We decided to give this a shot while in town. We eat a lot of Mexican so we figured it would be a no brainer given the positive reviews. The location is good with easy access and parking. Inside was clean and welcoming. There was a good amount of seating, limited outside seating, and a bar as well. They had your normal selection of import beers, margaritas, and specialty drinks. We were seated immediately but it was a Tuesday night so later in the week may be busier. Our waiter was very nice and helpful. We started with guacamole because who doesn't love that and it was great. It was fresh, a very large serving of it, and I'm embarrassed to say the three of us pretty much finished it all. I decided to go with the smothered burrito (veggie option) with salsa verde and man was it big! Definitely could split between two so now I have lunch for tomorrow. The flavor was good, nothing was too overpowering and I'd for sure order it again if we return. My wife got the veggie enchiladas with mole sauce they were good without being too spicy. If you're in the mood for Mexican food in the area and you're hungry then this is the place you're looking for. read more

Casa Oaxaca - Smothered Burrito - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

See all

My favorite Mexican spot in Bethel and surrounding area! Food and drinks are authentic and delicious and always great service. My faves are the quesabirria and my husband loves the enchiladas de mole with shrimp. Also worth mentioning, they make FRESH corn tortillas. Not every Mexican restaurant does this and that's what sets them apart. The drinks are creative and at a reasonable price. Highly recommend! read more

Casa Oaxaca - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

Quite costly for a burrito, but the quality and the size was excellent, living in California San Diego to be exact. Nobody has Mexican food like there. the gal at the front was very sweet. When in the area most likely will go back. read more

Absolutely incredible, life changing Mexican food. Staff is so friendly especially our waitress, vibe is so homely and cosy, music is great. Please go here if you want amazing food that makes you feel like ur getting a warm hug from your abuela. The food coma is worth it. read more

Casa Oaxaca - Carne asada torta - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

See all

In town for a play, and found this lovely spot. Amazing authentic Mexican food! Staff are so friendly and courteous. This is a must stop! read more

See all

We ate, we drank, and we were merry. The food was top notch, and the service was quite attentive. We had a Brirria appetizer sampler, and a smothered steak burrito. We left with more leftovers than the quantity that we ate. The atmosphere was friendly. Nicely decorated. It wasn't noticeably quiet, nor noticeably noisy. Just a room full of people eating dinner. Would definitely return. read more

Authentic food with a fun and festive atmosphere. The staff were very friendly and attentive. They have a full bar with specialty cocktails. Chips and salsa arrived as soon as we were seated. We had the appetizer sampler which for two people, could have been a meal. The Chicken Enchiladas and Carne Asada were both good choices. Overall very authentic Mexican food with a great atmosphere. A must try if you enjoy Mexican cuisine. read more

Casa Oaxaca - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

See all

Took inlaws and toddler with us for a post-shoppjng dinner. We feasted like kings and absolutely everything was delicious! From grilled chicken, to steak chimichurri, to carne asada with juicy ribeye, to even the lowly tilapia, elevated with purposeful flavor. Everything was a plate-finishing must. The tres leches while more cakey than usual, was still pleasantly refreshing. We already liked this place back when they had just started in Bethel and I'm very pleased jt was full of patrons and that their food offerings are even more stellar. Place also looks very colorful and inviting and service was quick and friendly. Definitely a repeater in the near future. read more

See all

A lovely place with wonderfully authentic Oaxaca food! Try the Mole - delicious. Service was quick and the place is nicely decorated and clean. read more

This was my first time in Casa Oaxaca . I came in for a little spur of the moment, lunch date with myself. The food was amazing. The shrimp tacos were delicious. The shrimp was the perfect texture and the sauce was amazing. I loved the decor in this restaurant. It was very festive. The service was outstanding. The server and manager were both hospitable, courteous, accommodating, and friendly. I highly recommend this place and I definitely will be back with friends. Not a critic, but I always leave recommendations in my reviews so the only thing I would say is to add a couple more side options on the plate with the tacos to add at our discretion.. like perhaps a spoonful of guacamole or re-fried black beans. Take a visit to this yummy restaurant guys... You will be delighted. read more

See all

We were hearing lots of great things about Casa Oaxaca. We stopped in on a Taco Tuesday. Plenty of parking in the lot. Really great decor. Plenty of seating on both sides of the restaurant including a nice bar area. There's also a tv in the bar area for sporting events. Very clean restaurant and a great staff. When we were leaving, I noticed the tortillas being made fresh in the front of the restaurant. Made the experience even better. The food is amazing. They start you off with chips and salsa. We came during happy hour on a Taco Tuesday. We wanted to get a little of everything to try. Everything had great flavors. My favorite taco we had were the Carnitas. Really delicious chimichangas with a fresh guacamole. The empanadas were fried perfectly. The were filled to capacity. It was not like other places that put a little meat in the middle and it's mostly shell. To end the night we ordered churros. Freshly fried with chocolate sauce and whipped cream. Really finished off the great experience. Definitely looking forward to coming back soon. read more

See all

Stumbled upon this place. And bumped into this wonderful bartender Guillermo. What a very wonderful server and bartender. He makes you feel at home. I ordered a chicken tortilla soup and some beef empanadas. The chicken tortilla soup was the absolute best. Nice spices and a great amount of chicken. I would definitely order again. The beef empanadas were filled with an ample amount of meat and a nice crust patty surrounding it. Very very very good. The place has a very nice decor and very clean and the restroom also very clean. A busy restaurant is all I need to see to know that the food is the bomb and I'm glad I came here. Happy eating read more

See all

Went here for a family birthday dinner. The food was very tasty (I had the steak fajitas). We ordered guacamole too which was well made and served with what I think were in house made tortilla chips. The ambiance in the restaurant was nice and the staff were super friendly and attentive. Even giving my father-in-law and I some hot well made hot sauce for us to try. Will be back to this gem of a place soon. read more

Casa Oaxaca - Steak Fajitas - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

First time here and the food, service and atmosphere were amazing! Loved the Mariachi Band! Stephanie was our server and she was very attentive. read more

Great food! Had takeout while staying in town. Ample portions, lots of flavor. Got chicken fajitas, two large chicken breasts, a nice chicken burrito served with a side, and carnitas. Would definitely go here next time in town. read more

Nice mexican spot offering a great happy hour mondays through fridays from 4-6 with $7 margarita and other specialty drinks and $6-$7 appetizers, although mostly fried, but with good flavor. As for the rest of the menu, it offers your typical Mexican flare. Their taco tuesdays are nothing spectacular but then again the are the smaller tacos with minimal in terms of content and not my style but their menu otherwise is pretty solid offering flavor, options and specials for the weekend. Rice and beans are decent but not the best I have had but probably the best ones in bethel area. Their nachos are good and the birria nachos are a homerun! Homemade guac is very good and the chips and salsa they greet you with are not your typical in terms of chips as they are on the thicker side and the salsa is very different - more of a puree than a chunky salsa and takes a little getting used to. The bar area is fun and hip and the bartender is super attentive and efficient. Decor is really cute with fun walls and lots of plants and nice mexican art throughout. They have table and booths and can handle large groups. Forgot to mention regular appetizers other than happy hour appetizers are very good!! Nice little find with a nice staff and some great GF options for those who have that dietary obligation. read more

Casa Oaxaca - Quessabirria-soooooo Good! - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

See all

My wife and I had come here a few times and enjoyed the food and the service. We had been so impressed that we invited our adult children, their partners, and my mother in law. Our reservations were accepted. Unfortunately, we were not aware they also seated a 40 person birthday party. From the time we were seated, to the time we received our food it was more than an hour . Needless to say, it would've been appreciated if they staffed to meet the demands of the evening. We have not returned since. read more

One of our favorite happy hour spots! Affordable food and drinks with excellent service to match. We enjoyed the mariachi band tonight! read more

See all

I loved it. I love Mexican food. And this is as authentic as possible in Ct (although I still favor the taco truck at Home Depot) this can't be beat for gorgeous drinks great service and fun atmosphere. Reasonably priced. read more

See all

The food is delicious, my favorite the carnitas with horchata, fast service, clean, organize and very Mexican ambiance. Love it! read more

Casa Oaxaca - Carnitas Entree, Tlayuda - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

Five Stars all the way! While visiting this part of CT we were torn between Thai or Mexican... we were SO happy we went with Casa Oaxaca!! It was outstanding! Not only was the food authentic and mouthwatering delicious, the service was exceptional and the ambiance was great! The chips and salsa were so fresh and delish. I had the POLLO AL TEQUILA which was Chicken Breast, Mushrooms a la Crema served with Mashed Potatoes. OMG! It was incredible!!!! read more

See all

Status: In 2022, Connecticut Magazine readers voted Casa Oaxaca to be one of the top Mexican restaurants in the state. With two other Mexican restaurants minutes away on the same road, Casa Oaxaca knows how to stand out and be a destination of choice. Hours and Specials: Casa Oaxaca strives to meet customers shifting needs by offering different menus throughout the day: 11:30-3 Breakfast/Brunch/Lunch; 3-6 Happy Hour; 6-9:30 (until 10:30 on weekends) Dinner. To boot, Casa Oaxaca draws customers back for special discounts: margaritas on Mondays, Tacos on Tuesdays, and cocktails on Wednesdays. Some favorites... Breakfast/Brunch: Chorizo breakfast torta, because it is uncommon dish (scrambled eggs, cheese, slices of chorizo and avocado encased in Mexican bread.) Lunch: The Carnitas bowl! This was served piping hot, with juicy, flavorful pork and colorful and artfully arranged accompaniments (guacamole, Chihuahua cheese, slices of lime, beans, rice, pico de gallo, and salsa verde). One of those dishes that makes me resistant to try a different menu item -- just hard to imagine it can be matched! Had a Margarita on ice... perfect choice. Happy Hour: The bartender suggested the citrus-infused El Cantarito, which was refreshing and stunningly presented in a clay tumbler. The chicken filled chimichangas were especially tasty. Service at bar and table suggests that employees are eager to make customers' dining experience positive, as well as help them learn about the restaurant's rotation of daily specials. The plating of the dishes reflects thought, care, and pride in what the restaurant offers. Location: Lot parking is effortless and interstate travelers can easily swing off and back on the highway (I-84, ramps 8 and 9) that runs parallel to Stony Hill Road. The restaurant is cheerfully decorated, and, thanks to the configuration of seating, conversation is easy, never muffled. Another plus... outdoor dining is available seasonally. read more

See all

We were in the area and looking for a good place for dinner. Little known to us we stumbled across the best Mexican restaurant this side of the border! Everything from the chips and salsa, to the margaritas, to the meal, and decor was all authentic and delicious! I went for the chicken mole. The waiter said this was a special family recipe, and it absolutely seemed like someone's abuela was in the kitchen cooking this delicious, flavorful sauce! Literally the best mole I have had anywhere, including Mexico! Don't think twice, stop here tonight for a delicious and authentic dinner tonight! read more

See all

This place is awesome! The atmosphere is warm, the staff is welcoming, the food and drink is both excellent and reasonably priced. Definitely give this place a try! read more

Casa Oaxaca - Menu - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

See all

Came for happy hour with a few friends. Tried all the food on the happy hour menu (when there was an option for beef or chicken, we chose the chicken, but the tacos we did one of each). Food was delicious! Drinks were tasty, a little on the weak side compared to other places I have been. We tried a variety of drinks including mojitos (flavored and regular), margaritas (frozen and on the rocks), as well as sangria. As for desserts, we tried both the tres leches cake and the flan - but had the correct tastes, but the consistency was off from what I am accustomed to. Both desserts were a lot more "stiff". Service was ok. Our waitress disappeared for quite sometime to the point where we had to grab another employee to inquire where she went as we all ran out of beverages. Before that point and when she returned, she was very friendly and attentive. The waiter that stepped in for her during the time she had "possibly stepped out" was very nice and attentive as well. All that being said, will come again. read more

See all

Went there last night. The salsa was awful. Tasted like tomato sauce. I ordered enchiladas with Mole sauce. I love Mole sauce this was way too spicy and the refried beans had no taste as well as the rice. The chips were hard and tasteless. The fried ice cream was not like you would expect. Had brandy and it didn't burn off. It tasted too much like alcohol. The server was friendly but slow. I don't think I would go back. read more

The place was completely empty when we got here we only had a few appetizers but they were delicious and decently priced. The nachos and empanadas are pictured. Very cute and clean inside. read more

Casa Oaxaca - Appetizers - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

Amazing place! Staff is always so friendly, drinks are great, great bar atmosphere, the food is amazing! It is hard to find a great Mexican Restaurant in CT... This one checks all of the boxes. read more

See all

Absolutely the best Oaxacan restaurant in the area. The food quality was outstanding all made from scratch. Our server was friendly, attentive and took amazing care of us. The decor was beautiful and inviting. Look forward to our next visit. read more

Casa Oaxaca - Bar - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

Hubby and I were on a road trip and followed the signs off 84... amidst a few other restaurants we found this gem! Service was friendly, food delicious, portions generous! Try it! read more

We ate there this evening. We ordered the empanadas to start literally nothing inside when I tell you empty for $14 and money doesn't scare me when it comes to restaurants. The dinners came. They were by the worst. My wife had the stuff burrito which was a raw inside And I had the enchiladas ice cold and you couldn't even cut the outside. It was like a rock oddly ridiculous merchant conserve things like this. I'm leaving my phone number 718-344-6386. It was the worst food I've ever had and I've eaten there before That spiraling downhill read more

I normally don't write bad reviews unless something really egregious occurred, but I feel like I need to write one tonight, to maybe save someone else from actually expecting good Mexican food from this place. I use the star ratings and reviews pretty extensively to determine where to try new restaurants. And the rating for this one and its descriptions actually led me to try it out. In all fairness, it was a Tuesday, and it was a delivered meal. So we know it's not going to be as good as maybe Friday, and in the restaurant. But this level of disappointment needs some action. We ordered a smothered chicken burrito, in ranchero sauce, chicken enchiladas in mole, side of tostones, a horchata, and chips and guacamole. Of all of these items, the only thing that was good was the tortilla chips. Most of this order went into the garbage. It wasn't bad. It just wasn't good. The portions are enormous, so that's a plus, considering the prices. However, both chicken dishes had chicken that was dry enough to choke on. The Ranchero sauce really appeared to be just blended canned tomatoes, with no salt, no spices. The mole was sweet enough to have had a Hershey bar dropped into it, and again, the chicken was dry, and flavorless. The horchata had a layer of silt at the bottom, and was thick, and strongly flovored with clove. Probably the only thing that had seasonings. The tostones were enormous, thick, chewy and dry. Probably 4 in in daimeter and 1/4 in thick, and absloutely dry. Wondered if they cooked them in an air fryer. We're not food snobs. We like good food. Yes, we're familiar with good Mexican food. I lived in San Diego for a number of years, and have lived up and down the CA coast. Been to Oaxaca. This stuff wasn't it. read more

Save your hard earned dollars because you don't need to travel to southern Mexico! I ordered 2 entrees and a Tamarind juice and was blown away at the quality of their food. Might as well be gourmet! These chefs are beyond experts. Fair prices for abundant servings. Muy muy muy rica comida! Olvidelo read more

Went to Casa Oaxaca with my dad and friend. We went for lunch as we was down in the area and looking for mexican style food. This was a very different take on mexican food. The service was pretty good and the food was pretty good too. I got the chicken tortilla soup and enchilada roja off the lunch specials menu. My father got the $4 taco Tuesday special and tried each of the 4 taco flavors. My friend got the chicken quesadilla. The chicken tortilla soup was very good but gave off more of a stew vibe than a typical soup. The enchilada rojas were good, you could absolutely tell they were homemade. I did really like the soup. I tried my friends quesadilla, it was pretty good but what you would expect off a quesadilla. My father's tacos very good and different as there were variations you wouldn't seem to find on most menus. I really enjoyed my experience and I would love to go back at dinner to see the rest of their menu. It was really fun, especially to watch the woman making the corn tortillas from scratch right in front of us. read more

See all

What an amazing place! Food was BEYOND delicious, vibe was great. The whole restaurant and bathrooms were also very clean. Our server, Adam was AMAZING! Super attentive, friendly and fun! The BEST mole I have eaten on the east coast and the house hot sauces do not disappoint. It is really hard to impress to this West coast girl, but this place was GREAT! P.S. you can tell they also own a bakery because the desserts were so fresh and delicious! read more

Casa Oaxaca - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

I gave this spot another chance. We ordered the chicken tacos and birria burrito & both were delicious. The service was excellent! read more

Casa Oaxaca - Chicken tacos & birria tacos - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

Let me start off by saying we were a pretty big group, celebrating a birthday in the midst of a northeastern 10"+ snow storm. In the midst of all this, the service was phenomenal and extremely polite. Some of us had alcoholic beverages and from my understanding they are made on stronger side. Their guacamole delicious, you can taste the slightest hint of lime every once in awhile, perfectly chunks of tomato. It was amazing, haven't had that good guac in quite a bit. We had too large of a party for me to get pictures of everyone's meals, just got a few of who was sitting around me. I got the carnitas tacos- they were ok. A little dry - I added guac to mine. My husband got the carnitas entree and his rice and refried beans were very savory. Everyone else around us seemed to be very pleased with their meals. We ended off with a birthday cake we brought that they cut and served. I wiuld def recommend if you're looking to try Mexican food. read more

See all

Big portions, the queso was amazing, only one server working but still quick and attentive! Cute atmosphere and seriously yummy food. read more

Casa Oaxaca - Queso Fundido, Mole Oaxaca, Churrasco - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

A friendly gem of freshly made Mexican food! They spoiled every other Mexican restaurant for me! Tortillas made to order, fresh guacamole & salsa, delicious entrees! A must go! read more

Casa Oaxaca - Carne asada tacos - Mexican Near Me - Bethel, Connecticut

See all

We have been driving past this place for years. We finally went in. The place is great. The food was very good. Our waiter was great. There was even two guys walking around and singing at the tables. Great atmosphere. I had a burrito and my wife enchiladas. The gauc was VERY good. Almost forgot. The house margaritas are one of the better ones we have had locally. We will go back .. read more