Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Calogero’s

    4.8 (6 reviews)
    Closed 4:00 pm - 12:00 am (Next day)
    Updated 3 weeks ago

    Calogero’s Cocktail Bars Photos

    CALOGERO’S ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Calogero’s

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Danny K.

    Went opening day and while they are still working out the minor details, the service and drinks were spot on! Would recommend the tiramisu ice cream drink! Large list of martinis, cocktails, wine, beer, and small bites. You can tell lots of details went into the design of the interior and soon to be outside patio. This place has the Bay View charm and a great addition to the neighborhood!

    Phil G.

    Calogero's, as all of Milwaukee seems to know, is the Italian-style bar run by the good folks at Santino's Restaurant. Calogero's has an amazing publicist, because not only is everyone talking about the bar, but the place was packed on a Wednesday night. My spouse and I were fortunate to find two seats at the bar. Much of the staff from Santino's was brought over, and they are trained well. Professional and helpful, they will ensure your evening goes smoothly. The decor echoes Santino's, creating a dark, sultry effect that emulates the La Dolce Vita of 1950s and 1960s Rome. It's a wonderful attempt, but after spending much time in Rome, I was fully aware this was Milwaukee. However, Calogero's is cool for the Cream City. What I particularly enjoyed was the amazing selection of Amaro. It's a favorite apertif of mine, and I tried three of them on Calogero's menu. They were all delicious, especially the Bitter Truth EXR. Appetizers are served as well. Calogero's is a hip bar that adds a touch of sophistication to Bay View's burgeoning scene.

    See all

    11 days ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    19 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    27 days ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    27 days ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Phil G.
    145
    1640
    1868

    6 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    19 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Calogero’s

    You might also consider

    The Tin Widow - Tin Window

    The Tin Widow

    4.7(107 reviews)
    1.3 miWalker's Point
    $$

    We stopped in on a whim after dinner out in the deer district. Driving home when I saw the holiday…read moreinflatables and I thought if I can find a parking spot, we are going in. I had heard about the Tin Widow's holiday pop up being one of the best area, the hype was not wrong. From the entrance to the ceiling and walks, this place is the definition of deck the halls. Unless you get here right when they open it early in the holiday season, I would expect a crowd. The drink menu is so fun with holiday themed drinks served in matching glassware. You can even purchase the glass/mug for an additional fee. A lot of the cocktails looked to be batched cocktails which help with the bartender's efficiency. Highly recommend making this place a holiday stop. I'm also curious to stop in after the holidays to experience it without all the holiday decor.

    Stopped in for their Miracle on 2nd St holiday pop-up. We only had to wait about 5-10min for a…read moretable, but it does get busy fast, especially on weekends. They had several seasonal cocktails in special festive cups, which you could also buy to take home. I got the Cheery Cherry Chocosaurus, which was good, but pricey for what it was. Almost all the seasonal drinks were $15 each and didn't seem too big. The venue itself is medium sized, but feels crammed quickly. There's more people let in at a time than there is seating, so you have to move fast to get a seat. I'll likely come back during the summer to try something else.

    Photos
    The Tin Widow - Interior

    Interior

    The Tin Widow
    The Tin Widow

    See all

    Agency - Inside

    Agency

    4.3(23 reviews)
    2.5 miEast Town, Downtown

    Wow! This may be the best cocktail bar in the city. It is a full vibe that must be experienced…read more Craft cocktails in a charming, warm, inviting space similar to a Victorian era home back in the 1900s. Service is impeccable. They do a tremendous job of explaining the menu and food options in detail, and ensure you have a great experience from start to finish. The drinks? Nothing short of amazing. They vary the featured cocktails menu every 8 weeks, so most likely you'll get a different experience every time you go. However you can always get your classic cocktails like Margaritas, French 75 and Martinis. They also can do any drink NA which is the first of its kind in the US. They have an option called dealers choice, where you can pick the spirit and flavor profile of the drink you want: spicy, sour, floral, smoky etc. no limits! You write down on a card what you want and they craft you a cocktail based on your selections. They also offer a variety of food pairings to go along with the select, featured drink you order. We got spring rolls, a braised, pork infused doughnut, and an incredible bone broth that still has me in a tizzy. Fair warning: it's small and difficult to get a reservation - don't try your luck walking in, this place is a hot ticket and you won't be able to get in without a resy, which could be weeks or months out. This is a true gem of a cocktail bar, and is as good as anything you would find in New York or Chicago.

    Liked the vibe - reminds me of shakers cigar bar but without all the smoke (like, a bit spooky,…read moreold, maybe haunted but also very cool). We stopped here after dinner, so we stuck mostly with the cocktails. Unfortunately, nothing on the seasonal menu really stuck out to me. I stuck with the "traditional" cocktails (spicy watermelon bubblegum, and then banana daiquiri). Hubs went for the halo halo food (which was so cute! All the typical ingredients but served in cubist fashion), and the paired drink. The paired drink was supposed to have different layers of flavor, but they all mixed together quite a bit. Tasty, just not the "layered" experience we thought. I think they almost do themselves a disservice comparing themselves to the aviary - that is a crazy high bar to meet. Granted, maybe we would have been more impressed if we had more of the seasonal cocktails despite them not seeming interesting? Probably wouldnt go out of my way to go here again, but it is a cool vibe and the cocktails were good.

    Photos
    Agency - Big Big, water

    Big Big, water

    Agency
    Agency - The Sea Witch

    See all

    The Sea Witch

    Boone and Crockett - Negroni + Manhattan

    Boone and Crockett

    4.3(224 reviews)
    1.1 miHarbor View
    $$

    Still a big fan of Boone and Crocket…read more I love the masterful mix of taxidermy and chandeliers. I love that they do game nights in style with a big screen and lots of energy. I love that I can slip into a dimly lit booth with my date and enjoy a exquisitely mixed cocktail and maybe even a game of cribbage by candlelight. I truly love it all. I love that they've expanded the food truck offerings and have a small food truck park on their property. You can order from Taco Moto (and maybe others as well, we're just partial to Taco Moto) right from a QR code at your table or booth and they'll text you when your food is ready (which you're welcome to enjoy in Boone & Crocket). It's truly a magical bar on the lakefront with, have I mentioned? Plenty of parking to boot. Get to it!

    Just visited for the first time with a friend for a few drinks on a Friday night. We were there…read morerelatively early so it wasn't crowded yet. I can see the appeal of the place. There are plenty of little nooks and corners to hang out in small or larger groups. I'm sure it's extra good in the warmer months. They have a big patio area. The cocktails on tap were excellent - well balanced and tasty. I tried the Manhattan and the Negroni. They were also pretty reasonable. Service was good. I could really do without all the dead creatures hung everywhere though. It's just not that cool in 2026, even in Wisconsin. Maybe show some respect for animals.

    Photos
    Boone and Crockett - Indoor bar

    Indoor bar

    Boone and Crockett
    Boone and Crockett - Indoor bar

    See all

    Indoor bar

    Calogero’s - cocktailbars - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...