on the fish.. it wasn't crispy but my scallops melted in my mouth. I'll definitely be back for the pasta! I recommend 100%! read more

See all

The food tasted good. I had calamari, Caesar small salad, and angel hair pomaordoro. The angel hair was supposed to have garlic...I didn't taste any. They up charged me 2$ for anchovies on my salad (2 small slices). I thought it should have $$$ instead of 2. Decor is nice, clean. The waiter was slow: took forever. Decent but better Italian. It did exceed Olive Garden read more

Composed Roasted Beet Salad with Goat Cheese Pistachio and drizzled honey. I loved it!! read more

Cafe Pomigliano - Italian Near Me - Green Oaks, Illinois

Totally disappointed. The food is good but the service was not there. Had to ask for everything, from bread to drinks to receiving the check . I go out to dinner for the whole experience. Our server Juan did not make the cut read more

My wife & I went here last night for the first time. Overall positive experience. Service good, drinks good, meals and desert good, atmosphere good. Overall tough to complain about. If I was critical of anything maybe a touch pricy for the quantity of food and the side dish of pasta was a touch bland. But having said that both main courses were very Good, the salad was split as an appetizer and was very good and the handmade tiramisu for dessert was fabulous. Atmosphere - 5/5 Food 4.5 /5 Food for price 4/5 Service 5/5 We recommend. read more

My first time and we sat outside. Salads and bread and olive oil and wine and decor were all excellent but they lost a star because there seemed to be no sense of urgency in the service .... Could be easily fixed by having a manager of some sort keeping an eye on things and checking on the tables. But none was to be seen. Servers just didn't seem to have any sense of urgency towards getting to the tables. read more

I have been going here for 26 years. I recently attended dinner after Covid and ordered my traditional favorites. Unfortunately, the quality and taste were Very Disappointing! Please, check your ingredients, attention to flavors and cost for these scant and very tasteless dishes. I am certain that this has nothing to do with Covid restrictions, or availability of ingredients- please correct these problems. I miss quality Italian food with memorable flavor! read more

We dined at Pomigliano for Mother's Day and it was perfect. They had both a breakfast and a lunch buffet. My husband can't stop raving about the salmon. I thought it was all delicious and look forward to going back again and again ... Forgot to mention that the staff is very friendly and accommodating. read more

Had a wonderful time there for their Mother's Day Brunch. My wife and daughters were greeted with flowers when we sat down. Both me and my wife were given Mimosas right away. I figured we were ordering off the menu, but they had a nice brunch buffet with a large variety. The staff was very nice abs accommodating. It was nice to finally experience a little normal. Thank you and we will be back for next years Mother's Day. read more

I hate to pile on but there was a lot of issues. Mainly with the food. The scallops and shrimp were lightly seasoned but veal, filet, and ravioli were not seasoned. I mean nothing, zero. One big blah. Pasta sauce ? Ugh.On a good note the Old fashion was amazing. Place was half full on a Saturday night...enough said. Dinner for 4 (2 teens) $280! read more

Wait staff was prompt. The ambiance was awkward with no music. The food was ok at best. Not screaming to come back even if some one were to pay for my meal. But on a positive note the crab cake appetizer was tasty. read more