Today was my second time at Cafe Yerushalmi, the food on 03/26 was delicious that I had to have it today for lunch. The Moroccan Cigars with Tahini and pickles were crunchy and delicious. I don't believe I've ever had fresh grape leaves that were warm, and I don't want to eat them any other way now. The falafel remind me of the falafel at Mam's in Key West (iykyk). Fresh, crunchy, moist, everything a handmade falafel should be. Today, I had my husband try the same order I ordered and he said we have to put it on rotation. If you haven't tried this spot, you are doing yourself a disservice. Go try it. read more

Cafe Yerushalmi - Grape leaves - Falafel Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Amazing food, amazing Maggie!! The owner was the sweetest person ever! This is the best kosher food you can find in Tallahassee! read more

Cafe Yerushalmi - Falafel Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Very delicious cuisine, enjoyed the hummus, grape leaves and meats, We live in PCB area but this was certainly worth the drive, the owner is also very nice and accommodating read more

The food here was amazing I would so settle for the pargiot it was so good! The service was very good and fast! Would so try again

First off, The owner is absolutely adorable. You can tell she takes a lot of thought and pride in her food. I will certainly be returning! Very fresh food, and good portion size. We ordered: - Matzo ball soup: I've never had this before but it was perfect, tasty and super comforting on a cold day - Grape leaves: the best grape leaves I've ever had, seriously a 10/10!!! - Yerushalmi hummus plate: very tasty, I do tend to like my hummus with more garlic though. Still very creamy and tasty and a huge portion! read more

See all

. The chicken cutlets were rancid and smelled. The freezer where they were kept is either broken or its temp is set too low to keep food healthy. Customers may think they're tasting seasoning but it's rancidity and can cause food poisoning read more

I was visiting Tallahassee after many years, and came across this small restaurant owned by this enchanting Israeli lady! She is stretched thin because she is the waiter, cook, cashier... Everything, but your patience will reward you with some authentic Israeli food. We had the falafel platter, and everything in that plate was homemade, from the freshly baked pita to the silky smooth hummus, the falafel, the Israeli health salad.. And served with pickles and extra tahini sauce, Jerusalem-style! The Israeli apple soda was the perfect cold beverage. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Reheated food and not fresh made from scratch, also just trying it gave me a strong stomach ache that lasted a week. I eanted to like this place since it is family owned but I wouldn't recommend.. read more

Restaurant was really dirty. Food was mediocre and took a while to get out. Service was nice but water cost money and the restaurant seemed dead at lunch time on a Saturday. Unfortunately won't be back unless they offer better prices. read more

I found this place while looking for Mediterranean restaurants. I drove right by as traffic was pretty bad. However, I was able to drive around the block and right into the parking lot. The food is all kosher, with all the appetizers being vegetarian. I tried the grape leaves. I'm used to them being served with tzatziki sauce. These were served warm in a juice I couldn't identify but they were delicious. A little sweet, a little spicy (very little) and extremely tender. I had Moroccan cigars, a type of small roll made of potatoes. It was served with tahini sauce. I was talked into getting a bourekas, which I got with mushrooms. They had potato and another kind, all vegetarian options. They have some Israeli brand juices and drinks, along with can cokes and LaCroix and Gatorade. Water and tea round out the selection. Stop by and try something new. You might just be surprised! read more

Cafe Yerushalmi - Grape leaves and Moroccan Cigars - Falafel Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Excellent food! Great customer service! I had the beef kebab with hummus Israeli salad & falafel With a side of the tropical Israeli nectar drink and I also asked for their spiciest sauce( since I love everything spicy) The food definitely had some flavor and is healthy Will be coming back! read more

Cafe Yerushalmi - Falafel Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

The owner is the sweetest most pure soul ever. It was just her and one other worker taking orders and making the food. The food was extremely authentic and delicious. I recommend it to anyone visiting the FSU area! A taste of Israel in Tallahassee. read more

If you're looking for authentic Israeli food, this is it! Everything is delicious and I'm always coming back for the excellent food and service. Sometimes the business hours are affected by holidays so make sure to double check! My personal favorite is the shawarma on Laffa with a side salad. If you're vegetarian, I strongly recommend the Falafel Pita! (Order it with all of Magi's recommended toppings) read more

Cafe Yerushalmi - Shawarma on Laffa with Side Salad - Falafel Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

This no-frills little place is truly a gem. You won't find any Israeli food more authentic than this outside of Brooklyn, Boca Raton, and of course Israel. The owner is a sweet Israeli lady who is also the cook, so you know it's got to be good. She was apparently the cook over at FSU's Hillel before she decIded to open up her own place just south of the stadium. Must-tries are the shakshuka (pictured), which she serves right from the skillet, the turkey shawarma hummus, and of course the falafels. The baklava for dessert is among the best I've ever had. Note: this is truly the definition of a mom-and-pop place. When I went, she was the cook, server, and cashier, so don't expect white tablecloth service. But do expect great, authentic food served with great love and attention. read more

Cafe Yerushalmi - Shakshuka - Falafel Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Now this is authentic! Absolutely delicious. The grape leaves. The hummus my goodness was the best. The tabouli was different, more bulgar, tomato, onion, cranberry raisins yum! The Chicken Schnitzel was Excellent! We will definitely return and I can totally recommend you give it a go! The service was excellent but y'all the food was just so good. My husband enjoyed his dinner very much too! He had vegetarian Shakshouka. Which he totally enjoyed! read more

Very nice experience. Authentic food from a lady that you can tell is passionate about what she does. The hummus plates are out of this world! read more

Wonderful food and the owner was so kind! Can't say enough about the home cooked food. The Shakshuka was cooked perfectly and the falafel as well. Enjoyed the Matza ball soup as well. Everything was fresh and delicious! ******* read more

My first time coming here! I barely spotted the place as I passed by to run at the the nearby trail. We came back after I finished and it was fantastic! Admittedly we had got there just before closing and didn't realize it at the time, yet we were served very nicely and presented with many great options! Unfortunately I don't have a picture, but I got the Chicken Schnitzel Pita Sandwich & a Mushroom Boureka while my dad got the Kebab Plate & a Potato Boureka! I've only had a pita sandwich once in my life before and it was from a fast food restaurant, but the one here really blew me away -- I loved it! The combination of the pita bread with the sauce & veggies worked perfectly. The Boureka was also very nice; a toasty and flaky exterior with a good mushroom filling inside. Overall, the food was worth every penny and the service was very nice! We'll definitely come back! read more

I unfortunately have to give Cafe Yerushalmi a 3/5 rating. I really wanted to LOVE this place... First, Cafe Yerushalmi is a great addition to the Tallahassee food scene, apart from chain "Mediterranean" restaurants, we did not have any authentic Israeli food until Cafe Terushalmi opened last Winter. Having grown up in Montréal, where Israeli restaurants were on every second block in my neighborhood, I had high expectations from this new place. There are a few things that I do love about Cafe Yerushalmi. First, I love that it is locally owned. There is nothing better than supporting a small local restaurant. Second, the menu has many diverse options that you cannot find anywhere else in Tallahassee. Third, the Israeli salad and eggplant were delicious. However, I thought that the falafels were dry and not as flavorful as I would have liked. I also thought that it was a little bit expensive- while the setting is casual, the prices are on the higher end. I would definitely give this place another chance- it could have been an "off" night. read more

Had the falafel plate and the shawarma pita. Both were outstanding. The pita was homemade and served piping hot. The hummus was the best I've ever had. Finished with a tasty baklava. Next trip to Tallahassee, I'd go out of my way to have lunch here again. read more

Yummy!!!! Authentic homemade feels here! Magi, the owner, she's so sweet! I felt like I was at her home. The hummus was amazing! Also the baklava! So so good read more

Cafe Yerushalmi - Falafel Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

food was AMAZING and the place is ran by the sweetest older lady. it feels like a sunday meal at grandma's house:). the pita bread was very fresh and the restaurant was very clean and tidy. definitely going back again!!! read more

Wow! This place is a GEM! Maggie knows what she is doing! This hidden gem is some of the best food in Tallahassee. Maggie is the sweetest kindest person with the best customer service. The place is nice and quiet with cultural music and art around you. 10/10 would recommend visiting. read more

See all

The food is unique but not great and the service is slow. Had the pita sandwich with chicken thigh. The chicken had gristle but the veggie add ons were good. read more

I can't give this place anything less than 5 stars. The food was absolutely amazing. The lady running the restaurant was so sweet and recommended us the Moroccan cigars and they did not disappoint The shakshouka was phenomenal and it was the first place I could find in Tallahassee that served birek and shakshouka. I ordered the shawarma pita and it was soooo yummy. Highly recommend. This place deserves all the hype. read more

See all

Delicious food. The restaurant was very cozy and the owner was the sweetest woman. Best falafel I've ever had in Tallahassee. I would have taken pictures but it got eaten too fast. :) read more

I've been meaning to go to Cafe Yerishalmi since I first heard it was open. It's located in the old Banditos Burritos location. When I arrived there was one woman working by herself, the owner I assume? I came specifically for the matzo ball soup, something I had been craving since I moved here from the West Coast. Once there, I decided to also order a falafel pita and tabbouleh. That turned out to be a lot of Food that I ate on for a few days. The falafel was okay. I enjoyed the Israeli salad in the pita and the pickles, but I still prefer Sahara's falafel. The soup was good. It could have been more seasoned for me but it was clean and filling. The star of the meal was the tabbouleh! It was delicious and why I will go back. The woman made it while I waited, which allowed me to customize it a little (light tomatoes) and it had dried cranberries, which gave it a pop! And though it was pricy, it was a huge serving. I would have liked some crispy pita with it, but it was so good I ate it straight with it spoon! I look forward to going and trying other dishes. read more

Amazing, authentic food. We had falafel, bourekas, the hummus with turkey shawarma, shakshuka, and baklava for dessert. Every single thing was so delicious, it is impossible to pick a favorite! Can't wait to come back again and again to try everything on the menu. As with all amazing food, it takes time to prepare, so don't come in a rush. It's a true dining experience that takes you to Jerusalem. read more

Cafe Yerushalmi - Gorgeous restaurant with great seating! - Falafel Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

So disappointed my husband and me. However the server was extremely sweet, we just didn't enjoy the food and we tried a lot of dishes with such high expectations. read more

Cafe Yerushalmi is a wonderful addition to the Tallahassee restaurant market. It is a kosher restaurant where are you feel like you are being fed from your mothers kitchen. The owner and chef is a warm friendly woman who loves to Make you feel welcome and will let you know what she has on the stove cooking right then. She provides take away as well as delivery and there are a few tables, socially distanced if you want to eat there. When you go into the restaurant, there are even more dishes that are not listed on the printed menu, such as matzoh ball soup and other traditional jewish/Israeli dishes. Go there and feel welcomed! read more

Best homemade Mediterranean in town, hands down. Entering the Cafe is like stepping into your long-lost grandma's kitchen where you fill up on authentic Israeli food using all kosher ingredients. I've become a regular here, and after sampling most of the menu, the shwarma kebab is my favorite (chicken schnitzel is a close second)! Included are some photos from previous visits just to whet your appetite. Don't miss out on one of the best small business in town! read more

See all

Really really good food! First time going and I know I will be back! I had the kebab combo, Moroccan Cigars, Hummus, and another incredible food starter! All really good food, the hummus was incredible and made me want more pita to deep into it! The kebab was so delicious and filling! Definitely a place to check out in Tallahassee that is one of a kind! read more

See all

Just a very heartwarming lady from Jerusalem serving up some heartwarming cuisine. Her hummus is definitely spectacular, a somewhat thin, maximally smooth character with a perfect chickpea-nutty tahini flavor. Only the best of quality pita as well. What else can I say? If you want authentic foods an Israeli grandmother would make, and perhaps a great conversation with a kind Israeli woman, then come here for your food needs. In the words of Maui, "you're welcome." read more

Been here 3 times now, everything I've had is great. The woman who takes your order (believe the owner) is really sweet, always smiling, and will recognize you after a few times. You can tell she really cares about you enjoying the food. I have always gotten take out, but people are always eating there (inside & outdoor seating). I've had the yerushalmi hummus, brisket plate when they had it as a special, and shawarma plate. All were good but the yerushalmi hummus & brisket are my favorite so far. Israeli salad side is really good, as is the (fried) eggplant side. Also great pita read more

SO delicious. Seriously one of the best falafel pitas I've ever had. Very, very sweet (and talented) woman who runs the place. Don't forget to order a piece of baklava! read more

Clean, delicious, Kosher!!!! The perfect definition of a mom and pop shop. Authentic Israeli food made by the owner Maggie's own hands. The best food I've had in all of Tallahassee. She's only been open 6 months so let's help this establishment blossom. God Bless her, such a sweet woman read more

Cafe Yerushalmi - Fried Eggplant, Chicken Schnitzel, Beef Kebab, Tabouli Salad, Rice - Falafel Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Magi's cooking is phenomenal! This is authentic Israeli food, with fresh and all kosher ingredients. You can't go wrong with anything you order, but my favorites are the fried eggplant and the kibbeh. She serves real hummus, nothing like the stuff you get in the store. For a genuine Israeli experience, get a platter and then stuff everything you can fit into your pita, including the salad and the French fries. And mango juice on the side! Wonderful restaurant, best middle eastern food in Tallahassee! read more

Delicious falafel, fried eggplant, Israeli salad, and the puffiest pitas I've seen in country. Call ahead if you have a group, as there is a small staff. read more

One of my favorite Tally spots! The owner is fantastic and the falafel is the best I have ever had (and I've eaten a lot of different falafel). I also tried shakshuka for the first time and was wary about the poached eggs but this dish changed my life forever, in the best way possible. I moved away and think about this place every day. Every time I come back to visit, this is the #1 destination on my agenda. 10/10 would recommend to anyone who wants quality food for a good price. read more

The food is delicious and authentic. The woman who owns it cooks, serves and runs the register. So don't expect the Applebee's experience. This is an old-world mom & pop experience. My wife and I had a large sampling of the menu and everything was absolutely delicious and all made by hand with natural ingredients. So glad that we stopped in. We'll be back often! read more