Casa Mia rocks! They have a Sole' pizza that is epic! It reportedly has won awards for being so tasty! The service at Casa Mia is also amazing! We are treated like family each and every time we are in. Love this place! read more

We used to love this place but they got rid of the marinated steak and now we don't wanna go back. The other problem is that the red wine is terrible. I love red wine and theirs is just not good. read more

An absolutely horrible experience with online ordering. The order sat for close to an hour-- a $30 pizza boxed and "warming", salad and dressing in a bag on the counter, the garlic bread with cheese came without cheese and the texture of bread was as if it had been microwaved--too tough to eat. It all went into the trash, and manager Brian tells me he is not "authorized " to make a refund?! Despite calls and an online request to speak to the general manager, we've received no call or email from this person. We are out $55 and so tired of poor customer service. Eat elsewhere. read more

OMG!! I love the puyallup CM, but it has gone downhill. Pizzas are bland and scarce toppings This place..the best pizza ever! Stranda Susina chicken, cashews, basil, onion..yummy!! I orders the small, it's packed so high with toppings, I'll have leftovers for 2 days! and I am NOT SHARING !! Oh and the house salad may be only Iceberg, olives (yuck) and mozzarella, but the house dressing is to die for! read more

Casa Mia - Pizza Strada Susina Don't knock cashews on your pizza til you try it! - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

The food was excellent. Their garlic bread with dipping sauce is very tasty. Excellent meal of all you can eat spaghetti, salad, rolls and garlic bread. Definitely won't go away hungry. Came again 4/10/16. Service is great. Just now waiting on their garlic bread - never a disappointment!! read more

See all

One of my favorite restaurants in town. Have a couple standby items I always get. First is the tortellini in the butter and cream sauce. I've got the servers tuned to let me know how,the sauce is that day. I don't like it too runny. It's just so,yummy. The oven baked steak is pretty good too. Don't forget about the pizza....it is one of the top five in town. Can't really go wrong here. read more

This is an unpretentious, homestyle restaurant that places a heavy emphasis on excellent service, cozy atmosphere and authentic tastes - and succeeds impressively. In doing so, it fills an important niche in Olympia's hierarchy of restaurants, that of the neighborhood, family-run, Italian-American restaurant typically found in larger urban areas. This is not chain-store food, nor by-the-numbers pizza. It is an honest attempt at the dishes and flavors found in the real deal. Prices are reasonable, service attentive and the food simple but on target. I'm very happy to frequent this restaurant whenever I can; otherwise I'd have to get on a plane and fly to my old New York neighborhood to find something as inviting and flavorful. Indeed, this is Italian-American comfort food at its authentic best. Grazie e buon appetito! read more

Been a customer since 1958 or so at the first Casa Mia in Aberdeen WA. The Lacey and Olympia "Casas" are much different from that original one OTHER than, they still serve damned good pizza. The menu is diverse Southern Italian. The pizzas now include gourmet varieties explaining how this local franchise has won some national competitions. Another consistent feature is good service. Both Oly area locations also offer seating for small groups and large families. read more

This is my go-to Italian restaurant [albeit not 'precisely authentic Italian']. I've seen some complaints from other reviewers regarding the lack of Italian authenticity, but I think Casa Mia's simplistic approach is very smart & absolutely delightful! I love everything here, but my faves are the (always) fresh Casa Mia salad & the Chicken Parmagiana dish prepared with white sauce and fettucinni. My boyfriend prefers the Spinach Ravioli dish and their garlic bread with dipping sauces is amazing...The food is always prepped with care as the open kitchen area is easily viewable from the dining room seating area. The chef and assistants can always be seen wearing gloves and using food safety precautions (which is always of paramount concern to me!). Aside from the food, the vibe here is chill and service is prompt and courteous. I love you Casa!! read more

Stopped by on way home from Seattle. Had the spaghetti, hubby had the cheese ravioli. Both dishes drenched in same runny non-descript tomato sauce. Ravioli was terrible. Spaghetti was barely ok. Service ok as well. If you want a quick stop of messy pasta that reminds me of an elementary school cafeteria, then you won't mind Casa Mia. read more

Casa Mia - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

Ok so there is an absolutely HOT (lack of a better word) server here.... That's first... Ok the cheese pizza is not very good... We asked for light sauce and got heavy sauce...But let's get back to the red head. Gorgeous.... Spicy chicken Caesar salad is the A-.... The mushroom risotto with truffle sauce topped with a slight balsamic drizzle is a solid B... Asparagus with a slight balsamic drizzle as well.... Absolutely fantastic also a A-.... Back to the red head.... Wow! Ok Casa Mia gets a thumbs up.... We will be back... P. read more

Casa Mia - Love this place... - Pizza Near Me - Olympia, Washington

My all time favorite place for Pizza and their salad with bleu cheese is the best! I grew up on Casa Mia Pizza at the original Casa Mia in Hoquiam.. read more

Best price Excellent pesto Yummy bread Great service Friendly I will be back for sure. read more

This is a great local family oriented Italian restaurant. It is not fine dining. It is good quality food at reasonable prices. The sort of place you would take your kids, or a large group. The pizzas are unique, especially the potato, gorgonzola and truffle oil. Another favorite of mine is the four cheese. Olympia does have a lot of great pizza places so I would not necessarily say they are the best, just great at what they offer. They also have nice basic starter salads, mannicotti and lasagna. I would not say they have outdoor seating, but they do have a closed in porch/veranda type area they use more in the summer. read more

Came here again, this time to dine in. Food was ok again, nothing great. This time the restaurant was practically empty yet got the same slow service. I would not avoid this restaurant if others wanted to go but with so many other really good local restaurants this is pretty low on my list, too bad too because I have not found much competition for Italian food read more

See all

My wife and I have been meaning to try Casa Mia for awhile. People we know have raved about it and the reviews have usually been good. We went there for my birthday and the entire experience was just awful. The food was bland, flavorless, and looked like it was a frozen dinner reheated. Service wasn't great but with the labor shortage it is understandable. Disappointing all around. read more

I have had curb side to go dinner twice at the Yelm location. I love raviolis with meat sauce these did not disappoint both occasions. I look forward to in house dinning to try something else on menu. Staff very friendly and courteous. read more

They won a national award for their Strada susina and it's obvious why. I researched them before I first ever ordered and I've never ordered anything else from them. It is the best pizza in Olympia, hands down. Fight me. read more

Excellent happy hour, especially the margarita pizza!! It's great.

Not sure what's happening to this place but the food is not as good. Pizza doesn't taste the same serving sizes are smaller, you don't get bread anymore unless you ask for it. Will have to try the Lacey location next to see if it's food has gone down hill. read more

I'm from Olympia and my family and I have been coming to Casa Mia for years. It's always a favorite, always delicious and hits the sweet spot for your budget. I adore their Strada Susina Pizza and I've never experienced another pizza place with this combination of toppings: Tomato and Gorgonzola Parmigiano Sauces with Roast Chicken, Cashews, Onions and Fresh Basil. The cashews, gorgonzola and basil send it completely over the edge. It's an all-time favorite! Their pepperoni is also some of the best pepperoni I've had on a pizza as it's thick-sliced homemade pepperoni. Their Casa Mia dinner salad is the simplest thing in the world, iceberg, shredded mozzarella, black olives and your choice of dressing and yet it is one of the most satisfying salads ever. Other favorites include the fettuccine Alfredo, chicken parmigiana, minestrone and their mango zagablione! Over the years this place has stayed consistent and true to its standard menu and even expanded with new offerings of fig, almond pesto and prosciutto pizza, happy hour and butternut squash ravioli. read more

Clean good service Had ice burg salad which was good but the tomatoes overloaded with oregano were out of place... the pizza- stunk...I am from NY so this prefab dough with skimpy toppings was not worth me over going back....Cold good beer and nice wine.... Service nice read more

And old friend and I wanted to meet up for lunch while we were both back in our home town, and she suggested Casa Mia. I wasn't super excited by my first look at the exterior, however, once I got inside I was shocked... what an adorable little place! I couldn't believe I had never been there before! Casa Mia has been around in Washington State since 1952, serving Italian food made the old fashioned way. I was surprised that it was almost totally empty at noon on a Saturday, but my friend and I were able to grab a nice booth in the back and the restaurant really started to fill up while we were there. We started with warm, soft, white Italian bread and green salads with olives and cheese. Then we both chose traditional fettuccini with alfredo sauce. The portion size was huge and we both ended up taking a lot home. There was nothing sensational or unique about the food, but it was tasty and filling and the atmosphere was great. I would definitely go back. read more

Ordered spaghetti and literally it came with three meatballs and no seasoning. Just noodles and canned spaghetti sauce.

No need for a review. This place is always amazing ! My daughter loved their salad and bread... I loved their hot chocolate chip cookie... Not to mention their yummy pastas ! read more

I love the Manicotti and the Caesar Piadini. The only way to earn the fifth star for my review would be to add delivery!!! I probably do carry out about 2-3 times a month... would definitely order more often if they delivered. Probably a good thing they don't deliver actually, too easy to get manicotti then... read more

I have been going to the downtown Casa Mia location for as long as I can remember. Like all Casa Mia locations, they have done an excellent job of upgrading their persona with the changing times, while remaining steadfast in their attention to detail and quality in their food. The ambiance at this location is very special, taking advantage of the previous owners large garage doors and creating a faux patio to provide an al fresco atmosphere even in the coldest of winter. The service is speedy and efficient yet patient for those who enjoy an extended meal experience. In addition to the wonderful dining experience, Casa Mia is involved in the community, supporting organizations who seek to make the world a better place. The partnership between Casa Mia and it's community are helping make this world a better place. read more

I do not know what the issues are that I would give less than a 5 star for deliicious Italian food. We have been going for years and are impressed with new management. read more

Not overly impressed. Food was just okay. Half/half manicotti and cannelloni---. The red sauce is nicely flavored, the white sauce lacks depth in flavors. Potato with truffle oil pizza was drenched in oil. The server who "drizzled" the truffle oil treated it as if it were chocolate syrup on ice cream. Way too much. Mushroom risotto was too wet and needed cream or something to finish off Spaghetti was a hit with my 11 year old...red sauce is good. Server was abrupt. Never received the Pinot I ordered. Experience was simply a dinner with not much to write home about. read more

I find myself craving Casa Mia at times.... There is nothing extraordinary about Casa Mia, the inside is really low key, intimate cozy, and small- typical Italian restaurant look. I like Casa Mia the same way I like Olive Garden when I'm craving some run of the mill Italian I will go to either. Usually I choose Casa Mia for quick, and better customer service. The food is good, large portions, usually warm soft bread for an appetizer and the salad (which usually doesn't come w/ the meal) probably has the best mozzarella cheese I ever tasted goes swimmingly well w/ the house dressing which I like alot. read more

Good, not great, pizza and a very good meatball sammy. Nice atmosphere and a friendly staff. If you want pizza, try Vics or Old School.

OK, wish I had the pizza though. The bread is great, the pasta was eaten up by the kids, healthy portions for take-home. I had the calzone and it was pretty cool inside but had good flavor. The staff was nice, the setting is nice and comfortable and it is an enjoyable dining establishment. I am not rushing back. read more

The only reason I won't give it a 5 is because the salad was really disappointing. All out was was lettuce and cheap mozzarella cheese(the kind that comes shredded in a bag) and some black olives out of a can. I didn't even eat more then a few bites. Besides that, the staff were friendly and the food(I had butternut squash ravioli) was definitely worth it. read more

Came to this Casa Mia as it is the only one I have not eaten at in the past. Small restaurant but nice and clean. Was seated quickly however, it took time for a server to come and take my order. What was disappointing is that they took orders from someone who came almost 10 minutes after me. Said something about it. I ordered the Caesar Salad as well as the Onion Soup, OUTSTANDING as I asked for additional mozzarella cheese compared to the Lacey restaurant for the salad and also asked for more onion in the soup. Request was filled and both were delicious. Only thing I would like to see is for the bread (really a small biscuit) to be diced or cut up BEFORE they put it in the onion soup as you have to take it out to cut it up. If not for that, I would have given 5 stars. Again both items were delicious. read more

Food here is always good....we split a strada susada pizza -- it's one of our favorites. The arugula salad also fab and I love their house salad. I always have the zabaglione for dessert - it's light and creamy with mango puree and some sort of creamy cheese sauce....it is to die for. read more

This place makes the claim that they are the best pizza in Washington State and have even won awards to validate that claim. I'm not trying to rain on their parade because the pizza was actually pretty good. Much better than a Pizza Hut or Dominos pizza... BUT there is better pizza in Washington State. read more

We waited 15min before finally waving the waitress down to order. She didn't smile or seem happy to be here at all. Never said 'your welcome' to my thank yous. Just walked away. The bread they bring you was really good but my food was fucking disgusting! Fake chicken, wilted lettuce and runny Caesar dressing. read more

We almost went to a more expensive Italian place but decided we weren't dressed well enough for it and ended up as Casa Mia. The atmosphere is casual/family friendly and relaxed, didn't bother us any! The food was super delicious, it's great to find a home style Italian place (from the Boston area). This place did not disappoint and the food looked so good I almost didn't want to touch it. There were a few hiccups as it was super busy on a Saturday night but nothing that wasn't easily fixed. Staff was super pleasant and cared that your service was good. When they went to go get more bread for us the threw a roll out and replaced one in the new basket before it got to us. Definitely would recommend. *Did not have dessert because we were so comfortably full but it sounded amazing! ***edit: after writing this I'm pretty positive I was charged too much. read more

Though its nothing to write home about, Casa Mia in downtown Olympia is definitely an acceptable place to grab some Italian. The price is fairly reasonable for what you're getting and the food ain't bad either, though I've certainly had better Italian in my day. I got the small spaghetti with puttanesca sauce. It came with a salad (very simplistic and yummy- mozzarella and black olives smothering iceburg lettuce, accompanied by a very delicious and what I suspect to be homemade Italian dressing) and a basket of rolls that my husband, mother-in-law and I shared. The puttanesca sauce was pretty basic and good, and the spaghetti itself wasn't too greasy from oil. The rolls seemed as if they might have been store-bought, but warm bread is warm bread (a.k.a awesome). My husband got the fettucini alfredo, which he said tasted too "buttery", and his mom got a small cheese pizza which she found tasted "okay". However, it should be noted that both of my aforementioned relatives are somewhat picky and exclusive when it comes to food, so please take their opinions with a grain of salt ;). Our waitress was very nice and the service was relatively speedy, which most of us have to admit is a rarity in a lot of establishments these days. The ambiance is very much the kind of thing I look for in any small restaurant or cafe- kind of bohemian, rough around the edges, and homey. This place definitely gave off that kind of vibe to me for whatever reason. So to sum up, the food was acceptable, the service was nice, and the atmosphere was cozy and relaxing. I would recommend it as a nice alternative to any of the other places that might get packed out on certain nights (Olive Garden, Brewery City, etc). But if your tastes are particularly sophisticated or you're looking for something more satisfying, I might be more inclined to direct you to the notoriously great places (again, Olive Garden, Brewery City, Old School, etc, etc, etc.) read more

Wow!!!!! The three cheese chicken pizza was insane. Best pizza I have ever had. Go try it. Today. Right now. Great service and life changing pizza. read more