Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Carmen's Italian Ice

    4.6 (5 reviews)

    Carmen's Italian Ice Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Carmen's Italian Ice

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    I've been here a couple of times and I try so many different ice creams. Everytime we are close by we stop to by,

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 2
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 5,065 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Bruster's Real Ice Cream

    Bruster's Real Ice Cream

    4.4
    (536 reviews)
    2.8 mi
    $$
    Speaks Spanish
    Free parking

    One sunny weekend when the temperature was hot, I thought since I was in the area, I would come and…read moretry something different. As I drove in the lot, I could tell the place was busy (a line in their drive-thru and lots of folks at the entrance (ordering or picking up, I was not sure). I was willing to wait. I saw they had some June specials and a few caught my eye: Brookie - Upside Down Pineapple Cake Jamaican Me Crazy Key Lime Pie Mixed Berry Cheesecake Strawberry Matcha Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Ube There were some others, but I could not decide on which one I wanted (wished I could try all the above). I settled on the one called "Jamaican Me Crazy". The employee described it as: Coconut Ice Cream with Fudge Swirl and Almonds. I only got 1 small scoop since I was trying it for the first time - it was good. Next time, I will need to get 2 scoops as I really enjoyed the flavor of that one. The line in front went very quickly as I sat and ate my ice cream on the premises. There were several employees tending to the customers. I wonder if I can make it back before the end of June to try some of those other flavors, seeing that I have a $1 off coupon.

    Bruster's is a great stop for some summer ice cream! It's a grab and go kind of place but they have…read moreoutdoor seating sprinkled around. I noticed they added more lawn chairs since the weathers nice! The staff is always helpful and quick at serving orders. They have a bunch of flavors to pick from and honestly it can be sort of a hit or miss. The classics are always great though like the cookies and cream or butter pecan. I got the cherry vanilla and honestly that's my bad because I thought it would be real cherries not maraschino cherries lol. The mixed berry cheesecake was so good though, it had a mixed berry jam and graham crackers swirled throughout. The pistachio was another slight miss for us. I appreciate the amount of pistachios sprinkled throughout but the base was giving amaretto/almond flavoring as opposed to a true pistachio ice cream. (I also don't like amaretto) so that doesn't help lol but overall glad I tried the flavors and now I can try different ones next time!

    Photos
    Cone cake with banana chocolate chip ice cream, fudge layer, and chocolate cake.
    Cone cake with banana chocolate chip ice cream, fudge layer, and chocolate cake.
    Regular Crunchy Waffle Cones with strawberries and New York Cheesecake
    Regular Crunchy Waffle Cones with strawberries and New York Cheesecake
    Oreo and double Chocolate on a Crunchy Waffle Cones

    See all

    Oreo and double Chocolate on a Crunchy Waffle Cones
    Carmen's Italian Ice & Cafe

    Carmen's Italian Ice & Cafe

    4.6
    (510 reviews)
    3.9 mi
    $

    Although I have tried my fair share of funky flavors, I have never come across as many unique and…read moregenuinely tasty options as those at Carmen's Italian Ice. Calling the selection good would be an understatement. Flavors and styles lined the walls, and they have even introduced seasonal spring drinks alongside their custards and Italian ice. I ordered a gelati, which came with two flavors and the option to add a warm brownie in the center. They also offer prepackaged pints to take home. The only item that could not be sampled was the not fried chicken, their iconic Shark Tank inspired creation shaped like a chicken leg, where the novelty lies more in the form than the flavor. Some flavors had intriguing names like Tiger Blood and Midnight Fantasy, and the staff were more than happy to explain each one in detail. *Midnight Fantasy: featured a chocolate base mixed with chunks of brookie. It leaned heavier with a slightly grainy texture from the cookie pieces, but the chocolate itself was not overly sweet. It worked best when paired with something lighter. The brookie itself was well balanced, with a fudgy brownie component and a cookie that had a snickerdoodle like quality. *Mango Italian Ice: had a clean, fruity flavor and a smooth texture. It was not overly icy and paired nicely with the custard on top. *Honey Milk: was my favorite of everything I tried. The honey flavor came through strongly, both in taste and aroma, while the milky richness added a smooth creaminess. It paired beautifully with the Italian ice and balanced the richness of the Midnight Fantasy. *Spring Break Soda: was an interesting take on a Sprite style drink, with kiwi syrup, blue raspberry syrup, grenadine, and cold foam. It definitely delivered a sugar rush. There was a tropical feel, but it may be best suited for those with a serious sweet tooth. There is likely something for everyone here, and the friendly service makes it easy to find your match. While I would probably skip the sodas, the Italian ice and custard stood out for their quality.

    I'm so glad I finally tried this place! It's still delicious even during the winter time. The staff…read moreis extremely kind and generous. They were serving us 20 minutes before they opened (2pm). We weren't aware of the hours, but they still helped us and apologized for not having all their displays up. There is only outdoor seating that is shared with other neighboring establishments. The menu is enormous. It's a big overwhelming, but the staff is very patient and will answer all questions and guide you. You can even sample many flavors! I ended up getting a kids gelati with ube custard and horchata ice. I love that they have a mini size and such unique flavors here!!

    Photos
    Carmen's Italian Ice & Cafe
    6/8/23 - Vanilla custard & chocolate Italian ice large gelati (on Jayden day)
    6/8/23 - Vanilla custard & chocolate Italian ice large gelati (on Jayden day)
    Coffee & Nutella twist

    See all

    Coffee & Nutella twist
    Sarah’s Handmade Ice Cream & Treats

    Sarah’s Handmade Ice Cream & Treats

    4.6
    (89 reviews)
    2.9 mi
    $$

    I've been here an unhealthy amount of times. I think it's like once a week (maybe). This has been…read morethe go to spot after a rough work week. They switch out some flavors based on holidays or months. This month (may) is aapi month so they have a lot of delicious Asian inspired ice cream flavors. My favorite is mango sticky rice, Thai ice tea and black sesame crumb cake. Some of the past flavors I like was orange chocolate chip, Bethesda brown brickle (always on the menu), salt & cream oatmeal cookie, bourdon walnut pie, and earl grey speculoos. Yeah like I said I've been here a lottttt!

    Sarah offers plenty of flavors, but none of them truly stood out…read more I was stunned upon entering as the wall was covered with every flavor imaginable. There were endless fruity and chocolate combinations to choose from. I had a chuckle at their Luck O' The Irish flavor, a leprechaun inspired mix of mint Oreo and Lucky Charms. There was a sign stating that samples were limited to two, but I appreciated that the employees let us try a few extra given the overwhelming variety. *Lavender Honey: leaned far more heavily into honey than lavender. I was disappointed by how faint the floral notes were. The base was overly milky and dominated by sweetness rather than any delicate herbal flavor. *Cherry Blossom: suffered from the same issue of muted flavors. Supposedly a rose water and cherry combination, neither ingredient made much of an impression on the base. The rose lacked any fragrance and the cherry failed to provide either tartness or brightness. *Salted Caramel: slightly too aggressive with the sea salt, though it could have worked if the caramel had more depth. Instead, the caramel lacked any rich, toasted flavor, leaving the overall profile rather flat. The variety was entertaining, but the execution fell short. Many of the flavors sounded far more exciting than they actually tasted. The mix-ins and toppings needed to be incorporated more generously, and the bases themselves required stronger infusions to carry the advertised flavors. In the end, the playful names were more memorable than the ice cream itself.

    Photos
    Ube cheesecake and banana pudding ice cream cone
    Ube cheesecake and banana pudding ice cream cone
    Ube Cheesecake Ice Cream Cup
    Ube Cheesecake Ice Cream Cup
    Can you believe all of these flavors?

    See all

    Can you believe all of these flavors?

    Carmen's Italian Ice - icecream - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...