I have been in the tire business on the Upper Cape for 40 years. I used to look at them as a competitor. But they have sunk so low that their lowest common denominator is just sad. I sent my co worker to have tires rotated. They charged him $60.00! No lie! Only the quality of the men behind the desk may be judged accordingly. read more

2 flat tires....replaced and put on within 2 hours....brought my lawn tractor tires to be replaced....they dismounted the old and remounted the new..left overnight and were ready first thing in the AM....The original boss left the business in his son's hands...Father, Bob, picked the right guy as the service and products were more than satisfactory... read more

This place sucks went in offering to purchase a new tire for rental car knowing I'm leaving in an hour for airport man on left side of counter is a real peckerhead to say the least although I own a home in Hyannis and have a vehicle here I will go elsewhere for tires here on out and will urge my family and friends who are all residents to do the same ( empty shop, parked in front of an empty bay and got hit with an attitude) read more

I recently went to the Orleans location to replace all tires on my car and the rep behind the counter was absolutely no help and seemed like he couldn't care less. I asked a few questions about the noise levels from a few different tires and he said he didn't know. He offered me tires for $400 each and when I asked for other options he just rattled off a few names but made no suggestions or offered any information. I went elsewhere (town Fair Tire) and when I told the rep at the other store that I had an unsatisfactory experience he told me that he wanted to write the owner of Cape and Island to thank him for all the business they get for the same reason. If you need help picking out tires don't bother with Cape and Islands Orleans. read more

If you like getting ripped off and crappy customer service Cape & Islands Tire is the place for you! I brought two trailer tires in for tube install in may. They charged me for labor and materials to install two tubes. One went flat a week ago and I noticed that there was no tube. I brought it back with my receipt and they tried to charge me to do the same job that they didn't do the first time and accused ME of bringing in a different tire and trying to rip them off! The place is a shit hole and the employees are morons from top to bottom. read more

I seldom write negative reviews but the Falmouth location needs a complete over haul. How they compete with competition is questionable. Lesson learned that price is not a factor especially when the low priced dealer can't get tires as promised. When in Falmouth go to another tire store.... read more

Joe was very helpful and honest. The price he quoted was reasonable and exact. No surprises. Will always do business with Cape & Islands Tire. read more

Customer service at the Orleans store was one of the top 4 worst I've ever had in my life. Rude on the phone, dropping the car off, and picking the car up. Not going back. read more

I would never recommend them. Go around the corner to Cape Tire. So much nicer and a local place. I showed up with a slow leak in 1 of my tires. There was a condescending person that treated me lousy. Do you want the business or not? Doesn't seem like it. Don't mean to bother you. I'll tell others too. Thanks. read more

My friend hit a curb in West Yarmouth that wrecked her front right tire. We had to leave our rental the next day and needed to quickly replace the tire. Joe was a godsend. He ordered the right tire and installed it within 6 hours. We are so grateful to him and the staff. read more

We were on our way to Provincetown with our 34 ft travel trailer attached over the memorial day weekend. Our left front tire on our truck was going flat & we were fortunate enough to be by cape & Island tire. We pulled in & they were able to plug the nail w/o unhitching the RV. Matt & his team were wonderful & we were in & out w/i the hr. Thanks so much for the help & would recommend them again!!!​ read more

Boss order tire ties was told it would be ready Wednesday showed up not in yet went back on Friday guy behind the counter didn't know anything about it long story short tire still wasn't ready read more

The tire mounting estimate per tire was given as $20.00 per wheel via phone. Upon arrival to the shop, I was charged $40.00 per wheel simply to mount the tire on the steel rim. Mount cost almost as much as the 14 inch diameter tire. Very poor customer support and dishonest. read more

Had bought 2 tires to be mounted and put back on the front or RV. Spare tire was to be put inside the RV. Wheel simulators to be put back on and extensions to be put back on the rear. Spent $1127.69 for work to be done. Dropped off at noon. Was called at 4 pm saying it was done and we close at 4:30pm. Told them I wanted to keep a front tire that was removed. Arrived at 4:18pm to pick up. The tire I wanted to keep was put on my spare ( didn't ask for that to be done). I had to find my spare tire that was removed to keep for future use. Extensions were not put on rear. I mentioned numerous times extensions need to go on. They seemed hesitant to install them. He said those things always leak. I've never had a problem with them. Joe said come back in the morning we'll put them on free of charge. Call that noon said can I come down to have those installed he said I spoke with the technician he said they leaked. We went back and forth then he said if you get new ones I'm going to charge you $50 to install them. You just lost a good customer I said. Have spent thousands of dollars for tires over the years there never had a problem. So after an hour and a half of my time I got them on the RV they don't leak at all. I called him to tell him that he told me to go f*** myself. Wow. And Joe is the manager. He needs to go. Fire his ass read more

I have felt with cape and islands tire for many years..until now.. I had a visible nail in my tread.i simply wanted a plug put in. It was a slow friday morning in late sept. '17. There were several young men on duty in the repair bays. Between the loud music ( easily heard in the waiting area), then constantly showing each other their cell phones and "vaping". The front desk person quickly took care of my request, passing it onto a young man. So, 1 hour .. and ..$25.00 later My vehicle is ready.. Upon inspection I see that my center cap for my rim ( which is no longer made), is broken. There is greasy hand prints on both the front right and left quarter pannel. I then had to proceed to the car wash wash ($11.00) down the street. I now have my mechanic seaching for the center cap. To my dismay, my local loyalty again has been broken.i will not only NOT recommend Cape and Islands Tire but will discurage ANYONE from frequenting this establishment. HAPPY TRAILS CAPE AND ISLANDS TIRE.. read more

Problem solver Rick got me squared away with four new tires and front end alignment. Prompt and personal service is a good thing to count on. These fellows are "on the ball". Price was competitive with the"big box" store. Service staff was in view. They executed mounting of tires with care on aluminum wheels. All wheels were carefully balanced an reinstalled on the vehicle. The vehicle was delivered as per rick's time line for completion after front end alignment was done with hard copy read out on adjustments provided.it is gratifying to see such professional grade service is still available at a local level. Well done! read more

Company truck blew a tire and we needed a tire quick. They charged me $241 for one tire. I was desperate and he also didn't give me the price until after the tire was mounted. I asked to pay and he said, "I'm not sure just yet who is going to put the tire on so I can't give you a price." I'm serious. Yesterday I brought my truck to another tire shop thinking I might as well change all the tires to be safe. I purchase three more tires--total price, $541 for the three. So, I would say they completely took advantage of me, never offered a tier of different style/priced tires. All simply because I needed a tire and wasn't out shopping for a tire. Bad business. read more

A terrific place in Orleans! I purchased tires for my old Subaru. When my low air indicator on my new Subaru came on, I stopped in to see if they would top off the air in my tires. They cheerfully took care of it and no charge. Needless to say l, when I need new tires for this car, I'll head here. read more

The people here are great. The tire prices were good and there is no sales bullsh*t. Every time I have a problem, they've solved it for me. Very quick service and very genuine people. Free wi-if and coffee. I did research before going in and asked them for recommendations and theirs mirrored my research. Highly recommended. read more

I was visiting Yarmouth, MA when I hit a curb and got a flat tire. I needed it repaired ASAP as I had to leave for home the next day. I called Cape & Islands Tire in Hyannis and spoke with Joe who told me he could order the tire by 10:00 AM and it would arrive at 2:00 PM. At 2:02 I received a call from Joe that my tire had arrived. I went to the shop and by 3:15 it was installed and I was good to go. Thank you Joe. I would highly recommend this shop to anyone needing tires or any type of auto repair. read more

THANK YOU JUSTIN! We ended up with a nail in our tire on Nantucket. The tire place on the island was awful. We called Cape & Island Tire and they were able to order us two tires for the price of one tire on Nantucket. Thankfully after the Nantucket tire place wasted a day with a failed order, Justin answered the phone after 5pm. He was so helpful. The tires arrived as we got off the ferry today and we are back on the road. Thank you!! read more

Thank you, what a great bunch of guys there! I called other tire places in the area trying to get a tire replaced that i had installed as part of a pair last year by Sears in Hyannis. It was shredding its belt for some reason and i didn't like them when they installed them for an inflated price. I called others as i said and all i got was ; well, we can make you an appointment for next week some time and... Yeah right, while i could have a serious accident if my tire blew out! Cape and islands Tire took me right in, and about twenty minutes later, and a reasonable price, they gave me my keys back and told me they checked all my other tires too and they were fine. Thanks guys, you have my business always. read more

I went to this place on December 19 because I needed an alignment and the tire pressure checked before a family trip to Florida pulling a 12,000 pound fifth wheel when I left the place I noticed that my steering wheel is a little bit crooked and when I got home I check my tire pressure and it was way below recommended pressure for pulling such a heavy trailer but the worst thing is that on the way to Florida my truck had a loud clunk coming from the Front passenger side it turned out to be one of the camber bolts that the technician failed to tighten I came back this weekend from Florida and went to Sullivan tire as soon as they could get me in they did an alignment and they said that was really out of specs I have the paperwork to prove it do yourself a favor and stay away from this Place read more

Went to C & I tire in Wareham and as always was quite pleased. There are not many local places I can bring my 40' motor home and get great service. I needed new valve stems and new valve stem extensions installed and John did a great job. Prompt, courteous, reliability, and expertise are the main stays of this operation. I will surely be back. Thanks Guys Lou read more

Went in for an alignment (hot pot hole). I had to ask for the before and after sheet. It indicated that it needed an alignment. They called to say the alignment was done and I needed four new tires at $900+ dollars because they were scalloped. I previously worked at Goodyear and wanted to check it out for myself. The tires we're fine. I had the mgr show me what they were talking about. He and I looked ... he agreed the tires were fine. NO scalloping. read more

I brought my car in to get 1 tire. Two of the employees were sitting at the desk eating and didn't even acknowledge us when we walked in. The girl who did acknowledge us was very very rude. She couldn't be bothered with us. We walked out. I will never recommend that place. The expensive prices they charge are ridiculous and their service sucks. read more

Associate was informative and the work was done very quickly -at a reasonable price).

Fast service, they were able to take my car within minutes when the local dealership didn't have an appointment for a month. They were friendly, knowledgeable and very reasonably priced. read more

Super friendly, super fast! Won't try to rip you off. read more

Cape & Islands Tire - Tires Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

See all

I hadn't been there in over 20 years. I thought I was getting a fair price on tire sensors until a friend paid half the price at the tire place around the corner. Expensive lesson...I should have shopped. read more

Those guys are great! They tell you what you really need done, no extra add ons just to take your money.Such a breath of fresh air! So glad they do breaks now too! Won't go anywhere else! read more

STAY AWAY! I'm talking about the alignment shop, not the tire shop. I think they sub-contract for the tire part of the business. The shop is dirty, worn, and very outdated. It's run by two grouchy old guys. The mechanic took me to task because my tires weren't properly inflated. They never told me I could use the tire shop waiting room so I had to stand around for 45 minutes in the crappy shop. There was a very dirty chair available. I told the mechanic my steering wheel was not in the right position, he said he would take care of it...not! The icing on the cake was Rush Limbaugh on the radio. No, I'm not going back to straighten my steering wheel. read more

Cape and Island Tire Co in Orleans MA. I would not even consider using this company again for any services much less tires for my car. I bought a set of 4 top of the line tires and the technician who was untrained and probably poorly paid (according to the staff the owner is "cheap"). Had tires put on then when I drove away paying quite bit of money I noticed the front tire was wobbly as I drove. Took the car back and when I informed the manager he said "Oh yeah- this happens all the time." and "we are short staffed." I told him it was not acceptable and the young man fixed his error. I asked him to check all the tires and he did. I asked he manager to have owner call me. Owner called me, said "oh yeah I've been working with that kid." we settled on a refund price and then the owner became combative at best and refused to honor his agreement. He sent me a pittance and then in texts said "well nobody was hurt." I informed him and the manager that there was a safety breach in the installation of the tires and there needs to be a safety check protocol for when tires are replaced. I did get them to inspect the car for any issues. I disputed the charge and the owner contacted me and I reiterated what we had spoken of . The manager called me once again and then when I said "have the owner call me" he never did. I contacted the credit card company again after Cape and Island Tire put the charge through again. THIS IS FRAUD. I contacted the owner via text as this is the only way he likes to communicate on 1/4/18 to resolve this issue with him. To this date 1/15/18 he has not had the decency to contact me. I was conveying this issue to a friend of mine who said " I never liked that company anyway- they suck." I have decided to clear the dispute, pay the bill, move on with my life and write this review warning people DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY. read more

I never write reviews but my experience at Cape and Island Tire was so pleasant I owe them a nice recommendation. I am visiting the Cape, so I found them through a Google search. They had the highest rating so I went with it. I was panicked when my tire pressure light appeared after the long drive here. They were profession, helpful, and fast! I had my 7 month old in the waiting area and they could not have been more welcoming! They fixed my tire issue and did it without taking advantage of an out of towner...an honest and professional company. Thanks!!! read more

Super friendly, quick and great service! Sent someone out same day to pick up a tire they didn't have in house.